Optimization of factorization scale in QED Drell-Yan-like processes

Andrej Arbuzov, Uliana Voznaya, Aliaksandr Sadouski · 2025

Read Optimization of factorization scale in QED Drell-Yan-like processes by Andrej Arbuzov, Uliana Voznaya, Aliaksandr Sadouski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00437.txt.

Introduction

Andrej Arbuzov, Uliana Voznaya, and Aliaksandr Sadouski examine a technical choice in precision particle physics calculations: the factorization scale. In electron-positron annihilation processes like the QED Drell-Yan-like reactions they study, corrections from initial state radiation depend on that scale choice. A poor choice can distort predictions, while a well-tuned one keeps approximations honest.

The authors analyze different prescriptions for setting the scale, working at leading and next-to-leading logarithmic accuracy, where the largest radiation effects are summed in order. They then compare each prescription against known complete one-loop and two-loop results. The comparisons single out the scale choices that track the exact answers best, giving calculators a firmer basis for future precision work.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrej Arbuzov, Uliana Voznaya, Aliaksandr Sadouski
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00437

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Optimization of factorization scale in QED Drell-Yan-like processes Andrej Arbuzov, Uliana Voznaya, Aliaksandr Sadouski Abstract The dependence of corrections due to the initial state radiation in e + ​ e − e^{+}e^{-} -annihilation processes on the choice of the factorization scale is investigated. Different prescriptions of the factorization scale choice are analyzed within the leading and next-to-leading logarithmic approximations. Comparisons with the known complete two-loop results are used to optimize the scale choice. I Introduction Current and future high-precision experiments challenge the theory by demanding very accurate predictions which require in particular calculation of higher-order contributions within perturbation theory. Despite the great progress in the development of multi-loop computational methods, computing the full \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{2}) electroweak and even QED radiative corrections to realistic observables in high-energy physics remains a complex task. The QED structure function 1 1 1 These functions are better to be called QED parton distribution functions (QED PDFs). approach Kuraev and Fadin 1985 circumvents this problem by systematically taking into account higher-order contributions, amplified by the powers of the so-called large logarithm L=\ln\frac{\mu_{F}^{2}}{\mu_{R}^{2}}, (1) where \mu_{F} is the factorization scale and \mu_{R} is the renormalization scale. Here, we consider the perturbative expansion of radiative corrections in the series both in \alpha and the large logarithm. Terms of the order \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{n}L^{n}) are usually called the leading logarithmic contributions (LO), and those of the order \mathcal{O}(\alpha^{n}L^{n-1}) are the next-to-leading (NLO) ones, and so on. The renormalization scale in QED is usually chosen to be equal to the electron mass m_{e} , so in what follows we will use \alpha(\mu_{R}^{2})\equiv\alpha\approx\alpha(0) . This choice is dictated by the need to explicitly define and control the terms singular in the electron mass. Regarding the factorization scale, its choice is somewhat arbitrary. The known explicit analytic results show that the factorization scale should correspond to the characteristic energy scale of the process under consideration, e.g., the factorization scale equal to the t -channel momentum transfer \mu_{F}=\sqrt{-t} is a reasonable choice for small-angle Bhabha scattering Arbuzov and Scherbakova 2006 . One should keep in mind that the ultimate result of calculations of a (renormalization invariant) observable quantity in all orders in \alpha and L should not depend on the choice of both renormalization and factorization scales. Moreover, for any given order in \alpha the sum of all contributions with different powers of L should not depend on the factorization scale value. Variation of the factorization scale leads to redistribution of contributions between terms with different powers of L in horizontal lines of the following formal representation of radiative corrections \displaystyle\alpha^{0}~(\mathrm{Born}) \displaystyle\alpha^{1}L^{1} \displaystyle\alpha^{1}L^{0} (2) \displaystyle\alpha^{2}L^{2} \displaystyle\alpha^{2}L^{1} \displaystyle\qquad\alpha^{2}L^{0} \displaystyle\alpha^{3}L^{3} \displaystyle\alpha^{3}L^{2} \displaystyle\qquad\alpha^{3}L^{1} \displaystyle\alpha^{3}L^{0} \displaystyle\ldots Optimization