Polarization Diagnostics Applied to Coronal Mass Ejections and the Background Solar Wind
S.E.Sarah E. \lnm Gibson \orcid 0000-0001-9831-2640, C.E.Craig E. \lnm DeForest \orcid 0000-0002-7164-2786, C.A.Curt A. \lnm de Koning, S.R.Steven R. \lnm Cranmer \orcid 0000-0002-3699-3134, Y.Yuhong \lnm Fan, H.Huw \lnm Morgan, E.Elena \lnm Provornikova, A.Anna \lnm Malanushenko, D.David \lnm Webb · 2025
Read Polarization Diagnostics Applied to Coronal Mass Ejections and the Background Solar Wind by S.E.Sarah E. \lnm Gibson \orcid 0000-0001-9831-2640, C.E.Craig E. \lnm DeForest \orcid 0000-0002-7164-2786, C.A.Curt A. \lnm de Koning, S.R.Steven R. \lnm Cranmer \orcid 0000-0002-3699-3134, Y.Yuhong \lnm Fan, H.Huw \lnm Morgan, E.Elena \lnm Provornikova, A.Anna \lnm Malanushenko, D.David \lnm Webb (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00714.txt.
Introduction
Sarah Gibson and eight co-authors sharpen a polarization trick for locating solar eruptions in three dimensions. Sunlight scattered by electrons is polarized, and the ratio of radial to tangential polarization reveals where compact structures sit along the line of sight. The PUNCH mission was designed around exactly this diagnostic for coronal mass ejections and the background solar wind.
The same ratio, the authors note, doubles as a local measure of how steeply density falls off in the quiet wind, which creates ambiguity. Judging whether a structure is compact enough for 3D positioning becomes essential. Building from single sight lines to full three-dimensional ejection models, they measure how accurately polarization properties of both eruptions and quiet wind can be diagnosed. The challenges and opportunities of PUNCH data are mapped together.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S.E.Sarah E. \lnm Gibson \orcid 0000-0001-9831-2640, C.E.Craig E. \lnm DeForest \orcid 0000-0002-7164-2786, C.A.Curt A. \lnm de Koning, S.R.Steven R. \lnm Cranmer \orcid 0000-0002-3699-3134, Y.Yuhong \lnm Fan, H.Huw \lnm Morgan, E.Elena \lnm Provornikova, A.Anna \lnm Malanushenko, D.David \lnm Webb |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00714
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Polarization Diagnostics Applied to Coronal Mass Ejections and the Background Solar Wind S.E.Sarah E. \lnm Gibson \orcid 0000-0001-9831-2640, C.E.Craig E. \lnm DeForest \orcid 0000-0002-7164-2786, C.A.Curt A. \lnm de Koning, S.R.Steven R. \lnm Cranmer \orcid 0000-0002-3699-3134, Y.Yuhong \lnm Fan, H.Huw \lnm Morgan, E.Elena \lnm Provornikova, A.Anna \lnm Malanushenko, D.David \lnm Webb Abstract The ratio of radially to tangentially polarized Thomson-scattered white light provides a powerful tool for locating the 3D position of compact structures in the solar corona and inner heliosphere, and the Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere (PUNCH) has been designed to take full advantage of this diagnostic capability. Interestingly, this same observable that establishes the position of transient blob-like structures becomes a local measure of the slope of the global falloff of density in the background solar wind. It is thus important to characterize the extent along the line of sight of structures being studied, in order to determine whether they are sufficiently compact for 3D positioning. In this paper, we build from analyses of individual lines of sight to three-dimensional models of coronal mass ejections (CMEs), allowing us to consider how accurately polarization properties of the transient and quiescent solar wind are diagnosed. In this way, we demonstrate the challenges and opportunities presented by PUNCH polarization data for various quantitative diagnostics. 1 Introduction The Polarimeter to Unify the Corona and Heliosphere, or PUNCH, is a NASA Small Explorer Mission. PUNCH studies the “young” solar wind, by obtaining direct, continuous 3D imaging of the entire corona and inner heliosphere in polarized white light via four synchronous smallsats. It launched in March, 2025, with a two-year prime mission duration. See DeForest et al. 2025 for an overview of the mission, its instruments, and its scientific objectives. A primary science target for PUNCH is characterizing Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs; see, e.g., Malanushenko et al. 2025 ) which are generally expected to incorporate coherently twisted magnetic fields, i.e., magnetic flux ropes (see, e.g., Provornikova et al. 2025 ). PUNCH provides a full-circle field of view (FOV) from five solar radii outward, mosaicking the fields of view of a central Near Field Imager (NFI) ( Colaninno et al. 2025 ) with three Wide Field Imagers (WFI) ( Laurent 2025 ) . In this way, PUNCH fills existing gaps between coronagraphs and heliospheric imagers and obtains continuous wide-field observations of the evolution of CMEs and their substructure from the Sun throughout the