Impact of Localization in Early-Universe QCD Phase Transition

Janus Capellan Aban 1,2,∗ , Edmayelle Villavicencio Alforja 3,† , Vincent Gene L. Otero 3,‡ · 2025

Read Impact of Localization in Early-Universe QCD Phase Transition by Janus Capellan Aban 1,2,∗ , Edmayelle Villavicencio Alforja 3,† , Vincent Gene L. Otero 3,‡ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00465.txt.

Introduction

Janus Capellan Aban, Edmayelle Villavicencio Alforja, and Vincent Gene Otero ask how quark localization changed the early universe's great phase transition, when quark-gluon plasma cooled into ordinary matter. Disorder from gluons can pin quarks in place, cutting the effective freedom they carry. The authors add that effect to the MIT bag model, a standard simple description of the transition.

Localization raises the critical temperature by roughly seven percent, and the transition starts earlier in cosmic time. The mixed phase then lasts only about eight microseconds, roughly a quarter shorter than the plain bag model predicts, and the hadronic phase cools faster. Energy density and pressure curves shift downward, landing in better agreement with lattice QCD data from the HotQCD collaboration. Disorder, it seems, left a real fingerprint on cosmic cooling.

Catalog record

CREATORJanus Capellan Aban 1,2,∗ , Edmayelle Villavicencio Alforja 3,† , Vincent Gene L. Otero 3,‡
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00465

