Constraining memory-burdened primordial black holes with graviton-photon conversion and binary mergers

Po-Yan Tseng 1,2 and Yu-Min Yeh 1 · 2025

Read Constraining memory-burdened primordial black holes with graviton-photon conversion and binary mergers by Po-Yan Tseng 1,2 and Yu-Min Yeh 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01848.txt.

Introduction

Po-Yan Tseng and Yu-Min Yeh look for primordial black holes that should have evaporated away but, under the memory-burden effect, might linger as dark matter. Memory burden stabilizes an evaporating black hole and suppresses its emission, reopening a mass window below a quadrillion grams for black hole dark matter that older constraints had closed.

The authors probe an earlier, unsuppressed phase instead. In their first scenario, gravitons emitted while the holes were still young cross the recombination era. They convert into photons in filament magnetic fields, through the Gertsenshtein effect. The resulting photon spectrum is compared with gamma-ray sensitivities. It excludes a window of masses, from hundreds of thousands to tens of millions of grams, for holes making up the dark matter. A second scenario, mergers today recreating young holes, is noted as highly model-dependent.

Catalog record

CREATORPo-Yan Tseng 1,2 and Yu-Min Yeh 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01848

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining memory-burdened primordial black holes with graviton-photon conversion and binary mergers Po-Yan Tseng 1,2 and Yu-Min Yeh 1 Abstract The memory-burden effect stabilizes the evaporating Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) before its complete decay. This also suppresses the evaporation flux via the entropy factor to the k k -th power and circumvents severely astrophysical and cosmological constraints, such that it opens a new mass window for PBH Dark Matter lighter than 10 15 10^{15} g which has entered the memory-burden phase in the present epoch. In this study, we propose two scenarios to probe PBHs in the earlier semiclassical phase that evaporate at unsuppressed rates. The first scenario considers gravitons, emitted semiclassically from PBHs, propagating across the recombination epoch, then the magnetic field in the cosmological filaments converts them into photons via the Gertsenshtein effect. The second scenario relies on the PBHs mergers today, reproducing young semiclassical black holes with unsuppressed evaporation. We perform computations of the extragalactic photon spectrum from PBHs emission according to these scenarios. The upper limits on the fractional abundance of PBH are obtained by comparing with the sensitivities of gamma-ray observations. The graviton-photon conversion scenario excludes the mass window 7.5 × 10 5 ​ g ≤ M PBH ≤ 4.4 × 10 7 ​ g 7.5\times 10^{5}\,{\rm g}\leq M_{\rm PBH}\leq 4.4\times 10^{7}\,{\rm g} with f PBH ≥ 1 f_{\rm PBH}\geq 1 and k = 1 k=1 . Meanwhile, the merging scenario, which is insensitive on k k , restricts PBH Dark Matter lighter than 2.2 × 10 11 2.2\times 10^{11} g. 1 Introduction The hypothesis Primordial black holes (PBHs) are proposed to form in the early Universe and constitute the entire dark matter (DM) abundance Hawking 1971 ; Chapline 1975 ; Khlopov 2010 ; Carr et al. 2016 ; Carr et al. 2021 ; Carr and Kuhnel 2020 ; Green and Kavanagh 2021 . This scenario has been thoroughly studied for PBH masses M_{\rm PBH} from Planck mass ( M_{\rm Pl} ) to 10^{20}M_{\odot} Carr et al. 2021 . It leads to a mass window in the astroid range M_{\rm PBH}\subset [ 10^{17} g, 10^{22} g] where single mass PBH constitute the entirety of dark matter. For PBH lighter than 10^{17} g, it is severely constrained due to the black hole (BH) Hawking evaporation Hawking 1975 ; Gibbons and Hawking 1977 . Hawking adopted semi-classical calculation and showed that a BH emits a thermal spectrum of particles, associated with a temperature scale as T_{\rm PBH}\propto 1/M_{\rm PBH} . Consequently, the PBH evaporation process is self-similar and end with a final burst when M_{\rm PBH}\to M_{\rm Pl} . However, Ref. Dvali 2018 ; Dvali et al. 2020 pointed out that the semi-classical approximation will break down when the BH lost about half of its initial mass. Subsequently, the backreaction of the emission on the quantum state of the BH, called the memory burden effect, significantly suppresses the BH evaporation by the