On energy and its positivity in spacetimes with an expanding flat de Sitter background
Rodrigo Avalos, Eric Ling, Annachiara Piubello · 2025
Read On energy and its positivity in spacetimes with an expanding flat de Sitter background by Rodrigo Avalos, Eric Ling, Annachiara Piubello (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01713.txt.
Introduction
Rodrigo Avalos, Eric Ling, and Annachiara Piubello revisit a pillar of mathematical relativity: the positive energy theorems, which say an isolated gravitating system cannot have negative total energy. The classic proofs assume the system fades into flat Minkowski space at infinity, but real astrophysical objects sit inside an expanding universe, not empty stillness.
The authors take de Sitter space as the background. It is written in flat expanding coordinates. Each time slice there is a flat space, stretched with a special, umbilic second fundamental form. Because de Sitter space has a cosmological horizon, no global energy exists, so they define a quasi-local energy by adapting the Liu-Yau energy to this setting. They then establish that the energy is positive for bounded values. The values lie in the regime they analyze. This extends the spirit of the classical theorems to an expanding cosmos.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rodrigo Avalos, Eric Ling, Annachiara Piubello |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01713
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On energy and its positivity in spacetimes with an expanding flat de Sitter background Rodrigo Avalos, Eric Ling, Annachiara Piubello Abstract . The positive energy theorems are a fundamental pillar in mathematical general relativity. Originally proved by Schoen–Yau and later Witten, these theorems were established for asymptotically flat manifolds where the metric tends to the standard Euclidean metric and whose second fundamental form decays to zero at infinity. This ansatz on the metric and second fundamental form is motivated by the desire to model an isolated gravitational system with a Minkowski space background for the spacetime. However, actual astrophysical massive objects are not truly isolated but rather exist within an expanding cosmological universe, where the second fundamental form is umbilic. With this in mind, we seek a notion of energy for initial data sets with an umbilic second fundamental form. In this work, we present a definition of energy in such an expanding cosmological setting. Instead of Minkowski space, we take de Sitter space as the background spacetime, which, when written in flat-expanding coordinates, is foliated by umbilic hypersurfaces each isometric to Euclidean 3-space. This cosmological setting necessitates a quasi-local energy definition, as the presence of a cosmological horizon in de Sitter space obstructs a global one. We define energy in this quasi-local setting by adapting the Liu–Yau energy to our framework and establish positivity of this energy for certain bounded values of the cosmological constant. 1. Introduction Let ({M},{g}) be a four-dimensional spacetime, i.e., a time-oriented Lorentzian manifold. An initial data set is a quadruple (M,g,k,\lambda) , where M is a spacelike hypersurface, g is the metric induced on M , k is the second fundamental form of M in {M} , and \lambda is a constant. We note that the pair (g,k) may depend on \lambda . In what follows we assume that \lambda\geq 0. When \lambda=0 , we adopt the classical notation (M,g,k) . In particular, if u is the future-directed unit timelike vector field, then, in our convention, (1) k(X,Y)=\langle\nabla_{X}u,Y\rangle, where X,Y are tangent vector fields on M and \nabla is the spacetime Levi-Civita connection. With this convention, a positive mean curvature of the slice corresponds to expansion towards the future. The initial data set must satisfy the Einstein constraint equations, which arise from the Gauss–Codazzi decomposition of the Einstein field equations. In the presence of a cosmological constant \Lambda=3\lambda^{2} , these constraints take the form: (2) \displaystyle 2\rho+2\Lambda \displaystyle=R_{g}+({\rm tr}_{g}k)^{2}-|k|_{g}^{2}, \displaystyle J \displaystyle={\rm div}_{g}\left[k-({\rm tr}_{g}k)g\right], where R_{g} is the scalar curvature of the induced metric g , \rho denotes the energy density, and J is the momentum density of the matter fields. An initial data set is said to satisfy the dominant energy condition with respect to \Lambda if the inequality (3) \rho\geq|J|_{g} holds. We remark that the dominant energy condition used here is derived from the spacetime dominant energy condition applied to the stress-energy tensor {T}=\mathcal{G}+\Lambda{g}, where \mathcal{G} is the Einstein tensor associated with {g} . Specifically, we require that for