The Penrose singularity theorem, MOTS stability, and horizon topology in weighted spacetimes
Eric Ling, Argam Ohanyan, Eric Woolgar · 2025
Read The Penrose singularity theorem, MOTS stability, and horizon topology in weighted spacetimes by Eric Ling, Argam Ohanyan, Eric Woolgar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26675.txt.
Introduction
Eric Ling, Argam Ohanyan, and Eric Woolgar revisit two classic theorems of general relativity in weighted spacetimes. The Penrose singularity theorem says trapped surfaces force a spacetime to be incomplete, and Hawking's horizon topology theorem restricts the shape of black hole horizons. Weighted spacetimes add a density weight to the geometry.
Ling and his two co-authors define weighted versions of trapped surfaces and prove suitable forms of both theorems under a weighted null energy condition. The results hold in any spacetime dimension and for a synthetic dimension that need not match it. Their work also supports a weighted scalar curvature that differs from the trace of the weighted Ricci curvature. When the synthetic dimension is a whole number, these curvatures read naturally through warped product metrics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eric Ling, Argam Ohanyan, Eric Woolgar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26675
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Penrose singularity theorem, MOTS stability, and horizon topology in weighted spacetimes Eric Ling, Argam Ohanyan, Eric Woolgar Abstract . We consider versions of the Penrose singularity theorem and the Hawking horizon topology theorem in weighted spacetimes that contain weighted versions of trapped surfaces, for arbitrary spacetime dimension and synthetic dimension. We find that suitable generalizations of the unweighted theorems hold under a weighted null energy condition. Our results also provide further evidence in favour of a weighted scalar curvature that differs from the trace of the weighted Ricci curvature. When the synthetic dimension is a positive integer, these weighted curvatures have a natural interpretation in terms of warped product metrics. 1. Introduction The major singularity theorems of general relativity due to Penrose and Hawking, described in Hawking–Ellis [ 24 , Chapter 8] and proved more than 50 years ago, give conditions on the geometry of spacetime that imply some form of causal geodesic incompleteness. This does not provide much information about the nature of spacetime singularities. It leaves open the question of whether such a singularity is mild enough to permit spacetime to be extended past it with perhaps only a slightly loss of smoothness of the differentiabile structure. Recent work has provided greater insight into these questions. It is now known that some spacetimes cannot be extended, at least not without significant loss of smoothness [ 39 ] . A fascinating development has been the work of Cavalletti–Mondino [ 6 ] , which shows that the Hawking cosmological singularity theorem holds in the very weak setting of a Lorentzian length space that need not have any differentiable structure at all. This theorem uses a “synthetic” version of the strong energy condition, derived from the theory of optimal transport. The techniques used to prove the theorem draw heavily on measure theory. Indeed, when the structure provided by the Lorentzian metric and its associated volume form cannot be assumed, more basic structures are still necessary, including assumed causal relations and reference measures. To make further progress, a synthetic notion of the null energy condition is desirable. Versions of those have been put forward by McCann [ 29 ] , Ketterer [ 25 ] and Cavalletti–Manini–Mondino [ 7 , 8 ] . Ketterer was able to use the proposed synthetic null energy condition to prove Penrose’s black hole singularity theorem and the Hawking monotonicity formula in the smooth setting, and to obtain results for a weighted family of synthetic conditions known as synthetic Bakry–Émery null energy conditions. Meanwhile, the approach of Cavalletti–Manini–Mondino extends to the synthetic setting, where those authors are able to obtain a