Quantum Acoustics Demystifies the Strange Metals
Eric J. Heller, Alhun Aydin, Anton M. Graf, Yubo Zhang, Joost de Nijs, Yoel Zimmermann, Xiaoyu Ouyang, Shaobing Yuan, Alvar Daza, Zixuan Chai, Siyuan Chen, Jasper Jain, Mingxuan Xiao, Chenzheng Yu, Zhongling Lu, Joonas Keski-Rahkonen · 2025
Read Quantum Acoustics Demystifies the Strange Metals by Eric J. Heller, Alhun Aydin, Anton M. Graf, Yubo Zhang, Joost de Nijs, Yoel Zimmermann, Xiaoyu Ouyang, Shaobing Yuan, Alvar Daza, Zixuan Chai, Siyuan Chen, Jasper Jain, Mingxuan Xiao, Chenzheng Yu, Zhongling Lu, Joonas Keski-Rahkonen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01853.txt.
Introduction
Eric Heller and thirteen colleagues argue that a whole class of materials has been misunderstood because physicists treated lattice vibrations too statically. Strange metals show resistivities that grow linearly with temperature, at the so-called Planckian rate, over thousands of degrees. Phonons were long dismissed as incapable of explaining that. The authors contend the dismissal rested on perturbative methods that missed time-dependent, nonperturbative electron-lattice physics.
Their lens is quantum acoustics, a framework parallel to the quantum optics Glauber built for light sixty years ago. The team treats the standard Fröhlich model nonperturbatively, in the right parameter regime. From it they derive Planckian transport, polarons, charge density waves, and pseudogaps. They also account for the Drude peak anomaly and the missing low-temperature resistivity behaviors. The new physics, they claim, was hiding in the old model all along.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eric J. Heller, Alhun Aydin, Anton M. Graf, Yubo Zhang, Joost de Nijs, Yoel Zimmermann, Xiaoyu Ouyang, Shaobing Yuan, Alvar Daza, Zixuan Chai, Siyuan Chen, Jasper Jain, Mingxuan Xiao, Chenzheng Yu, Zhongling Lu, Joonas Keski-Rahkonen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01853
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Acoustics Demystifies the Strange Metals Eric J. Heller, Alhun Aydin, Anton M. Graf, Yubo Zhang, Joost de Nijs, Yoel Zimmermann, Xiaoyu Ouyang, Shaobing Yuan, Alvar Daza, Zixuan Chai, Siyuan Chen, Jasper Jain, Mingxuan Xiao, Chenzheng Yu, Zhongling Lu, Joonas Keski-Rahkonen Abstract Phonons have long been thought to be incapable of explaining key phenomena in strange metals, including linear-in- T Planckian resistivity from high to very low temperatures. We argue that these conclusions were based on static, perturbative approaches that overlooked essential time-dependent and nonperturbative electron-lattice physics. In fact “phonons” are not the best target for discussion, just like “photons” are not the best way to think about Maxwell’s equations. Quantum optics connects photons and electromagnetism, as developed 60 years ago by Glauber and others. We have developed a parallel world of quantum acoustics. Far from being only of academic interest, the new tools are rapidly exposing the secrets of the strange metals, revealing strong vibronic (vibration-electronic) interactions playing a crucial role forming polarons and charge density waves, linear-in- T T resistivity at the Planckian rate over thousands of degrees, resolution of the Drude peak infrared anomaly, and the absence of a T 4 T^{4} low-temperature resistivity rise in 2D systems, and of a Mott-Ioffe-Regel resistivity saturation. We derive Planckian transport, polarons, CDWs, and pseudogaps from the Fröhlich model. The “new physics” has been hiding in this model all along, in the right parameter regime, if it is treated nonperturbatively. In the course of this work we have uncovered the generalization of Anderson localization to dynamic media: a universal Planckian diffusion emerges, a “ghost” of Anderson localization. Planckian diffusion is clearly defined and is more fundamental than the popular but elusive, model dependent concept of “Planckian speed limit”. I Introduction In the 1950s and 1960s, the Hanbury-Brown Twiss experiment made it imperative to unify the particle-like photon picture of light with the wave-like electromagnetic field obeying Maxwell’s equations. Thus was born the new paradigm of quantum optics, where Glauber coherent states became the vehicle to travel from photons to electromagnetic waves. The opportunity to develop solid state theory of lattice vibration along parallel lines has been largely neglected. The phonon plays the role of the photon, and the acoustic waves play the role of the electromagnetic waves. The connection goes back to Schrödinger, who worked out the number state-coherent state connection in 1926, Fig. 1 schr . The former is natural to the time-independent Schrödinger equation, and the latter needs the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. We have recently been developing this paradigm for electrons in a lattice and have found it to be remarkably powerful for both physical insight and computations. We call it quantum acoustics. We do not need to