Symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy: Haar random and graph states

Norihiro Iizuka, Simon Lin · 2025

Read Symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy: Haar random and graph states by Norihiro Iizuka, Simon Lin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00905.txt.

Introduction

Norihiro Iizuka and Simon Lin study a refined measure of multipartite entanglement, called symmetry resolved genuine multi-entropy, in two kinds of random quantum states. The measure tracks entanglement shared among many parties at once, split by the value of a conserved charge.

For Haar random states, the most unbiased random states, they derive explicit formulas in the large system limit under a global charge symmetry. The dependence on subsystem sizes turns out to look much like the case with no conserved charge. Numerical work on spin systems covers both Haar random and graph states. The graph state results show distinctive entanglement patterns, which the authors contrast with the Haar random behavior.

Catalog record

CREATORNorihiro Iizuka, Simon Lin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00905

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy: Haar random and graph states Norihiro Iizuka, Simon Lin Abstract We study the symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy, a measure that captures genuine multi-partite entanglement, in Haar random states and random graph states in the presence of a conserved quantity. For Haar random states, we derive explicit formulae for the genuine multi-entropy under a global U ⁡ ( 1 ) U(1) symmetry in the thermodynamic limit, and find that its dependence on subsystem sizes closely resembles that of fully Haar random states without a conserved charge. We also perform numerical analyses, focusing on spin systems for both Haar random and graph states. For random graph states, our numerical analyses reveal distinctive features of their multi-partite entanglement structure and we contrast them with the Haar random case. I Introduction Entanglement is the defining feature of a quantum system. Suppose that we have a system M which we further divide into two subsystems M=A\cup B . We can quantify the amount of entanglement between A and B by calculating its entanglement entropy : S(A)=-\tr(\rho_A\log\rho_A), (1) where \rho_{A}=\tr_{B}\rho_{AB} is the reduced density matrix of system A . The entanglement entropy is a ubiquitous diagnostic: it obeys area laws Bombelli:1986rw ; Srednicki:1993im ; Callan:1994py and distinguishes quantum phases via entanglement spectra Li:2008kda , it is geometrized by Ryu–Takayanagi in holography Ryu:2006bv ; Ryu:2006ef , and for Haar random states it yields the universal Page curve Page:1993df ; Page:1993wv . However, the entanglement entropy is a rather coarse measure for the entanglement structure of the system. In particular, it is only sensitive to the bipartite entanglement between system A and B in a pure state, while being agnostic to the much richer multi-partite entanglement structure of the system. A typical quantum state in a generic system contains more than bipartite entanglement, and measures built solely from entanglement entropies can fail to detect these signatures of multi-partite entanglement. A nice example to illustrate this is the following two states PhysRevLett.86.5184 ; Gadde:2022cqi : \displaystyle\ket{\psi_{1}} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left(\ket{\uparrow\uparrow\downarrow}+\ket{\uparrow\downarrow\uparrow}+\ket{\downarrow\uparrow\uparrow}\right) (2) \displaystyle\ket{\psi_{2}} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left(\ket{\uparrow\uparrow\uparrow}+\sqrt{2}\ket{\downarrow\downarrow\downarrow}\right) (3) Although the reduced density matrices of these two states are different, they share the same spectrum, i.e. , the same set of eigenvalues. Consequently, any entanglement entropy or Rényi measure, which depends solely on the eigenvalue spectrum, cannot distinguish between the two states. However, higher-partite quantities that are more sensitive than spectral data, such as the multi-entropy or the entanglement negativity, can differentiate between them. Multi-entropies, or more generally, Rényi multi-entropies are generalizations of the Rényi entanglement entropy into higher \mathtt{k} -partite 1 1 1 In the literature, such subdivisions are often referred to as \mathtt{q} -partite, however in this letter we use \mathtt{k} -partite instead, reserving q for charge-related quantities. ( \mathtt{k}>2 ) subdivisions Gadde:2022cqi ; Gadde:2023zzj . They are constructed from symmetric contractions of the density matrix and is sensitive to higher-partite entanglements in the system. However, the multi-entropy does not always capture truly or genuine higher-partite entanglement by itself, since it is also sensitive to lower-partite correlations. For example, the \mathtt{k}=3 