From pathological to paradigmatic: A Retrospective on Eremenko and Lyubich’s entire functions

Núria Fagella, Leticia Pardo-Simón · 2025

Read From pathological to paradigmatic: A Retrospective on Eremenko and Lyubich’s entire functions by Núria Fagella, Leticia Pardo-Simón (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27356.txt.

Introduction

Núria Fagella and Leticia Pardo-Simón look back at a paper that reshaped a field, in this 2025 survey. The paper, by Eremenko and Lyubich, came out in 1987 in the Journal of the LMS. Its subject was entire functions, formulas defined for every complex input, and how points move when the formula is applied again and again.

The 1987 paper built examples with wild behavior no one had seen in this setting. The trick was a clever stretch of classic approximation theorems, tools for mimicking one function with another. Those examples set methods the field still uses. They also raised questions that guided much later work on such dynamics. Fagella and Pardo-Simón trace that influence across the decades since.

Catalog record

CREATORNúria Fagella, Leticia Pardo-Simón
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27356

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From pathological to paradigmatic: A Retrospective on Eremenko and Lyubich’s entire functions Thanks: This work was partially supported by the project PID2023-147252NB-I00 financed by MICIU/AEI MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033, FEDER, EU, by the Spanish State Research Agency, through the Severo Ochoa and María de Maeztu Program for Centers and Units of Excellence in R&D (CEX2020-001084-M), and by the Catalan government through ICREA Academia 2020. The second author is a Serra Húnter fellow. Núria Fagella, Leticia Pardo-Simón Abstract . This article surveys the impact of Eremenko and Lyubich’s paper “Examples of entire functions with pathological dynamics” , published in 1987 in the Journal of the LMS . Through a clever extension and use of classical approximation theorems, the authors constructed examples exhibiting behaviours previously unseen in holomorphic dynamics. Their work laid foundational techniques and posed questions that have since guided a good part of the development of transcendental dynamics. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 37-02; Secondary 37F10, 30D05 1. Introduction and historical context Let f be a holomorphic endomorphism of S , where S might be either the Riemann sphere, \widehat{{\mathbb{C}}}={\mathbb{C}}\cup\{\infty\} , and so f is a rational map, or S={\mathbb{C}}, f does not extend to \widehat{\mathbb{C}} (i.e. infinity is an essential singularity) and f is a transcendental entire map. A central theme in complex dynamics is the study of the asymptotic behaviour of the iterates, or self-compositions, f^{n} , as n\to\infty . Building on early foundational work by Schröder, Koenigs, Leau, Montel and others, the systematic study of one-dimensional holomorphic dynamics began in the early 20 th century with the pioneering contributions of Fatou and Julia. One of their key insights was the partition of the dynamical space S into two complementary sets: the set where the sequence (f^{n}) forms a normal family and the behaviour is stable under perturbation, today known as the Fatou set and denoted F(f) , and its complement J(f)=S\setminus F(f) , the Julia set , where the dynamics is chaotic, and small changes in initial conditions can lead to vastly different outcomes. The fundamental properties of these two sets were already established in the early works of Fatou and Julia, but several questions were posed, some of which took decades to be solved, or still remain unsolved. Following these foundational developments, the field entered a relatively quiet period. Nevertheless, important contributions continued to appear, notably from Baker and Brolin. A significant revival occurred in the 1980s, largely spurred by computer-generated images of the Mandelbrot set and related structures. These visualisations illustrated that even simple functions, such as quadratic polynomials, could give rise to extremely complex and aesthetically striking dynamical behaviour. Perhaps even more decisive was the new perspective brought by Sullivan, drawing connections between the iteration of rational maps and quasiconformal deformations of Riemann surfaces via his celebrated proof of the nonexistence of non-preperiodic components of the Fatou set [ Sul82 ] . With these new techniques, Douady and Hubbard introduced a systematic framework for studying the dynamics of quadratic polynomials and developed powerful tools such as polynomial-like mappings [ DH84 , DH85 ] , leading to renormalization theory, a cornerstone of today’s modern complex dynamics. The introduction of such tools in the field and this renewed interest led to a period of intense activity and development, which continues to this day. A singular value of a holomorphic map f is a point w around which some single-valued analytic inverse branch of f can be continued; equivalently, w is a critical or an asymptotic value. The singular set S(f) is the closure of the set of singular values. Rational maps exemplify finiteness: they have no asymptotic values and only finitely many critical values; thus S(f) is finite. Transcendental entire functions are different: infinity is an essential singularity, the (topological) degree is infinite, and S(f) may be infinite; asymptotic values can occur (e.g., 0 for e^{z} ). Additionally, by Picard’s Theorem, in any punctured neighbourhood of infinity at most one value is omitted, hence the global behaviour is significantly more intricate and harder to control. It is in this setting that Alexandre E. Eremenko and Mikhail Yu. Lyubich, building on Baker and Herman’s earlier work, began a systematic study of the iteration of transcendental entire functions. In a series of papers beginning in the 1980s they laid down the foundational tools and ideas for the field, e.g., see [ EL89 ] . Their work introduced new techniques from classical complex analysis into holomorphic dynamics and proposed a number of challenging questions that have since guided the development of the subject. Central to this narrative is the pathological examples paper, published in English in 1987 in the Journal of the London Mathematical Society [ EL87 ] ; its contents trace back to work undertaken in Kharkiv (Ukraine) in the fall of 1983 [ EL84a ] , with an announcement in 1984 [ EL84b ] . Despite its modest length of 11 pages, it had a lasting impact on the field. In this article, the authors present a refined version of Runge’s classical approximation theorem and combine it with Arakelyan’s theorem to construct five transcendental entire functions, each exhibiting surprising and at the time previously unseen dynamical behaviours. The significance of their article lies in two aspects. First, it initiated the use of classical approximation theorems from complex analysis, particularly Runge’s and Arakelyan’s theorems, as a method for constructing transcendental entire functions with prescribed dynamical features. This approach has since become a standard tool in the field. Second, the examples provided in the paper revealed new dynamical behaviours, considered at the time pathological in comparison to the relatively tame and better understood world of rational dynamics, and posed natural questions, some of which still remain open. Nearly four decades later, these examples are no longer viewed as anomalies but rather as foundational and even emblematic of the richness and depth of transcendental dynamics. What once seemed exotic, unnatural or even pathological is now regarded as insightful, paradigmatic and central to our understanding of the subject. This expository note is devoted to a careful examination of the 1987 paper, its context, techniques, and enduring influence on the modern theory of transcendental dynamics. 2. Approximation results: the technique Approximation theory in complex analysis deals with how well functions that are analytic or continuous on a set can be approximated by analytic functions defined on a larger set. Classical results like Runge’s theorem (1885) show that any function analytic on a neighbourhood of a compact set K with connected complement can be uniformly approximated on K by polynomials. This idea was later extended by Mergelyan and Arakelyan, whose theorems allow approximation even on certain unbounded sets, as long as the sets satisfy certain regularity conditions at infinity. These results can be used to construct analytic maps with specific properties by carefully choosing the functions to be approximated. For more information on the topic, see the recent survey [ FFW20 ] . In the context of dynamical systems, the underlying idea is rather simple: one wants to know whether certain model dynamics can occur for entire functions. To explore this, one prescribes the desired behaviour using a model map , defined and being analytic in pieces (or patches) of the plane, and whose analytic extension

Read the complete text