The CatWISE2020 Quasar dipole: A Reassessment of the Cosmic Dipole Anomaly

Masroor Bashir, Pravabati Chingangbam, Stephen Appleby · 2025

Read The CatWISE2020 Quasar dipole: A Reassessment of the Cosmic Dipole Anomaly by Masroor Bashir, Pravabati Chingangbam, Stephen Appleby (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00822.txt.

Introduction

Masroor Bashir, Pravabati Chingangbam, and Stephen Appleby recheck a claimed anomaly in the large scale structure of the universe. A standard test compares the motion implied by the cosmic microwave background with the uneven sky counts of distant quasars. An earlier study of the CatWISE2020 quasar catalog found a mismatch at very high significance.

The team reruns the test with careful simulations that include quasar clustering, the survey's depth pattern, and its exact sky coverage. The mismatch shrinks but does not vanish, landing near three and a half sigma rather than the earlier claim. They also show that fitting extra multipoles on a partial sky can bias the dipole estimate upward, a caution for future surveys.

Catalog record

CREATORMasroor Bashir, Pravabati Chingangbam, Stephen Appleby
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00822

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The CatWISE2020 Quasar dipole: A Reassessment of the Cosmic Dipole Anomaly Masroor Bashir, Pravabati Chingangbam, Stephen Appleby Abstract The cosmological principle, which asserts a statistically homogeneous and isotropic universe on large scales, is a foundational assumption of the standard cosmological model. A critical test of this principle involves the kinematic interpretation of the Cosmic Microwave Background temperature dipole, conventionally attributed to our peculiar motion relative to the cosmic rest frame. The Ellis-Baldwin test provides a probe of this kinematic interpretation by searching for a matching Doppler-driven dipole in the number counts of extragalactic radio sources. Recent measurements from the CatWISE2020 quasar catalog have reported a dipole amplitude significantly exceeding the kinematic expectation, with a claimed significance of 4.9 ​ σ 4.9\sigma . We present a comprehensive reassessment of this test using the same dataset, incorporating major sources of uncertainty in the statistical inference. We use a simulation framework based on the FLASK package, incorporating lognormal realizations of the large-scale structure, the quasar clustering bias, the survey’s radial selection function, and its exact sky coverage. Our simulations account for the kinematic dipole, the intrinsic clustering dipole, shot noise, and survey geometry effects. The analysis yields a revised significance of the kinematic dipole excess of 3.63 ​ σ 3.63\sigma in the absence of a clustering dipole, and 3.44 ​ σ 3.44\sigma in the presence of a randomly oriented clustering dipole. When the clustering dipole is aligned with the kinematic dipole direction, the significance decreases further to 3.27 ​ σ 3.27\sigma . Our analysis demonstrates that although the anomaly is reduced in significance, it cannot be explained solely as a result of the clustering dipole or mode coupling arising from the survey mask. show][email protected] I Introduction The cosmological principle, which proposes that the universe is statistically homogeneous and isotropic on sufficiently large scales, forms the bedrock of modern cosmology. This principle is directly tested through observations of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and large-scale structure. The dipole anisotropy observed in the CMB temperature has been conventionally interpreted as a kinematic effect due to our peculiar motion relative to the CMB rest frame. According to the most recent measurement the velocity inferred from CMB dipole measurements is 369.82\pm 0.11~\text{km/s} , in the direction (l,b)=(264.^{\circ}021,48.^{\circ}253) ( Planck Collaboration et al. 2020a ) . An important consequence of this kinematic interpretation is that it must be observable not only in the CMB but also as a corresponding Doppler-induced dipole anisotropy in flux-limited, all-sky surveys. The Ellis-Baldwin test can provide a crucial verification of this interpretation by searching for a Doppler-induced dipole in the number counts of distant radio sources ( G. F. R. Ellis & J. E. Baldwin 1984 ) . Given a population of sources with a homogeneous and isotropic sky distribution, an observer’s peculiar velocity induces a dipolar modulation in the flux and the number of sources per unit solid angle, from which a kinetic dipole amplitude can be inferred and