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Impact of Localization in Early-Universe QCD Phase Transition Janus Capellan Aban 1,2,∗ , Edmayelle Villavicencio Alforja 3,† , Vincent Gene L. Otero 3,‡ Abstract We introduce a phenomenological modification of the MIT bag model equation of state that incorporates quark localization arising from gluon-induced disorder in the quark-gluon plasma. This model effectively reduces the quark degrees of freedom encoded in the product of the disorder activation function G ⁡ ( W ) G(W) and the localization efficiency factor H ⁡ ( T ) H(T) . As a result, the critical temperature is increased roughly by 7% . Employing the Friedmann equation, we find that the onset of the phase transition occurs earlier. Consequently, the mixed phase duration is only 8.22 ​ μ ​ s 8.22\,\mu s , which is 24% shorter than the bag model, and the hadronic phase cools faster. The Stefan-Boltzmann limit is reached at much higher temperatures, causing the energy density and pressure curves of the bag model to shift downward and yielding better agreement with the lattice QCD data from the HotQCD collaboration. Our results show that the localization of quarks plays a significant role in the cooling dynamics of the early universe. † † ∗ e-mail: [email protected] † e-mail: [email protected] ‡ e-mail: [email protected] I Introduction In lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD), it is known that at high temperatures, the quark Dirac eigenmodes can localize near the critical temperature Giordano:2013lia ; Kovacs:2010wx . The movement of the localized quarks in this regime is restricted to small spatial regions. In the presence of the disorder induced by the gluon fields background, this phenomenon can be regarded as an Anderson-like localization Giordano:2013taa ; Giordano:2013kza ; Giordano:2014qna ; Giordano:2014cua ; Giordano:2021qav ; Garcia-Garcia:2005azc ; Kovacs:2012zq ; Horvath:2025ypt ; Evers:2007zsx , in which a transition occurs from delocalized to localized states separated by a mobility edge. Such a localization of quarks may alter the thermodynamic behavior of the quark-gluon plasma (QGP) and change the history of cooling in the early universe. A well-known description of the equation of state (EOS) of deconfined quarks and gluons is provided by the MIT bag model Johnson:1978uy ; Chodos:1974je ; Chodos:1974pn ; DeGrand:1975cf . In the confinement phase, this model treats the quarks as non-interacting particles contained within a bag. This bag acts like an infinite potential well in which quarks are free to move but are prohibited from escaping. It has an associated bag constant B that encapsulates the vacuum pressure, maintains the quark confinement, and counteracts the outward pressure they exert on the bag wall. When the outward pressure exceeds the inward vacuum pressure, the bag becomes unstable and, if this condition persists, the QGP phase forms eventually. As a result, the quarks can move over large distances and contribute to thermodynamical quantities such as energy density \varepsilon and pressure p . Although the bag model reproduces many physical features of the QGP, it treats quarks as non-interacting particles and neglects disorder-induced localization. The recent lattice results Giordano:2013lia ; Kovacs:2010wx ; Giordano:2013taa ; Giordano:2013kza ; Giordano:2014qna ; Giordano:2014cua ; Giordano:2021qav ; Garcia-Garcia:2005azc ; Kovacs:2012zq ; Horvath:2025ypt ; Evers:2007zsx on localization motivate us to extend this bag framework by including the disorder and temperature dependent suppression of quark degrees of freedom (d.o.f.) . In this study, we examine the localization effects of the disorder W arising from gluon fields on the EOS of the MIT bag model. In particular, we apply this framework to the early-universe QCD phase transition, where the localization of quarks is analogous to the Anderson localization. In effect, the d.o.f. of quarks will be suppressed due to the limitation of their motion. The relevant suppression factor F_{ext}(W,T) is expressed as a function of the product of the disorder activation function G(W) and the localization efficiency factor H(T) . For simplicity, we assume that the disorder parameter W is directly proportional to the temperature T . Moreover, the suppression factor reduces the quark contribution to the energy density and pressure in the early-universe scenario. We assume that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic Weinberg:1972 as it expands from the onset of the big bang. This makes the time evolution of thermodynamical quantities, such as energy density and pressure to be governed by the Friedmann equation Guardo:2014rta ; Florkowski:2010mc ; Ornik:1987up \displaystyle-\frac{d\varepsilon}{3\sqrt{\varepsilon(T)}(\varepsilon(T)+p(T))}=\sqrt{\frac{8\pi G}{3}}dt\>\>. (1) Using the above Eq. ( 1 ), one can obtain the time evolution of temperature T(t) to examine the impact of the quark localization on the cooling of both plasma and hadron phases. Consequently, the localization alters the duration of the mixed-phase regime. To assess our model, we compare our results with lattice QCD data from the HotQCD collaboration HotQCD:2014kol . Indeed, the localization model yields better agreement than the MIT bag model, using conditions consistent with a realistic QCD EOS applied to relativistic heavy-ion collisions at RHIC Florkowski:2010mc . This work is organized as follows: In Section II , we briefly discuss the MIT bag model EOS Chodos:1974je ; Fogaca:2009wf including the contribution from the electroweak sector. In Section III , we introduce the localization effects of the disorder arising from the gluon fields as a phenomenological modification of the MIT bag model. In this localization framework, we consider a suppression factor F_{ext}(W,T) for the d.o.f. of quarks defined as a function of the product of the disorder activation function G(W) and the localization efficiency factor H(T) . We then apply this localization model to the early-universe QCD phase transition, where the cosmic expansion is governed by the Friedmann equation Guardo:2014rta ; Florkowski:2010mc ; Ornik:1987up . For Section IV , we discuss the implications of quark localization on the thermodynamical quantities such as energy density and pressure, and its consequences to the cooling dynamics of the plasma and hadronic phases in the early-universe scenario. We also compare our findings with lattice QCD data from the HotQCD collaboration HotQCD:2014kol . Finally, our conclusion is presented in Section V . II The MIT bag Model In this section, we consider the EOS of the QGP as described by the well-known MIT bag model Chodos:1974je . In this model, quarks and gluons are free to move within a finite region called the bag. However, once the outward pressure on the bag wall exceeds the confining pressure, quarks and gluons can move across larger spatial regions, indicating the deconfined phase of the system. As described by the MIT bag model for temperature T>T_{c} , the energy density and pressure in the deconfined phase are given by Chodos:1974je ; Fogaca:2009wf \displaystyle\varepsilon_{qgp}(T)=g_{qgp}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{30}T^{4}+B\>\>\>\>\>\textrm{and}\>\>\>\>\>p_{qgp}(T)=g_{qgp}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{90}T^{4}-B, (2) while for T<T_{c} we have \displaystyle\varepsilon_{\pi}(T)=g_{\pi}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{30}T^{4}\>\>\>\>\>\textrm{and}\>\>\>\>\>p_{\pi}(T)=g_{\pi}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{90}T^{4}, (3) where T_{c} is the critical temperature for the phase transition. The quantities g_{qgp}=g_{g}+\frac{7}{8}g_{q} and g_{\pi} denote the d.o.f. of QGP and the pion gas, respectively. Here, the value of g_{\pi} is 3, while for two (three) different quark flavors, g_{qgp}=37 (47.5). Interestingly, for very high temperatures, the bag EOS approaches the Stefan-Boltzmann limit \displaystyle\dfrac{\varepsilon_{qgp}}{T^{4}}=\dfrac{37}{30}\pi^{2}\>\>\>\textrm{and}\>\>\>\dfrac{\varepsilon_{qgp}}{T^{4}}=\dfrac{47.5}{30}\pi^{2} (4) for two and three quark flavors, respectively. The inclusion of the electroweak sector will generate additional contributions to the energy density and pressure given by \displaystyle\varepsilon_{ew}(T)=g_{ew}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{30}T^{4}\>\>\>\>\>\textrm{and}\>\>\>\>\>p_{ew}(T)=g_{ew}\dfrac{\pi^{2}}{90}T^{4} (5) which are relevant within the temperature range considered in this study as in Florkowski:2010mc . By treating electroweak particles as massless, the effective d.o.f. becomes g_{ew}=14.25 Yagi:2005yb , coming from the

Read the complete text