Novel H c2 H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism in a spin triplet superconductor – Application to UTe 2 –

Kazushige Machida · 2025

Read Novel H c2 H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism in a spin triplet superconductor – Application to UTe 2 – by Kazushige Machida (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01148.txt.

Introduction

Kazushige Machida proposes a new mechanism that can suppress the upper critical field of a spin triplet superconductor, the magnetic field strength at which superconductivity dies. In equal spin pairing, he shows theoretically, that field can be pushed down from the usual orbital limit to arbitrarily small values while the transition stays second order.

That behavior differs sharply from the known Pauli limit for ordinary singlet superconductors, where the reduction is capped and the transition turns first order. Machida applies the mechanism to UTe2, a leading spin triplet candidate, fitting critical field data for several crystal orientations at ambient and applied pressure. He concludes the material realizes a non-unitary equal spin triplet state, and the analysis identifies its pairing symmetry.

Catalog record

CREATORKazushige Machida
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01148

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Novel H c2 H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism in a spin triplet superconductor – Application to UTe 2 – Kazushige Machida Abstract A novel H c2 H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism is theoretically proposed in a spin triplet superconductor (SC) with equal spin pairs. We show that the upper critical field H c2 H_{\rm c2} can be reduced from the orbital depairing limit H c2 orb H^{\rm orb}_{\rm c2} to arbitrarily small value, keeping the second order phase transition nature. This mechanism is sharply different from the known Pauli-Clogston limit for a spin singlet SC where the reduction is limited to ∼ \sim 0.3 H c2 orb H^{\rm orb}_{\rm c2} with the first order transition when the Maki parameter goes infinity. This novel H c2 H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism is applied to UTe 2 , which is a prime candidate for a spin triplet SC, to successfully analyze the H c2 H_{\rm c2} data for various crystalline orientations both under ambient and applied pressure, and to identify the pairing symmetry. It is concluded that the non-unitary spin triplet state with equal spin pairs is realized in UTe 2 , namely ( b ^ + i ​ c ^ ) ​ k a (\hat{b}+i\hat{c})k_{a} in 3 B 3u which is classified under finite spin orbit coupling scheme. I Introduction It is well known that the upper critical field H_{\rm c2} is suppressed by the so-called Pauli-Clogston mechanism for spin-singlet superconductors through the Zeeman effect, which is characterized by the Maki parameter \alpha_{\rm Maki} sant-james . For larger \alpha_{\rm Maki}\geq 1 the phase transition at H_{\rm c2} becomes first order from usual second order phase transition, and the reduction of H_{\rm c2} is saturated, tending gradually to a lower bound \sim 0.3H^{\rm orb}_{\rm c2} with the orbitally limited H^{\rm orb}_{c2} toward \alpha_{\rm Maki} \rightarrow \infty 214 . In contrast, there exists no known H_{\rm c2} suppression mechanism for a spin-triplet superconductor, except that the d-vector is firmly locked parallel to the external field direction. This situation is the same as in the spin-singlet case. Thus it would be quite surprising if we see that H_{\rm c2} is suppressed by an external field when the d-vector is rotated perpendicular to it. Recently, much attention has been focused on a newly found heavy Fermion superconductor UTe 2 ran ; aoki0 ; review ; review1 . Since the upper critical field far exceeds the Pauli paramagnetic limit set by H_{\rm p}=1.75T_{\rm c}\sim 3.5 T for all crystalline directions, it is expected that the realized pairing symmetry belongs to a spin-triplet category review ; review1 . However, details of the pairing function remain unidentified and are much debated until now review ; review1 . Because of the rich internal degrees of freedom in the spin-triplet pairing function which consists of the spin SO(3)^{\rm spin} and