Incorrect Citation Association for Articles in Online-Only Springer Nature Journals

Tamás Kriváchy · 2025

Read Incorrect Citation Association for Articles in Online-Only Springer Nature Journals by Tamás Kriváchy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01675.txt.

Introduction

Tamás Kriváchy documents a data bug quietly corrupting citation counts across many online-only Springer Nature journals, including Scientific Reports, Nature Communications, the Communications and npj families, and many BMC titles. The errors reach back to articles from 2001.

Most likely caused by an API response error in the publisher's metadata, countless references point wrongly at Article Number 1 of a volume. The fallout is lopsided: a few articles are massively over-cited while many others lose citations they earned. In both Scientific Reports and Nature Communications, five of the ten most-cited articles carry article number 1. Kriváchy cross-checked the distortion in Crossref, OpenCitations, Semantic Scholar, and the journals' own sites, and traces the cause to the messy shift from page numbers to article numbers.

Catalog record

CREATORTamás Kriváchy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01675

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Incorrect Citation Association for Articles in Online-Only Springer Nature Journals Tamás Kriváchy Abstract We show that citation metrics of journal articles in many of the online-only Springer Nature journals and associated ones are distorted, going back to articles from 2001. We find that most likely due to an API response error, there are many incorrect references which typically lead to Article Number 1 of a given Volume. Among others, the issue affects journals such as Scientific Reports, Nature Communications, Communications journals, Cell Death & Disease, Light: Science & Applications, as well as many BMC, Discovery and npj journals. Beyond the negative effect of introducing incorrect reference information, this distorts the citation statistics of articles in these journals, with a few articles being massively over-cited compared to their peers, while many lose citations; e.g. both in Scientific Reports and in Nature Communications, 5 of the 10 top cited articles have article numbers of 1. We validate the distorted statistics by assessing data from multiple scientific literature databases: Crossref, OpenCitations, Semantic Scholar, and the journals’ websites. The issue primarily arises from the inconsistent transition from page-based referencing of articles to article number-based referencing, as well as the improper handling of the change in the publisher’s article metadata API. It seems that the most pressing problem has been present since approximately 2011, which we estimate affects the citation count of millions of authors. I Introduction For better or worse, citation metrics have been a cornerstone of evaluating the impact and relevance of scientific research, particularly since the mid-20th century. The precise number of citations an article receives, i.e. how many other articles reference it, can be difficult to determine exactly and varies from source to source Sweetland 1989 ; Li et al. 2010 ; Franceschini et al. 2016a ; Franceschini et al. 2016b ; Meho and Yang 2007 ; Kratochvíl 2017 ; Martín-Martín et al. 2018 ; Yang and Meho 2006 ; Franceschini et al. 2013 ; van Eck and Waltman 2019 ; Kumpulainen and Seppänen 2022 ; Buchanan 2006 . Regardless of the exact method, having a database without major errors is a crucial element in evaluating the impact of scientific research. The most crucial step in reducing these errors would be to have correct references in research articles, which unfortunately is not always the case Key and Roland 1977 ; Eichorn and Yankauer 1987 ; Doms 1989 ; Foreman and Kirchhoff 1987 ; Kristof 1997 ; de Lacey et al. 1985 ; Schulmeister 1998 ; Lawson and Fosker 1999 ; Siebers and Holt 2000 ; O’Connor and Kristof 2001 ; Oermann et al. 2002 ; Gosling et al. 2004 ; Wyles 2004 ; Aronsky et al. 2005 ; Taylor 1998 ; Spivey and Wilks 2004 ; Davies 2012 ; Jergas and Baethge 2015 . Among the many challenges that are encountered when having to handle references, a seemingly simple yet significant one is the transition from paper-based scientific journals to fully online ones. In an attempt to make references clearer and more concise, many online-only journals reference articles via a single “article number” instead of using the pages they appear on in the journal. A print-first journal may have a reference such as Author A, Author B. Fascinating article title. Nature 777, 8888–8898 (2100) where we used 777 as an example Volume Number, 8888 as the Start Page and 8898 as the End Page and 2100 as the year of publication. In contrast, more modern, online-only journals often use the format Author A, Author B. Fascinating article title. Nature Communications 777, 999 (2100) where we used Volume 777 and Article Number 999 as an example. Figure 1: Citation count histogram for Nature Communications Volume 16 (the volume of the current year, 2025) according to Crossref for articles that were published on the same day as Article Number 1 of this volume (data as of 2nd of October 2025). The citation count for Article Number 1 in Vol. 16 is depicted with the dashed red line. Here, we report on a large number of wrongly attributed citations of articles published in journals belonging to or in relation to the Springer Nature Group, which may affect both database handling and correct reference generation. Based on our analysis, the mis-citations happen primarily due to the above adaptation from a page-based numbering to an article number-based one; more specifically, from the improper technical handling of the change. The problem seems to stem from the absence of the Article Number in most formats of the article metadata obtained through the SpringerLink Application Programming Interface (API), or possibly from the handling of the fields in RIS file format provided by the publisher on Springer Nature Link websites. The dominating result is that many times instead of attributing a citation to Article X of Volume V , it is attributed to Article 1 of Volume V , though sometimes it may be attributed to another low number, as we detail later. Consider, for example, Nature Communications, whose volume numbers have been incremented yearly since 2018. There, the first article to be published in each year typically gets attributed much more citations, whereas the other articles lose those citations; see Fig. 1 for the year 2025 up to here. This effect is robust across various citation count data providers, and is also an issue on the journals’ websites themselves. It also seems to be an issue for all online-only journals using article numbers on SpringerLink. The phenomenon can have countless effects ranging from the inefficient functioning of scientific literature networks, to the improper gauging of scientists’ merits, impacting their prestige in the field and how they are judged when it comes to e.g. conference invites, grant and position applications. The manuscript is structured as follows. In Sec. II we introduce the technical issues on SpringerLink which we believe could cause problems in citation networks. In Sec. III we discuss the effects we observed in mistaken citation and distorted citation counts. In Sec. IV we gauge the scope of the problem. Finally, in Sec. V we finish with a discussion. In the Appendices, we provide examples that support the findings. II Technical issue When exporting a citation from Springer Nature websites, the default and only export option is a file prepared in RIS format. In this format there is no dedicated field for Article Number, hence the Article Number (for those journals which use this) is placed in the Start Page (SP field), each article receives Issue Number (IS) 1 and the End Page (EP) field is not provided in all online-only articles we have seen. Hence, even if one is unaware of the use of Article Numbers, each article may be interpreted as being a single-page digital article starting on page SP of the given Volume. Article numbers are typically incremented by 1, so the subsequently published article will have an Article Number of 1 larger. The typical user encounters only the previously detailed citation export when using Springer Nature websites. However, if one uses the SpringerLink API provided by the publisher to extract article information in JSON format (one of the most popular formats), one encounters the terrifying fact that the Article Number is not present among the

Read the complete text