The Role of Search Engines in the Amplification and Suppression of LGBTIQ+ Polarization

Ronja Rönnback, Chris Emmery, Marie Šafář Postma, Filip Milde, Jan Charvát, Henry Brighton · 2025

Read The Role of Search Engines in the Amplification and Suppression of LGBTIQ+ Polarization by Ronja Rönnback, Chris Emmery, Marie Šafář Postma, Filip Milde, Jan Charvát, Henry Brighton (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27248.txt.

Introduction

Ronja Ronnback leads five co-authors in a large study of how search engines shape exposure to polarizing content on LGBTIQ+ issues. Search engines are trusted daily by hundreds of millions, yet their ranking algorithms necessarily elevate some views over others. Prior polarization research focused on social media, leaving search largely unexamined.

The team analyzes one and a half million results for neutral and negative queries across the United Kingdom, Germany, and France. Choice of search engine proves the strongest determinant of exposure to polarizing content, ahead of query polarity, while location and language matter comparatively little. The findings give quantitative evidence that differences between search technologies, more than user opinions or language, drive what people encounter on contested topics in Europe.

Catalog record

CREATORRonja Rönnback, Chris Emmery, Marie Šafář Postma, Filip Milde, Jan Charvát, Henry Brighton
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27248

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Role of Search Engines in the Amplification and Suppression of LGBTIQ+ Polarization Ronja Rönnback, Chris Emmery, Marie Šafář Postma, Filip Milde, Jan Charvát, Henry Brighton Abstract Search engines are used and trusted by hundreds of millions of people every day. However, the algorithms used by search engines to index, filter, and rank web content are inherently biased, and will necessarily prefer some views and opinions at the expense of others. In this article, we examine how these algorithmic biases amplify and suppress polarizing content. Polarization refers to a shift toward and the acceptance of ideological extremes. In Europe, polarizing content in relation to LGBTIQ+ issues has been a feature of various ideological and political conflicts. Although past research has focused on the role of social media in polarization, the role of search engines in this process is little understood. Here, we report on a large-scale study of 1.5 million search results responding to neutral and negative queries relating to LGBTIQ+ issues. Focusing on the UK, Germany, and France, our analysis shows that the choice of search engine is the key determinant of exposure to polarizing content, followed by the polarity of the query. Location and language, on the other hand, have a comparatively minor effect. Consequently, our findings provide quantitative insights into how differences between search engine technologies, rather than the opinions, language, and location of web users, have the greatest impact on the exposure of web users to polarizing Web content. 1 Introduction Search engines have the capacity to influence people’s preferences, opinions, and decisions on an immense scale. In 2023, for example, Bing reported more than 100 million active daily users despite only achieving a single-digit market share [ 3 ] . This implies that Google, which has a market share of over 90% in many parts of the world, may attract over 1 billion daily users [ 59 ] . The scale of search engine use, along with findings that show that people often trust search engines more than social and traditional media [ 14 , 15 ] , has fueled the concern that search engine users are susceptible to influence and manipulation [ 17 , 2 ] . For example, subtle changes to the ranking of politicized search results can shift the voting preferences of undecided voters from one candidate to another [ 18 ] . Given this capacity to influence web users at scale, it is crucial to understand the ways in which search engines are biased toward certain views and opinions at the expense of others, and whether these biases undermine the integrity of the Web [ 30 , 70 ] . A key barrier to studying search engines is that, like many online platforms, their algorithms are hidden from public view [ 53 ] . Moreover, countermeasures designed to block automated interactions make it technically challenging to conduct large-scale scientific analyses. While a number of large-scale monitoring studies have sidestepped this problem, they have tended to focus on the political bias of English language search results, considered only users located in the US, and restricted their attention to Google and occasionally Bing [ 56 , 55 , 45 , 54 ] . Building on this work, we set out to examine the role played by four independent search engines in the propagation and suppression of polarizing content in Europe. Polarization, which refers to a shift toward and the acceptance of ideological extremes [ 10 ] , is seen as a threat to the online information space by key European institutions [ 20 , 19 ] . Polarizing content typically lacks credibility, tends to be misinformative, is frequently politicized, and often targets minority groups such as LGBTIQ+ people, which includes people who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and queer [ 64 , 27 , 34 , 16 , 26 ] . In this article, we examine to what extent search engines return low credibility, politicized results likely to fuel polarizing, extremist views toward LGBTIQ+ people. Taking a data-driven approach, we monitored four independent search engines (Google, Bing, Yandex, and Mojeek) over a 3-month period and collected over 1.5 million search results. By controlling the location from which queries were issued, the language they were issued in, and whether the queries conveyed neutral or negative perspectives on LGBTIQ+ issues, we show that the choice of search engine has the greatest impact on exposure to low credibility, polarizing content. Yandex and Mojeek, for example, return over eight times as many low credibility results as Google and Bing. Our findings provide quantitative insights into how differences between search engine technologies, rather than the views, opinions, language, and location of web users, have the greatest impact on the exposure of web users to polarizing Web content. 2 Polarization, LGBTIQ+ rights, and search engine monitoring Recent years have seen an increase in the polarization of traditional and social media [ 37 , 4 , 6 ] . This shift toward ideological extremes has negative consequences, such as threatening the functioning of democratic institutions [ 13 ] , and undermining trust and adherence to the rule of law [ 51 ] . Although a range of social and political factors drive the process of polarization, the role of technologies such as social media platforms are increasingly under scrutiny [ 7 , 71 ] . The questions of how and to what extent online platforms play a role in polarization have been posed in relation to several countries [ 5 ] , but beyond the observation that different countries appear to be affected to different degrees, much remains uncertain [ 37 , 20 , 4 , 66 ] . In this article, we address the role of search engines in the amplification and suppression of polarizing content relating to LGBTIQ+ people. LGBTIQ+ rights are of particular interest due to a growing body of research identifying a connection between anti-gender ideology (which seeks to oppose women’s rights as well as LGBTIQ+ rights [ 64 , 27 , 49 ] ) and democratic backsliding, where democratic processes are undermined in favor of autocratic rule [ 21 , 41 , 26 ] . Because the character of online anti-LGBTIQ+ discourse varies depending on the language and the country where it occurs, we developed a multilingual dataset of search engine queries that we use to monitor search engines in different countries. For example, in Germany, polarizing discourse on Twitter/X often invokes the idea of vaccine-induced homosexuality [ 40 ] . In contrast, in France, it is more common to use LGBTIQ+ slurs to insult political figures and athletes, and invoke disinformation narratives about homosexuality and disease [ 40 ] . Focusing on these cultural differences, our investigation of the amplification and suppression of polarizing content addresses a perceived threat to the online environment recently highlighted by key European institutions [ 20 , 19 , 64 ] . In contrast to our data-driven focus on search engines, previous work has tended to explore the issue of LGBTIQ+ polarization from a social, legal, and security perspective. This work often relies on case studies and aims to provide a detailed examination of specific regions [ 49 , 23 , 65 , 1 , 16 ] ,

Read the complete text