introduce a new physical model, but rather we develop the Fröhlich model in a perfectly valid but neglected coherent state representation. New physics emerges, as well-grounded as it is in quantum optics. The traditional solid state paradigm is one of particles, i.e. phonons. In special contexts, involving transducers, for example, acoustic waves are familiar, but the unification of phonons and acoustic waves has been lacking. It is natural that the coherent state is again the right tool to unify the wave and particle pictures, this time in solid state physics. Far from being of only academic interest, quantum acoustics has made it possible to understand several of the high-temperature superconductor, above- T_{c} “strange metal” mysteries, within a single theoretical context and within perhaps the most well established model of electron-vibration interactions (Fröhlich). This paper reviews that progress and points the way to likely future developments. Earlier, we put the time-dependent real space “wave-on-wave,” or WoW code described below through its paces regarding ordinary metals heller22 . It gave essentially exact agreement with the Bloch-Grüneisen, perturbative + Boltzmann transport theory, including a T^{4} ( T^{5} in 3D) low temperature rise of resistivity at low T heller22 . Neither perturbation theory nor Boltzmann transport was used. Now we are applying quantum acoustics to the high T_{c} materials in their strange “normal” (non-superconducting) state, and it is yielding a cornucopia of results. The WoW approach, including the lattice interacting with the electrons and vise-versa is nonperturbative and coherence preserving; both traits are needed to understand the strange metals. We have already explained or believe we will be able to explain most of the above experimental results above T c , but we cannot yet claim to have pinned down the very low temperature linearity of resistivity. We have plausible lattice-electron scenarios, but this leads us into speculation, which we mostly avoid here. The veil is lifting on many of the strange metal mysteries and controversies, after nearly 40 years. It has become crystal clear that electron-lattice interactions are essential to understand the strange metal physics. “Strongly correlated” behavior is often cited as a hallmark of strange metals. In our perspective, there is a strong coupling that emerges within the venerable Fröhlich Hamiltonian, and is vibronic in origin: Electrons become strongly coupled indirectly with each other because they are each strongly coupled to the same lattice and its deformations due to thermal vibrations and the presence of the electron back-action. Even near 0 Kelvin, given a deformation potential constant of 10 or 20 eV, strong electron-lattice coupling emerges in strange metals (but not for ordinary metals). The basis for this approach can be traced back to the semiclassical (with respect to the lattice) polaron theory of Landau and Pekar landau1948effective , as amplified by Leopold et al. leopold2022landau . In analogy with an electron in a classical electromagnetic field, Landau-Pekar takes a classical lattice approach as opposed to a quantized, number-state, phonon-based approach. Another important antecedent is Peierls distortion of a lattice. This very idea shifts us quietly into a coherent state representation of the lattice because it is extremely inconvenient to think of the distortions in terms of phonon occupations. Sound waves in a crystal coming from a transducer also necessarily slip us into the coherent state representation, or at least a classical lattice picture. The Fröhlich Hamiltonian, with its centerpiece electron-phonon interaction term, generates strongly coupled emergent behavior, if it is allowed to remain always “on,” acting coherently to unlimited order. The quantum acoustics paradigm can implement the Fröhlich Hamiltonian nicely, but it should be noted that the quantum acoustics framework is much more general than the Fröhlich model. That is, much higher order models can also be accommodated with quantum acoustics. We make the case below that quantum acoustics, wherein “coherent and always on” electron lattice interactions happen naturally, holds the key to much of the strange metal phenomenology. Several papers have laid the groundwork heller22 ; PhysRevLett.132 ; Aydin24 ; aydin_polaron_2025 and have offered plausible explanations to important strange metal mysteries. Using quantum acoustics framework, we have so far provided explanations for (a) bypass of the Mott-Ioffe-Regel limit heller22 , (b) low-frequency Drude peak suppression and displacement PhysRevLett.132 , (c) linear-in- T resistivity with Planckian slope from hundreds of degrees down to at least 50K, and lower with strong magnetic fields Aydin24 , and (d) definitive and spontaneous “real time” polaron and CDW formation in dynamical WoW simulations aydin_polaron_2025 , superseding linear response and perturbative approaches. The term “quantum acoustics”