Modeling the Construction of a Literary Archetype: The Case of the Detective Figure in French Literature DOI: 00000/00000

Jean Barré, Olga Seminck, Antoine Bourgois, Thierry Poibeau · 2025

Read Modeling the Construction of a Literary Archetype: The Case of the Detective Figure in French Literature DOI: 00000/00000 by Jean Barré, Olga Seminck, Antoine Bourgois, Thierry Poibeau (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00627.txt.

Introduction

Jean Barré, Olga Seminck, Antoine Bourgois, and Thierry Poibeau trace the making of the detective, a literary archetype, across one hundred fifty years of French fiction. Using quantitative methods and character-level embeddings, they test whether one archetype truly unites figures from M Lecoq in 1866 to Commissaire Adamsberg in 2017. A supervised model can indeed capture that unity across the whole span.

Within the unity, the role mutates. The detective grows from a secondary figure into the central character and the reasoning machine of the classical detective story. After the Second World War, the imported American hardboiled tradition seeps into France, and the archetype darkens. The detective now navigates social violence and moral ambiguity. Computational reading makes the long arc of a cultural figure measurable.

Catalog record

CREATORJean Barré, Olga Seminck, Antoine Bourgois, Thierry Poibeau
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00627

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling the Construction of a Literary Archetype: The Case of the Detective Figure in French Literature DOI: 00000/00000 Jean Barré, Olga Seminck, Antoine Bourgois, Thierry Poibeau Abstract This research explores the evolution of the detective archetype in French detective fiction through computational analysis. Using quantitative methods and character-level embeddings, we show that a supervised model is able to capture the unity of the detective archetype across 150 years of literature, from M. Lecoq (1866) to Commissaire Adamsberg (2017). Building on this finding, the study demonstrates how the detective figure evolves from a secondary narrative role to become the central character and the “reasoning machine” [ 35 ] of the classical detective story. In the aftermath of the Second World War, with the importation of the hardboiled tradition into France, the archetype becomes more complex, navigating the genre’s turn toward social violence and moral ambiguity. [orcid=0000-0002-1579-0610] [orcid=0000-0003-4617-5992] [orcid=0009-0008-8117-4120] [orcid=0000-0003-3669-4051] LaTTiCe Laboratory, CNRS-ENS-PSL, Paris, France \pubvolume 1 \pagestart 1 \pageend 1 \conferencename Proceedings of Computational Humanities Research 2025 \conferenceeditors Editor1 Editor2 keywords Computational Literary Studies, Detective Fiction, Detective Figure, Character Embeddings, Genre Evolution, NLP, Machine Learning 1 Introduction Distant reading [ 30 ] has become a key methodological approach in literary studies, enabling the large-scale analysis of digitized corpora through computational techniques. By moving beyond the traditional canon to include lesser-studied works, it offers a broader perspective on literary trends over time [ 29 , 38 , 5 , 4 ] . While distant reading can be applied to various aspects of literary texts, the analysis of literary characters has emerged as a particularly productive area of research, allowing scholars to explore narrative structures, character portrayals, and cultural representations at scale. A foundational work in this line of inquiry is provided by [ 3 ] , who propose a Bayesian mixed-effects model to infer latent character types from a large corpus of English novels. Their study demonstrates that computational methods can identify underlying character personas by analyzing linguistic patterns associated with character descriptions, actions, and dialogues. Following this seminal approach, the computational literary studies community has developed specialized tools to automate the extraction of character information. Notable examples include BookNLP for English [ 2 , 1 ] , as well as its counterparts adapted to other languages such as French [ 26 ] , German [ 15 ] , and Dutch [ 43 ] . These pipelines enable researchers to systematically identify and cluster all mentions of a given character, alongside associated linguistic features including agentive and passive verbs, modifiers, and direct speech. Leveraging these computational methods within distant reading frameworks, subsequent research has explored significant literary phenomena, notably the representation of gender [ 39 , 31 , 41 ] and the structural analysis of plot dynamics [ 19 , 18 ] . In this study, we use this character modeling approaches to study the emergence and evolution of the detective archetype in French fiction. The