2D or not 2D:

a “holographic dictionary” for Lowest Landau Levels · 2025

Read 2D or not 2D: by a “holographic dictionary” for Lowest Landau Levels (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01630.txt.

Introduction

Gautam Mandal, Ajay Mohan, and Rushikesh Suroshe build a dictionary between two descriptions of electrons in a magnetic field. Two-dimensional fermions in a perpendicular field organize into Landau levels. Restricting to the lowest level turns the plane itself into a phase space. The two coordinates no longer commute. The usual quantization recipe, in terms of one coordinate, then fails.

The authors instead construct a one-dimensional quantum mechanics. It sits inside the two-dimensional one and captures lowest-level physics exactly. It includes a precise correspondence between the 2D fermion density and the 1D Wigner distribution. In a large-N limit the correspondence becomes an identity and yields an upper bound on the fermion density, a direct Pauli-exclusion effect. Entanglement entropy of subregions behaves unlike either conventional 1D or 2D systems, a fingerprint of the noncommutative space.

Catalog record

CREATORa “holographic dictionary” for Lowest Landau Levels
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE126 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01630

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

2D or not 2D: a “holographic dictionary” for Lowest Landau Levels Abstract We consider two-dimensional fermions on a plane with a perpendicular magnetic field, described by Landau levels. It is well-known that, semiclassically, restriction to the lowest Landau levels (LLL) amounts to imposing two constraints on a 4D phase space, which transforms the 2D coordinate space ( x , y ) (x,y) into a 2D phase space, thanks to the non-zero Dirac bracket between x x and y y . A straightforward application of Dirac’s prescription of quantizing LLL in terms of L 2 L^{2} functions of x x (or of y y ) fails because the wavefunctions are clearly functions of x x and y y . We find it possible, however, to construct a different 1D QM, sitting differently inside the 2D QM, which describes the LLL physics. The construction includes an exact 1D-2D correspondence between the fermion density ρ ⁡ ( x , y ) \rho(x,y) and the Wigner distribution of the 1D QM. In an appropriate large N N limit, (a) the Wigner distribution is upper bounded by 1, reflecting the semiclassical intuition that a phase space cell can have at most one fermion (Pauli exclusion principle) and (b) the 1D-2D correspondence becomes an identity transformation. (a) and (b) then imply an upper bound for the fermion density ρ ⁡ ( x , y ) \rho(x,y) which verifies known facts from LLL physics. We also explore the entanglement entropy (EE) of subregions of the 2D noncommutative space which displays behaviour distinct from conventional 2D systems as well as from conventional 1D systems, falling somewhere between the two. The main distinguishing feature of the EE, which is directly attributable to the noncommutative nature of space, is the absence of a logarithmic dependence on the size of the entangling region, even though there is a Fermi surface. In this paper, instead of working directly with the Landau problem, we consider a more general problem, namely 2D fermions in a rotating harmonic trap, which reduces to the Landau problem in a special limit. Among other consequences of the emergent 1D physics, we find that post-quench dynamics of the (generalized) LLL system is computed more simply in 1D terms, which is described by well-developed methods of 2D phase space hydrodynamics (see, e.g. [ 1 ] for a recent application). 