A Comparison of Galacticus and COZMIC WDM Subhalo Populations

Jack Lonergan, Andrew Benson, Xiaolong Du · 2025

Read A Comparison of Galacticus and COZMIC WDM Subhalo Populations by Jack Lonergan, Andrew Benson, Xiaolong Du (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27103.txt.

Introduction

Jack Lonergan, Andrew Benson, and Xiaolong Du compare two ways of predicting small dark matter clumps around galaxies. Warm dark matter, made of lighter, faster particles than the cold standard, should suppress low-mass subhalos. The team contrasts a semi-analytic model called Galacticus with the COZMIC suite of direct N-body simulations across several particle masses.

Both approaches predict fewer low-mass subhalos as particle mass drops, plus lower peak speeds and larger peak radii than cold dark matter at fixed mass. The semi-analytic model gives tighter statistics from larger samples, while simulations show the same broad trends. Differences trace to halo finders, resolution, and modeling choices. The agreement supports using the faster model to explore warm dark matter effects widely.

Catalog record

CREATORJack Lonergan, Andrew Benson, Xiaolong Du
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27103

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Comparison of Galacticus and COZMIC WDM Subhalo Populations Jack Lonergan, Andrew Benson, Xiaolong Du Abstract We present a comparative analysis of warm dark matter (WDM) subhalo populations generated by the semi-analytic model Galacticus and the COZMIC suite of dark matter-only N N -body simulations. Using a range of thermal relic WDM particle masses (3–10 keV), we examine key summary statistics—including the subhalo mass function, spatial distribution, maximum circular velocity V max V_{\text{max}} , and its corresponding radius R max R_{\text{max}} —to evaluate the consistency between these two modeling frameworks. Both models predict a suppression of low-mass subhalos correlated with decreasing WDM particle mass, and that WDM subhalos tend to have lower V max V_{\text{max}} and larger R max R_{\text{max}} values than their CDM counterparts at fixed mass. While Galacticus provides more statistically precise results due to a larger sample size, the COZMIC simulations display similar qualitative trends. We discuss how differences in halo finder algorithms, simulation resolution, and modeling assumptions affect subhalo statistics. Our findings demonstrate that Galacticus can reliably reproduce WDM subhalo distributions seen in N N -body simulations, offering a computationally efficient tool for exploring the implications of WDM across astrophysical phenomena. 1 Introduction Understanding the nature of dark matter remains one of the most profound unsolved problems in modern physics. The current fiducial model of the universe is the Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM), which accurately predicts the observed large-scale structure of the universe, for wavenumbers k\lesssim 10\text{ h}/\text{Mpc} ( Frenk et al. 1985 ; Aghanim et al. 2020 ; Peebles 2020 ) , where (h=H_{0}/100\hbox{km/s/Mpc}) denotes the dimensionless Hubble parameter. At smaller, non-linear scales (k\gtrsim 10\text{ h}/\text{Mpc}) , however, tensions begin to emerge between \Lambda CDM predictions for the distribution of matter and observational data. A comprehensive overview of small-scale CDM challenges and their proposed solutions can be found in Bullock & Boylan-Kolchin 2017 . The abundance of challenges with CDM on small scales has motivated the development of alternative dark matter models ( Spergel & Steinhardt 2000 ; Tulin & Yu 2018 ; Dodelson & Widrow 1994 ; Hu et al. 2000 ; Hui et al. 2017 ; Berezhiani & Khoury 2016 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2013 ; Foot & Vagnozzi 2015 ) . One proposed alternative model to CDM is Warm Dark Matter (WDM). Warm dark matter assumes that dark matter is a particle with relativistic thermal velocities in the early universe. These high thermal velocities allow WDM particles to free-stream out of overdense regions in the early universe, suppressing the formation of WDM halos below their free-streaming scale ( Bode et al. 2001 ) . Warm dark matter’s ability to suppress small-scale structure and produce halo profiles with lower concentrations has motivated it as a potential solution to specific, small-scale issues with CDM, such as the