Semiclassical Gravity Beyond General Relativity: Insights from Torsion
R. Morales-Cabrera, Y. Bonder · 2025
Read Semiclassical Gravity Beyond General Relativity: Insights from Torsion by R. Morales-Cabrera, Y. Bonder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01684.txt.
Introduction
R. Morales-Cabrera and Y. Bonder build a semiclassical theory of gravity in which spacetime can twist as well as curve. Torsion, the twisting part of the connection, appears in Einstein-Cartan theory, a classical modification of general relativity. Semiclassical gravity treats matter quantum mechanically while gravity stays classical, and the question is whether that hybrid can be made consistent once torsion is present.
Working with a free Klein-Gordon field coupled non-minimally in four dimensions, the authors show the theory can be axiomatized. Hadamard renormalization gives well-defined expectation values for the energy-momentum and spin-density operators, the two sources torsion couples to. They identify the renormalization ambiguities by building a renormalization Lagrangian from differential forms, and they confirm that the conformal anomaly persists even with torsion switched on.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. Morales-Cabrera, Y. Bonder |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01684
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Semiclassical Gravity Beyond General Relativity: Insights from Torsion R. Morales-Cabrera, Y. Bonder Abstract We develop a semiclassical theory of modified gravity with nontrivial spacetime torsion. In particular, we show that the semiclassical treatment can be axiomatized in the case of Einstein–Cartan theory with a nonminimally coupled, free Klein–Gordon field, in four dimensions. Using Hadamard renormalization, we obtain well-defined expectation values for both, the energy–momentum and spin–density operators. These objects exhibit scale and renormalization ambiguities; we identify the latter by constructing a renormalization Lagrangian in terms of differential forms, which are particularly well suited for this purpose. Furthermore, we analyze the conformal anomaly, which persists in the presence of torsion. 1 Introduction General Relativity (GR) is the currently accepted theory of gravity. In this framework, gravity is interpreted as the curvature of spacetime, and the spacetime metric, which is the only gravitational field, is determined by Einstein’s equations. In turn, these equations are sourced by the matter energy–momentum tensor. GR has been experimentally confirmed to a high degree of precision [ 1 ] . However, several open questions remain, such as the nature of dark matter and dark energy [ 2 ] , and the possible resolution of singularities [ 3 ] . Attempts to address these issues often invoke modified gravity theories [ 4 ] . Prominent examples are f(R) models [ 5 ] , scalar–tensor theories [ 6 ] , and Chern–Simons gravity [ 7 ] , as well as frameworks where the spacetime geometry is not fully determined by the metric. The latter includes Einstein–Cartan theory [ 8 , 9 ] , which incorporates a nontrivial spacetime torsion. The inclusion of torsion leads to theories with interesting properties. For instance, torsion can modify the singularity theorems [ 10 ] and alter the behavior of the early Universe [ 11 ] . Moreover, it allows for an energy–momentum tensor that, in general, is not divergence-free [ 8 ] . Importantly, the empirical success of GR does not rule out the presence of torsion. In fact, Einstein–Cartan theory reproduces all experimentally tested predictions of GR [ 12 ] . Whas is more, within the framework of the Standard Model, possible signatures of torsion can be sought as new interactions involving polarized Dirac spinors [ 13 ] . A fundamental assumption in any theory of gravity, including GR and Einstein–Cartan theory, is that all matter fields are classical. However, matter is most accurately described by quantum mechanics. Indeed, quantum field theory provides some of the most precise experimental validations of any physical theory to date [ 14 ] . Nevertheless, gravitational interactions have not been consistently incorporated into the quantum framework. This is mostly due to conceptual issues arising from Einstein’s equations: the “left-hand side” involves the metric tensor, a classical field, while the “right-hand side” depends on matter, described by quantum fields. This inconsistency, together with other considerations [ 15 ] , points to the need for a more fundamental theory, commonly referred to as quantum gravity. Despite extensive efforts, including candidates such as string theory [ 16 ] and loop