Open-Source Highly Parallel Electromagnetic Simulations for Superconducting Circuits

David Sommers, Zach Degnan, Divita Gautam, Yi-Hsun Chen, Chun-Ching Chiu, Arkady Fedorov, Prasanna Pakkiam · 2025

Read Open-Source Highly Parallel Electromagnetic Simulations for Superconducting Circuits by David Sommers, Zach Degnan, Divita Gautam, Yi-Hsun Chen, Chun-Ching Chiu, Arkady Fedorov, Prasanna Pakkiam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01220.txt.

Introduction

David Sommers and colleagues introduce SQDMetal, an open source workflow to model the electromagnetic behavior of superconducting quantum circuits. Such tools matter greatly when designing quantum devices, but the standard tools are mostly commercial, and open parallel alternatives have been scarce.

SQDMetal is a Python interface that links Qiskit Metal for design, Gmsh for meshing, Palace for large parallel runs, and ParaView to view the results. Mesh studies show strong agreement with two leading paid packages on eigenmode and capacitance numbers. Models of resonators and transmon qubits match experiments well. Extras include getting Hamiltonians by the energy participation ratio method, kinetic inductance effects, and full 3D device geometry.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Sommers, Zach Degnan, Divita Gautam, Yi-Hsun Chen, Chun-Ching Chiu, Arkady Fedorov, Prasanna Pakkiam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01220

