Universal numerical convergence criteria for subhalo tidal evolution
Barry T. Chiang 1,2, Frank C. van den Bosch 1, Hsi-Yu Schive 2,3,4,5 · 2025
Read Universal numerical convergence criteria for subhalo tidal evolution by Barry T. Chiang 1,2, Frank C. van den Bosch 1, Hsi-Yu Schive 2,3,4,5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26901.txt.
Introduction
Barry T Chiang, Frank C van den Bosch, and Hsi-Yu Schive set universal rules for when simulated dark matter subhalos can be trusted. Subhalos and satellite galaxies in cosmological simulations suffer overmerging: weak resolution makes tides strip them too fast and destroys them early. Past studies of the problem covered few orbits and assumed round, isotropic subhalos.
Chiang and his two co-authors run the first extensive suite on anisotropic subhalos across resolutions and orbits. They report a universal criterion: a subhalo's tidal radius must always span at least twenty cells, or twenty softening lengths, for its evolution to converge. They also give a universal formula for the scatter from discreteness noise. By their estimate, as many as half of all subhalos in leading simulations may be unresolved in force or mass, and they advocate adaptive refinement tied to the tidal radius.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Barry T. Chiang 1,2, Frank C. van den Bosch 1, Hsi-Yu Schive 2,3,4,5 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 93 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26901
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Universal numerical convergence criteria for subhalo tidal evolution Barry T. Chiang 1,2, Frank C. van den Bosch 1, Hsi-Yu Schive 2,3,4,5 Abstract Dark matter subhalos and satellite galaxies in state-of-the-art cosmological simulations still suffer from the “overmerging” problem, where inadequate force and/or mass resolution cause artificially enhanced tidal mass loss and premature disruption. Previous idealized simulations addressing this issue have been restricted to a small subset of the subhalo orbital parameter space, and all assumed subhalos to be isotropic. Here, we present the first extensive simulation suite that quantifies numerical convergence in the tidal evolution of anisotropic subhalos under varying numerical resolutions and orbits. We report a universal force resolution criterion: the subhalo’s instantaneous tidal radius must always be resolved by at least 20 cells in adaptive mesh refinement (AMR)-based simulations, or by 20 softening lengths (Plummer equivalent) in tree-based simulations, regardless of refinement details or subhalo physical properties such as concentration or velocity anisotropy. We also report a universal expression for the discreteness-noise-driven scatter in the bound-mass fraction of subhalos that depends only on the subhalo mass resolution at infall and the instantaneous bound mass fraction, agnostic of any further subhalo properties. Such stochastic discreteness noise causes both premature disruption and, notably, spurious survival of poorly mass-resolved subhalos. We demonstrate that as many as 50 percent of all subhalos in state-of-the-art cosmological simulations are likely to be either force and/or mass unresolved. Our findings advocate for adaptive softening or grid refinement based on the instantaneous tidal radius of the subhalo. Numerical convergence of subhalo tidal evolution keywords dark matter – galaxies: halos – galaxies: kinematics and dynamics – methods: numerical 1 Introduction In the established paradigm of hierarchical structure formation ( Peebles 1971 ; Cole et al. 2000 ; Frenk & White 2012 ; Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 2016 , e.g.) , the growth of structure is driven by the continuous accretion of lower-mass systems. Once accreted, these “substructures” undergo tidal evolution that causes them to spiral inward due to dynamical friction, while experiencing mass loss due to tidal stripping and tidal shocking ( Chandrasekhar 1943 ; Gnedin et al. 1999 ; van den Bosch et al. 2018 , e.g.) . The abundance and demographics of dark matter substructures provide important small-scale probes of the nature of dark matter via observables that include, among others, the decay signals of dark matter particles ( Strigari et al. 2007 ; Pieri et al. 2008 ; Ando et al. 2019 , e.g.,) , gravitational lensing distortions ( Vegetti et al. 2014 ; Hezaveh