1 Introduction and Summary Classically it is argued that an electron moving in a lowest Landau level (LLL) 1 1 1 Landau levels refer to energy levels of electrons on a plane with a constant, perpendicular magnetic field. This system and its generalizations are described in detail in Appenndix A and Section 2 . has a 2D phase space description [ 2 , 3 ] . The argument is that the LLL constraints (two in number) reduce the original 4D phase space to 2D. The 2D reduced phase space can be coordinatized by the original coordinates (x,y) themselves, since they develop a nontrivial Dirac bracket (see, e.g. [ 4 ] and the review in Appendix B ): namely, \{x,y\}_{{}_{DB}}=\varepsilon\equiv\frac{1}{2mw} . Ordinarily, the appearance of such a symplectic structure in the ( x,y ) plane would lead one to expect the following: (a) The LLL system should be describable in terms of a 1D QM in which 2 2 2 following Dirac’s prescription of quantizing a constrained system [ 4 , 5 ] . the Dirac bracket goes over to a commutator bracket: \displaystyle[x,y]=i\hbar\varepsilon\equiv i\hbar_{\rm eff},\quad\hbar_{\rm eff}=\hbar\varepsilon={\frac{\hbar}{2m\omega}}. (1.1) In other words, the LLL Hilbert space H_{LLL} should be describable by square integrable ( L^{2} ) functions of x , on which y behaves as -i\hbar_{\rm eff}{\frac{\partial}{\partial x}} . 3 3 3 or, by L^{2} functions of y on which x behaves as i\hbar_{\rm eff}{\frac{\partial}{\partial y}} . We will find that this does not work (see Section ( 2.3 ) for details and to see what version of the equation ( 1.1 ) does work out). 4 4 4 Note the contrast with gauge theories where the constraints define the full Hilbert space and the Dirac brackets do go over to commutator brackets. (b) Since (x,y) is supposed to behave like a phase space, one would expect that the fermion density \rho(x,y) for an N -fermion state should obey an upper bound following from the Pauli exclusion principle, namely that a phase space cell of size \hbar_{\rm eff} cannot hold more than one fermion. Quantitatively, one would expect \displaystyle 0\leq\langle\rho(x,y)\rangle\leq\rho_{\rm max},\quad\rho_{\rm max}={\frac{1}{\hbar_{\rm eff}}}={\frac{2m\omega}{\hbar}} (1.2) We will find that, even though (a) does not hold, (b) does hold in a suitable semiclassical limit (see Section ( 4 ) for details). This is a puzzle: if (a) does not hold, that would appear to imply that quantum mechanically x and y are not conjugate variables; in that case, how does Pauli exclusion principle still hold for fermions in the (x,y) plane? This is one of the main questions we explore in this paper. The answer to this question is based on the fact that there is a different 1D QM sitting inside the full Hilbert space (in terms of a coordinate which is neither x nor y , see ( 3.1 ), ( 3.2 )), which is isomorphic to the LLL Hilbert space. This allows us to derive a 1D-2D correspondence which leads to expressions for LLL observables in terms of this specific 1D QM. In particular, it leads to an exact expression for the fermion density \langle\rho(x,y)\rangle in LLL states in terms of (an integral transform of) the corresponding Wigner function of the 1D problem (see ( 3.9 ), ( 4.16 )). We find that in the semiclassical limit implemented by large N (see ( 4.12 )), the above integral transform between the fermion density and the 1D Wigner function becomes an identity transformation (see, e.g. ( 4.25 )). In this limit, the phase space corresponding to the 1D QM gets identified with (x,y) and the corresponding 1D Wigner function obeys an upper bound of 1 (where the bound is saturated for single Slater states 5 5 5 By a Slater state, we refer to an N -particle state whose wavefunction \Psi can be written as a Slater determinant of N single-particle wavefunctions \psi_{i} : \Psi(\vec{x}_{1},...,\vec{x}_{N})={\rm Det}_{i,k}[\psi_{i}(\vec{x}_{k})] . In the second quantized notation this is a Fock space state of the form |F\rangle=c^{\dagger}_{\psi_{N}}...c^{\dagger}_{\psi_{1}}|0\rangle. ). Consequently, \rho(x,y) satisfies ( 1.2 ) above, since it gets identified with the Wigner function \left(\text{times}{\frac{1}{\hbar_{\rm eff}}}\right) . Besides the above question of the bound, the 1D-2D correspondence allows us to address dynamical questions of the LLL system in 1D terms, which is described by well-developed methods of 2D phase space hydrodynamics (see, e.g. [ 1 ] for a recent application). In this paper, we also discuss if the effective 1D property of the LLL system is reflected in the ground state entanglement entropy (EE) of a subregion 6 6 6 Taken to be disc shaped for simplicity. of size R of the (x,y) plane, where the Fermi energy is well within the LLL band. Unlike in a conventional free fermion system with a Fermi surface (such as free fermions in a 2D harmonic trap), where the EE is supposed to go as R\log R , in the LLL context

Read the complete text