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Open-Source Highly Parallel Electromagnetic Simulations for Superconducting Circuits Preprint: APS/123-QED David Sommers, Zach Degnan, Divita Gautam, Yi-Hsun Chen, Chun-Ching Chiu, Arkady Fedorov, Prasanna Pakkiam Abstract Electromagnetic simulations form an indispensable part of the design and optimization process for superconducting quantum devices. Although several commercial platforms exist, open-source alternatives optimized for high-performance computing remain limited. To address this gap, we introduce SQDMetal, a Python-based API that integrates Qiskit Metal (IBM), Gmsh, Palace (AWS), and Paraview (Kitware) into an open-source, highly parallel simulation workflow for superconducting quantum circuits. SQDMetal enables accurate, efficient, and scalable simulations while remaining community-driven and free from commercial constraints. In this work, we validate SQDMetal through mesh convergence studies which benchmark SQDMetal against COMSOL Multiphysics and Ansys, demonstrating excellent agreement for both eigenmode and electrostatic (capacitance) simulations. Furthermore, we simulate superconducting resonators and transmon qubits, showing reasonable agreement with experimental measurements. SQDMetal also supports advanced capabilities, including Hamiltonian extraction via the energy participation ratio (EPR) method, incorporation of kinetic inductance effects, and full 3D modeling of device geometry for improved predictive accuracy. By unifying open-source tools into a single framework, SQDMetal lowers the barriers to entry for community members seeking to access high-performance simulations to assist in the design and optimization of their devices. I Introduction The field of superconducting quantum circuits has emerged as one of the leading theoretical and experimental platforms in the pursuit of fault-tolerant quantum computing 4 ; 30 . Over the past two decades, this maturing field has experienced significant growth, highlighted by the evolving sophistication of experimental techniques and circuit design to improve qubit coherence times 13 . As the field continues to develop, focus is shifting from understanding the physics underlying superconducting circuit behaviour 21 to addressing engineering challenges, such as the design and optimization of device geometries 16 . Computational tools such as electromagnetic simulation software have become increasingly important for optimizing superconducting circuit design 28 ; 16 . Numerous frameworks have been proposed to simulate device behaviour and extract the circuit Hamiltonian using electromagnetic solvers. Among the most widely adopted are the lumped oscillator model (LOM) 18 ; 7 , blackbox quantization (BBQ) 20 , and the energy participation ratio (EPR) 17 , which employ electrostatic, driven frequency domain, and eigenmode simulations, respectively. These approaches enable designers to evaluate, refine, and optimize circuit parameters prior to fabrication. However, performing such simulations remains challenging for researchers and engineers with limited access to proprietary electromagnetic solvers such as Ansys HFSS or COMSOL. Furthermore, implementing commercial electromagnetic solvers on high-performance computing (HPC) systems to achieve greater simulation efficiency and accuracy often incurs significant licensing costs. In this work, we present an accurate, efficient, and fully open-source simulation workflow that leverages high-performance parallelization to remove the dependence on commercial software, thereby lowering barriers to entry for research groups and fostering a community-driven approach. The simulation package, which we have termed SQDMetal, is a Python application programming interface (API) that integrates existing open-source tools for the design and simulation of superconducting quantum devices. The core software components of SQDMetal include: • Qiskit Metal 27 — an open-source framework developed by IBM for the design of superconducting quantum chips and devices. • Gmsh 9 — an open-source finite element mesh generator developed by Christophe Geuzaine and Jean-François Remacle for creating 3D meshes and models. • Palace (Parallel Large-scale Computational Electromagnetics) 23 — an open-source electromagnetic solver developed by Amazon Web Services (AWS) for HPC environments, enabling faster and more accurate large-scale simulations. • ParaView 24 — an open-source visualization and post-processing tool developed by Kitware for analyzing and rendering finite element simulation results. Our major contribution in this work is the integration of these open-source software packages into a cohesive workflow, enabling design and simulation to be executed from within a single Jupyter notebook. Our framework provides control over meshing and simulation parameters through a set of simple commands. We also plan to expand the functionality of SQDMetal to address evolving community needs. Our goal is to promote usability and encourage programmatic design which enhances code re-usability. Through this integration, we aim to deliver an open-source platform that the community can readily adopt and extend. This paper presents SQDMetal’s architecture, validation, and applications in superconducting circuit simulation. Section II describes the device design and simulation workflow. Section III compares the SQDMetal API with existing commercial solvers (Ansys and COMSOL Multiphysics) to validate its accuracy and reliability via a mesh convergence study. Finally, Section IV presents a comparison between simulation results obtained with SQDMetal and experimental measurements of superconducting resonators and qubits, showing good agreement in the process. Figure 1: Visualization of the SQDMetal workflow and the software packages used for each process. II Workflow The operation of the SQDMetal API is shown in Fig. 1 , providing a diagrammatic representation of our workflow. The process begins with Qiskit Metal, where the superconducting device is designed. Qiskit Metal features an extensive component library and enables users to programmatically develop circuit layouts in Python via Jupyter notebooks 27 . Qiskit Metal also supports community-driven development, allowing users to create and share custom components that can be integrated into new designs 29 . Once the initial device design is complete, our API reconstructs the geometry in Gmsh and generates a finite-element mesh according to user-defined parameters. Users can control the meshing process through simple commands that specify the minimum and maximum element sizes and the distance over which transitions occur. SQDMetal also incorporates the adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) feature available in Palace, allowing users to define a seed mesh that is automatically refined by the solver to improve simulation accuracy. Because the quality of the finite-element mesh directly affects the accuracy of electromagnetic simulations, SQDMetal provides fine-grained control to ensure that device geometries are meshed with sufficient resolution. After meshing, the SQDMetal API transfers the generated mesh file to Palace to perform finite-element electromagnetic simulations. Palace is developed on top of MFEM, an open-source high-performance C++ library for finite-element discretization, and is designed to operate across a wide range of platforms from laptops to supercomputers 2 . While proprietary software packages such as COMSOL Multiphysics and Ansys HFSS also support finite-element electromagnetic simulations on HPCs, there are few open-source alternatives. Palace addresses this gap by providing scalable, open-source computational electromagnetics capabilities. Within SQDMetal, we have integrated Palace’s functionality to perform the following types of simulations: 1. Electrostatic simulations to compute capacitance matrices, 2. Eigenmode simulations to determine eigenfrequencies, quality factors, and energy participation ratios (EPR), and 3. Driven radio-frequency (RF) simulations to extract scattering parameters. In the final step of the workflow, SQDMetal utilizes ParaView to visualize the results of the simulation, including the computed electric and magnetic field distributions. Using Paraview, users can verify the simulated fields exhibit physically consistent behaviour, ensuring that the simulation accurately represents device performance. ParaView also provides extensive post-processing capabilities, such as numerical integration and quantitative field analysis, allowing users to extract key metrics directly from the simulation data. At this stage, a full cycle of the SQDMetal workflow has been completed. Users can then modify their device design based on the simulation results and re-run the workflow, establishing an iterative process between design, simulation, and analysis that facilitates efficient device optimization.

Read the complete text