figure of the detective has become a ubiquitous presence in contemporary popular culture, extending far beyond literature into cinema, television series, and various media adaptations. However, its roots lie firmly within English and French literary traditions [ 11 , 12] , particularly between the late 19th and early 20th centuries, a period crucial to the construction and popularization of detective fiction as a genre. We decided to focus exclusively on the detective archetype in French literature. Although there are numerous interconnections and reciprocal influences with the Anglo-American tradition, illustrated by Poe’s Dupin inspiring Gaboriau’s Lecoq [ 34 , 32 ] , who in turn influenced Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes [ 8 , 22 ] , the depth and distinctiveness of the French detective tradition alone present a substantial challenge. To be more specific, we build a classifier that is able to automatically detect characters that are detectives (Section 3 ). We study the emergence of the detective figure by quantifying the percentage of detectives per year in a large corpus of French fiction Chapitres Corpus [ 21 ] , and show that the detective characters tends to be more and more central to the novels as the literary genre is building up (Section 4 ). Finally, we also demonstrate that our methods support literary theory about the emergence of detective subgenres, such as the Hard-Boiled detectives (putting forward solitary characters fighting organized crime as well as corrupt authorities) and French Roman Noir or Neo-Polar (Section 5 ). Our computational analysis shows how the critical perspective from canonical whodunit figures expands to broader representations of the detective, capturing subtle shifts and variations in characterization over time. 2 The Detective Archetype 2.1 Definition The detective archetype constitutes a foundational figure within detective fiction, evolving from a peripheral puzzle solver to a central character embodying rationality and methodical reasoning. As Dubois emphasizes, classic detectives such as Dupin, Holmes, and Rouletabille favor purely intellectual work, distancing themselves from direct action: “he solves the problems presented to him by pure analytical deduction” [ 14 ] . This approach aligns closely with the notion of a reasoning machine [ 35 ] , which disregards human motives or psychology, focusing solely on the accuracy of deductions regarding actions. Consequently, the detective evolves into an extreme symbol of rationality, whose methods rely systematically on interpreting clues and signs to solve a mystery. This fundamental definition of the detective is intimately linked to the whodunit , a subgenre of detective fiction that stands out for its puzzle-like plot, with clues and red herrings carefully scattered to invite the reader to match wits with the detective and try to uncover the truth before the final revelation. Todorov [ 36 ] analyzes the specificity of the whodunit by highlighting a double narrative structure: the hidden story of the crime and the visible story of the investigation. In this way, the identity and role of the detective are inseparable from the whodunit : the detective becomes both the reader’s guide and double in logically reconstructing a crime that has already occurred. While canonical detective figures such as Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes or Gaboriau’s Père Tabaret epitomize this rational genius archetype, meaning that intelligence and ingenious reasoning are key to solving the mystery by the end of the novel, the archetype is not limited to officially sanctioned investigators. Holmes or Tabaret themselves, for instance, are no professional police detectives. Rather, the archetype comprises a complex aggregation of characters, roles, and traits that evolve through time and across literary subgenres. It can be embodied by a wide variety of characters, ranging from private and amateur detectives to police officers, overly inquisitive journalists, and even criminals [ 9 ] . In France, this diversification materialized through increasingly ambiguous and complex figures, such as Arsène Lupin, simultaneously detective and criminal, pursued by genuine detectives like Commissioner Ganimard or the amateur sleuth Isidore Beautrelet. These diverse incarnations underscore the archetype’s adaptability and illustrate how detective fiction explores multiple perspectives, social roles, and investigative approaches through a spectrum of distinct yet interconnected characters. 2.2 Origins The detective archetype emerged from mid-19th-century literary developments, influenced by proto-detective figures such as Edmond Dantès ( Le Comte de Monte Cristo ), Rodolphe ( Les Mystères de Paris ), and Rocambole (Ponson du Terrail) [ 20 ] . Its

Read the complete text