Strongly Forbidden Thermodynamic Oscillations in Quasi-One-Dimensional Conductors

A.G. Lebed · 2025

Read Strongly Forbidden Thermodynamic Oscillations in Quasi-One-Dimensional Conductors by A.G. Lebed (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01068.txt.

Introduction

Andrei Lebed predicts a second forbidden effect in quasi one dimensional conductors, following his related work on magnetoresistance oscillations. Here the claim concerns specific heat, the amount of energy needed to warm the material, which he argues must oscillate in some of these metals in a way standard theory forbids.

The oscillations arise from electron electron interactions when magnetic breakdown occurs, a tunneling between open electron orbits that interfere with each other. Lebed names two organic conductors where the effect should exist, the same pair treated in his companion work, and suggests experimentalists look for the oscillations there. As with the resistance effect, the phenomenon sits beyond the Fermi liquid picture of metals.

Catalog record

CREATORA.G. Lebed
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01068

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strongly Forbidden Thermodynamic Oscillations in Quasi-One-Dimensional Conductors Preprint: Natala-PRL A.G. Lebed Abstract We theoretically show that strongly forbidden oscillations of a specific heat have to exist in metallic phases of some quasi-one-dimensional (Q1D) conductors. They appear due to electron-electron interactions under condition of the magnetic breakdown phenomenon between the so-called open interference electron orbits. We argue that such forbidden thermodynamic oscillations can exist in Q1D conductors (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 and (Per) 2 Au(mnt) 2 , where TMTSF stands for tetramethyltetraselenafulvalene, Per is polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon and mnt is mononitrotoluene, and suggest to discover them. pacs 74.70.Kn It is well known that, in layered quasi-one-dimensional (Q1D) conductors, closed quasi-particle orbits do not exist in a magnetic field. This prevents the appearance of quantum effects due to the so-called Landau quantization [1] of electron energy levels in the field. Nevertheless, in magnetic fields in Q1D conductors, there are some other quantum effects - the Bragg reflections of electrons from the Brillouin zones boundaries [2-5]. They cause the existence in (TMTSF) 2 - and (ET) 2 -based Q1D conductors, where TMTSF stands for tetramethyltetraselenafulvalene and ET stands for the so-called ethyl group, of such quantum phases as the Field-Induced-Spin-Density-Wave (FISDW) ones, exhibiting 3D Quantum Hall effect [5]. Moreover, the above mentioned conductors demonstrate some exotic angular conductivity oscillations of quantum interference origin such as Lebed’s Magic Angles (LMA), Third Angular Effect (TAE), and Lee-Naughton-Lebed’s (LNL) angles in their metallic phases (for a review, see Refs. [5,6]). According to the most of current theories, some LMA, TAE, and LNL angular oscillations can be explained by the Bragg reflections of non-interacting electrons within the Fermi liquid (FL) approach [1,5]. Meanwhile, as was shown theoretically [7-10], interactions of Q1D electrons can result in weak [7,8] and the strongest [9,10] deviations from the FL theory in magnetic fields. Indeed, as shown in Ref.[7], some novel oscillations appear in kinetic properties, like conductivity, whereas in Ref.[9] it was shown by Yakovenko that the similar to [7] angular and magnetic oscillations could appear even in thermodynamic properties such as magnetic moment of electrons moving along open orbits. Note that the last statement strongly contradicts the FL theory [1]. Due to small amplitudes of the predicted non-FL oscillations, the non-FL effects [9,10] have not been observed yet in Q1D metals. The next important step in the theory [11] was the consideration of the weak deviations from the FL results for open electron trajectories in magnetic fields under the condition of magnetic breakdown between open electron orbits (i.e., due to the so-called Stark effect [12-17]). It was shown [11] that electron-electron scattering time oscillations were much increased in their magnitudes and such oscillations were probably experimentally observed in resistivity measurements in (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 [18]. The goal of our Letter is to study theoretically influence of the Stark variant of the magnetic breakdown on the most principle violations of the FL theory - the appearance of the forbidden thermodynamical oscillations. In particular, we show that electron-electron interactions cause the existence of the forbidden specific heat oscillations in metallic phases of some Q1D conductors even in the absence of closed quasi-particles orbits in a magnetic field. The amplitudes of such oscillations are highly enlarged, if we compare them to the oscillations [9]. Physical origin of the oscillations of specific heat is an oscillatory nature of electron spectrum under the condition of magnetic breakdown [15-17], where the corrections to specific heat can be considered as strong fluctuations which, as shown by us below, exist far above the FISDW Peierls phase transition. Therefore, we hope that they can be observed in a metallic phase of Q1D conductor (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 in experiments similar to the more recent experiment [19]. Note that there is a principle difference between our current calculations and the results of Refs. [15-17]. In this Letter, we calculate corrections to specific heat in a metallic phase, whereas all previous calculations were performed in FISDW phase. From mathematical point of view, this means that our current calculations involve a product of four Green’s functions, in contrast to the case [15-17], where only products of two Green’s functions were considered. From physical point of view, we calculate forbidden in the FL theory oscillations, in contrast to Refs. [15-17], where allowed in the FL theory oscillations were considered. Another candidate for the predicted by us non FL effects is Q1D conductor (Per) 2 Au(mnt) 2 , where Per is polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon and mnt is mononitrotoluene, which also exhibits the Stark effect [20]. Figure 1: Quasi-one-dimensional Fermi surface of the organic conductor (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 in the presence of anion ordering gap, \Delta [see Eq.