multi-entropy can be nonzero even for a state that contains only bipartite entanglement (such as an Bell-pair state). Thus, one cannot determine whether a nonzero value of the \mathtt{k}>2 multi-entropy arises from bipartite correlations or from genuinely higher \mathtt{k}>2 multi-partite entanglement. To resolve this issue, one can define the k -partite genuine multi-entropies ( {\rm GM}^{\mathtt{(k)}} ) Iizuka:2025ioc ; Iizuka:2025caq , by systematically subtracting all the contributions from lower-partite entanglements such that the genuine multi-entropies are only sensitive to k -partite entanglements. These new measures have recently been used to argue the necessity of higher-partite entanglement in holographic systems Iizuka:2025bcc ; Akers:2019gcv ; Akers:2024pgq ; Hayden:2021gno ; Li:2025nxv . For recent developments of GM, see Harper:2025uui ; Iizuka:2025elr ; Berthiere:2025toi ; Balasubramanian:2025hxg ; Bao:2025psl ; Akella:2025owv ; Yuan:2025dgx . When the system of interest possesses a conserved charge Q , its Hilbert space decomposes into distinct sectors labeled by the total charges of the system. This is often the case in real-world scenarios, in which the charge Q can be the total energy or the electric charge of the system. It is natural to ask how does the entanglement structure change when one restricts to such a charged sector, or in other words, under symmetry-resolution . The study of symmetry-resolved entanglement has been under active research in the recent years Goldstein:2017bua ; Xavier:2018kqb ; Bonsignori:2019naz ; Fraenkel:2019ykl ; Murciano:2019wdl ; Feldman:2019upn ; Murciano:2020vgh ; Capizzi:2020jed ; Lau:2022hvc ; Neven:2021igr ; Ares:2022koq , especially for the study of the Page curve Bianchi:2019stn ; Murciano:2022lsw . However, most literature on this line of research has been focusing on bipartite entanglement measures 2 2 2 See Ref. Berthiere:2023gkx for results on two symmetry-resolved tripartite entanglement measures: computable cross-norm (CCNR) negativity and reflected entropy. Also see Ref. Jain:2025aqs on the symmetric resolution of the Q-measure of global entanglement Meyer:2001ckx . , and a systematic treatment for multi-partite entanglement is lacking. In this letter, we initiate a first step in the systematic study of symmetry-resolved multi-partite entanglement by investigating the behavior of GM under symmetry resolution. We employ spin chain systems endowed with a global U(1) symmetry as tractable toy models to enable explicit calculations of the symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy. Our broader motivation lies in black hole physics, especially in understanding black hole (genuine) multi-entropy curves Iizuka:2024pzm , where conservation laws such as total electric charge and energy are intrinsic. In such contexts, symmetry resolution provides a natural framework to isolate how conservation constraints modulate genuine multi-partite entanglement. It would be interesting to investigate how the (genuine) multi-entropy curves are modified (1) in the presence of a conserved quantity, and (2) when the ensemble is restricted to special classes of states. In this letter, following the approaches of Bianchi:2019stn ; Murciano:2022lsw , we provide analytical formulae of symmetry-resolved multi-entropy for Haar random states (states described by a random vector in the Hilbert space) in the thermodynamic limit, which we compare with numerical evaluations. We also look at a different class of states known as graph states . They are stabilizer states built from acting with commuting Clifford operators according to a graph. This letter is structured as follows: In Sec. II we briefly review the notion of GME and the symmetry resolution of entanglement entropy. In Sec. III we study symmetry-resolved genuine multi-entropy curves for the ensemble of Haar random states and random graph states. We conclude with several remarks in Sec. IV . Some technical derivations are relegated to the appendix. II Prerequisites II.1 Symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy We begin by reviewing symmetry resolution of bipartite entanglement entropy for Haar random states Bianchi:2019stn ; Murciano:2022lsw . To make the discussion concrete, we will throughout consider a system of N spins with a global U(1) charge Q , defined as the expectation value of the following operator: \hat{Q}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{N}(\sigma^{(i)}_{z}+1)=\text{\# of spin-up sites}. (4) Q ranges from 0 to N . Suppose total spin number Q is conserved, then the system’s Hilbert space factorizes into a direct sum of sectors with definite charge Q : \mathcal{H}=\bigoplus_{Q=0}^{N}H(Q). (5) Given a pure state \rho=\ket{\psi}\bra{\psi} for the total system in a specific Q sector, we can divide the total system into two subsystems A and B . Because of the conserved charge, the

Read the complete text