Comparing the magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability dynamics in two- and three-dimensions
Manohar Teja Kalluri, Andrew Hillier · 2025
Read Comparing the magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability dynamics in two- and three-dimensions by Manohar Teja Kalluri, Andrew Hillier (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27053.txt.
Introduction
Manohar Kalluri and Andrew Hillier compare a plasma instability in flat simulations versus full three-dimensional ones. The magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability drives mixing when a heavy fluid rests on a lighter one under a magnetic field. It shapes behavior in space plasmas and lab experiments alike, yet computing limits often force two-dimensional studies.
Running direct simulations in both settings across weak to strong fields, the pair find richer mode mixing in three dimensions. The three-dimensional layer mixes at small scales with less bulk spread, releases less stored energy, and dissipates more through small vortices. Growth rises steadily with field strength in three dimensions but not in two. Two-dimensional runs still track magnetic-to-kinetic energy conversion fairly, but not the full turbulence.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manohar Teja Kalluri, Andrew Hillier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27053
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparing the magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability dynamics in two- and three-dimensions Manohar Teja Kalluri, Andrew Hillier Abstract The magnetic Rayleigh–Taylor instability (MRTI) governs plasma mixing and transport in a wide range of astrophysical and laboratory systems. Owing to computational constraints, MRTI is often studied using two-dimensional (2D) simulations, but the extent to which 2D captures the true three-dimensional (3D) dynamics remains unclear. In this work, we perform direct numerical simulations of non-ideal, incompressible MRTI in both 2D and 3D, systematically varying the magnetic field strength from weakly to strongly magnetized regimes. We find that the 3D system exhibits richer mode interactions due to the coexistence of interchange, undular, and mixed modes—structures that are inherently absent in 2D. The mixing layer in 3D has enhanced small-scale mixing and reduced fluid dispersion compared to 2D, which is characterized by large-scale plumes. Energy diagnostics reveal that the gravitational potential energy released is higher in 2D, primarily because of inefficient mixing and significant fluid dispersion. In contrast, 3D systems display greater energy dissipation and anisotropy, driven by small-scale vortical motions. The non-linear growth of the instability increases monotonically with magnetic field strength in 3D but shows a non-monotonic trend in 2D. Despite these broad differences, the rate of magnetic-to-kinetic energy conversion remains remarkably similar across dimensions, indicating that 2D simulations can meaningfully capture reconnection-driven processes but not the full turbulent evolution. Overall, our results demonstrate that 2D MRTI simulations cannot reliably represent 3D mixing, energy dynamics, or nonlinear growth, highlighting the fundamental importance of three-dimensionality in magnetized plasma instabilities. [ orcid=https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5441-9224 ] [ orcid=https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0851-5362 ] † † highlights: keywords Rayleigh-Taylor instability ,Magnetic fields ,two-dimensional and three-dimensional simulations ,non-linear instability † † credit: Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Software, validation, Visualization, Writing — original draft, review and editing † † credit: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Project administration, Resources, Supervision, Writing — reviewing 1 Introduction When a fluid of high-density ( \rho_{h} ) is supported by another fluid of low-density ( \rho_{l} ) in the presence of gravitational and magnetic fields, perturbations at the interface of the two fluids could lead to the penetration of one fluid into the other, a phenomenon called the magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability (MRTI) ( Rayleigh 1883 ; Taylor 1950 ; Kruskal et al. 1954 ; Roberts 1963 ) . The region of penetration or mixing is called the mixing layer . The evolution of RTI over time is shown in Figure 1.1 . Through fluid penetration, MRTI plays a crucial role in the transportation and mixing of plasma in laboratory ( Zhou et al. 2024 ) and astrophysical systems ( Zhou 2017a ; Zhou 2017b ) . For example, transportation of