Algorithmic Predation: Equilibrium Analysis in Dynamic Oligopolies with Smooth Market Sharing

Fabian R. Pieroth, Ole Petersen, Martin Bichler · 2025

Read Algorithmic Predation: Equilibrium Analysis in Dynamic Oligopolies with Smooth Market Sharing by Fabian R. Pieroth, Ole Petersen, Martin Bichler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-27008.txt.

Introduction

Fabian Pieroth, Ole Petersen, and Martin Bichler revisit predatory pricing, where a firm cuts prices to drive rivals out. Scholars have long debated whether such behavior can be a stable equilibrium, meaning a pattern no firm wants to break, in finite-horizon market games where firms may exit after losses. A classic model by Selten allows smooth market sharing but resists exact solution once exits are allowed.

The team uses deep reinforcement learning, where software agents learn by trial and reward, to compute and verify equilibria. The algorithms converge reliably under both full and partial information. When firms face uneven costs, the resulting equilibria show predatory pricing. The finding answers a long-open question and gives regulators fresh evidence to consider.

Catalog record

CREATORFabian R. Pieroth, Ole Petersen, Martin Bichler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-27008

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Algorithmic Predation: Equilibrium Analysis in Dynamic Oligopolies with Smooth Market Sharing Fabian R. Pieroth, Ole Petersen, Martin Bichler Abstract Predatory pricing – where a firm strategically lowers prices to undermine competitors – is a contentious topic in dynamic oligopoly theory, with scholars debating practical relevance and the existence of predatory equilibria. Although finite-horizon dynamic models have long been proposed to capture the strategic intertemporal incentives of oligopolists, the existence and form of equilibrium strategies in settings that allow for firm exit (drop-outs following loss-making periods) have remained an open question. We focus on the seminal dynamic oligopoly model by Selten (1965) that introduces the subgame perfect equilibrium and analyzes smooth market sharing. Equilibrium can be derived analytically in models that do not allow for dropouts, but not in models that can lead to predatory pricing. In this paper, we leverage recent advances in deep reinforcement learning to compute and verify equilibria in finite-horizon dynamic oligopoly games. Our experiments reveal two key findings: first, state-of-the-art deep reinforcement learning algorithms reliably converge to equilibrium in both perfect- and imperfect-information oligopoly models; second, when firms face asymmetric cost structures, the resulting equilibria exhibit predatory pricing behavior. These results demonstrate that predatory pricing can emerge as a rational equilibrium strategy across a broad variety of model settings. By providing equilibrium analysis of finite-horizon dynamic oligopoly models with drop-outs, our study answers a decade-old question and offers new insights for competition authorities and regulators. Keywords predatory prcing \cdot oligopoly \cdot dynamic game \cdot equilibrium learning 1 Introduction Predatory pricing is loosely defined as a firm’s deliberate reduction of prices to levels that, while not necessarily below cost, are unsustainable for potential or existing competitors in the long run. In dynamic oligopoly competition, the strategic behavior associated with predatory pricing manifests as a dominant player systematically lowering prices to deter entry or push competitors out of the market ( Gates et al. 1995 ) . Antitrust laws, such as the Sherman Antitrust Act in the U.S. and Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), address abusive practices like predatory pricing. For example, Article 102 of the TFEU prohibits a dominant firm from ”directly or indirectly imposing unfair purchase or selling prices.” However, whether predatory pricing is a concern in practice has long been controversial. DiLorenzo 1992 argues that while a firm might be able to successfully price other firms out of the market, there is no evidence to support the theory that the virtual monopoly could then raise prices. Also, courts have been skeptical of predatory pricing claims. For example, the U.S. Supreme Court has set high hurdles to antitrust claims based on predatory pricing theory ( May 1994 ) . On the other hand, the US Department of Justice argues that predatory pricing is a real problem, courts are out of date, and too skeptical ( Bolton et al. 