of the scale choice should help to concentrate most of the corrections in terms with higher powers of the large logarithms, i.e., the LO and NLO ones. At the same time, we try to reduce the contribution of the terms with lower powers of L (and higher powers in \alpha ) which are more difficult to calculate. In this way, we attempt to improve the convergence of perturbative calculations and reduce the theoretical uncertainty due to unknown higher-order terms. Here, we consider the specific case of electron-positron annihilation into a virtual photon or Z boson. This process can be treated similarly to the Drell-Yan process in QCD with factorization between parton density functions (PDFs) in the initial state and the hard subprocess, see ref. Arbuzov and Voznaya 2024 for details. The article is organized as follows. In the next Section we discuss application of several approaches for choosing the factorization scale. The Section is divided into three parts. In the first part, we compare the differential distributions obtained with three different factorization scales. In the second part, we analyze the effects of varying the factorization scale in the total cross-section. In the third part, we test the effectiveness of the standard scale variation procedure ( \mu_{F}\to\mu_{F}/2,\ 2\mu_{F} ), commonly used to estimate the uncertainties due to the scale dependence. The final Section contains concluding remarks. II Factorization scale choices There are known many ways to optimize the factorization scale choice, see e.g. Di Giustino 2022 . In the conventional scale setting (CSS) scheme, \mu_{F} is chosen to be equal to the characteristic energy scale of the hard sub-process, for example, to the invariant mass of the final state lepton pair in Drell-Yan-like processes at the LHC Anastasiou et al. 2004 and to the muon mass for the muon decay spectrum Arbuzov et al. 2002 . However, this approach has a number of drawbacks: in some processes there may be more than one characteristic scale (e.g., in large-angle Bhabha scattering we have amplitudes both in s and t channels), the results can depend also on the choice of the renormalization scale and scheme. The method of the fastest apparent convergence (FAC) Grunberg 1984 exploits the notion of effective charges. A similar approach was also proposed by N.V. Krasnikov Krasnikov 1981 . The basic idea is that an effective charge can be associated with a given physical quantity, and higher-order corrections to the quantity can be absorbed by renormalization of that charge, so that the LO-corrected expression is equal to the sum of the LO and NLO corrections Ingelman and Rathsman 1994 . In the case of differential distributions and if anomalous dimensions contribute to the physical quantity of interest, the FAC method suggests choosing the \mu_{F} value which corresponds to the fastest convergence of the series of the results obtained in the LO, NLO, NNLO, and further approximations. The Brodsky-Lepage-Mackenzie (BLM) Brodsky et al. 1983 procedure is based on the resummation of vacuum polarization effects in the running coupling constant. The optimal renormalization and factorization scales for a particular process at a given order can be determined by computing the vacuum polarization parts of the diagrams of that order, and by setting the scale with which the terms proportional to the number of flavors N_{f} are absorbed into the coupling constant. The principle of maximal conformality (PMC) Brodsky and Di Giustino 2011 ; Yan et al. 2025 is a generalization of the BLM prescription to all orders and different types of observables. This approach aims to make results of perturbative calculation being invariant with respect to the renormalization scale and scheme choices. The main idea is to exploit the renormalization group invariance. As a result, the convergence of the perturbative QCD series can be improved. It should also be noted that the application of the PMC approach requires careful consideration of higher-order effects Kataev and Mikhailov 2015 ; Kataev and Molokoedov 2023 . The principle of minimal sensitivity (PMS) was proposed by P.M. Stevenson Stevenson 2022 . According to this principle, the optimal factorization scale is the one for which the result is least sensitive to the value of the scale. According to PMS, the scale can be chosen by equating the derivative of a physical quantity of interest with respect to the factorization scale to zero (or to its apparent minimum value). Our goal here is to analyze the applicability and effectiveness of various scale selection prescriptions for a specific QED process where analytical results are known for several orders in \alpha and L . II.1 Factorization scale choices in differential distribution Let’s

Read the complete text