Delegate Pricing Decisions to an Algorithm? Experimental Evidence
Hans-Theo Normann, Nina Rulié, Olaf Stypa, Tobias Werner · 2025
Read Delegate Pricing Decisions to an Algorithm? Experimental Evidence by Hans-Theo Normann, Nina Rulié, Olaf Stypa, Tobias Werner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27636.txt.
Introduction
Hans-Theo Normann, Nina Rulié, Olaf Stypa, and Tobias Werner test in 2025 whether firms let a self-learning program set prices. The program is known to favor collusive prices, which are high prices that help all firms but hurt buyers. In a repeated pricing game, subjects act as firms across rounds.
In one arm, subjects set prices by hand. In others, they could hand price choice to the program at each game's start, or take its advice and still override it. Hand-off rose when override was allowed. Prices fell below the hand-set arm in both program arms. Human control thus turned a collusive tool toward more rivalry, not less.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hans-Theo Normann, Nina Rulié, Olaf Stypa, Tobias Werner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27636
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Delegate Pricing Decisions to an Algorithm? Experimental Evidence Hans-Theo Normann, Nina Rulié, Olaf Stypa, Tobias Werner Abstract We analyze the delegation of pricing by participants, representing firms, to a collusive, self-learning algorithm in a repeated Bertrand experiment. In the baseline treatment, participants set prices themselves. In the other treatments, participants can either delegate pricing to the algorithm at the beginning of each supergame or receive algorithmic recommendations that they can override. Participants delegate more when they can override the algorithm’s decisions. In both algorithmic treatments, prices are lower than in the baseline. Our results indicate that while self-learning pricing algorithms can be collusive, they can foster competition rather than collusion with humans-in-the-loop. ¶ ¶ footnotetext: We are grateful to Zach Brown, Emilio Calvano, and Ed Hopkins for valuable comments. Seminar participants and conference audiences at the following venues gave useful feedback on the paper: Aarhus University, BSE Summer Forum Workshop on Computational and Experimental Economics (Barcelona), LEE Workshop on Human-AI Interaction, University of Michigan, VfS Annual Conference 2025 (Cologne). We thank Maximilian Andres, Juri Nithammer, and Lisa Bruttel for their support in running sessions in Potsdam. The pre-registration can be found here https://osf.io/fh89u/. Ethical approval was granted by the German Association for Experimental Economic Research (no. Cmvrj3oD). Keywords : Artificial Intelligence, Algorithm Aversion, Collusion, Experiment, Human-Machine Interaction JEL Codes : C90, D43, L12 1 Introduction The increasing use of pricing algorithms across different markets is sparking significant antitrust concerns. Pricing algorithms are used by traditional businesses, such as gas stations ( Assad et al. 2024 ) and supermarkets ( Competera 2024 ) , and are particularly relevant in the growing e-commerce sector ( Chen et al. 2016b , European Commission 2017 ) . This growing reliance on algorithms has raised concerns among regulators and legal scholars about potential anti-competitive effects. Algorithms may tacitly learn to collude without explicit instruction or enable hub-and-spoke collusion when supplied by a common provider ( Bundeskartellamt and Autorité de la concurrence 2019 , Competition & Markets Authority 2021 , Ezrachi and Stucke 2020 , e.g.,) . These concerns are supported by empirical and theoretical work showing that algorithm adoption can facilitate coordination and raise prices ( Brown and MacKay 2023 , Banchio and Mantegazza 2022 , Assad et al. 2024 , Musolff 2024 , see, for instance,) . Furthermore, simulation studies demonstrate that reinforcement learning algorithms can autonomously learn to sustain supra-competitive pricing strategies ( Calvano et al. 2020 , Klein 2021 ) . This paper considers the decision-making process of individuals when adopting such pricing algorithms. In contrast to previous studies, we do not treat algorithm adoption as an exogenous experimental condition, but as a strategic choice made by humans, such as pricing managers. Humans can often be reluctant to rely on algorithms, even when they are superior. This well-documented phenomenon, known as “algorithm aversion” may inhibit the adoption of pricing algorithms ( Dietvorst et al. 2015 , Dietvorst et al. 2018 ) . Moreover, in a repeated pricing setting, the decision not to adopt