A Self Propelled Vortex Dipole Model on a Catenoid arXiv: 2500.0000
Khushi Banthia, Rickmoy Samanta · 2025
Read A Self Propelled Vortex Dipole Model on a Catenoid arXiv: 2500.0000 by Khushi Banthia, Rickmoy Samanta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00923.txt.
Introduction
Khushi Banthia and Rickmoy Samanta study vortex dipoles, pairs of swirling flows that propel themselves, moving on a catenoid, the hourglass shaped surface formed by rotating a hanging chain curve. The catenoid has variable negative curvature, so geometry itself steers the motion.
They build the full dynamical system, including how the two vortices interact and how each interacts with the curved surface. The Hamiltonian dynamics make dipoles follow the surface's geodesics, matching recent results, and a conserved momentum comes from the surface's rotational symmetry. Direct and exchange scattering are showed, along with rotating motion for chiral pairs. A finite size dipole model then shows self propulsion emerging to leading order, directed across the dipole axis.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Khushi Banthia, Rickmoy Samanta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00923
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Self Propelled Vortex Dipole Model on a Catenoid arXiv: 2500.0000 Khushi Banthia, Rickmoy Samanta Abstract We investigate vortex dipoles on surfaces of variable negative curvature, focusing on a catenoid of arbitrary throat radius “ a a ” as a concrete example. We construct the effective dynamical system taking into account the inter-vortex mutual interactions as well as the self-interaction arising from the geometry of the catenoid. The resulting Hamiltonian dynamics reveals that dipoles move along geodesics of the catenoid, consistent with recent works, Gustafsson, J. Nonlinear Sci, 32, 62 (2022) and Drivas, Glukhovskiy and Khesin, International Mathematics Research Notices, Volume 2024, Issue 14, Pages 10880–10894 (2024) . We utilize the symplectic structure to find a conserved momentum map J J related to the U 1 U_{1} symmetry along the azimuthal direction. We explicitly demonstrate the conservation of the Hamiltonian and J J for arbitrary throat radius a a . Next, we apply the formalism to demonstrate direct and exchange scattering of classical vortices on the catenoid surface. For comparison, we also demonstrate that chiral pairs with similar initial configurations lead to collective rotational motion (with azimuthal drift) instead of scattering. We finally construct a finite dipole dynamical system on the catenoid, building on the dipole-dipole interactions and demonstrate the emergence of the self propulsion terms to leading order in dipole size. This provides a concrete realization, on a curved minimal surface, of the intuitive statement that a finite dipole propels orthogonal to the direction of its axis, with a speed modulated by curvature. 1 Introduction Vortex dipoles, consisting of two counter-rotating vortices of equal strength, are fundamental self-propelled structures arising in many two-dimensional (2D) and quasi-2D flows. They represent the simplest mode of coherent transport and appear across a wide range of systems, from oceanic and atmospheric vortices to plasmas, superfluids, and Bose–Einstein condensates (BECs). In planar incompressible fluids, classical point-vortex theory aref ; saffman ; lin1 ; lin2 has been very successful in describing their translational motion, pair interaction, and scattering dynamics. Finite-core and additional viscous effects account for dipole deformation, asymmetric decay, and interaction with walls or background shear Delbende2009 ; Dehtyriov2020 ; Flore1994 ; Hinds2009 . Many works have investigated the subtle role of curvature and topology of the underlying fluid domain in dipole and vortex motion in general bg ; hally ; kimok ; kimura ; newton1 ; newton2 ; crowdymarshall ; Boatto2008 ; Koiller2009 ; Turner2010 ; Borisov2014 ; voigt ; boattok ; boattod ; Gustafsson2022 ; Lydon2023 ; khesin2024 , see also sam1 ; sam2 ; sam3 . When the underlying surface is non-Euclidean, the geometric coupling between curvature and vorticity modifies both the Hamiltonian structure and the resulting trajectories, along with a geometry-dependent interaction kernel. Several recent studies sam1 ; sam2 ; sam3 have also demonstrated quasi-periodic and chaotic regimes depending on initial separation and curvature. Such analyses underline that curvature acts as an effective external field for vortex motion, breaking the translational symmetry that guaranties uniform propagation in the plane. A significant body of mathematical literature Boatto2008 ; Koiller2009 ; boattok ; boattod ; Gustafsson2022 ; khesin2024 has provided analytic arguments towards Kimura’s geodesic conjecture (that tightly bound opposite-sign vortex pairs follow geodesics of the surface), finding that the conjecture holds for infinitesimally close vortex pairs but acquires curvature-dependent corrections at finite separation. Dipoles have also received enormous interest in many recent condensed matter experiments, particularly the work of Neely et al. Neely2010 , who observed the controlled nucleation and long-lived propagation of quantized vortex dipoles in an oblate BEC. Freilich et al. Freilich2010 subsequently developed experimental techniques to extract