1999 ) . Predatory pricing has received renewed attention due to the presence of automated pricing agents in legal studies ( Leslie 2023 ; Cheng and Nowag 2023 ) . Although a considerable body of scholarship aims to explain how algorithms can collude to fix prices ( Bichler et al. 2025 ) , almost no literature discusses anti-competitive behavior of algorithmic agents in the form of predatory pricing. In this article, we address two related problems: First, can we expect algorithmic pricing agents in a dynamic or multi-stage oligopoly model to converge to an equilibrium? We focus on state-of-the-art deep reinforcement learning (DRL) algorithms as they constitute prime candidates for pricing agents in the field ( Deng et al. 2024 ) . Convergence to an equilibrium is far from obvious, because we know that learning algorithms do not converge to equilibrium even in simple static games ( Sanders et al. 2018 ) . Even less is known for multi-stage games. We draw on a recent approach to verify whether a strategy profile resulting from the interaction of DRL agents is a Nash equilibrium ( Pieroth et al. 2025 ) . Second, we aim to understand in which environments we can expect a predatory equilibrium to emerge, and when this is not the case. 1.1 Dynamic Oligopoly Competition Dynamic oligopoly models are well-suited to study predatory pricing, as firms interact over discrete time, repeatedly setting prices. Current choices influence future outcomes through mechanisms like demand inertia or strategic responses ( Milgrom 1990 ) . Firms must be able to accumulate revenue over time, enabling recoupment of early losses, and must have the option to exit, drop out, or withdraw from the market to avoid further losses ( Telser 1966 ) . These interactions are often modeled as infinite-horizon stochastic games, where the Nash equilibrium (NE) ( Nash 1950 ) serves as the primary solution concept. Assuming complete information, these models can be solved using dynamic programming techniques, resulting in Markov Perfect Equilibria (MPE), a refinement of the NE ( Maskin and Tirole 1988 ) . Previous literature showed the existence of MPEs displaying predatory behavior due to evasion of fixed costs or competitive advantage ( Cabral and Riordan 1994 ; Besanko et al. 2011 ; Rey et al. 2022 ) . Markov perfect equilibria (MPE) are not stable to small changes in payoffs and can shift discontinuously ( Fudenberg and Kreps 1993 , 518) . Closed-form solutions are rare; instead, dynamic programming methods are used ( Pakes and McGuire 1992 ) , though convergence is not guaranteed and multiple MPEs may exist. By excluding history-dependent strategies, MPEs can miss key dynamics in settings with learning or private information. These methods also face practical limits: they require discrete state and action spaces, full observability, and are difficult to extend to continuous or imperfect-information environments without high computational cost. Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) methods such as PPO ( Schulman et al. 2017 ) can handle continuous action and state spaces, as well as imperfect information. Pieroth et al. 2025 use DRL with self-play to learn candidate equilibria in multi-stage games, verifying convergence to a Nash equilibrium ex-post. These techniques constitute a breakthrough as they allow for equilibrium computation in finite-horizon, dynamic game-theoretical models. We build on this framework and present its first application for equilibrium analysis in dynamic oligopoly models. 1.2 Contributions We study the dynamic oligopoly model of Selten 1965 , where N firms produce a homogeneous good over a finite horizon T ( Section 3.2 ). Firms set prices from an interval, and market shares (demands) evolve based on price differences relative to the market average. This demand inertia – capturing brand loyalty, switching costs, or network effects ( Besanko et al. 2011 ) – leads to smooth market sharing , where small price cuts yield small market share gains. Unlike Bertrand competition ( Bertrand 1883 ) , this avoids the paradox of prices being driven to marginal cost. Selten’s model yields more realistic pricing dynamics and has become influential for analyzing industries with limited price responsiveness, such as gasoline retail, banking, and telecommunications. We compare two market models: firms either exit the market if unprofitable, like in contestable markets with a low barrier to entry, or persist despite losses. The model by Selten 1965 does not allow for dropouts, which

Read the complete text