Black hole interiors of homogeneous holographic solids under shear strain

Yuanceng Xu, Li Li, and Wei-Jia Li · 2025

Read Black hole interiors of homogeneous holographic solids under shear strain by Yuanceng Xu, Li Li, and Wei-Jia Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00877.txt.

Introduction

Yuanceng Xu, Li Li, and Wei-Jia Li look inside anti-de Sitter black holes in holographic axion models, which describe strongly coupled materials that break translation symmetry. They strain these solids by shearing them and ask what happens to the black hole interior.

Shear, they find, always removes the inner Cauchy horizon. The bridge like structure inside collapses there, the geometry turns sharply anisotropic, and the interior heads toward a spacelike singularity. For power law axion potentials, strong shear can also create a domain wall with a scaling region near the boundary and a Kasner style epoch near the horizon. Deeper inside, the dynamics settle into anisotropic Kasner behavior, sometimes alternating between epochs as the singularity nears.

Catalog record

CREATORYuanceng Xu, Li Li, and Wei-Jia Li
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00877

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Black hole interiors of homogeneous holographic solids under shear strain Yuanceng Xu, Li Li, and Wei-Jia Li Abstract We investigate the interior of AdS black holes under finite shear strain in a class of holographic axion models, which are widely used to describe strongly-coupled systems with broken translations. We demonstrate that the shear anisotropy necessarily eliminates the inner Cauchy horizon, such that the deformed black hole approaches a spacelike singularity. The anisotropic effect induced by the axion fields triggers a collapse of the Einstein-Rosen bridge at the would-be Cauchy horizon, accompanied by a rapid change in the anisotropy of the spatial geometry. In addition, for a power-law axion potential, sufficiently large shear deformations give rise to a domain wall solution that includes a Lifshitz like scaling geometry near the boundary as well as a near horizon Kasner epoch with the Kasner exponents determined by the powers of the potential. Finally, we find that the interior dynamics of black holes generally enter an era described by an anisotropic Kasner universe at later interior time. Depending on the form of the potential, they either tend to stable Kasner universes, or exhibit an endless alternation of different Kasner epochs toward the singularity. 1 Introduction Since the Einstein equation was introduced in general relativity, the theoretical understanding of black hole exteriors has become well-established. In recent years, observational breakthroughs, including gravitational-wave detection LIGOScientific:2016aoc and direct imaging of black hole shadows EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2019ths , have further enriched our empirical knowledge of these regions. However, the physics of black hole interiors remains far less understood, primarily due to the presence of a curvature singularity enclosed by the event horizon, where conventional physical laws cease to hold. The inevitability of such singularities within general relativity was rigorously established by Penrose and Hawking Penrose:1964wq ; Hawking:1970zqf . In contrast to the spacelike singularity of the Schwarzschild solution, the singularity of a Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole or a Kerr black hole is timelike owing to the presence of a Cauchy horizon. Moreover, the strong cosmic censorship (SCC) conjecture Isenberg:2015rqa asserts that any Cauchy horizon must be dynamically unstable to preserve the causal integrity of the spacetime Ringstrom:2015jza . A seminal contribution to the understanding of black hole interiors is the Belinski-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz (BKL) conjecture Lifshitz:1963ps ; Belinsky:1970ew ; Belinski:1973zz , which describes the dynamical behavior of spacetime near a spacelike singularity. According to this, the geometry undergoes chaotic, oscillatory dynamics characterized by an infinite sequence of Kasner epochs—periods of anisotropic expansion or contraction governed by distinct Kasner exponents. For a large number of models, the alternation between these epochs can be elegantly described using a cosmological billiard picture Damour:2002et ; Henneaux:2007ej , wherein the system’s evolution is mapped to a billiard ball reflecting off the walls of a multi-dimensional potential. This analogy provides a powerful tool for analyzing the chaotic nature of the BKL singularity and has profound implications for both the physics of black hole interiors and the early-universe cosmology. Another motivation for studying black hole interiors stems from the holographic duality Maldacena:1997re , which remarkably links weakly-coupled gravities to strongly coupled