every future-directed timelike vector {v} , the vector -{T}({v},\cdot)^{\sharp} is also future-directed timelike. Consequently, this dominant energy condition depends explicitly on \Lambda . This condition ensures that energy density dominates momentum flux, reflecting the physical requirement that energy flows cannot exceed the speed of light. If \Lambda\geq 0 and the dominant energy condition with \Lambda holds, then the geometrical energy density \mu satisfies (4) \mu:=\rho+\Lambda\geq|J|_{g}. Note that this is the dominant energy condition without \Lambda . Moreover, \mu is determined entirely by the geometry of the initial data: (5) \mu=\frac{1}{2}\bigg(R_{g}+({\rm tr}_{g}k)^{2}-|k|_{g}^{2}\bigg). Noether’s theorem (see [ Arn89 ] ), loosely speaking, states that conserved quantities correspond to symmetries of the system. Therefore, to define conserved quantities such as energy in general relativity, we look for global symmetries of the spacetime. These symmetries are generated by Killing vector fields, which are vector fields that preserve the metric along their flow (i.e. they generate isometries of the spacetime). In particular, a timelike Killing vector field corresponds to a time-translation symmetry and, by Noether’s theorem, gives rise to a conserved energy. However, most spacetimes do not possess such global symmetries. This is why asymptotically Minkowskian spacetimes are of particular interest: in these spacetimes the geometry approaches Minkowski space at infinity, where a timelike Killing vector field exists. This asymptotic symmetry provides the structure needed to define a conserved energy at infinity. The ADM energy [ ADM61 ] E_{\mathrm{ADM}} plays a central role in the analysis of asymptotically flat spacetimes. It is derived from the Hamiltonian formulation of general relativity under the assumption of a fixed Minkowski background. It provides a notion of total energy for an isolated gravitational system and is invariant under asymptotically flat coordinate transformations [ Bar86 , Chr88 ] . This invariance guarantees that the energy is well-defined independently of the observer’s coordinate choice at infinity. The ADM energy is defined for initial data sets (M,g,k,\lambda=0) that satisfy specific fall-off conditions at spatial infinity, namely: (6) g_{ij}=\delta_{ij}+O_{2}(|x|^{-\tau}),\qquad k_{ij}=O_{1}(|x|^{-1-\tau}), where \tau>\frac{1}{2} . These asymptotic conditions ensure that the metric g approaches the flat Euclidean metric and that the extrinsic curvature k decays appropriately. Assuming integrability of \mu and J , the energy is then defined as (7) E_{\mathrm{ADM}}=\frac{1}{16\pi}\lim_{r\to\infty}\int_{S_{r}}\sum_{i,j}\left(\partial_{i}g_{ij}-\partial_{j}g_{ii}\right)\frac{x_{j}}{r}\,d\mu_{\delta}, where d\mu_{\delta} denotes the area measure on the coordinate sphere S_{r}=\{|\mathbf{x}|=r\} induced by the Euclidean metric \delta . We remark that in this setting also the linear momentum and ADM mass would be well defined. A fundamental result in mathematical relativity is the Positive Energy Theorem . It was first proved for the time symmetric case k\equiv 0 independently by Schoen and Yau [ SY79 ] and Witten [ Wit81 ] . It was later extended for the case of a general k with appropriate asymptotic decay by Schoen and Yau [ SY81a , SY81b ] . The theorem states that, under the assumption that the dominant energy condition holds, the ADM energy is non-negative: (8) E_{\mathrm{ADM}}\geq 0. Equality occurs if and only if the initial data (M,g,k) arises from a spacelike slice of flat Minkowski spacetime. Extensions of the positive energy theorem exist for other asymptotic geometries. In the case \Lambda<0 , corresponding to asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds, the notion of energy was introduced by Wang [ Wan01 ] and further developed by Chruściel and Herzlich [ CH03 ] . The Riemannian positive mass theorem in this setting was proven under the assumption that the manifold is spin in [ Wan01 , CH03 ] . The positivity of the energy in the hyperboloidal, non-spin case has been established by Sakovich (see [ Sak21 ] and references therein). When \Lambda>0 , the situation becomes more delicate. A Positive Energy Theorem in this setting has been established by Borghini and Mazzieri [ BM18 , BM20 ] for compact static metrics. We also note the connection with rigidity and the Min–Oo conjecture (see [ BMN11 ] , where it was shown to be false). In contrast with [ BM18 , BM20 ] , our focus is on umbilic initial data sets, which are not static. The question we want to address is how to describe isolated gravitational systems within an expanding universe. Observational evidence of the accelerated expansion of the universe strongly supports a cosmological model with a positive cosmological