prominence material into the solar corona, mixing of prominence and corona material in the solar atmosphere ( Hillier 2018 ) , transportation of stellar material into the surrounding medium in supernova ( Fraschetti, F. et al. 2010 ) , accretion of material onto the central object in accretion discs ( Kulkarni and Romanova 2008 ) . MRTI in astrophysical and laboratory systems often involves complex physics, making its numerical modelling computationally demanding. Consequently, two-dimensional (2D) simulations are widely used, as they provide insight into the non-linear dynamics at substantially reduced computational cost ( Popescu Braileanu, B. et al. 2023 ; Zhdankin et al. 2023 ; Porth et al. 2014 ; Changmai et al. 2023 ) . However, do 2D simulations capture the true physics of a three-dimensional (3D) system? Possibly not. This comes from multiple reasons. One of them is the difference in the nature of energy dynamics. The energy cascade in an HD turbulent system is direct (large-scale to small-scale) in 3D, and inverse (small-scale to large-scale) in 2D. That is, in HD, self-organisation and coherent vortices appear only in a 2D system ( Fundamenski 2009 ) . In contrast, both the 2D and 3D cases of MHD turbulence have a direct energy cascade. That is coherent, large-scale magnetic structures occur in both 2D and 3D ( Fundamenski 2009 ) . The other reason is the differences in the wave modes existing in 2D and 3D. In 2D simulations, the perturbations are at a fixed angle with respect to the magnetic field. On the contrary, in 3D, the perturbations can be a wide range of angles relative to the magnetic field. In this paper, we study the differences between 2D and 3D MRTI predominantly from the perspective of different wave modes. To elaborate on how the existence of different wave modes to could influence the dynamics, we use the linear MRTI theory. The linear growth rate expression for an MRTI is given by ( Chandrasekhar 1961 ) \sigma_{mhd}=\sqrt{\frac{\rho_{h}{-}\rho_{l}}{\rho_{h}{+}\rho_{l}}kg{-}\frac{2k^{2}B^{2}cos^{2}\theta}{(\rho_{h}{+}\rho_{l})}}, (1) where k is the perturbation wave mode, B is the magnetic field strength, and \theta is the angle between k and B . We find that, for a given \rho_{h},\rho_{l},g,k , and B growth rate is least when \theta is 0 (modes are parallel to the imposed magnetic field, called undular modes), and largest when \theta=\pi/2 (modes are perpendicular to the imposed magnetic field, called interchange modes). The other modes that are at a different angle 0<\theta<\pi/2 are called mixed modes. In a 2D system, the interface is a line with the magnetic field imposed at an angle to the perturbation wave modes. Thus, the perturbation has either undular or interchange modes. In contrast, the interface in a 3D system is a plane ( xy- plane). While the magnetic field remains directed along x , perturbation wave modes can exist anywhere within the xy -plane. This leads to a broad spectrum of wave modes — purely undular ( k_{x}\neq 0,k_{y}=0 ), purely interchange (modes with k_{x}=0,k_{y}\neq 0 ), and mixed modes ( 0<\theta<\pi/2 , k_{x}\neq 0,k_{y}\neq 0 ). As a result, 3D MRTI exhibits a rich variety of wave behaviours, producing complex dynamics arising from these different mode types. By comparison, 2D MRTI dynamics are governed exclusively by undular modes, resulting in a more straightforward MRTI evolution. Most fundamental MRTI studies have focused on 3D dynamics ( Stone and Gardiner 2007b ; Stone and Gardiner 2007a ; Carlyle and Hillier 2017 ; Kalluri and Hillier 2024 ) . On the other hand, most astrophysical MRTI studies used 2D simulations ( Popescu Braileanu, B. et al. 2023 ; Zhdankin et al. 2023 ; Porth et al. 2014 ; Changmai et al. 2023 ) . However, a study establishing the relevance of 2D MRTI physics for the 3D case is lacking. While Jun et al. 1995 examined MRTI in both 2D and 3D, their analysis was limited to comparing kinetic and magnetic energies at a magnetic field strength of B_{0}=2\%B_{c} . Several other important aspects, such as fluid mixing, energy dissipation, energy anisotropy, and non-linear growth rates, remain unexplored. Magnetic fields are known to significantly influence RTI behaviour. For example, Stone and Gardiner 2007b demonstrated that stronger magnetic fields suppress small-scale wave modes, resulting in a more laminar mixing layer. Similarly, Kalluri and Hillier 2024 found that increasing the magnetic field reduces dissipation and turbulence, while enhancing anisotropy and nonlinear growth. These findings suggest that conclusions drawn from comparing 2D and 3D MRTI at a single field strength may not hold across different magnetic field strengths . To gain an understanding of