quantum gravity [ 17 ] , no fully satisfactory formulation of quantum gravity has been achieved. A relevant question, therefore, is how to incorporate certain quantum aspects of the matter description into gravity. One approach is to consider quantum field theory in curved spacetime (QFTCS) [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . In this framework, the geometry is fixed and quantum matter fields propagate on it. Although QFTCS has provided profound theoretical insights, such as the Unruh effect [ 24 ] and Hawking radiation [ 25 ] , additional steps are required to account for the influence of quantum matter on spacetime geometry. One possibility is semiclassical gravity [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] , where gravity is sourced by the expectation values of quantum matter fields. Notably, even though QFTCS does not include quantum aspects of gravity, semiclassical gravity remains the most fundamental description of nature currently available. In this work, we adopt a semiclassical perspective. We assume that if a modified theory of gravity improves upon GR, its semiclassical extension should provide an even closer approximation to a fundamental description of nature. It is therefore essential to investigate whether modified gravity theories can be axiomatized and whether the methods of Hadamard renormalization can be extended to them. As a first step in this direction, we address these questions within Einstein–Cartan theory. We organize the paper as follows. In Sec. 2 , we provide a brief overview of semiclassical gravity and introduce some technical aspects. Section 3 presents the Einstein–Cartan theory, and in Sec. 4 , we derive the corresponding Hadamard bi-parametrix. In Sec. 5 , which constitutes the core of the paper, we introduce the axiomatic framework employed in the renormalization scheme, identify the resulting ambiguities, and review the conformal anomaly. Finally, Sec. 6 contains our conclusions. Some useful expressions are collected in the Appendix. Throughout this work, we use units where c=\hbar=G=1 , except in Subsec. 5.3 where G\neq 1 . Abstract spacetime indices are denoted by lowercase Latin letters from the beginning of the alphabet. We consider a four-dimensional spacetime and use the metric g_{ab} and its inverse g^{ab} to lower and raise indices, respectively. We adopt the metric signature (-+++) and follow the curvature conventions of Ref. [ 29 ] . Symmetrization (antisymmetrization) is indicated by enclosing indices in parentheses (brackets), with a factor of 1/n! , where n is the number of indices involved, excluding those between vertical bars. Finally, we assume that all fields are smooth and that spacetime is globally hyperbolic. 2 Preliminaries In semiclassical GR, the equations of motion are [ 22 ] \mathring{G}_{ab}=8\pi\omega(\tau_{ab}), (1) where the left-hand side denotes the Einstein tensor constructed purely from the metric (we use the ring throughout the text to indicate quantities that only depend on the metric), and the right-hand side represents the expectation value, in a given state, of the operator associated with the energy–momentum tensor. In this way, both sides of Eq. ( 1 ) are tensorial fields. We begin by discussing the left-hand side of Eq. ( 1 ). The metric curvature tensor, {\mathring{R}_{abc}}^{\ \ \ d} , is constructed using the torsion-free and metric-compatible derivative operator \mathring{\nabla}_{a} . These two properties mean, respectively, that (\mathring{\nabla}_{a}\mathring{\nabla}_{b}-\mathring{\nabla}_{b}\mathring{\nabla}_{a})f=0, (2) for any scalar function f , and \mathring{\nabla}_{c}g_{ab}=0. (3) The only nontrivial trace of {\mathring{R}_{abc}}^{\ \ \ d} is \mathring{R}_{ab}={\mathring{R}_{acb}}^{\ \ \ c} , which defines the Ricci tensor and satisfies \mathring{R}_{ab}=\mathring{R}_{ba} . Moreover, the trace of the Ricci tensor is the Ricci scalar, \mathring{R}=g^{ab}\mathring{R}_{ab} . Finally, the Einstein tensor is given by \mathring{G}_{ab}=\mathring{R}_{ab}-\frac{1}{2}\mathring{R}g_{ab}. (4) Regarding the right-hand side of Eq. ( 1 ), there are some technical subtleties. In the particular case of a free Klein–Gordon field \Phi , which we consider for simplicity, its associated energy–momentum tensor is quadratic in \Phi [ 29 ] . However, upon quantization this expression becomes ill-defined, since the corresponding “quantum object,” \hat{\Phi} , is an operator-valued distribution. In other words, \hat{\Phi} only becomes an operator after acting on a test function. Hence, an expression such as \hat{\Phi}^{2}[f]=\hat{\Phi}[\hat{\Phi}[f]], (5) where f is a test function, is not well-defined.