The Inequity of Consumption-Based Tax Systems

Thiago Dias, José Roberto Iglesias, Sebastian Gonçalves · 2025

Read The Inequity of Consumption-Based Tax Systems by Thiago Dias, José Roberto Iglesias, Sebastian Gonçalves (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01823.txt.

Introduction

Thiago Dias, José Roberto Iglesias, and Sebastián Gonçalves test the fairness of consumption taxes with agent-based simulations. Consumption-based systems, which tax spending rather than income, are often defended as simple and neutral; the authors examine whether they actually redistribute wealth in a socially fair way.

Simulating wealth exchanges among agents under flat consumption taxes, they compare universal redistribution of the revenue with optimal targeted redistribution. The regressivity is stark: the poorest 40 percent of households contribute over half of the total tax revenue at most tax rates, because poorer households spend nearly all they have. Even the better redistribution schemes struggle against this built-in tilt. The authors present the numbers as quantitative input for designing fairer fiscal policy.

Catalog record

CREATORThiago Dias, José Roberto Iglesias, Sebastian Gonçalves
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01823

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Inequity of Consumption-Based Tax Systems Thiago Dias, José Roberto Iglesias, Sebastian Gonçalves Abstract This study examines the lack of redistributive effectiveness of consumption-based tax systems with respect to social fairness. Through numerical simulations, we explore the wealth exchanges among economic agents subject to flat consumption taxes, comparing universal redistribution with optimal targeted approaches. The results demonstrate that consumption taxes exhibit inherent regressivity, disproportionately burdening the poorest 40% of households who contribute over half of total tax revenue for most tax rates. The findings challenge the equity of consumption taxes and provide quantitative insights for designing more fair fiscal policies. [type=author, auid=000, bioid=1,orcid=0000-0003-0641-7686] [type=author, auid=000, bioid=2,orcid=0000-0002-0232-299X] [type=author, auid=000, bioid=3,orcid=0000-0002-3100-9126] keywords Econophysics ,Agent-based modeling ,Consumption tax ,Wealth distributions ,Inequality † † credit: Conceptualization, Software, Methodology, Visualization, Writing—original draft, Writing—review & editing † † credit: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing—original draft, Writing—review & editing † † credit: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing—original draft, Writing—review & editing † † corresponding: Corresponding author 1 Introduction Wealth inequality has been a subject of global concern since the nineteenth century, with early analyses by Marx and Pareto [ 1 , 2 ] . A certain degree of equity in wealth distribution has been shown to be necessary for maintaining a functional and stable economy [ 3 ] . Nevertheless, disparities between the assets held by the rich and the poor have been increasing worldwide [ 4 ] . Cross-country comparisons of wealth (or income) distributions reveal two broad classes: a wealthy elite, comprising about 5–10% of the population, whose wealth follows a Pareto power-law distribution; and the remaining majority, whose income is better described by Gibbs or log-normal distributions [ 5 , 6 ] . Since asset transactions drive healthy economies, the concentration of wealth within a small elite leads to stagnation and, ultimately, the collapse of an economy. In the twenty-first century, almost all countries have experienced (and continue to experience) increasing concentration of resources [ 7 , 8 ] . In an ideal laissez-faire market, even without explicit bias, the rich would systematically accumulate more wealth in the form of money, capital, and property. Analytical work further shows that, under such conditions, all available resources ultimately concentrate in a single individual [ 9 ] . Taxation and redistribution are widely employed to curb rising economic inequality. These mechanisms represent a transfer from richer to poorer agents through taxation, helping to prevent economic stagnation. In a previous contribution, we examined the impact of wealth—and consumption—tax systems on inequality [ 10 ] . We found that, for each tax rate, there exists a redistributional share of the population that minimizes inequality. Moreover, our results showed that wealth-based systems are generally more effective at reducing inequality than consumption-based ones. Nevertheless, most countries adopt the latter [ 11 ] , typically directing