Thermodynamic nature of upbend resonance and validity of Brink-Axel hypothesis in the low-energy region

L. Tan Phuc, N. Quang Hung, N. Ngoc Anh, N. Dinh Dang · 2025

Read Thermodynamic nature of upbend resonance and validity of Brink-Axel hypothesis in the low-energy region by L. Tan Phuc, N. Quang Hung, N. Ngoc Anh, N. Dinh Dang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01696.txt.

Introduction

L. Tan Phuc, N. Quang Hung, N. Ngoc Anh, and N. Dinh Dang investigate a puzzling bump in how atomic nuclei emit gamma rays at low energies. This upbend resonance in the radiative strength function matters for neutron capture rates and stellar nucleosynthesis, yet its origin is still debated.

Extending an exact thermal pairing plus phonon damping model, the authors compute strength functions for nuclei from scandium-44 to samarium-153 across odd-odd, odd-mass, and even-even systems, matching the available measurements. The upbend, they find, comes from non-collective particle-particle and hole-hole excitations about three times stronger than the giant dipole resonance. Because it appears only at finite temperature in their framework, the upbend breaks the Brink-Axel hypothesis at very low gamma energies, and a global relation ties its integrated strength to mass number.

Catalog record

CREATORL. Tan Phuc, N. Quang Hung, N. Ngoc Anh, N. Dinh Dang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01696