inner solar system. This large FOV is also intended to yield new insight into the formation, evolution and 3D structure of stream interaction regions (SIRs) that arise between fast and slow wind streams ( de Koning et al. 2025 ) . PUNCH obtains both brightness and polarized brightness measurements to image and locate evolving SIR and CME structures in 3D: a measurement of great importance to space weather predictions ( Seaton et al. 2025 ) . Until PUNCH, only coronagraphs (i.e., no heliospheric imagers) have had both brightness and polarized brightness observations. PUNCH is the first heliospheric imager to be designed with polarization capability and to have the sensitivity, spatial FOV, and polarization capability needed to locate and track bright structures as they propagate, with both its inner coronagraph and its three heliospheric imagers operating as a single “virtual instrument”. In Section 2 we review how these data may be directly related to a 3D position of a compact mass, or “superparticle”, along a particular line of sight. We also consider how the same image data can provide a completely different diagnostic, a local measure of the global falloff of the background solar wind density. We discuss the transition between these two extremes and how the viewing angle on a compact mass and its width along a line of sight affects the ability to establish its 3D location via polarization,and discuss unavoidable uncertainties in polarization analysis due to the size and location of a scattering mass. In Section 3 , we present a variety of forward modeled CMEs, comparing the 3D position of the CME front to ground truth simulation knowledge of the position of mass along the line of sight. We also discuss how front-back ambiguity associated with polarization analysis can be resolved using the wide field of view and sensitivity of PUNCH images, and how establishing the 3D postion of CME substructures might be used to diagnose magnetic flux rope chirality. In Section 4 , we present our conclusions. Figure 1: Geometry of the system. The superparticle is the grey oval, and the observer is shown as the eyeball on the bottom right, looking along a line of sight with elongation angle \varepsilon (see Appendix A for definitions of other variables). Also indicated is the cross section of the Thomson Surface (TS), which is significant because it is the location of closest approach to the Sun for each line of sight, and thus strongest illumination. Near the sun, this occurs in or near to the plane of the sky, but for wider elongation angles, the radial closest approaches of the (non-parallel) lines of sight forms the spherical surface shown here. Note that in the mapping of the bottom-left image, the sky plane is the Y-Z plane as is commonly assumed for close-in coronagraph images (since PUNCH is in Earth orbit, the X-Y-Z coordinate system used here are assumed to be Radial-Tangential-Normal (RTN) (see Burlaga 1984 ; Fränz and Harper 2002 ). For lines of sight farther out, it is more common (and appropriate for the PUNCH mission) to map the structure onto the celestial sphere in an azimuthal-equidistant mapping with grid spacing constant in elongation angle ( \varepsilon ) as seen projected on the X_{im}-Y_{im} image plane (bottom-right inset). See DeForest et al. 2025 for further discussion of this figure. 2 Polarization Diagnostics 2.1 Background The brightness and polarization of the white light corona was first considered theoretically by Schuster 1879 , and then in comparison to observations of solar eclipses ( Young 1911 ; Minnaert 1930 ; Baumbach 1938 ; Öhman 1947 ; van de Hulst 1950 ) . These analyses demonstrated how radiation from the solar photosphere is Thomson scattered in the optically-thin corona, and how the linearly polarized component of that radiation (polarized brightness, or pB ) becomes an excellent diagnostic of the line-of-sight integral of n_{e} ( Altschuler and Perry 1972 ; Munro and Jackson 1977 ; Inhester 2015 , see also) . The fall-off with distance of n_{e}(r) has been studied using pB by multiple authors, including Saito et al. 1970 ; Munro and Jackson 1977 ; Fisher and Guhathakurta 1995 ; Guhathakurta, Holzer, and MacQueen 1996 ; Gibson et al. 1999 ; Edwards et al. 2023 . Others have combined coronagraph data with radio and in-situ measurements to find density parameterizations that cover distances from the low corona to interplanetary space ( Bird and Edenhofer 1990 ; Leblanc, Dulk, and Bougeret 1998 ; Mann et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . Many of the density diagnostic studies cited above used observations of pB from ground-based coronagraphs. Total brightness ( tB ) – i.e., the sum of radial and tangential brightnesses – is difficult to measure from the ground because of the largely unpolarized sky brightness background (except during a solar eclipse). With the