too-big-to-fail (TBTF) problem and the missing satellites problem (MSP; Viel et al. 2013 ). Several studies, however, have shown that the missing satellites problem can be alleviated with baryonic processes ( Benson et al. 2002a ; Brooks et al. 2013 ; Jeon et al. 2025 ) , and recent discoveries of Milky Way satellites ( Kim et al. 2018 ) as well as satellite counts in other galaxies ( Nierenberg et al. 2016 ) suggest that the number of satellites is actually consistent with predictions from \Lambda CDM. The primary factor that influences the free-streaming scale of warm dark matter is the mass of the warm dark matter particle, m_{\text{WDM}} ( Schneider et al. 2013 ) . A wide range of methods have been used to constrain the warm dark matter particle mass, including Lyman- \alpha forest observations ( Ballesteros et al. 2021 ; Garcia-Gallego et al. 2025 ) , dwarf galaxy counts ( Dekker et al. 2022 ) , stellar stream features ( Banik et al. 2018 ) , strong gravitational lensing ( Gilman et al. 2020 ) , and the cosmic reionization history ( Tan et al. 2016 ; Lopez-Honorez et al. 2017 ) . Many of these approaches utilize simulations of WDM to analyze its matter distribution through summary statistics. Different modeling approaches for WDM can lead to subtle differences in the corresponding summary statistics ( Avila-Reese et al. 2001 ; Wang & White 2007 ; van den Bosch & Jiang 2016 ) . Understanding the underlying assumptions and methodologies of each simulation is crucial for interpreting and comparing these statistical discrepancies. One class of model that is able to generate halo populations more rapidly than N -body/hydrodynamical simulations is semi-analytic models (SAMs). SAMs simulate the formation and evolution of dark matter halos (and galaxies) by applying analytic descriptions for certain physical processes to increase the computational efficiency of the model. This computational efficiency is the primary advantage of SAMs, and enables the generation of a large number of realizations—significantly more than would be feasible with full N -body simulations—allowing statistical properties to be measured within a reasonable time frame ( Henriques et al. 2009 ; Benson & Bower 2010 ; Bower et al. 2010 ) . The main drawback of using SAMs is that there is a greater degree of approximation involved compared to working with N-body simulations. Several studies have shown that SAMs are able to obtain reasonably accurate summary statistics, when compared to N-body simulations ( Benson et al. 2002b ; Taylor & Babul 2004 ; Zentner et al. 2005 ; Pullen et al. 2014 ; Yang et al. 2020 ; Nadler et al. 2023 ) . SAMs have also been used to generate input data for machine learning algorithms, enabling the rapid production of statistically representative halo populations ( Kamdar et al. 2016 ; Elliott et al. 2021 ; Lonergan et al. 2025 ) . In this paper, we compare modeling approaches of WDM dark matter subhalo populations made by the semi-analytic model Galacticus ( Benson 2012 ) 1 1 1 https://github.com/galacticusorg/galacticus , we use revision 79e9402 . and the COsmological ZooM-in simulations with Initial Conditions beyond CDM (COZMIC) N-body simulation suite ( Nadler et al. 2025 ; An et al. 2025 ) . Work has already been done to compare Galacticus CDM halo populations against simulation data ( Yang et al. 2020 ; Nadler et al. 2023 ) , as well as to compare predictions for WDM halo populations from another semi-analytic model, SASHIMI-W ( Ando 2023 ) , with simulations ( Ono et al. 2025 ) . The results from Ono et al. 2025 primarily focus on comparing subhalo mass functions (SMFs) between models. In this work, we will expand on these results by comparing additional summary statistics as well as including simulations with a wider range of WDM particle masses in our analysis. This paper is organized as follows: In Section 2 , we introduce the simulations and semi-analytic model Galacticus used to generate both WDM and CDM halo populations. In Section 3 , we present our results in the form of summary statistics characterizing each halo population. In Section 4 , we discuss the implications of our results, including possible sources of discrepancy and limiting features of each model. In Section 5 , we summarize with general conclusions. 2 Models Here, we outline the modeling frameworks used to generate z=0 subhalo populations. While

Read the complete text