orbital D_{\rm 2h}^{\rm orbital} parts in general, the multiple superconducting states are expected to exist. Indeed recent several experiments including specific heat rosuel and flux flow measurements sakai unambiguously demonstrate that at least three phases exist in the H - T plane ( H\parallel b ) at the ambient pressure, in addition to previously known multiple phase diagrams in the H - T plane under pressure P pressure0 ; pressure1 ; pressure2 ; pressure3 ; pressure4 . These observed multiple phase diagrams are a hallmark of a spin-triplet superconductor (SC) and similar to UPt 3 taillefer ; sauls ; upt3 ; ohmi ; yo ; tsutsumi1 another spin-triplet SC with the three phases; A, B and C in the H - T plane and also the superfluid 3 He which consists of the A and B phases in the P - T plane 3he ; mizushima . It is instructive to remind of the fact that in the A phase in the superfluid 3 He the transition temperature T_{\rm c} splits into two; the A 1 phase with T_{\rm c1} and A 2 phase with T_{\rm c2} under applied field H . The former (latter) shits up (down) linearly in H up to at least 16T ishimoto because the spin \uparrow\uparrow ( \downarrow\downarrow ) pairs gain (loose) the magnetic energy. Here since we are advocating that in UTe 2 the A 1 and A 2 like non-unitary pairing state is able to describe a variety of exotic phenomena, including the T_{\rm c} increase with increasing H(\parallel b) review ; review1 . This particular phenomenon is akin to the T_{\rm c1}(H) rise of the A 1 phase under H mentioned. Then it is natural to ask where the decreasing T_{\rm c} for the A 2 phase with \downarrow\downarrow pairs exists in the H - T phase diagram because the A 1 and A 2 are originated from the same mother A phase. We are motivated by the recent intriguing two experimental papers hc2' ; pressure : The first paper hc2' reports the orientational dependences of the initial slopes dH_{\rm c2}/dT at T_{\rm c} and H_{c2} for all crystalline angles as will be shown later (see Fig. 3 ). Since according to a standard formula: H^{\rm WHH}_{\rm c2}(T\rightarrow 0)\sim-0.7({dH_{\rm c2}/dT})_{T_{\rm c}}\cdot T_{\rm c} , given by Wertharmer, Helfand, and Hohenberg whh , H_{\rm c2} must be proportional to the initial slope. While along the c -axis H^{c}_{\rm c2}=17 T nearly coincides with -({dH_{\rm c2}/dT})_{T_{\rm c}}=6 T/K by multiplying a factor 3 with T_{\rm c}=2.1 K, the other directions H^{a}_{\rm c2}=12 T and H^{b}_{\rm c2}=23 T should be compared with H^{\prime a}_{\rm c2}=-15 T/K and H^{\prime b}_{\rm c2}=-23 T/K. Thus the actual H^{a}_{\rm c2} and H^{b}_{\rm c2} are far below the expected H^{a}_{\rm c2}\sim 45 T and H^{b}_{\rm c2}\sim 75 T by multiplying the same factor 3. This implies some unknown mechanism to exist in order to explain these large H_{\rm c2} suppressions which should be field-orientation dependent. The other paper pressure reports the impressive pressure evolution of the H - T multiple phase diagrams for H \parallel b : The high field phase SC2 in their terminology above H=14 T in the ambient pressure progressively goes down toward lower field and eventually reaches the H=0 line and is stabilized at higher T than the lower field phase SC1 at around P=0.19 GPa. Together with other pressure experiments pressure3 ; pressure1 ; pressure4 ; pressure2 this pressure evolution of the multiple phase diagrams is seemingly independent of the above H_{\rm c2} suppression phenomenon, but in this paper we show a deep internal interdependence between them due to the inherent nature of the pairing symmetry realized in UTe 2 . These analyses lead us to believe in identifying our pairing symmetry. Figure 1: Schematic H - T phase digram for H\parallel b -axis machida5 ; machida6 . In the A 1 (A 2 ) phase the spin polarization \mathbb{S} points to the antiparallel (parallel) direction along the a -axis at low fields and turns to the parallel (antiparallel) to the b -axis in higher fields above the d-vector rotation field H_{\rm rot} denoted by TCP. H_{\rm m} is the first order metamagnetic transition. The dotted line inside the A 1 phase is the hypothetical transition line for the A 2 phase. Since the present paper belongs to a series of our papers on UTe 2 machida1 ;

Read the complete text