et al. 2016 ; Meneghetti et al. 2020 , e.g.,) , gaps in stellar streams ( Carlberg 2012 ; Erkal et al. 2016 ; Bonaca et al. 2019 , e.g.,) , and the abundance of satellite galaxies ( Anderhalden et al. 2013 ; Nadler et al. 2021 , e.g.,) . In order for the inference of these methods to yield unbiased constraints on the nature of dark matter, it is of crucial importance that we are able to make predictions for the substructure characteristics for a given dark matter model that are both accurate and precise. Because of the non-linearities involved, the tidal evolution of dark matter substructure is typically studied using numerical simulations. However, due to the finite mass and force resolution, these simulation results are not always reliable ( van den Bosch 2017 ; van den Bosch & Ogiya 2018 , e.g.) . In particular, over the years it has become clear that there are two separate numerical problems at play: inadequate subhalo identification and overmerging. Subhalo-finding algorithms often lose track of or simply fail to identify subhalos, especially near the center of the host halo ( Behroozi et al. 2013 ; Carlsten et al. 2020 ; Mansfield et al. 2024 ; Diemer et al. 2024 , e.g.) . This issue is particularly prevalent with configuration-space-based subhalo finders such as HFOF ( Klypin et al. 1999 ) , SubFind ( Springel et al. 2001 ) , SKID ( Stadel 2001 ) , and AHF ( Knollmann & Knebe 2009 ) , which rely only on the spatial clustering of particles. Several halo-finder comparison studies ( Onions et al. 2012 ; Knebe et al. 2013 ; Behroozi et al. 2015 ; van den Bosch & Jiang 2016 ; Forouhar Moreno et al. 2025 , e.g.) have demonstrated improved identification of subhalos when using the full 6D phase-space information (e.g., 6DFOF ( Diemand et al. 2006 ) , Rockstar ( Behroozi et al. 2013 ) , VELOCIraptor ( Elahi et al. 2019 ) ), or by tracking particles across simulation outputs (e.g., SURV ( Tormen et al. 1998 ) , HBT+ ( Han et al. 2012 ; Han et al. 2018 ) , Sparta ( Diemer et al. 2024 ) , Symfind ( Mansfield et al. 2024 ) , Bloodhound ( Kong et al. 2025 ) , Haskap Pie ( Barrow et al. 2025 ) ). However, even with these more elaborate subhalo finders, there has been little sign of convergence in the radial distribution of subhalos ( Mansfield et al. 2024 ; Forouhar Moreno et al. 2025 ) . Overmerging is a problem of the simulation itself. Whenever a subhalo is poorly resolved, it experiences too much mass loss, which causes the subhalo to dissolve prematurely ( van den Bosch et al. 2018 ; van den Bosch & Ogiya 2018 ; Amorisco 2021 ; Errani & Peñarrubia 2020 ; Errani & Navarro 2021 , e.g.) . In fact, these and other studies ( Drakos et al. 2020 ; Drakos et al. 2022 ; Benson & Du 2022 ; Stücker et al. 2023 ) have argued that a properly resolved isotropic cold dark matter (CDM) subhalo should never completely disrupt in the absence of baryons. It has been shown that this artificial disruption causes a significant underprediction of the substructure abundance with potential far-reaching ramifications for cosmological inference ( van den Bosch 2017 ; Webb & Bovy 2020 ; Green et al. 2021 ; Grand et al. 2021 ; Mansfield & Avestruz 2021 ; Mansfield et al. 2024 ) . It might also explain why state-of-the-art cosmological simulations still manifest a pronounced deficit of surviving subhalos and satellite galaxies within the inner 0.1 – 0.3 of the host halo’s extent, relative to the observed radial distribution of substructures in both massive galaxy clusters ( Natarajan et al. 2009 ; Natarajan et al. 2017 ; Ragagnin et al. 2022 ) and Milky Way-scale environments ( Kelley et al. 2019 ; Graus et al. 2019 ; Carlsten et al. 2020 ; Carlsten et al. 2022 ; Grand et al. 2021 ; Lovell et al. 2021 ) . Properly simulating the tidal evolution of substructure requires both sufficient mass and force resolution. Formally, a simulated (sub)halo is a coarse-grained discretization of its actual phase-space distribution function. With decreasing mass resolution (i.e., decreasing number of macro-particles used to represent the substructure), the resulting discreteness noise introduces Poisson fluctuations in the density profile and gravitational potential of the subhalo, which adversely impacts its dynamical evolution ( Romeo et al. 2004 ; Romeo et al. 2008 , e.g.) . In particular, as shown in van den Bosch & Ogiya 2018 , insufficient mass resolution introduces stochasticity