Avoiding Blindness in Baryon Number Violating Processes: Free-Beam and Intranuclear Paths to Neutron-Antineutron Transitions

Joshua L. Barrow, Peter Fierlinger, Yuri Kamyshkov, Bernhard Meirose, David Milstead, Rabindra N. Mohapatra, Valentina Santoro · 2025

Read Avoiding Blindness in Baryon Number Violating Processes: Free-Beam and Intranuclear Paths to Neutron-Antineutron Transitions by Joshua L. Barrow, Peter Fierlinger, Yuri Kamyshkov, Bernhard Meirose, David Milstead, Rabindra N. Mohapatra, Valentina Santoro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01829.txt.

Introduction

Joshua Barrow and six colleagues compare the two ways to hunt one of the rarest hypothetical events in physics. It is a neutron turning into an antineutron. That change would violate baryon number. One approach watches free neutrons in a beam; the other watches enormous detectors for the annihilation that follows a conversion inside a nucleus, a sign of matter instability.

Translating the strong intranuclear limits into free-neutron terms traditionally relies on nucleus-specific estimates. Those estimates say how the medium suppresses conversion. They are computed in mean-field theory, under a single-operator assumption. The authors warn that this suppression can be scenario-dependent, shifting the translation by several orders of magnitude and blinding searches that trust it blindly. They call for a broader phenomenology program for the transition, akin to those built for electric dipole moments, before next-generation searches commit.

Catalog record

CREATORJoshua L. Barrow, Peter Fierlinger, Yuri Kamyshkov, Bernhard Meirose, David Milstead, Rabindra N. Mohapatra, Valentina Santoro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01829

