Spontaneous Raman Scattering under Vibrational Strong Coupling: The Critical Role of Polariton Spatial Mode Coherence
Maxime Dherbécourt, Joël Bellessa, Clémentine Symonds, Guillaume Weick, David Hagenmüller · 2025
Read Spontaneous Raman Scattering under Vibrational Strong Coupling: The Critical Role of Polariton Spatial Mode Coherence by Maxime Dherbécourt, Joël Bellessa, Clémentine Symonds, Guillaume Weick, David Hagenmüller (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01723.txt.
Introduction
Maxime Dherbécourt, Joël Bellessa, Clémentine Symonds, Guillaume Weick, and David Hagenmüller settle a dispute about light scattering from molecules in an optical cavity. When a molecular vibration couples strongly to a cavity mode, the two form polaritons. Early reports claimed big changes to spontaneous Raman scattering from such systems. Later experiments mostly disagreed.
The authors build a microscopic quantum model that keeps the spatial shape of the polariton modes. In a cavity filled evenly with molecules, overlap between polaritons and cavity resonances enforces selection rules. Those rules suppress the claimed Raman peaks, which matches most experiments. In a thin, quasi-two-dimensional layer, the rules lift. Peaks at the polariton energies then return. The key factor is the spatial overlap of cavity and vibration. The model now makes that factor calculable.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Maxime Dherbécourt, Joël Bellessa, Clémentine Symonds, Guillaume Weick, David Hagenmüller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01723
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spontaneous Raman Scattering under Vibrational Strong Coupling: The Critical Role of Polariton Spatial Mode Coherence Maxime Dherbécourt, Joël Bellessa, Clémentine Symonds, Guillaume Weick, David Hagenmüller Abstract Resonant coupling of a vibration to a cavity mode has been reported to dramatically modify spontaneous Raman scattering, but subsequent studies have produced conflicting results. In this Letter, we develop a microscopic quantum framework that captures the spatial structure of polaritonic modes. In a homogeneously filled cavity, spatial overlap between polaritons and cavity resonances enforces selection rules that suppress the initially reported polaritonic Raman peaks, consistent with most experiments. In contrast, for a quasi-two-dimensional (2d) molecular layer, these rules are lifted, yielding Raman peaks at the polariton energies. Our work clarifies that the Raman response under vibrational strong coupling is determined by cavity-vibration spatial mode overlap and offers a framework for Raman studies of strongly coupled quasi-2d systems. The strong light-matter coupling regime arises when the interaction strength between confined electromagnetic modes and material excitations exceeds their respective loss rates Kimble 1998 ; Raimond et al. 2001 . This regime gives rise to hybrid polariton states Hopfield 1958 , which have been explored across a wide range of platforms Bellessa et al. 2004 ; Törmä and Barnes 2014 ; Baranov et al. 2018 ; Schneider et al. 2018 ; Garcia-Vidal et al. 2021 ; Barra-Burillo et al. 2021 ; Wright et al. 2023 . A key feature of these hybrid states is the formation, via the optical mode, of an extended coherent superposition of material excitations. Extended polariton coherence has been directly observed Aberra Guebrou et al. 2012 and further evidenced through energy transfer Andrew and Barnes 2000 ; Coles et al. 2014 ; Zhong et al. 2017 ; Schäfer et al. 2019 ; Georgiou et al. 2021 ; Bard et al. 2022 ; DelPo et al. 2021 ; Castagnola et al. 2024 and polaritonic metasurfaces Chevrier et al. 2019 . Strong light-matter interactions in optical cavities have attracted significant interest for their ability to influence fundamental processes such as chemical reactivity Hutchison et al. 2012 ; Kowalewski et al. 2016 ; Herrera and Spano 2016 ; Flick et al. 2017 ; Thomas et al. 2019 ; Yuen-Zhou et al. 2021 ; Fregoni et al. 2022 ; Mandal et al. 2023a , transport Orgiu et al. 2015 ; Feist and Garcia-Vidal 2015 ; Schachenmayer et al. 2015 ; Hagenmüller et al. 2017 ; Balasubrahmaniyam et al. 2023 ; Sandik et al. 2025 , and intermolecular interactions Haugland et al. 2021 ; Hirai et al. 2021 ; Biswas et al. 2025 ; Haugland et al. 2025 . In a pioneering 2015 experiment, it was shown that vibrational strong coupling (VSC)—the collective coupling of molecular vibrations to a cavity mode Long and Simpkins 2015 ; Shalabney et al. 2015a —can profoundly alter spontaneous Raman scattering Shalabney et al. 2015b . By tuning a Fabry-Perot cavity into resonance with a vibrational mode of PVAc molecules, a Raman enhancement of over two orders of magnitude was observed, along