Local perception operators and classicality: new tools for old tests
Rohit Kishan Ray · 2025
Read Local perception operators and classicality: new tools for old tests by Rohit Kishan Ray (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-00314.txt.
Introduction
Rohit Kishan Ray reframes a basic question in quantum physics: instead of asking whether a state breaks Bell-type limits, ask directly whether the state is local, meaning explainable by classical means. Checking Bell violations is a global task that needs full correlation data. Ray introduces local perception operators, tools that compress global measurements into statistics a local observer can actually access.
From those operators he derives two witnesses, tests that flag nonlocal behavior: one usable by a single party with classical side information, and one that needs both sides. The criteria use only first moments and standard measurements, and they depend on local data and measurement geometry. They can certify classical explanations in cases where standard Bell tests stay inconclusive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rohit Kishan Ray |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-00314
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Local perception operators and classicality: new tools for old tests Rohit Kishan Ray Abstract Quantum nonlocality is often judged by violations of Bell-type inequalities for a given state. The computation of such violations is a global task, requiring evaluation of global correlations and subsequent testing against a Bell functional. We ask instead: when is a given state local (classical)? We formalize this question via local perception operators (LPOs) that compress global observables into locally accessible statistics, and we derive two complementary witnesses—one implementable by a single party with classical side information, one intrinsically two-sided. These tools revisit familiar Bell scenarios from a new operational angle. We show how the witness leads to state-aware constraints that depend on local marginals and measurement geometry, with natural specializations to canonical scenarios. The resulting criteria are built from first moments and standard projective measurements and provide a way to certify compatibility with local hidden variable explanations for the LPO-processed data in regimes where conventional Bell violations may be inconclusive. I Introduction Identifying whether a given quantum state accommodates a local hidden variable (LHV) description is one of the fundamental quests of the studies of quantum foundation. Various tests exist in this regard, the famous of the lot the Bell-CHSH test, an inequality first introduced by Bell 1964 , and then reformulated to be tested on a two qubit system by Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) Clauser et al. 1969 . Any state that satisfies the bound set by this inequality has a LHV description, and cannot be described by one if the inequality is violated. This violation was experimentally first tested by Aspect et al. 1982 albeit with some ‘loopholes’, for the famous loophole free experiment for the same, see Hensen et al. 2015 . These pathbreaking works paved the way for exploration and characterization of the quantum-ness of states. This involved proposing more tests to characterize the said quantum-ness of general multipartite state Mermin 1990 , providing more than two measurement settings to test the hidden structure of these states Collins and Gisin 2004 , generalization of Bell-type inequality Collins et al. 2002 among a sea of other works (for an overall review, see Brunner et al. 2014 ; Cavalcanti and Skrzypczyk 2016 ). Popescu 1995 introduced the concept of super-quantum correlations, that not only maintain no-signaling, but also produce violations more than that prescribed by the traditional Bell-type inequalities. While all of these tests serve a purpose of deciding whether or not a given state is quantum by noticing violations, we can’t be so certain of their nature if the violations don’t happen. As it was noted by Collins and Gisin 2004 , and Tavakoli et al. 2020 , we see that there exist states, which suggest that a given state has LHV description under traditional Bell-CHSH test, can be actually non-local, and LHV model cannot reproduce the full quantum statistics. This renders the identification of states that have LHV description ambiguous, and dependent on multiple tests. Another approach of identifying whether a composite state is entangled (more quantum) or separable is by utilizing the Peres-Horodecki criterion, which considers the non-negativity of the partially transposed density matrix to be necessary criteria for separability Peres 1996 ; Horodecki 1997 . Various other such separability based criteria exist, and they allude to the difficulty of using these criteria for higher dimensions and increasing partitions of a given composite state. In this paper, we attempt to address this gap. We introduce a “witness” that assesses the degree of separability of a given composite state. Using this. we can identify a wide class of states that accommodate LHV description, and can be extended to multipartite states of arbitrary dimensions. The LPO witnesses (symmetric and asymmetric) introduced here do not detect entanglement per se . Rather, they bound what can be inferred from local marginals about the value of a chosen Bell functional after LPO processing. Accordingly, the asymmetric witness supplies a sufficient condition for LHV‑compatibility of the LPO‑processed statistics, whereas the symmetric witness furnishes state‑dependent upper bounds without