redistribution to about 10% of the vulnerable population [ 12 ] . A recent example comes from France, where the government changed five times in less than two years [ 13 ] , struggling to pass a budget that reduced workers’ incomes and benefits, while resisting the adoption of even a modest tax on the hyper-rich [ 14 ] . This resulted in continuous social unrest. Consumption taxes, such as the value-added tax (VAT), are often considered unfair because they disproportionately burden lower-income households [ 15 , 16 ] . To mitigate this regressivity, some essential goods primarily consumed by these households are exempted from taxation. Nevertheless, some authors defend consumption tax base. For example, Bradford and Todler [ 17 ] argued that this taxation is neutral between current and future consumption , since individuals are taxed only when they spend. In practice, this means that the after-tax purchasing power remains the same whether income is consumed immediately or first invested and then consumed after generating returns. Bankman and Weisbach further compared ideal taxes ( i.e. , a time-invariant flat tax rate) on consumption and income concluding that the former is preferable because it appropriately charge most forms of wealth input [ 18 ] . Here, we employ a Statistical Physics framework to study wealth transactions at the microscopic level and their impact on the macroeconomic measures. This approach has been shown to successfully capture the complexity of economic data [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 9 ] . In particular, this work analyzes the fairness of a consumption-based tax system. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 presents the model; Section 3 discusses the motivation for using the Palma index alongside the Gini coefficient; and Sections 4 and 5 present the results and conclusions, respectively. 2 Kinect exchange model with consumption taxes The model studied here is a variant of the Yard-Sale model, where economic agents engage in wealth exchanges through pairwise interactions. A population of N=10^{4} agents is considered, each characterized by two attributes: their wealth w_{i} and their risk propensity \alpha_{i} . At the beginning of the simulation, both w_{i} and \alpha_{i} are randomly assigned. While the risk propensity remains fixed during the dynamics, wealth flows between agents, subject to the conservation rule \sum_{i}w_{i}=1 . To avoid numerical underflow, a minimum wealth threshold of w_{\min}=10^{-12} is imposed: if an agent’s wealth falls below this value, it is set to zero, and the agent ceases to participate in further exchanges. During each Monte Carlo step (MCS), all agents with w>w_{min} are randomly paired, ensuring that every agent engages in exactly one exchange. Taking agents i and j to engage in an exchange and assuming that agent i wins, the post-transaction wealths are given by \displaystyle w_{i}(t+1) \displaystyle=w_{i}(t)+(1-\lambda)\,\Delta w, \displaystyle w_{j}(t+1) \displaystyle=w_{j}(t)-\Delta w, (1) where w_{i(j)}(t+1) and w_{i(j)}(t) denote the wealth of agent i ( j ) after and before the transaction, respectively, and \lambda is the tax rate. Although it may appear from Eq. ( 1 ) that only the winner is directly taxed, this is not the case: in practice, sellers and workers include the tax in the price of goods and services. To mimic realistic wealth exchanges, the amount at stake must be the same for both individuals. This is ensured by [ 22 , 3 ] \Delta w=\min\big[\alpha_{i}w_{i}(t),\alpha_{j}w_{j}(t)\big], (2) where \alpha_{i(j)} represents the fraction of wealth each agent risks in the transaction. After the trade and collecting the taxes, the total fiscal revenue ( \Lambda ) is equally distributed among the agents that belong to the fraction \tau (also referred to as the target) of the population with wealth sorted increasingly. Unlike the trivial case of wealth tax, where the revenue from taxation for a given \lambda during the entire simulation is the same, regardless of \tau ; in the case of a consumption tax, \Lambda depends on the amount of wealth exchanged at each step. Please see Subsection 4.1 for a more detailed discussion of the case of low \lambda , where the number of exchanges is severely reduced due to the high inequality. The experience in some countries shows that high tax rates can trigger evasion or push taxpayers to relocate their businesses to more flexible jurisdictions [ 12 ] . In our model, evasion is not possible, as all trades are taxed, and migration is also excluded because the fixed- N constraint prevents agents from moving to other economies. Moreover,

Read the complete text