with two peaks attributed to vibro-polariton modes. These results sparked extensive follow-up studies using various cavity designs Takele et al. 2021 ; Ahn and Simpkins 2021 ; Menghrajani et al. 2022 ; Verdelli et al. 2022 , which, however, consistently reported only a single Raman peak at the bare vibrational frequency, with no evidence of polaritonic splitting or enhanced Raman scattering. The authors of Ref. Shalabney et al. 2015b argued in a subsequent paper Nagarajan et al. 2021 that surface-enhanced Raman scattering and modifications of the top mirror induced by laser interaction could alter the interpretation of their first results. In parallel, theoretical works based on Tavis-Cummings-like models del Pino et al. 2015 ; Strashko and Keeling 2016 with a single homogeneous cavity mode predicted polaritonic signatures in the Raman spectrum. The calculated intensities were similar to those in free space, failing to explain the large enhancement reported initially and contradicting later experiments. As a result, the mechanisms governing spontaneous Raman scattering under VSC remain highly debated and unresolved. Figure 1: N molecules are confined in a Fabry-Perot cavity of thickness L . (a) The cavity field is quantized along \hat{\mathbf{z}} , yielding discrete mode indices n . Raman scattering is driven by a laser of frequency \omega_{\mathrm{L}} and detected at frequency \omega_{\mathrm{S}} and angle \theta_{\mathrm{S}} , corresponding to polariton modes with indices n_{\mathrm{L}} and n_{\mathrm{S}} . Selection rules suppress the resonant polariton Raman peaks with n=1 . (b) Each molecule j has electronic and vibrational degrees of freedom: a ground-state vibrational mode \ket{v}_{j} of frequency \omega_{0} strongly coupled to the cavity, and excited-state vibrational modes \ket{w}_{j} of frequencies \omega_{w} weakly coupled to the cavity. In this Letter, we develop a microscopic quantum framework for spontaneous Raman scattering in Fabry-Perot cavities that explicitly incorporates the spatial structure of the cavity modes [Fig. 1 (a)]. Translational invariance parallel to the cavity plane enforces conservation of in-plane momentum. Along the cavity axis, the polariton inherits the spatial profile of the cavity mode resonant with the vibrational transition. Together with the mode structure of the incident and scattered fields, the polariton profile imposes additional selection rules. For a cavity homogeneously filled with molecules as in the original experiment Shalabney et al. 2015b , this polaritonic spatial structure, absent in standard Tavis-Cummings-like models, suppresses resonant polaritonic Raman peaks, fully consistent with most experimental observations. To modify the selection rules arising from the overlap between the coherent superposition of vibrations and the cavity modes involved in Raman scattering, we extend our analysis to a quasi-2d geometry in which a thin molecular layer is embedded at a fixed position along the cavity axis. This configuration permits Raman peaks at the polariton energies, in stark contrast to the homogeneous case. These results demonstrate that extended molecular coherence in polaritonic states play a pivotal role in shaping Raman scattering under VSC. Our work thus makes a significant contribution toward resolving the recent controversy surrounding the fate of spontaneous Raman scattering in strongly coupled systems and lays the groundwork for applying Raman spectroscopy to investigate strongly coupled quasi-2d materials. We consider a Fabry-Perot cavity formed by two mirrors separated by a distance L , which supports a set of quantized electromagnetic modes labeled by an in-plane wavevector \mathbf{q} and a mode index n\in\mathbb{N} , which reflects the breaking of translational invariance along the cavity axis z [Fig. 1 (a)]. The cavity contains N identical molecules, each located at an in-plane position \bm{\rho}_{j} and an axial position z_{j} . We use the Born-Oppenheimer framework, where a molecular wavefunction is factorized into electronic and nuclear components. We restrict the electronic structure to the two lowest manifolds: a ground state with zero energy and a first excited state at energy \hbar\omega_{\mathrm{e}} . The nuclear ground-state manifold consists of a single harmonic vibrational mode with frequency \omega_{0} , while the excited-state manifold includes multiple vibrational modes \ket{w}_{j} with energies \hbar\omega_{w} , which are nonresonantly coupled to the cavity [Fig. 1 (b)]. Given the typically low molecular densities in experiments Shalabney et al. 2015b ; Takele et al. 2021 ; Ahn and Simpkins 2021 ; Menghrajani et al. 2022 ; Verdelli et al. 2022 , intermolecular dipole-dipole interactions vary slowly in space and can