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Avoiding Blindness in Baryon Number Violating Processes: Free-Beam and Intranuclear Paths to Neutron-Antineutron Transitions Joshua L. Barrow, Peter Fierlinger, Yuri Kamyshkov, Bernhard Meirose, David Milstead, Rabindra N. Mohapatra, Valentina Santoro Abstract Experimental searches for neutron–antineutron ( n → n ¯ n\rightarrow\bar{n} ) transitions can be considered via two approaches: conversion in free-neutron beams and intranuclear transformation leading to matter instability in large-mass detectors. Plans for next-generation searches make it timely to highlight the complementarity, necessity, and limitations of each method. Converting the bound neutron limit into one for free neutrons traditionally utilizes nucleus-specific estimates of the in-medium suppression of n → n ¯ n\rightarrow\bar{n} , obtained within mean-field theory under a single-operator assumption. This paper highlights how this suppression can be scenario-dependent, which can lead to deviations from the standard approach that can span several orders of magnitude. A further goal of the paper is to point out the need for a broader phenomenology program for n → n ¯ n\rightarrow\bar{n} that is akin to those developed for electric dipole moments and other systems for which short-distance new physics must be studied in-medium. Introduction Of all of the hitherto observed conservation laws, the apparent protection of baryon number ( \mathcal{B} ) is perhaps the most fragile. Theories of baryogenesis Riotto and Trodden 1999 ; Dine and Kusenko 2003 ; Babu et al. 2006 ; Canetti et al. 2012 ; Babu et al. 2013 require baryon number violation (BNV) as a Sakharov condition Sakharov 1967 . Similarly for the conservation of lepton number ( \mathcal{L} ), baryon number ( \mathcal{B} ) is conserved in the Standard Model (SM) at the perturbative level due to an accidental global symmetry Weinberg 1979 ; Wilczek and Zee 1979 . Both conservation laws are typically not respected when the SM is extended. Away from the perturbative sector, the violation of \mathcal{B} and \mathcal{L} is predicted to occur within the electroweak sector of the SM via sphaleron and instanton processes ’t Hooft 1976 ; Kuzmin et al. 1985 where the quantity ( \mathcal{\mathcal{B}-\mathcal{L}} ) is instead conserved. While \Delta\mathcal{B}=1 searches Abe et al. 2017 ; Abe et al. 2014 ; Hirata et al. 1989 dominated attention in early GUT paradigms Georgi and Glashow 1974 ; Langacker 1981 ; Hebecker et al. 2024 , decades of null results motivate complementary paths. Many well-motivated frameworks of physics beyond the SM violate \mathcal{B} by two units Mohapatra and Marshak 1980 ; Mohapatra and Senjanovic 1981 ; Nussinov and Shrock 2002 ; Babu et al. 2006 ; Barbier et al. 2005 ; Phillips et al. 2016 ; Calibbi et al. 2016 . The most sensitive way to search for a \Delta\mathcal{B}=2 transition is via neutron-antineutron transformations ( n\rightarrow\bar{n} ). One method to do this considers an antineutron produced in a long free neutron beam Fidecaro et al. 1985 ; Bressi et al. 1990 ; Baldo-Ceolin et al. 1994 ; Addazi et al. 2021 , while the other utilizes large-volume underground detectors Berger et al. 1990 ; Chung et al. 2002 ; Aharmim and et al. SNO Collaboration ; Abe and et al. Super-Kamiokande Collaboration ; Abe and et al. Super-Kamiokande Collaboration to search for intranuclear transitions which lead to matter instability. Each can lead to a highly unique \bar{n}N annihilation signature of multipion final states. While “free” neutron searches are generally inhibited only by energy level splittings \delta E originating from environmental magnetic fields which can be largely shielded away, the strong nuclear field inhibits the n\rightarrow\bar{n} transition. A nucleus-specific parameter, R=T_{b}/\tau_{f}^{2} , is generically applied to any experimentally determined intranuclear (bound) lifetime lower limit ( T_{b} ) to recover the associated square of the oscillation period for free neutrons ( \tau_{f} ). Estimations of R are based on phenomenologically mature mean-field/optical potential models assuming a contact interaction and momentum-independent microscopic mixing Alberico et al. 1982 ; Dover et al. 1983 ; Alberico et al. 1984 ; Dover et al. 1985 ; Dover et al. 1989 ; Alberico et al. 1991 ; Hufner and Kopeliovich 1998 ; Friedman and Gal 2008a ; Barrow et al. 2022 ; Barrow et al. 2020 . Typical values of R lie in the range of 10^{22}-10^{23}\, s -1 . Remarkably, given that sensitivities of free and bound searches are determined by wholly different sets of practical constraints, the limits from each method are very similar. The most competitive free or free-equivalent oscillation time lower limits from each method are 0.86\times 10^{8}\, s Baldo-Ceolin et al. 1994 from a direct search at the Institut Laue Langevin (ILL), and an inferred limit of 4.7\times 10^{8}\, s Abe and et al. Super-Kamiokande Collaboration from Super-Kamiokande. With neither method offering dominant sensitivity, it is important that physics which is not captured in the standard R estimations be considered. As will be discussed in this letter, scenarios beyond the mean field paradigm used in standard R determinations may change the intranuclear suppression of n\rightarrow\bar{n} by multiple orders of magnitude. These include multi-operator interference and non-local transitions. These are relatively unexplored in the literature, particularly with respect to possible cancellations among operator contributions and potential nuclear or kinematic enhancements, unlike, for example, CP -violating operators underlying electric dipole moment (EDM) observables which are tightly bounded by a broad and complementary suite of measurements (neutron, diamagnetic atoms, paramagnetic molecules, etc.) Pospelov and Ritz 2005 ; Engel et al. 2013 ; Liu et al. 2007 ; Flambaum and Ginges 2002 ; de Vries et al. 2011 ; Bsaisou et al. 2015 . Neutrinoless double- \beta decay Engel and Menéndez 2017 ; Cirigliano et al. 2018 , dark-matter–nucleus scattering Fitzpatrick et al. 2013 ; Anand et al. 2014 ; Schneck et al. 2015 , and \mu\!\to\!e conversion Calibbi and Signorelli 2018 ; Kitano et al. 2002 provide further examples of systems for which there is an interplay between short distance and nuclear physics. Each n\rightarrow\bar{n} search method is complementary in the physics that it can elucidate. The observation of n\rightarrow\bar{n} at a free neutron experiment provides a powerful probe of Lorentz/CPT-violating backgrounds in the Standard-Model Extension (SME) and small Weak Equivalence Principle (WEP) violations Babu and Mohapatra 2015 ; Addazi et al. 2017 to which bound neutron searches are blind. The related \Delta\mathcal{B}=2 process of dinucleon decay is uniquely available via bound nucleon searches Litos et al. 2014 ; Gustafson et al. 2015 ; Takhistov et al. 2015 . Searches for n\rightarrow\bar{n} in free space and in various mediums may also give sensitivity to different sets of operator projections. .1 Search status and prospects Figure 1: Top: Intranuclear n\rightarrow\bar{n} experimental lower limits from SNO Aharmim and et al. SNO Collaboration , Kamiokande (Kam.) Takita et al. 1986 , IMB Jones et al. 1984a ,Frejus Berger et al. 1990 , SOUDAN-2 Chung et al. 2002 , and Super-Kamiokande (SK-2014 Abe and et al. Super-Kamiokande Collaboration , SK-2020 Abe et al. 2021 ), are shown as solid orange points as a function of neutron exposure; a DUNE sensitivity from the horizontal drift technical design report Abi et al. 2020 is shown in an open circle. Open translucent circles are shown for hypothetical ideal sensitivities for large underground detectors assuming a single true event and \sim 0 background. Bottom: Free neutron oscillation time as a function

Read the complete text