an algorithm could itself be a profitable deviation, which may in turn provide an incentive to price manually and not use a possibly collusive algorithm. The role of human adoption in shaping the effects of pricing algorithms has received limited attention, and overlooking this dimension may lead to overestimating the risk of algorithmic collusion. Our study addresses this gap by explicitly modeling adoption as a strategic choice and examining how it affects market outcomes. We conduct laboratory experiments to answer two research questions: First, are participants more likely to adopt a pricing algorithm when they retain the ability to override its recommendations? Second, how does the option to use a price algorithm affect market prices when adoption is left to human decision-makers? The algorithm used in our experiment has been trained through extensive simulations with popular reinforcement learning algorithms, similar to those studied by Calvano et al. 2020 and Klein 2021 . It learns a collusive strategy and is capable of sustaining tacit collusion when matched against itself or other reinforcement learning algorithms. In algorithmic self-play, it colludes at the monopoly price and cannot be profitably exploited. Participants are made aware of these potential profit-increasing effects of the algorithm throughout the experiment. 1 1 1 Our setup reflects a scenario where firms knowingly outsource pricing to an algorithm capable of sustaining collusion. From a policy perspective, this may be viewed as a lower bound on the anti-competitive risk of algorithmic pricing, since one would expect adoption rates and potential harms to be higher when firms believe such algorithms are collusive and profitable. In our laboratory experiment, participants play five indefinitely repeated supergames. We vary whether participants can adopt an algorithm at the start of each of these supergames and how much control they must relinquish to it if they adopt it. In the Baseline treatment, participants set prices themselves. In the Recommendation treatment, participants can adopt an algorithm that suggests prices, but its advice can be overridden. In the Outsourcing treatment, adoption entails full delegation and participants hand over all pricing decisions to the algorithm for the duration of the supergame. 2 2 2 In practice, both full delegation and algorithmic recommendations are commonly used. For instance, Huelden et al. 2024 and Li et al. 2021 report on a pricing system at a large e-commerce firm in which algorithms are fully responsible for pricing decisions by default, while humans can only intervene to overwrite them. On the other hand, for instance Garcia et al. 2024 describe algorithms for hotel room pricing that only serve as recommendations to human pricing managers. As such, both delegation treatments are also relevant from a practical perspective. Our design allows us to analyze how the anti-competitive effects of pricing algorithms depend on endogenous adoption choices and the degree of control participants retain. It also enables us to investigate algorithm aversion in a pricing context and test whether participants are more inclined to adopt an algorithm when they can override its recommendations, as discussed by Dietvorst et al. 2018 for non-strategic environments. Our results show that adoption of the algorithm is substantial. Across treatments and supergames, adoption rates range from 45% to 86%. Consistent with prior findings in non-strategic environments on algorithm aversion, we find that adoption is significantly higher in the Recommendation treatment than in Outsourcing , suggesting that participants are more willing to rely on the algorithm when they retain the ability to override its suggestions. However, adoption declines over time in both treatments, indicating that participants reassess the value of using the algorithm as they gain experience and learn from repeated market interactions. We find only limited evidence that pricing algorithms are pro-collusive with endogenous adoption. While these algorithms are collusive among themselves, this pattern does not carry over when adoption is left to human participants. While market prices are higher in Outsourcing than in the other treatments in the initial supergame, prices in both algorithmic treatments decline in later supergames. We identify repeated override decisions and strategic undercutting of algorithmic prices as key channels that drive those trends and, in turn, discourage further adoption. In the final supergame, market prices in the Baseline treatment, where no algorithm is available, are significantly