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Thermodynamic nature of upbend resonance and validity of Brink-Axel hypothesis in the low-energy region L. Tan Phuc, N. Quang Hung, N. Ngoc Anh, N. Dinh Dang Abstract The nature of low-energy enhancement in the radiative strength function (RSF), which is known as the upbend resonance (UBR) and has a crucial role in the description of neutron-captured cross section and stellar nucleosynthesis, is still under debate. The present letter extends the exact thermal pairing plus phonon damping model to explore the microscopic nature of the UBR and its thermodynamic origin over a wide mass range of odd-odd, odd-A, and even-even systems, from 44 Sc to 153 Sm, whose experimental RSFs, including the UBRs, are available. The results of our calculations indicate that the UBR originates from non-collective particle-particle and hole-hole excitations with a strength three times stronger than that of the giant dipole resonance. Moreover, our results reveal that the UBR, which emerges only at finite temperatures within the present framework, invalidates the Brink-Axel hypothesis in the very low E γ E_{\gamma} region. Last but not least, a global relation between the integrated strength of the RSF in the UBR region to that of the total RSF and the mass number is reported, for the first time, within the present study. The radiative strength function (RSF) or \gamma -rays strength function (gSF or \gamma SF) quantifies the probability that a compound nucleus decays by emitting \gamma -rays Batholomew1973 . This quantity plays a crucial role in the statistical description of \gamma -rays-induced reactions, such as the (n, \gamma ) one. The RSF serves as an essential input for numerous nuclear reactions and nuclear astrophysics calculations Koning ; Rauscher1 ; Rauscher2 ; Arnould , particularly those employing the Hauser-Feshbach model HauserFeshbach . However, limited experimental data necessitate the use of theoretical RSFs Goriely2019 . To develop a reliable RSF model, a deep understanding of its underlying physical mechanism is of paramount importance. Experimental RSFs reveal diverse nuclear structural behaviors, mostly nuclear resonances. The latter include the giant dipole resonance (GDR) at high energy ( E_{\gamma}\sim 15-20 MeV) Baldwin1947 and lower-energy resonances such as M 1 spin-flip resonance Kopecky1993 , pygmy dipole resonance (PDR) Nyhus , scissor resonance (SR) Voinov2001 , and upbend resonance (UBR) Voinov2004 ; Larsen2013 . First observed in 56,57 Fe Voinov2004 and later identified in several nuclei from 43 Sc Burger2012 to 153 Sm Simon2016 , the UBR exhibits an unexpected exponential enhancement in the RSF as E_{\gamma} approaches zero. Although it mainly affects the low-energy region (typically at E_{\gamma}\leq 3 MeV), the UBR significantly impacts the (n, \gamma ) cross-sections and astrophysical reaction rates with discrepancies exceeding an order of magnitude in neutron-rich nuclei Larsen2010 ; Spyrou2024 . Despite extensive studies during the last two decades, the microscopic origin of the UBR remains an open topic. Finding the origin of the UBR is challenging as its existence in the very low E_{\gamma} region seems impossible to be comprehended in theory. No corresponding strength is expected in the ground-state absorption experiments in even-even nuclei due to the pairing property of the nuclear force Markova2021 ; Litvinova2013 . However, experimental data have revealed the presence of the UBR in many even-even nuclei Voinov2004 ; Larsen2013 . Theoretical descriptions of the UBR are often approached based on the mean field and shell model (SM) calculations. Within the mean-field approaches, attempts have been made to attribute the origin of the UBR to the electric dipole ( E1 ) transitions at finite temperature by using the thermal continuum quasiparticle-random-phase approximation (TCQRPA) Litvinova2013 and finite-temperature relativistic time blocking approximation (FT-RTBA) Wibowo . The obtained results, although showing an enhancement of RSF at low E_{\gamma} , cannot convincingly describe the whole experimental RSF data. Recent advanced calculations using combined many-body methods, such as static-path approximation plus RPA (SPA+RPA), quasiparticle RPA (QRPA) with and without temperature dependence, shell-model Monte Carlo (SMMC) with maximum entropy method (MEM) Alhassid1 ; Alhassid2 ; Alhassid3 ; Frosini1 ; Frosini2 , which treat the UBR as M1 transitions, face similar limitations. Within the SM framework, the M1 nature of the UBR has been insistently suggested. However, the origin of these M1 transitions is still under debate and falls into two main interpretations. The foremost SM study for Mo isotopes Schwengner tied the UBR to the recoupling of spins of protons and neutrons with high- j orbitals, which is similar to the shears mechanism in magnetic rotation Frauendorf2001 . A later study for Ge isotopes Frauendorf2022 revealed that the UBR is strongest near closed shells, especially at the almost completely filled 1 g_{9/2} orbitals. Alternatively, a competing interpretation suggested that the strong low-energy M 1 transitions in 56,57 Fe nuclei are generated by the high- l terms in the 0 \hbar\omega transitions Brown . Other SM-based studies Schwegner2017 ; Midtb2018 ; Larsen2018 ; Fanto2024 proposed the coexistence of the UBR and the well-known SR. Nevertheless, the connection between the shears-like mechanism, which is supposed to cause the UBR, and the scissors vibration Iudice1978 , which generates the SR, remains unclear, despite both involving the neutron-proton reorientation. The latest advancement Chen , employing an angular-momentum-projected SM, has proposed that the UBR originates from a quasi-free scissors motion occurring only in weakly deformed nuclei, similar to free-rotation of neutrons with respect to protons. This mode is introduced as a new type of collective mode called scissors rotation. However, three limitations still remain in this study, namely i) the UBR has been observed in not only weakly deformed nuclei but also well-deformed ones, such as 151,153 Sm Simon2016 ; ii) only three Nd isotopes evidence its broad validity claim; and iii) theoretical descriptions of the UBR do not closely match experimental data (see Fig. 1 of Ref. Chen ). In the RSF study, the Brink-Axel hypothesis (BAH) BAH , which generally states that the RSF does not depend on the energies, spins and parities of initial and final states (it depends on E_{\gamma} only), is also a topic of interest. Although the BAH plays an important role in both fundamental and applied nuclear physics, its validity, despite confirmations from various studies Oslodata ; Markova2021 ; BAHtestexp1 ; BAHtestexp2 ; BAHtestexp3 ; BAHtestexp4 ; BAHtestexp5 ; BAHtesttheor1 ; BAHtesttheor2 ; BAHtesttheor3 ; BAHtesttheor4 , remains uncertain with open questions persisting, especially in the context of nuclear astrophysics Nabi ; Farooq ; Herrera ; Sieja2023 ; Misch ; HungPRL ; Johnson ; Angell ; Isaak2013 ; Isaak2019 ; Netterdon ; Wasilewska . Recent studies highlight deviations exceeding three orders of magnitude related to the use of BAH in calculating the stellar electron capture and \beta- decay rates at high temperature and high matter density Nabi ; Farooq . Given these uncertainties, validating the BAH is crucial for improving the RSF models and their applications. While the BAH seems to be well-established in the GDR region, its validity in lower energy regions ( E_{\gamma}\leq B_{n} ), such as the PDR and below, remains debated. Currently, as mentioned, only the SM Schwengner ; Brown ; Chen have successfully explained the UBR formation, whose results do not conflict with the BAH, but several studies have shown that the BAH is hardly valid in such a low-energy region Sieja2023 ; Misch

Read the complete text