8D conformal gravity with Einstein sector, and its relation to the Q Q -curvature
Nicolas Boulanger, Davide Rovere · 2025
Read 8D conformal gravity with Einstein sector, and its relation to the Q Q -curvature by Nicolas Boulanger, Davide Rovere (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01368.txt.
Introduction
Nicolas Boulanger and Davide Rovere construct conformal gravity theories in even dimensions that are extremized by Einstein metrics, meaning the usual solutions of general relativity also solve the conformal theory's equations. They begin by tidying the known six dimensional construction of Lu, Pang, and Pope.
They then prove that a unique eight dimensional conformal gravity action with the Einstein property exists, and they build it in full. The authors relate the construction to Branson's Q-curvature and the Fefferman-Graham obstruction tensor. They conclude that in every even dimension there is a unique conformally invariant gravity theory, up to boundary terms, with this property. Such results sharply limit how gravity can be changed while keeping Einstein metrics as solutions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicolas Boulanger, Davide Rovere |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01368
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
8D conformal gravity with Einstein sector, and its relation to the Q Q -curvature Nicolas Boulanger, Davide Rovere Abstract We first streamline the construction of the unique six-dimensional conformal gravity action found by Lü, Pang and Pope, that admits Einstein metrics as solutions to the field equations. We then prove that there exists a unique eight-dimensional conformal gravity action that admits Einstein metrics as solutions to the field equations, and explicitly build the corresponding action. Finally, we relate these results to Branson’s Q Q -curvature and the Fefferman-Graham obstruction tensor, to conjecture that on every even-dimensional space there exists a unique – up to boundary terms – conformally-invariant gravity theory that is extremised by Einstein metrics. 1 Introduction Conformal gravity is a privileged model for an extension of Einstein’s general relativity theory, since on top of the usual diffeomorphism symmetries, it is invariant under Weyl rescalings of the metric. As a classical theory of gravity, four-dimensional conformal gravity, also called Weyl gravity, was investigated in great details by several authors, see in particular Stelle:1977ry ; Riegert:1984zz ; Mannheim:1990ya ; Klemm:1998kf ; Dzhunushaliev:1999fy ; Emparan:2001wk ; Flanagan:2006ra ; Oliva:2012zs ; Lu:2012xu ; Lu:2015cqa . A review of the relevance of Weyl gravity throughout the last decades can be found in Scholz:2017pfo to which we refer for more references. Viewed as a quantum theory, conformal gravity was shown by Stelle Stelle:1976gc to be renormalizable, albeit non-unitary. This triggered an important body of works, where in particular Einstein gravity was argued to emerge from quantum corrections to Weyl gravity Adler:1982ri ; Zee:1983mj ; for a review, see e.g. Salvio:2018crh . The non-unitarity of conformal gravity has been discussed in many references, see e.g. Fradkin:1985am ; Antoniadis:1986tu , where precisely the non-unitary sector can be decoupled from the space of solutions to conformal gravity by imposing appropriate boundary conditions, thereby leaving the space of solutions of Einstein’s equations with a cosmological constant Maldacena:2011mk . Indeed, while the solutions to Einstein’s equations with a cosmological constant – namely, Einstein manifolds – are also solutions to the field equations of conformal gravity, the converse is not true. Nevertheless, as we mentioned above, Maldacena Maldacena:2011mk showed that the non-Einstein metrics of four-dimensional conformal gravity can be eliminated by imposing an appropriate Neumann boundary condition on the asymptotic (anti) de Sitter (A)dS spacetime metric, which constitutes a very interesting and concrete relation between Weyl and Einstein gravity theories. Whether this connection holds in higher spacetime dimensions D was tested in six-dimensional conformal gravity Anastasiou:2020mik , where the action actually is a two-parameter family of actions, due to the fact that in 6 D there exist three linearly independent scalar densities that are strictly Weyl-invariant Graham1985 ; parker1987invariants ; see e.g. Erdmenger:1997gy for a review, and below in the body of the paper. Instead, in four dimensions there is only one Weyl-invariant scalar density, the one leading to Weyl gravity. It was found in Lu:2013hx that, up to an overall factor in front of the action functional, there is a unique linear combination of the three local conformal invariants in 6 D for which Einstein metrics are solutions to the corresponding variational problem. In the present technical note, we want to see whether this property extends to eight dimensions D=8 . For the construction of the Lagrangian density, one has to start from the list of possible Weyl-invariant scalar densities in 8 D , also called local (or pointwise) conformal invariants, which were classified in Boulanger:2004zf by using the Weyl-covariant calculus developed in Boulanger:2004eh . These purely algebraic tools were also used in Boulanger:2018rxo to determine the general structure of global conformal invariants on manifolds of arbitrary dimension. It was already known from Alexakis:2005ft ; alexakis2012decomposition that, on closed manifolds of even dimensions D=2m , global conformal invariants are given by the integral over the manifold of the Euler density plus a linear combination of the local conformal invariants in that dimension, plus total derivatives. On manifolds of dimension D=4m-1 , m\in\mathbb{N}^{+}\, , further global conformal invariants were found in Boulanger:2018rxo , thereby completing the results of alexakis2012decomposition . In Section 2 we briefly review the Weyl-conformal calculus developed in Boulanger:2004eh . Then, in Section 3 we review the theories of conformal gravity in four and six dimensions, that admit an Einstein sector. In Section 4 we then discuss the notion of Q -curvature and illustrate it explicitly in dimensions two, four and six. Then, in Section 5 we construct the most general conformal gravity theory in eight dimensions, that admits an Einstein sector, and find that the result is unique, up to boundary terms and an additive constant proportional to the Euler characteristic. We relate this action to the eight-dimensional Q -curvature, to find that, up to boundary terms and an additive constant, our action coincide with the (normalised) integrated Q -curvature. We end the note in Section 6 with a general discussion of both the Q -curvature and the Fefferman-Graham obstruction tensor in arbitrary even dimension D=2m . We conjecture that there is only one conformal gravity action in even dimension, that admits an Einstein sector. It coincides with the integrated Q -curvature, up to normalisation, boundary terms, and additive constant proportional to the Euler characteristic \chi(M_{2m}) of the manifold. 2 Weyl-covariant tensor calculus The problem of classifying all the Weyl-invariant scalar densities built out of a metric in arbitrary (even) dimension is famously difficult, see e.g. Graham1985 ; bailey1994invariant ; bailey1994thomas ; gover2001invariant ; gover2003standard ; graham2005ambient and refs. therein. The problem is very simple in four dimensions for which the square of the Weyl tensor gives the solution, whereas it is already much more complicated in six dimensions parker1987invariants . In eight dimensions, the classification of the Weyl-invariant scalar densities built out of a metric tensor was obtained in Boulanger:2004zf . This classification relies on the Weyl-covariant tensor calculus developed in Boulanger:2004eh that we will briefly review in this section, as it is also instrumental in the classification of the Weyl-invariant action functionals that admit Einstein metrics as solutions to the variational problem. We use the conventions and notation of Boulanger:2007ab ; Boulanger:2007st , where the classification of Weyl anomalies in arbitrary dimension was obtained. First of all, we recall that the Weyl tensor is the traceless part of the Riemann curvature tensor. In components, we have W^{\mu}{}_{\nu\rho\sigma}=R^{\mu}{}_{\nu\rho\sigma}-2\left(\delta^{\mu}{}_{[\rho}K_{\sigma]\nu}-g_{\nu[\rho}K_{\sigma]}{}^{\mu}\right)\;, (1) in terms of the components of the Riemann tensor and of the Schouten tensor K_{\mu\nu}=\frac{1}{D-2}\left(R_{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2(D-1)}g_{\mu\nu}\right)\;. (2) Under infinitesimal Weyl rescalings of the metric \delta_{\sigma}g_{\mu\nu}=2\,\sigma(x)\,g_{\mu\nu}\;, (3) the components of Weyl tensors are invariant: \delta_{\sigma}W^{\mu}{}_{\nu\alpha\beta}=0\, . Denoting by \Delta_{\mu}{}^{\nu}\, the GL(D) generators that act on tensors through \Delta_{\mu}{}^{\nu}\,T^{\alpha}_{\beta}=\delta^{\nu}_{\beta}T^{\alpha}_{\mu}-\delta^{\alpha}_{\mu}T^{\nu}_{\beta}\, , the symbol \nabla_{\mu}=\partial_{\mu}-\Gamma_{\mu\nu}{}^{\rho}\,\Delta_{\rho}{}^{\nu} denotes the usual torsion-free metric-compatible (Levi-Civita) covariant derivative associated with the Christoffel symbols \Gamma_{\mu\nu}{}^{\rho} , in terms of which R^{\mu}{}_{\nu\rho\sigma}=\partial_{\rho}\Gamma_{\nu\sigma}{}^{\mu}+\ldots . The commutator of covariant derivatives gives [\nabla_{\mu},\nabla_{\nu}]V^{\rho}=R^{\rho}{}_{\sigma\mu\nu}V^{\sigma}\, and, in general, [\nabla_{\mu},\nabla_{\nu}]=R_{\mu\nu\rho}{}^{\sigma}{}\,\Delta_{\sigma}{}^{\rho}\, . The components of the Cotton tensor are given by C_{\alpha\rho\sigma}=2\,\nabla_{[\sigma}K_{\rho]\alpha}\equiv\nabla_{\sigma}K_{\rho\alpha}-\nabla_{\rho}K_{\sigma\alpha}\, . The Weyl-covariant derivative constructed in Boulanger:2004eh is given by {\cal D}_{\mu}=\nabla_{\mu}+K_{\mu\alpha}\,\bm{\Gamma}^{\alpha}\;, (4) where we refer to this work for the definition of the generators \bm{\Gamma}^{\alpha} ; see also below for a few examples. The important property of the Weyl-covariant derivative \cal D is that its curvature vanishes if and only if the