Recent progress in global optimizations of covariant energy density functionals
\firstname A. V. \lastname Afanasjev \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Osei \fnsep, \firstname A. \lastname Dalbah \fnsep · 2025
Read Recent progress in global optimizations of covariant energy density functionals by \firstname A. V. \lastname Afanasjev \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Osei \fnsep, \firstname A. \lastname Dalbah \fnsep (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00327.txt.
Introduction
A V Afanasjev, B Osei, and A Dalbah review recent progress in tuning a leading theory of atomic nuclei. The theory, covariant density functional theory, describes nuclei across the whole chart with a small set of energy functionals. Global optimization adjusts those functionals so predictions match data everywhere at once, a task that once cost too much computing time.
A newer anchor-based method changed that picture, allowing global fits at reasonable cost. It also works in very large model spaces, with a sound way to extend results toward an infinite space. That makes it possible to estimate errors from space cutoffs and from terms often left out of binding energy sums, such as electron binding. The review sums up where the field now stands.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | \firstname A. V. \lastname Afanasjev \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Osei \fnsep, \firstname A. \lastname Dalbah \fnsep |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00327
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Recent progress in global optimizations of covariant energy density functionals \firstname A. V. \lastname Afanasjev \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Osei \fnsep, \firstname A. \lastname Dalbah \fnsep Abstract The recent progress on global optimizations of covariant energy density functionals (CEDFs) and global calculations of binding energies within the covariant density functional theory (CDFT) has been analyzed and reviewed. Recently developed anchor-based optimization approach of Ref. TA.23 allows global optimizations of CEDFs at a reasonable numerical cost. Moreover, it permits such optimizations in a very large fermionic basis with a proper extrapolation to an infinite one. This allows to accurately estimate global calculation errors due to use of truncated fermionic basis and neglect of some contributions to binding energies (such as total electron binding energy). 1 Introduction Nuclear binding energies (or masses) is one of the most fundamental properties of atomic nuclei the accurate knowledge of which is important for nuclear structure, neutrino physics and nuclear astrophysics. In experiment, they are measured with an accuracy better than 1 keV. Theoretical calculations do not reach such an accuracy but there is on-going and continuous effort of different nuclear theory groups on an improvement of global description of nuclear masses. They are guided not only by the need for such predictions in nuclear astrophysics but also by an understanding that such observables, which are accurately and globally measured, provide important constraints on the properties of nuclear energy density functionals. The success in theoretical calculations of binding energies has been quite impressive in non-relativistic microscopic+macroscopic (mic+mac) approach and density functional theories (DFTs) with an accuracy of the global reproduction of experimental masses reaching \approx 0.5 MeV. One should say that it is achieved by going beyond the pure DFT framework via the introduction of phenomenological vibrational+rotational corrections (VRC) and Wigner energy. Without such corrections (i.e. at the mean field or at the DFT level) the accuracy of the reproduction of experimental data is seldom better than 1.5 MeV but typically it is lower that this value (see, for example, Ref. UNEDF2 ). A recent study within generator coordinate method (GCM) revealed some differences between the GCM results obtained for VRC and phenomenological ones based on cranking approximation (see Ref. LZY.25 ). It is limited to the Cr isotopes: thus, the global accuracy of phenomenological treatment of VRC is still not well established. There are also conflicting approaches to the definition of the Wigner energy. For example, this energy is proportional to a relative neutron excess |N-Z|/A in the mic+mac calculations of Ref. MNMS.95 . In contrast, it is localized in the vicinity of the N=Z line in Skyrme DFT calculations by Brussels group (see Ref. GSHPT.02 ). A similar progress in the study of binding energies within the CDFT framework has been substantially slower due to the following factors. First, for a given fermionic basis the numerical calculations of matrix elements