Modeling dust dynamics in OpenGadget3

G. Tedeschi-Prades, T. Birnstiel ,, K. Dolag ,, B. Ercolano ,, M. Hutchison · 2025

Read Modeling dust dynamics in OpenGadget3 by G. Tedeschi-Prades, T. Birnstiel ,, K. Dolag ,, B. Ercolano ,, M. Hutchison (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00631.txt.

Introduction

Giovanni Tedeschi-Prades, Til Birnstiel, Klaus Dolag, Barbara Ercolano, and Mark Hutchison add dust dynamics to the OpenGadget3 simulation code, a workhorse for astrophysics. Dust steers processes from star formation to planet building, and particle-based hydrodynamics handles it well through the one-fluid model, which treats gas and dust as one mixture with internal drift. Their implementation improves on the original formulation in several ways.

Time-dependent artificial viscosity and conductivity join a new treatment of dust diffusion built from a pressure-like term. The code passes the standard dusty benchmarks, box, wave, and shock tests, the last extended to multiple dimensions, plus a dusty blast wave. Keplerian disks, protoplanetary disks, and shear instabilities stress it further. The diffusion term helps most where dust dominates and drag is weak, though limits of the one-fluid picture remain.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Tedeschi-Prades, T. Birnstiel ,, K. Dolag ,, B. Ercolano ,, M. Hutchison
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00631