compared with the value obtained from the CMB. The 1.4 GHz NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS) data, that includes \sim 1.8 million sources, allowed astronomers to measure the dipole, providing an independent check of the kinematic interpretation ( J. J. Condon et al. 1998 ; C. Blake & J. Wall 2002 ; A. K. Singal 2011 ; C. Gibelyou & D. Huterer 2012 ) . Subsequent analysis by M. Rubart & D. J. Schwarz 2013 ; C. A. P. Bengaly et al. 2018 ; A. K. Singal 2019 ; T. M. Siewert et al. 2021 ; A. K. Singal 2023 ; J. D. Wagenveld et al. 2023 ; A. K. Singal 2025 ; N. J. Secrest et al. 2022a ; L. Böhme et al. 2025 consistently reported dipole amplitude exceeding the CMB prediction, suggesting potential tensions with the standard kinematic interpretation. This mystery deepened with more recent studies. N. J. Secrest et al. 2021 measured a dipole in the CatWISE2020 quasar catalog that was more than twice the CMB expectation at 4.9\sigma significance level and aligned at \sim 27 ∘ with respect to the CMB dipole direction. L. Dam et al. 2023 confirmed this anomalously large signal using Bayesian inference, and analyzed whether the mask can cause a considerable loss of dipole signal due to a leakage of power into higher multipoles. Further analysis of the same dataset was carried out by P. Tiwari et al. 2023 testing the data against FLASK simulations ( H. S. Xavier et al. 2016 ) by incorporating quasar clustering properties. They found a clustering dipole amplitude of D_{\text{clus}}=0.81\times 10^{-3} . While substantial, this clustering component cannot fully account for the observed amplitude excess. Notably, for angular scales corresponding to multipoles \ell\geq 10 (approximately >18^{\circ} ), the AGN/quasar clustering agrees with \Lambda CDM expectations. More recent analysis by A. Abghari et al. 2024 reveals additional complexities: the spatial distribution of quasars shows that if low-order multipoles (e.g. \ell=3 ) are comparable in size to the dipole, then that might indicate unknown systematic effects. Crucially, the 52.6\% sky cut in CatWISE2020 quasar catalog induces strong mode coupling, particularly between the octopole ( \ell=3 ) and the estimated dipole, leading to additional uncertainties. This coupling can result in dipole amplitude errors large enough that consistency with the CMB dipole cannot be ruled out, highlighting the critical challenge of disentangling true cosmological signal from mask-induced systematics. The conclusions of A. Abghari et al. 2024 were challenged in N. Secrest et al. 2025 , with questions raised about the magnitude of the higher \ell -mode amplitudes adopted. In this work, we perform a reassessment of the reported dipole anomaly by implementing a comprehensive treatment of uncertainties potentially underestimated in previous analyses discussed above. We systematically quantify the impact of key systematic effects on the significance level of the CatWISE2020 quasar dipole, including: shot noise contamination, higher-order clustering contributions, the amplitude and orientation of the intrinsic clustering dipole, mask-induced mode coupling, and the propagation of cosmic variance uncertainties in the clustering component. By incorporating these effects through simulations, we derive an updated statistical significance that reflects a more complete error budget, providing a updated evaluation of the dipole’s consistency with the kinematic interpretation. This paper is structured as follows. Section. II discusses the details of the CatWISE2020 quasar catalog and the sky mask geometry used for the analysis. Section. III presents the formalism for the number count dipole and outlines the least-square estimator employed to measure the dipole amplitude. In section IV , we analyze some sources of uncertainties and bias that affect the dipole measurement. This includes a quantification of the bias introduced by mode mixing due to incomplete sky coverage and an assessment of the cosmic variance inherent to the clustering signal. Section V describes our procedure for generating mock quasar catalogs, which are essential for statistical validation. Section VI presents our main results, where we quantify the statistical significance of the observed dipole under a series of distinct astrophysical scenarios. Finally, Section VII provides a discussion of our findings and the implications of our results. II CatWISE2020 Quasar Catalog The quasar sample used in this study is the catalog constructed by N. J. Secrest et al. 2021 from the CatWISE catalog ( P. R. M. Eisenhardt et al. 2020 ;

Read the complete text