quantum field theories, has emerged as a transformative framework across disciplines, while providing novel approaches to study black hole interiors. Some dual field theory quantities, in particular, correlation functions Fidkowski:2003nf ; Festuccia:2005pi , entanglement entropy Hartman:2013qma and quantum complexity Stanford:2014jda ; Brown:2015bva serve as complementary non-perturbative probes of interior dynamics. Recent studies have revealed that coupling matter fields to AdS-Schwarzschild Frenkel:2020ysx ; Hartnoll:2020rwq or RN black holes Hartnoll:2020fhc can dramatically modify their interior dynamics, particularly through the elimination of Cauchy horizons Cai:2020wrp ; An:2021plu ; Hale:2025ezt . The resulting dynamical evolution typically progresses through three characteristic phases: collapse of Einstein-Rosen (ER) bridge, Josephson oscillations and Kasner behavior near the singularity Hartnoll:2020fhc - with the latter potentially exhibiting Kasner inversions, transitions and reflections Cai:2023igv ; Cai:2024ltu . These phenomena have been verified in a broad class of systems within the framework of holography, including holographic superconductors Hartnoll:2020fhc ; Sword:2022oyg ; Cai:2021obq ; Cai:2024ltu ; Zhang:2025tsa ; Zhang:2025hkb , holographic semimetals Gao:2023zbd , holographic axion models Mansoori:2021wxf ; Mirjalali:2022wrg ; Prihadi:2025rwg ; Sword:2021pfm as well as the modified gravity with higher-derivative corrections Devecioglu:2021xug ; Devecioglu:2023hmn ; Grandi:2021ajl ; Caceres:2024edr ; Bueno:2024fzg . A common conclusion from these investigations is the necessity of coupling additional matter fields to the original gravitational theory to produce richer interior structures. Building on these developments, we examine black hole interiors within anisotropic holographic axion models Baggioli:2021xuv , with two crucial distinctions from previous work Mansoori:2021wxf ; Mirjalali:2022wrg ; Prihadi:2025rwg ; Sword:2021pfm : (1) our construction utilizes only the axion fields without additional (charged) scalar hair; and (2) the bulk axion fields realize the anisotropy on the boundary in a specific manner that allows finite shear deformations to be introduced in the holographic description 1 1 1 Previous studies focused on isotropic cases in the presence of axions, for which a proof for no inner-horizon is absent. . This model has been applied to study nonlinear elasticity and mechanical failure of amorphous solids Baggioli:2020qdg ; Pan:2021cux ; Ji:2022ovs ; Baggioli:2023dfj , and more recently, it uncovers an unexpected connection between non-linear elasticity and quantum complexity Xu:2025uzo . However, in this work, we focus instead on its implications for black hole interiors - particularly how shear deformations, crucial to analyzing the elasticity of boundary systems, manifest in interior spacetime dynamics. We first prove that shear anisotropy necessarily eliminates the inner Cauchy horizon, such that the deformed black hole geometry terminates at a spacelike singularity in contrast to numerous cases of holographic axion models where isotropic black holes, in general, have inner Cauchy horizons and a timelike singularity. We then focus on the dynamics of the black hole interior. The instability of the inner Cauchy horizon triggered by the small shear anisotropy leads to a rapid collapse of the ER bridge at the would-be inner horizon, together with a rapid change in the anisotropy of the spatial geometry. For sufficiently large shear deformation and the model with a power-law potential, the occurrence of ER bridge collapse is replaced by the emergence of an intermediate domain wall geometry spanning the event horizon. It displays an anisotropic Lifshitz like scaling near the boundary, and satisfies a general Kasner form near the singularity whenever the potential term is subdominant. On the contrary, when the potential term becomes important( e.g. exponential like potentials), the interior geometry can never reach an asymptotic scaling behavior. Instead, the evolution of the black hole interior exhibits an infinite sequence of Kasner epochs. This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 reviews the holographic axion model incorporating finite shear strain. In Section 3 , we rigorously demonstrate that anisotropic shear deformations induce the disappearance of the inner horizon. Section 4 presents numerical and analytical evidences for both the collapse dynamics of the ER bridge under small shear strains and a domain wall geometry induced by large shear deformations. The influence of shear deformation on near-singularity Kasner epoch is systematically investigated in Section 5 . Finally, we conclude in Section 6 and propose several directions for future research. More technical details are provided in Appendix A for the constraint on the axion potential and in Appendix

Read the complete text