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling dust dynamics in OpenGadget3 G. Tedeschi-Prades, T. Birnstiel ,, K. Dolag ,, B. Ercolano ,, M. Hutchison Abstract Context. Dust dynamics plays a critical role in astrophysical processes and has been modeled in hydrodynamical simulations using various approaches. Among particle-based methods like Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), the One-Fluid model has proven to be highly effective for simulating gas-dust mixtures. Aims. This study presents the implementation of the One-Fluid model in OpenGadget3 , introducing improvements to the original formulation. These enhancements include time-dependent artificial viscosity and conductivity, as well as a novel treatment of dust diffusion using a pressure-like term. Methods. The improved model is tested using a suite of dust dynamics benchmark problems: DUSTYBOX, DUSTYWAVE, and DUSTYSHOCK, with the latter extended to multidimensional scenarios, as well as a dusty Sedov-Taylor blast wave. Additional tests include simulations of Cold Keplerian Disks, dusty protoplanetary disks, and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities to evaluate the model’s robustness in more complex flows. Results. The implementation successfully passes all standard benchmark tests. It demonstrates stability and accuracy in both simple and complex simulations. The new diffusion term improves the handling of flows with large dust-to-gas ratios and low drag coefficients, although limitations of the One-Fluid model in these regimes remain. Conclusions. The enhanced One-Fluid model is a reliable and robust tool for simulating dust dynamics in OpenGadget3 . While it retains some limitations inherent to the original formulation, the introduced improvements expand its applicability and address some challenges in gas-dust dynamics. I. SPH implementation of the One-Fluid model 1 Introduction Dust, alongside gas, is one of the fundamental components of most astrophysical systems. From the cold interstellar medium to molecular clouds and protoplanetary disks, dust is observed ubiquitously across the Milky Way and other galaxies. Importantly, in many cases, dust is the only directly observable component, detected through its millimeter and infrared thermal emission. Gas properties are often inferred indirectly from dust observations, typically assuming a constant dust-to-gas ratio of 10^{-2} . Dust also plays a critical role in a variety of astrophysical processes. It contributes to the cooling of gas in star-forming regions ( Vogelsberger et al. 2019 ) , serves as a surface for chemical reactions that form complex molecules ( Minissale et al. 2016 ) , and provides the primary opacity source in many environments, impacting radiative transfer. Understanding the behavior of dust is therefore crucial not only for interpreting observations but also for modeling the physical conditions and evolution of astrophysical systems. While dust is generally assumed to be perfectly coupled to the gas, this assumption breaks down either for larger dust-to-gas ratios or for larger grain sizes. Protoplanetary disks are the astrophysical environment where dust dynamics has been most thoroughly studied. Here, the uncoupling of dust and gas is essential to understand the evolution of the disk and the early stages of planet formation ( Birnstiel 2024 ) . The radial drift of dust grains inward, one of the most important dynamical mechanisms to understand the evolution of disks, is caused by a slight difference between the rotational velocity of gas and of dust. But disks are not the only objects in which the dynamics of dust grains play a role. The outflows of AGB stars are also believed to be accelerated by radiation pressure on dust grains, which consequently accelerates gas by aerodynamic drag. The same mechanism is also proposed to fuel outflows from ”dusty torus” regions around AGNs ( Soliman & Hopkins 2023 ) . Given the importance of dust as a key component of many astrophysical systems, the inclusion of dust dynamics in modern hydrodynamical simulation codes has seen significant growth in recent years. One widely used approach involves post-processing gas-only simulations to study the behavior of dust. While this method improves upon the assumption of perfect coupling between dust and gas, it neglects the critical back-reaction of dust on gas motion. This omission can lead to inaccuracies, especially in scenarios with substantial dust-to-gas ratios or large grain sizes, where dust can significantly influence the gas dynamics. Self-consistent models of dust dynamics have been implemented in Eulerian codes, both as tracer particles, such as in AREPO ( McKinnon et al. 2018 ) , or as additional fluids, like in ATHENA++ ( Huang & Bai 2022 ) and FARGO3D ( Benítez-Llambay et al. 2019 ) . In Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) frameworks, the model that has achieved the most success in simulating dust dynamics is the One-Fluid model developed by ( Laibe & Price 2014a ) . This approach represents a significant departure from traditional multi-fluid methods by describing the motion of a gas-dust mixture self-consistently, rather than treating gas and dust as separate fluids coupled via aerodynamic drag. A notable implementation of the One-Fluid model, in the terminal velocity approximation limit, is in the SPH code PHANTOM ( Price et al. 2018 ) . While this model has been largely successful at simulating the dynamics of small dust grains, it still presents challenges when simulating large dust grains. Most notably, ( Laibe & Price 2014b ) observed that interpenetrating dust flows of weakly coupled grains can violate the assumptions underlying the fluid approximation for a pressureless dust model, causing the code to crash. More subtly, the inability of a pressureless fluid to capture the diffusive nature of a multi-valued velocity distribution leads to artificial clumping of dust, which can produce numerical failures or result in an overestimate of planetesimal formation timescales. This has led to the One-Fluid model to be used mostly in the terminal velocity approximation, where dust is assumed to couple efficiently to the gas on timescales smaller than the numerical integration timestep. One possible solution to this long-standing issue of simulating dust dynamics is the introduction of some form of dust pressure. For instance, Lynch et al. 2024 found that a treatment of dust pressure is needed in order to correctly simulate dust dynamics in debris disks. In this paper, we will describe the implementation of the full (i.e., not in the terminal velocity approximation) One-Fluid model for dust dynamics in OpenGadget3 . In particular, we will focus on improvements on the original implementation derived in ( Laibe & Price 2014b ) , such as time-dependent artificial viscosity and conductivity, and a model of dust diffusion via a dust pressure-like term to treat clumping in simulations of weakly coupled dust. While the limitations of the full One-Fluid model are still present in the most extreme cases, we show how these improvements can make the One-Fluid model suitable for a larger set of astrophysical applications compared to the terminal velocity approximation. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we show how the One-Fluid model is derived from the equations describing the motion of dust and gas separately and we show the discretization of the continuum equations in the SPH framework, including the improved viscosity and conductivity terms and the dust-pressure diffusion model. In Section 3, we show the performance of the code on a suite of standard numerical tests, as well as on more complex simulations such as the Cold Keplerian Disk and the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. Finally, in Section 4, we present our conclusions and outline potential avenues for future development. 2 Methods 2.1 The

Read the complete text