Scalar self-force effects in neutral W W -soliton backgrounds

Massimo Bianchi 1 , Donato Bini 2 , Giorgio Di Russo 3 · 2025

Read Scalar self-force effects in neutral W W -soliton backgrounds by Massimo Bianchi 1 , Donato Bini 2 , Giorgio Di Russo 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01402.txt.

Introduction

Massimo Bianchi, Donato Bini, and Giorgio Di Russo examine the W-soliton, a recently found solution in gravitational theory, in its neutral form. They work with both the genuine five-dimensional version and its reduction to four dimensions, comparing what the two share and where they part ways.

Much of the study follows particles moving through this background. The authors reconstruct the scattering angle for massless and massive particles, using exact formulas where possible and expansions they show how to sum up neatly. They then send a test scalar field through the soliton, compute its quasi-normal mode spectrum, and derive a fully analytic result for the radiated energy in a post-Newtonian expansion.

Catalog record

CREATORMassimo Bianchi 1 , Donato Bini 2 , Giorgio Di Russo 3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01402

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scalar self-force effects in neutral W W -soliton backgrounds Massimo Bianchi 1 , Donato Bini 2 , Giorgio Di Russo 3 Abstract We investigate several geometrical and physical properties of the recently found W W -soliton solution (neutral case). We discuss both the genuine 5d solution and its reduction to 4d and highlight similarities and differences. In both cases, we study scattering processes of massless and massive particles in the background, reconstructing the gauge-invariant scattering angle, either with exact expressions or with large-angular momentum expansion expressions, which we show how to resum in a useful form. Finally, we analyze the propagation of a test scalar field in the W W -soliton background and compute the spectrum of Quasi Normal Modes in the case of (non-)minimal coupling and the radiated energy in the case of minimal coupling. Our result for the energy loss is fully analytic and presented in a Post-Newtonian expansion, following the approach termed gravitational self force. I Introduction Finding viable descriptions for the micro-states of (neutral, rotating) Black Holes (BHs) is a very active endeavour Lunin:2001jy ; Bena:2015bea ; Bianchi:2018kzy ; Bena:2019azk . Recently significant progress has been made with the discovery of the so-called W -soliton Chakraborty:2025ger ; Dima:2025tjz , an exact solution of 5d Einstein-Maxwell (E-M) equations. The main virtue of these solution, as compared to Topological Stars Bah:2020ogh ; Bah:2020pdz ; Heidmann:2022ehn ; Bianchi:2022qph ; Heidmann:2023ojf ; Bianchi:2023sfs ; Bianchi:2024vmi ; DiRusso:2024hmd and their rotating versions Bianchi:2025uis ; Heidmann:2025pbb is that W -soliton exists in mass-charge regimes where BHs exist, too. So they can be taken as valid (charged) non-rotating BH micro-states. Quite remarkably their form is extremely simple and tractable, especially in the neutral case. Exact solutions of Einstein Equations (EEs) in 4d or higher dimensions are very few which are also physically relevant. Then, even if one were to consider W -solitons simply as mathematical solutions, one could get crucial information about gravity in a strong field regime. The neutral 5d W -soliton can be reduced to an exact spherically symmetric solution of 4d EEs, sourced by a single (complex) scalar field. Due to spherical symmetry, the 4d neutral W -soliton turns out to be very simple and, at the same time, rich of interesting geometrical and physical properties which we will try and examine. First of all, it approaches the Schwarzschild BH asymptotically, but it exposes a naked singularity, showing the typical repulsive-gravity effects as soon as one approaches it. Clearly the 4d naked singularities is a symptom of the genuine 5d nature of the solution, whereby it is perfectly smooth and horizonless. Apart from some geometrical characterization of the spacetime, that extends the analyses in Chakraborty:2025ger ; Dima:2025tjz , we study the scattering of (neutral) massless and massive particles off the W -soliton. We compute the scattering angle both in its exact form (in terms of elliptic integrals) and in a large-angular momentum expansion limit, at the geodesic level, i.e., without back-reaction which will be studied next, after developing the necessary formalism. We display useful resummations for the expanded forms, in terms of hypergeometric functions. The antiderivative with respect to the angular momentum of the scattering angle is the radial action, which is then simply obtained also in a resummed form. In turn, the radial action is related to the behaviour at infinity of the Jeffreys-Wentzel-Kramers-Brilluein (JWKB) solution for a test scalar field wave: this behaviour (monodromy) is fully accounted by the so called “renormalized angular momentum” \nu which can be computed according to different approaches, e.g., Mano-Suzuki-Takasugi (MST) Mano:1996vt and modern gauge theory approach Aminov:2020yma ; Aminov:2023jve ; Bautista:2023sdf ; Bonelli:2022ten ; Bonelli:2021uvf ; Bianchi:2021xpr ; Bianchi:2021mft ; Consoli:2022eey ; Fucito:2023afe ; Cipriani:2024ygw ; Bianchi:2023rlt ; DiRusso:2025qpf , based on quantum Seiberg-Witten (qSW) curves Nekrasov:2009rc ; Nekrasov:2002qd , that give complementary results in full agreement with one another. We display the Post-Newtonian expansion of \nu for various values of the angular momentum number \ell and check its identification with a_{\rm SW} up to a shift by 1/2. We also briefly discuss the Quasi Normal Modes (QNMs) with different overtones in the 4d case, by using different approaches: JWKB, Leaver, numerical integration. For the specific case of neutral W -solitons, our results match well with the more general results of Chakraborty:2025ger ; Dima:2025tjz . The main accomplishment of this work concerns in the study of a scalar field perturbing the background spacetime in 5d within the framework of gravitational self force (GSF). We limit our considerations to the minimal coupling case and to the massless scalar field case, as a proxy for the more interesting but more involved case of gravitational waves. The evolution equations are separated 1) in their angular dependence by expanding the field in (scalar) spherical harmonics; 2) in time, by Fourier transforming the time variable. One is left then with a single radial equation which is of the Confluent Heun type (CHE). We develop the analogue of the MST formalism (valid and by now almost standardized for BHs) to this special solution (see Bianchi:2024vmi for a similar treatment discussing the case of another special solution in 5d, called the “Topological Star” or “Top Star” for short, see e.g., Bianchi:2023sfs ; DiRusso:2024hmd ; Cipriani:2024ygw ; Bena:2024hoh ; Cipriani:2025ikx ; Bini:2025qyn ) and then compute the energy loss when the source is moving along a time-like circular equatorial geodesic 1 1 1 The angular momentum loss is proportional to the energy loss in this circular orbit case. . The rest of the paper is organized in two main parts. In the first part we study the 4d case, that is more than a simple warm-up exercise. Then we pass to consider the 5d case, the really important case. A whole section is devoted to the computation of the energy loss in scalar waves when the source is a neutral massive scalar particle moving along a circular geodesic. The results are compared with the ones for other backgrounds: the Schwarzschild BH and the Top Star. Finally, we make our concluding remarks and discuss plans for future work. We use mostly plus signature convention and units such (8\pi)G_{\text{N}}=1=c , unless differently specified. II 4d W neutral soliton Let us start by analyzing the properties of the neutral W -soliton from the reduced ‘bottom-up’ 4d perspective. The metric Chakraborty:2025ger ; Dima:2025tjz reads \displaystyle ds^{2}=-fdt^{2}+\frac{dr^{2}}{f}+fr^{2}(d\theta^{2}+\sin^{2}\theta d\phi^{2})\,, (1) with f=\sqrt{1-\frac{4M}{r}}\sim 1-\frac{2M}{r}+O\left(\frac{1}{r^{2}}\right)\,. (2) This solution approaches the familiar Schwarzschild BH solution as r\to\infty (far region), but it does not represent a black hole. It is sourced by a complex scalar field z=\frac{1}{\left(1-\frac{2M}{r}\right)}\left(\frac{2M}{r}+if\right)\,, (3) with non-canonical kinetic term such that 2 2 2 One can have a more elegant form for T_{\mu\nu} by defining \frac{1}{{\rm Im}\,z}\partial_{\mu}z=\partial_{\mu}\zeta since both z and \zeta will only depend on the radial variable r . However, this will remain only a formal simplification. T_{\mu\nu}=\frac{3}{4({\rm Im}\,z)^{2}}\left(N_{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2}({\rm Tr}N)g_{\mu\nu}\right)=\frac{3}{4({\rm Im}\,z)^{2}}N_{\mu\nu}^{\rm TR}\,, (4) where we have introduced the combinations \displaystyle N_{\mu\nu} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\partial_{\mu}z^{*}\partial_{\nu}z+\partial_{\mu}z\partial_{\nu}z^{*}=2\partial_{(\mu}z^{*}\partial_{\nu)}z\,, \displaystyle{\rm Tr}N \displaystyle= \displaystyle g^{\mu\nu}N_{\mu\nu}\,, (5) as well as X^{\rm TR}_{\mu\nu}=X_{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2}({\rm Tr}X)g_{\mu\nu} (6) for the trace-reversed form of a symmetric 2-tensor X . Explicitly, the non-vanishing components of T_{\mu\nu} are \left[T_{00},T_{rr},T_{\theta\theta},T_{\phi\phi}\right]=\frac{3M^{2}}{r^{4}f^{2}}\left[-1,-\frac{1}{f^{2}},r^{2},r^{2}\sin^{2}\theta\right]\,, (7) and the EE are written in units such that G_{\mu\nu}=T_{\mu\nu}\,. (8) The Khretschmann invariant is given by {\mathcal{K}}=R_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}R^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}=\frac{12M^{2}(69M^{2}-32Mr+4r^{2})}{r^{8}(1-\frac{4M}{r})^{3}} (9) implying

Read the complete text