Cost-of-capital valuation with risky assets
Hansjörg Albrecher, Filip Lindskog, Hervé Zumbach · 2025
Read Cost-of-capital valuation with risky assets by Hansjörg Albrecher, Filip Lindskog, Hervé Zumbach (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00895.txt.
Introduction
Hansjorg Albrecher, Filip Lindskog, and Herve Zumbach extend a standard insurance valuation method. Cost of capital valuation prices liabilities by charging for the buffer capital an insurer must hold, and regulators rely on it. The usual version assumes that buffer sits in riskless one year bonds.
The authors ask what changes when the buffer is invested in risky assets, such as a mix of stocks and bonds. They make precise how the split of the buffer between policyholders and investors shifts as the investments get riskier. They highlight the role of limited liability when insurance risks are heavy tailed. General theorems are paired with explicit results in specific stochastic models and with numerical work that underlines the main effects.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hansjörg Albrecher, Filip Lindskog, Hervé Zumbach |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00895
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cost-of-capital valuation with risky assets Hansjörg Albrecher, Filip Lindskog, Hervé Zumbach Abstract Cost-of-capital valuation is a well-established approach to the valuation of liabilities and is one of the cornerstones of current regulatory frameworks for the insurance industry. Standard cost-of-capital considerations typically rely on the assumption that the required buffer capital is held in risk-less one-year bonds. The aim of this work is to analyze the effects of allowing investments of the buffer capital in risky assets, e.g. in a combination of stocks and bonds. In particular, we make precise how the decomposition of the buffer capital into contributions from policyholders and investors varies as the degree of riskiness of the investment increases, and highlight the role of limited liability in the case of heavy-tailed insurance risks. We present a combination of general theoretical results, explicit results for certain stochastic models and numerical results that emphasize the key findings. 1 Introduction Risk-based solvency principles for insurance companies are at the heart of modern insurance regulation, see for instance the currently enforced Solvency II regulation in the European Union [ 12 , 14 ] and the Swiss Solvency Test (SST) in Switzerland [ 15 ] . According to these principles, the valuation of insurance liabilities must reflect not only expected future cash flows but also the uncertainty surrounding them. A central component in this process is the cost of capital, which represents the return that investors demand for providing capital to absorb unexpected losses, where the necessary amount of capital to ensure solvency is set by the regulator on the basis of the underwritten policies and a risk measure. While financial risks can typically be priced in a market-consistent way (cf. [ 20 ] ), this is more subtle for insurance risk (see e.g. [ 24 ] , [ 11 ] and [ 3 , 23 ] ). In the absence of a liquid market for insurance risks, one typically needs to adhere to a mark-to-model approach. The economic value of the insurance liabilities is then defined as the expected claim costs (’ best estimate ’) plus a margin (called risk margin in Solvency II, and market value margin in the SST) which reflects these capital costs. The justification is that for this monetary amount another insurance undertaking should then be willing to take over these liabilities, as it covers the costs it generates for integrating it into one’s business (an arm’s length transaction , cf. [ 12 ] ). The suggested cost-of-capital rate (above the risk free rate) for such considerations, and the standard value currently implemented, is 6\% . Recently, the European union decided to lower this value to 4.75%, cf. [ 19 , 14 ] , which after national transposition is expected to be enforced in the member countries by January 2027. See e.g. [ 17 , 2 ] for economic considerations to justify particular cost-of-capital rates. It may be natural to interpret that the insurance premiums should match the economic value of liabilities that the issuance of these insurance policies generates (as this is the value for which also another party should be willing to accept these risks). This would mean that the safety loading (on top of the pure premium reflecting expected claim costs) corresponds to the risk margin discussed above. From an actuarial perspective, this is a natural starting point for the concrete pricing of the policies, although several other factors will eventually play a role (including competition, demand/supply patterns, solidarity considerations etc.). More than that, at the general level of asset-liability management of the company, the company is exposed to several other sources of risks, and the regulatory rules ask to determine the solvency capital requirement that each of these generate, and the resulting values then need to be added up for the overall solvency capital satisfying the regulatory demand. That is, for simplicity, these risks are considered independently at first, and based on some (often very coarse) dependence assumptions between the different risk categories, the obtained sum can in a second step potentially be reduced by a diversification benefit, taking into account the fact that not all of these risks are likely to lead to losses at the same time. In the approach as described above, the insurance liabilities are considered in a stand-alone fashion, with the capital costs they generate (and therefore the necessary insurance premiums) possibly over-estimated, as they rely on the assumption that the solvency capital is invested solely in risk-less bonds. But in practice some of that capital can be invested into risky assets, generating higher returns than the risk-less bond and providing additional income that reduces the claim costs. At the same time, this position in risky assets introduces additional risk, which itself translates into the need for further solvency capital. In this paper, we would like to specifically investigate this trade-off directly by considering those two risks together. Concretely, considering a mix of risky and risk-less investment of the solvency capital, we would like to study up to which degree of ’riskiness’ of the investment the policyholders can benefit from smaller premiums for the same level of solvency of the insurance undertaking (under the assumption that the safety loading is determined by the generated capital costs). Our focus is on short-tailed risks in the non-life domain. Despite extensive literature on the joint valuation of actuarial and financial risks within the insurance product itself (particularly with life insurance applications in mind, see e.g. [ 8 , 6 , 5 , 4 ] ), to the best of our knowledge an explicit analysis of the trade-off between risky and risk-less assets of a non-life insurer for a policyholder’s perspective was not considered before. We therefore deliberately decide to keep the underlying model assumptions simple, in order not to blur the main analysis by overlays with other factors. This includes the restriction to a one-period model, independence between insurance and financial risk as well as a focus on the Value-at-Risk and Expected Shortfall as a risk measure, see Section 2 for details. It turns out that one can specify conditions under which the needed insurance premiums decrease with increasing weight in risky investment, up to a certain limit weight, up to which also the overall capital requirement is reduced. That is, a mild weight in risky investment is of advantage to all involved parties. Beyond that limit, the needed insurance premiums may decrease even further, but at the expense of overall increased capital requirements for the additionally introduced investment risk. Such considerations may also add to reflections about the justifications of currently implemented solvency capital charges in the standard model of Solvency II for equity risk (e.g. 39% shock for Type 1 assets and 49% shock for Type 2 assets, cf. [ 13 ] ). We reiterate that the purpose of the paper is to establish some concrete quantitative insights into the matter under very concrete and simple model assumptions. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 lays out the concrete model assumptions on which we base the considerations of the paper and establishes a number of general monotonicity results for the needed insurance premium, the invested amount of the shareholders and the overall solvency capital requirement