and the diagonalization of the matrices requires substantially more time (by at least one order of magnitude) than in the case of nonrelativistic DFTs since Dirac spinors contain large and small components of opposite parity (see Ref. TOAPT.24 ). Second, binding energies show very slow convergence as a function of the size of fermionic basis so that accurate calculations with an evaluation of infinite basis corrections to binding energies are numerically very expensive (see Refs. TOAPT.24 ; NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ ). It is only with the introduction of anchor-based optimization approach in Ref. TA.23 that such global optimizations of CEDFs become feasible (see Ref. NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ ). Recent global optimizations of harmonic oscillator basis in the CDFT carried out in Ref. OAD.25 offer the path to a further reduction of numerical expenses. The present paper analyses and reviews global optimizations of CEDFs and global mass calculations carried out in the CDFT. Using the functionals fitted in Ref. NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ as a benchmark, it discusses global calculation errors. Finally, the bottlenecks for the improvement of the description of binding energies are identified and traced back to specific regions of nuclear chart. They are due to the deficiencies in the description of single-particle properties. 2 The status of global calculations Global mass calculations in the CDFT have been carried for almost three decades and Table 1 provides a summary of such calculations for which \Delta B_{rms}\leq 3.0 MeV. Here \Delta B_{rms} is the rms difference between calculated and experimental binding energies. Column 3 displays whether corresponding functional has been fitted globally (Yes) or not (No) and whether global fits were done at the mean field (MF) or beyond mean field (BMF) levels. Note that only in Ref. AGC.16 the latter was employed but the BMF effects were treated at the phenomenological level (PHC) via rotational and vibrational corrections. Column 6 indicates whether the BMF effects have been into account in the global calculations either at the PHC or 5-dimensional Collective Hamiltonian (5DCH) levels. The accuracy of the description of binding energies provided in the last column of Table 1 is discussed in Sec. 4 . In the CDFT calculations all fermionic and bosonic states belonging to the shells up to N_{F} and N_{B} are taken into account in the diagonalization of the Dirac equation and the matrix inversion of the Klein-Gordon equation, respectively (see Sec. III in Ref. TOAPT.24 for details). These values are shown in the column 4 of Table 1 . Note that Woods-Saxon (WS) basis is used in Ref. RHB-e-e-continuum.22 and it is truncated in a different way as compared with harmonic oscillator (HO) basis. The truncation of the HO and WS bases leads to numerical errors in the calculation of nuclear binding energies. It is only in Ref. NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ that the approach effectively approximating to infinite basis is used in the calculations. Column 5 in Table 1 indicates whether total electron binding energies (TEBE) have been taken into account in the conversion of experimental atomic binding energies into nuclear ones. Binding energies provided in the Atomic Mass Evaluations (AME) are atomic ones i.e. they are the sums of nuclear binding energies and total electron binding energies AME2020-second . The absolute values of TEBE gradually increase from almost zero for Z=2 to approximately 1.6 MeV in superheavy nuclei with Z\approx 120 (see Fig. 1 in Ref. NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ and the last column in Table III in Ref. DFA.24 ). TEBE is neglected in absolute majority of fitting protocols of energy density functionals (EDFs) and global mass calculations with these EDFs (see Sec. III in NL5Z-DDMEZ-PCZ ). This represents another source of global errors. Table 1: The summary of existing global mass calculations in the CDFT. Note that the \Delta B_{rms} values shown in plain in the last column are defined from the comparison of experimental atomic binding energies and calculated nuclear ones (i.e. total electron binding energies are neglected). In contrast, bold style is used for the \Delta B_{rms} values defined from the comparison of experimental and calculated nuclear binding energies. See text for further details. functional refe- global HO TEBE BMF- \Delta B_{rms}\pm\delta B_{rms}^{negl} rence fit basis global [MeV] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 NL3* AARR.14 No N_{F}=N_{B}=20 No No 3.00 DD-ME2 AARR.14 No N_{F}=N_{B}=20 No No 2.45 DD-ME \delta AARR.14 No N_{F}=N_{B}=20 No No 2.40 DD-PC1 AARR.14 No N_{F}=N_{B}=20 No No 2.15 DD-MEB1 AGC.16