real-time dipole trajectories, finding connections between microscopic Gross–Pitaevskii dynamics and macroscopic vortex-particle models. More recent experiments Rooney2011 ; Goodman2015 ; White2014 ; Stagg2014 have developed deeper connections between experiments and theoretical studies in dipoles and vortex clusters in trapped condensates. In this work, we formulate a dynamical description of vortex dipoles in an incompressible and inviscid fluid domain of variable negative curvature, using the catenoid of arbitrary throat radius a as a canonical example. Starting from the geometry-dependent hydrodynamic Green’s function on the catenoid, we derive the explicit equations of motion for interacting vortices, incorporating both mutual and curvature-induced self-interaction terms. The resulting symplectic structure yields a conserved momentum map associated with the U(1) azimuthal symmetry, and we verify numerically the conservation of both the Hamiltonian and this momentum for arbitrary throat radius. We find that tightly bound dipoles propagate along geodesics of the catenoid, providing explicit confirmation of the geodesic conjecture of Kimura and its recent generalizations to surfaces of variable curvature. We then demonstrate direct and exchange scattering of these dipoles on the catenoid while for co-rotating vortex configurations, we demonstrate collective rotational states (with azimuthal drift). Extending the analysis to finite-sized dipoles, we construct an effective dynamical system that generalizes the planar dipole models to minimal surfaces of varying negative curvature, yielding analytic expressions for curvature-corrected self-propulsion and orientation dynamics (which are then explicitly validated by numerics). Our work establishes the catenoid as a tractable minimal-surface for analytic studies and provide a geometric basis for future investigations of self-propelled defects, dipoles and vortex clusters (along the lines of Ref. ( sam3 ) on curved manifolds. We organize the paper as follows: In Sec. ( 2 ) we provide the model Hamiltonian system and phase space, along with the associated momentum map corresponding to the azimuthal symmetry of the catenoid. This is followed by a comparison of the vortex dipole motion with catenoid geodesics and numerical checks on the conservation laws for catenoids of arbitrary throat radius in Sec. ( 3 ). In Sec. ( 4 ) we demonstrate the direct and exchange scattering of classical vortices on the catenoid surface. In contrast, Sec. ( 5 ) shows that co-rotating configurations show collective rotational motion with azimuthal drift. We construct a simple model for the dipole motion and orientation dynamics for finite sized dipoles and demonstrate the emergence of the self propulsion terms to leading order in dipole size in Sec. ( 6 ). These terms are then explicitly validated by numerics. We conclude in Sec. ( 7 ). 2 Model Hamiltonian System and Phase Space In this section, we review the essential aspects of the catenoid geometry needed to set up the dynamical system for the dipoles, closely following Ref. Boatto2008 ; Koiller2009 ; boattok ; boattod ; Gustafsson2022 ; khesin2024 . We consider the catenoid of throat radius a>0 described by X(v,u)\;=\;\big(a\cosh(v/a)\cos u,\;a\cosh(v/a)\sin u,\;v\big),\qquad u\in[0,2\pi),\;v\in\mathbb{R}. This gives the metric g=\cosh^{2}\!\big(\tfrac{v}{a}\big)\,dv^{2}\;+\;a^{2}\cosh^{2}\!\big(\tfrac{v}{a}\big)\,du^{2}\;=\;\cosh^{2}\!\big(\tfrac{v}{a}\big)\,\big(dv^{2}+a^{2}du^{2}\big). with the area element dA=a\cosh^{2}\!\big(\tfrac{v}{a}\big)\,dv\,du. Due to the preriodicity in the azimuthal coordinate u , the hydrodynamic Greens function may be written as G(v_{i},u_{i};v_{j},u_{j})\;=\;\frac{1}{4\pi}\,\log\!\Big(\cosh\!\big(\tfrac{v_{i}-v_{j}}{a}\big)-\cos(u_i-u_j)\Big). In order to keep the expressions compact, let us also define F_{ij}\;:=\;\cosh\!\big(\tfrac{v_{i}-v_{j}}{a}\big)-\cos(u_i-u_j),\qquad h(v):=\cosh\!\big(\tfrac{v}{a}\big). For N point vortices with strengths \Gamma_{i} at positions (v_{i},u_{i}) , the Hamiltonian governing effective vortex interactions on the catenoid is \displaystyle H\;=\;\sum_{1\leq i<j\leq N}\Gamma_{i}\Gamma_{j}\,G(v_{i},u_{i};v_{j},u_{j})\;-\;\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Gamma_{i}^{2}\,\log h(v_{i}). (1) The natural symplectic form induced by the area element is \omega\;=\;\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Gamma_{i}\,dA_{i}\;=\;\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Gamma_{i}\,a\,h^{2}(v_{i})\,dv_{i}\wedge du_{i}\;=\;\sum_{i=1}^{N}\Gamma_{i}\,a\cosh^{2}\!\big(\tfrac{v_{i}}{a}\big)\,dv_{i}\wedge du_{i}. The Hamiltonian vector field X_{H}=\sum_{i}(\dot{v}_{i}\partial_{v_{i}}+\dot{u}_{i}\partial_{u_{i}}) satisfies \iota_{X_{H}}\omega=dH , which leads us to the Hamilton’s equations \displaystyle\Gamma_{i}\,a\,h^{2}(v_{i})\,\dot{v}_{i}\;=\;\frac{\partial H}{\partial u_{i}},\qquad\Gamma_{i}\,a\,h^{2}(v_{i})\,\dot{u}_{i}\;=\;-\frac{\partial H}{\partial v_{i}}. (2) We thus differentiate the pairwise Green function: \frac{\partial G}{\partial u_{i}}\;=\;\frac{1}{4\pi}\,\frac{\sin(u_i-u_j)}{F_{ij}},\qquad\frac{\partial G}{\partial v_{i}}\;=\;\frac{1}{4\pi}\,\frac{1}{a}\,\frac{\sinh\!\big(\tfrac{v_{i}-v_{j}}{a}\big)}{F_{ij}}. and the local self interaction \frac{\partial}{\partial v_{i}}\Big(-\frac{1}{4\pi}\Gamma_{i}^{2}\log