k -th power of BH entropy S . Therefore, the life history of a PBH can be divided into semiclassical phase (before losing half of its initial mass) and burden phase. As a result, it prolongs the lifetime of low-mass PBHs and modifies their upper limits of abundance, thus opening up the light-mass window for PBH to be viable dark matter candidate. In recent literature, many phenomenological studies have been investigated on burdened PBHs Thoss et al. 2024 ; Chianese et al. 2025 ; Chaudhuri et al. 2025 ; Tan and Zhou 2025 ; Chianese 2025 ; Loc 2025 . In particular, for k=2 , the PBH with initial mass M_{\rm PBH}\subset [ 10^{5} g, 10^{10} g] can explain the entire dark matter abundance and satisfies various constraints Thoss et al. 2024 . This unconstrained mass window is mainly because the detectable photon or neutrino fluxes must be produced after cosmic recombination or matter-radiation equality, which are suppressed by entropy when the PBH is under the burden phase. Taking advantage of the feeble interaction between the graviton and other Standard Model (SM) particles, the graviton flux produced without entropy suppression from semiclassical phase of PBH, before cosmic recombination, can almost free streaming to present detections. We might detect those gravitons as a gravitational wave (GW) signal. Unfortunately, for low-mass PBH interested in memory burden, direct detection of such high-frequency GW signal is beyond the reach of current and future GW interferometers Inomata et al. 2020 ; Ireland et al. 2023 ; Barman et al. 2024 , since the energy of gravitons follows the temperature associated with the PBH mass. However, the Gertseshtein effect converts the gravitons into the photons under the external magnetic field, which significantly improves the detectability of the signal. In particular, we used the cosmological filaments as sources of magnetic fields and computed the conversion probability. This effect has been applied to the scenarios that gravitons generated from dark matter decay Dunsky et al. 2025 or PBH evaporation Ito et al. 2024 . In this work, we will adopt the latter approach and additionally include the memory burden effect. We consider the photon signals from two cases: i) The PBH emitted gravitons from both semiclassical and burden phases separated by the PBH formation mass times parameter q . ii) A new PBH from merging of two burdened PBHs restarts the semiclassical phase. The latter case is, unlike the first, insensitive to the parameter k , instead depends on q . Using the sensitivities of current and future gamma-ray observations within energy E_{\gamma}\subset [ 10^{-5} GeV, 10^{7} GeV], we set the upper bounds for the abundance of PBHs. This restricts the memory burden scenario so that the monochromatic mass PBH lighter than 2.2\times 10^{11} g as a viable dark matter candidate. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we review the memory burden effect and describe the implementation in the BlackHawk v2.3 package. In Section 3 , we formulate the Gertsenshtein effect and take an approximation for the conditions of cosmological filaments. Then we convolute the graviton spectra from PBH with the conversion probability to obtain the photon flux. In Section 4 , we briefly introduce the PBH merger and deduce Hawking spectrum from it. Considering the observational upper limits or sensitivities of extragalactic gamma-ray, we set constraints on PBH abundance in Section 5 . The results are summarized in Section 6 . 2 Memory Burden The memory burden effect considers the quantum state of the black hole (BH), deviating from the prediction of Hawking evaporation which assumes the semiclassical approaches Dvali 2018 ; Dvali et al. 2020 ; Dvali et al. 2024 . This effect is caused by the information store in the system resists its decay, which results in slowing down the evaporation and extending the lifetime of the black hole, when a black hole lost a certain fraction of its initial mass and the back reaction becomes significant. We follow the calculation of Ref. Chianese et al. 2025 . We denote M_{\rm PBH}|_{T_{\phi}} the initial mass of PBH formed at cosmological temperature T_{\phi} . Taking an example of PBHs generated from a dark first-order phase transition (FOPT), T_{\phi} indicates when the Yukawa interaction dominates a Fermi-Ball (FB) total energy, so that the FB becomes unstable and starts collapsing

Read the complete text