(4)]. Note that, in the absence of the so-called anion gap [14], Q1D electron spectrum of the (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 conductor can be written as [5] \epsilon^{\pm}({\bf p})=\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F})+2t_{b}\cos(p_{y}b^{*})]+2t_{c}\cos(p_{z}c^{*}), (1) where v_{F}p_{F}\gg t_{b}\gg t_{c} ; b^{*} and c^{*} are crystalline lattice parameters. The anion gap, \Delta(y)=\Delta\cos(\pi y/b^{*}) , leads to a doubling of the lattice periodicity along {\bf y} axis and the electron wave functions obey the following equations: \displaystyle[\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F})+2t_{b}\cos(p_{y}b^{*})]\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}) \displaystyle+\Delta\ \psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*})=\epsilon\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}), (2) \displaystyle[\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F})-2t_{b}\cos(p_{y}b^{*})]\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*}) \displaystyle+\Delta\ \psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y})=\epsilon\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*}). (3) As a result, in the presence of the anion gap there exist the following four sheets of the Q1D Fermi surface (see Fig.1): \displaystyle\epsilon^{\pm}_{n}({\bf p})=\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F}) \displaystyle+(-1)^{n}\sqrt{[2t_{b}\cos(p_{y}b^{*})]^{2}+\Delta^{2}},\ \ \,n=1,2, (4) which correspond to the real experimental situation in the (TMTSF) 2 ClO 4 at ambient pressure. [Note that here we disregard the term 2t_{c}\cos(p_{z}c^{*}) , but account for it at the end of the Letter in our final equations.] Let us now perform the so-called Peierls substitution [1,5,13], p_{x}\mp p_{F}\rightarrow-i\frac{d}{dx},\ \ \ p_{y}\rightarrow p_{y}-\frac{e}{c}A_{y}, (5) in Eqs.(2) and (3) in the external magnetic field perpendicular to conducting plane ({\bf a},{\bf b^{*}}) : {\bf H}=(0,0,H),\ \ \ {\bf A}=(0,Hx,0). (6) [Note that in this Letter we use system units where the Planck constant \hbar =1]. In this case, Eqs.(2) and (3) can be rewritten as \displaystyle\biggl[\mp iv_{F}\frac{d}{dx}+2t_{b}\cos\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\biggl)\biggl]\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y},x) \displaystyle+\Delta\ \psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*},x)=\epsilon\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y},x), (7) \displaystyle\biggl[\mp iv_{F}\frac{d}{dx}-2t_{b}\cos\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\biggl)\biggl]\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*},x) \displaystyle+\Delta\ \psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y},x)=\epsilon\psi^{\pm}_{\epsilon}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*},x), (8) where \omega_{c}=eHv_{F}b^{*}/c is the so-called cyclotron frequency of electron motion along open electron trajectories in the Brillouin zone [2,5]. Note that magnetic breakdown problem of Eqs. (7) and (8) was carefully studied in Ref.[17] where the magnetic breakdown field was calculated, H_{MB}=\frac{\pi c\Delta^{2}}{2ev_{F}t_{b}b^{*}}. (9) Below, we consider the case of very high magnetic fields [11,15,16], H\geq H_{MB}, (10) where we can use the perturbation approach with respect to the anion ordered gap for solutions of Eqs.(7) and (8). In this case, in the first approximation wave functions are symmetric (11) and anti-symmetric (12) combinations of two solutions of Eqs.(7) and (8) with \Delta=0 with opposite energy shifts due to \Delta\neq 0 . As a result, we obtain the following two component vector[11]: \displaystyle[\psi^{\pm}_{1}(p_{y},x),\psi^{\pm}_{1}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*},x)]=\frac{\exp[\pm i(\epsilon-\Delta^{*})x/v_{F}]}{\sqrt{2}} \displaystyle\biggl\{\exp\biggl[\pm\frac{i\lambda}{2}\sin\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\bigg)\bigg],\exp\biggl[\mp\frac{i\lambda}{2}\sin\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\bigg)\bigg]\biggl\} (11) and \displaystyle[\psi^{\pm}_{2}(p_{y},x),\psi^{\pm}_{2}(p_{y}+\pi/b^{*},x)]=\frac{\exp[\pm i(\epsilon+\Delta^{*})x/v_{F}]}{\sqrt{2}} \displaystyle\biggl\{\exp\biggl[\pm\frac{i\lambda}{2}\sin\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\bigg)\bigg],-\exp\biggl[\mp\frac{i\lambda}{2}\sin\biggl(p_{y}b^{*}-\frac{\omega_{c}x}{v_{F}}\bigg)\bigg]\biggl\}, (12) where \lambda=\frac{4t_{b}}{\omega_{c}},\ \ \ \ \omega_{c}=ev_{F}Hb^{*}/c. (13) Note that the symmetric (11) and anti-symmetric (12) wave functions have different energies [11,15,16], \epsilon^{\pm}_{1}({\bf p})=\epsilon-\Delta^{*},\ \ \epsilon=\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F}), (14) \epsilon^{\pm}_{2}({\bf p})=\epsilon+\Delta^{*},\ \ \epsilon=\pm v_{F}(p_{x}\mp p_{F}), (15) with the difference in energies, 2 \Delta^{*} , being an oscillating function of an inverse magnetic field : \Delta^{*}=J_{0}(\lambda)\Delta\simeq\Delta\ \sqrt{\frac{\omega_{b}}{2\pi t_{b}}}\cos\biggl(\frac{4t_{b}c}{ev_{F}Hb^{*}}\biggl), (16) where J_{0}(...) is the zeroth order Bessel function. It is

Read the complete text