constituting a Bell inequality. The paper is structured as follows—in section II , we introduce the local perception operator and discuss its key properties. In section III , we introduce our witness and prove the important bounds. In section IV , we present our numerical results, and we conclude in section V . II Local perception operator Consider a bipartite system AB in the Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}}_{AB}={\mathcal{H}}_{A}\otimes{\mathcal{H}}_{B} . For every density matrix \rho\in{\mathcal{H}}_{AB} , we can define the reduced local operator of subsystem {J\vphantom{\overline{J}}} as \rho_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}:=\text{Tr}_{{\overline{J}}}\left(\rho\right) , where {\overline{J}} denotes the complementary subsystem of {J\vphantom{\overline{J}}} . For a given operator X\in\mathcal{L}({\mathcal{H}}_{AB}) 1 1 1 \mathcal{L}({\mathcal{H}}_{AB}) is the set of all bounded linear operators acting on the Hilbert space {\mathcal{H}}_{AB} . , a ‘local perception operator’ (LPO) can be defined as: (X)^{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}_{\rho}=\Tr_{\overline{J}}[(I_{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}{\otimes}\rho_{\overline{J}})X]\,\in\mathcal{L}({\mathcal{H}}_{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}). (1) This LPO was introduced by Beretta in Refs. Beretta 2009 ; *beretta_2010_maximum . Although, primarily used to define local in the context of nonlinear thermodynamic modeling of composite quantum systems, by definition, LPO presents a ‘classical’ partitioning of a composite system. It has the following properties. Property 1 . Linearity — for a fixed \rho , (\alpha X+\beta Y)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho}=\alpha(X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho}+\beta(Y)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho}, (P.I.) Property 2 . \rho\mapsto(X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho} is an affine map in the marginal \rho_{\overline{J}} , but nonlinear in \rho . Property 3 . Classically communicated information — (X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho} contains the information about X that subsystem {J\vphantom{\overline{J}}} can infer after classically receiving \rho_{{\overline{J}}} , \Tr[\rho_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}(X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho}]=\Tr[(\rho_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}{\otimes}\rho_{{\overline{J}}})X]=\Tr[\rho_{{\overline{J}}}(X)^{{\overline{J}}}_{\rho}]\,. (P.II.) Property 4 . Uniqueness — Lemma 1 . For a fixed global X , the LPO (X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho} given by Eq. ( 1 ) is unique local operator satisfying property 3 Eq. ( P.II. ) for all bi-partitions of \rho . Proof. Let’s assume there is another operator Y\in\mathcal{L}({\mathcal{H}}_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}) that satisfies property ( P.II. ), implying \Tr(\rho_{\J}Y)=\Tr[(\rho_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}\otimes\rho_{{\overline{J}}})X] . If we define, \Delta:=Y-(X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho} , we immediately have \Tr(\rho_{\J}\Delta)=0 for all bi-partitions \rho_{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}},~\rho_{{\overline{J}}} of \rho . Which implies \Delta=0 . ∎ Property 5 . No-signaling — (X)^{{J\vphantom{\overline{J}}}}_{\rho} is invariant under unitary local operations in the subsystem {\overline{J}} Ray and Beretta 2025 . For any function X(\rho) (linear or nonlinear), the quantity (X(\rho))^{A} is independent of local unitary operations in B , such that (X(\rho))^{A}=(X(\rho^{\prime}))^{A} , for \rho^{\prime}=(I_{A}\otimes U_{B})\rho(I_{A}\otimes U_{B}^{\dagger}) where U_{B} is a random unitary acting on subsystem B . Property 6 . Preserving POVMs— Theorem 1 . Let \{E_{\alpha}\} be a POVM over {\mathcal{H}}_{A}\otimes{\mathcal{H}}_{B} with \sum_{\alpha}E_{\alpha}=I_{AB} . For any bipartite state \rho with marginals \rho_{A} and \rho_{B} , we have \sum_{\alpha}(E_{\alpha})_{\rho}^{A}=I_{A},\qquad\sum_{\alpha}(E_{\alpha})_{\rho}^{B}=I_{B} (2) where (E_{\alpha})^{A}_{\rho}:=\text{Tr}_{B}\left((I_{A}\otimes\rho_{B})E_{\alpha}\right) and similarly for B . Proof. Using linearity of partial trace we can write: \displaystyle\begin{split}\sum_{\alpha}(E_{\alpha})_{\rho}^{A}&=\sum_{\alpha}\text{Tr}_{B}\left((I_{A}\otimes\rho_{B})E_{\alpha}\right),\\ &=\text{Tr}_{B}\left((I_{A}\otimes\rho_{B})\sum_{\alpha}E_{\alpha}\right),\\ &=\text{Tr}_{B}\left((I_{A}\otimes\rho_{B})\right)\;=I_{A}\end{split} (3) And similarly for (E_{\alpha})_{\rho}^{B} . ∎ Corollary 1 . For any POVM \{E_{\alpha}\} and state \rho , the LPO based expectations (probabilities) p_{\alpha}^{(A)}:=\Tr(\rho_A (E_\alpha)_\rho^A) satisfy \sum_{\alpha}p_{\alpha}^{(A)}=1 . III LPO witness and its properties Consider A_{x} , B_{y} to be dichotomic observables with spectra \{\pm 1\} (POVM, or projective, as required from the context). We define the two-party linear Bell operator \mathcal{B} as \mathcal{B}=\sum_{x,y}\alpha_{xy}A_{x}\otimes B_{y}+\sum_{x}\beta_{x}A_{x}\otimes I+\sum_{y}\gamma_{y}I\otimes B_{y}. (4) Note, this formalism allows us to express CHSH, I_{3322} [or C_{3322} in our case, see Eq. ( 42 )], and many such generalized Bell-type inequalities. We can further write \displaystyle(A_{x}\otimes B_{y})^{A}_{\rho} \displaystyle=\text{Tr}_{B}\left((I\otimes\rho_{B})(A_{x}\otimes B_{y})\right)=A_{x}\underbrace{\Tr(\rho_B B_y)}_{b_{y}} \displaystyle(A_{x}\otimes B_{y})^{B}_{\rho} \displaystyle=\underbrace{\Tr(\rho_A A_x)}_{a_{x}}B_{y}. (5)