version of the Penrose singularity theorem for C^{0} -spacetime metrics on smooth manifolds, assuming a Bakry–Émery type null energy condition. In the setting of smooth manifolds, the Bakry–Émery Ricci curvature can be described as a variant of the familiar Ricci curvature that incorporates the Hessian of a weight function f . Precisely, the smooth m -Bakry–Émery Ricci curvature is (1.1) \ric^{f,m}:=\ric+\hess f-\frac{1}{m}df\otimes df, for some f\in C^{\infty}(M) and some m\in{\mathbb{R}}\cup\{\infty\} , where the m=0 case is often interpreted as being the case of f=const (so \ric^{f,0}:=\ric ) and m=\infty to mean \ric^{f,\infty}:=\ric+\hess f (note that \ric^{f,\infty}=cg is the gradient Ricci soliton equation). Since the m=0 case is standard, we will omit it from our considerations in this paper. Recall that the Penrose singularity theorem uses the notion of a closed trapped surface , i.e., a closed surface in which both null expansions are negative. In our setting, we will use the notion of a closed f -trapped surface in which the null expansions are modified by f ; see Section 2 . A Penrose-type singularity theorem, assuming nonnegativity of the m -Bakry–Émergy Ricci curvature in the m=\infty case, was proved by Case [ 5 ] . A version of Galloway’s null splitting theorem [ 14 ] (which can be interpreted as the rigidity of Penrose’s singularity theorem), assuming only a bound on the m -Bakry–Émery Ricci curvature along null directions (for any m ), was proved in [ 42 ] . But in the classical smooth setting, a version of the Penrose singularity theorem assuming only a bound on the m -Bakry–Émery Ricci curvature along null directions (for any m ) seems not to have appeared. In this paper we revisit the analysis in the smooth case (also called the classical case) of this condition. First, we give a proof of the m -Bakry–Émergy version of the Galloway null splitting theorem of [ 42 ] using a direct argument by utilizing the ellipticity of the Bakry–Émery null mean curvature operator (more closely following Galloway’s argument, rather than the conformal techniques utilized in [ 42 ] ). Then we establish the Penrose singularity theorem in the classical case for (almost) all values of m , i.e., we prove the following. Theorem 1.1 (Bakry–Émery Penrose singularity theorem) . Let (M,g) be a globally hyperbolic spacetime of dimension \dim M=n\geq 3 with noncompact Cauchy surfaces, f\in C^{2}(M) and m\in(-\infty,2-n]\cup(0,\infty] . Suppose that (M,g) satisfies the Bakry–Émery null energy condition \ric^{m}_{f}(\ell,\ell)\geq 0 for all null vectors \ell\in TM and contains a compact spacelike codimension- 2 surface S that is future f -trapped; i.e., \theta^{\pm}_{f}|_{S}<0 (where the \pm sign denotes the two future-null directions orthogonal to S ). Then: i) If m>0 then (M,g) is future null geodesically incomplete. ii) If m\leq 2-n or m=\infty then (M,g) is future null geodesically f -incomplete (see Definition 2.3 or [ 42 , Definition 1.3] ), and is geodesically incomplete if f is bounded above. We are also able to prove a one-sided version; see Theorem 3.5 . The m=2-n case of Theorem 1.1 is in fact just the usual Penrose singularity theorem. To see this, observe from formula ( B.7 ) of Appendix B that the conformal transformation {\tilde{g}}=e^{-2f/(n-2)} , together with the replacement of m=0 by m=2-n , preserves the null energy condition in the sense that (1.2) \ric_{\tilde{g}}(\ell,\ell)=\ric_{g}^{f,2-n}(\ell,\ell) for any null vector \ell . Now consider the null mean curvature \theta defined by a congruence of null geodesics with tangent field \ell issuing from a closed trapped surface \Sigma . Under this conformal transformation, we have \theta\mapsto\theta-\nabla_{\ell}f=\theta_{f} . Now say that f is bounded above. Then null geodesic incompleteness implies null geodesic f -incompleteness; see Remark 2.4 . The converse is true if f is bounded below. In this sense, Theorem 1.1 with m=2-n can be regarded as a conformally invariant statement of the usual Penrose theorem. If the null expansion of a closed surface \Sigma defined by the future-outbound null geodesics is identically zero, then we say the surface is marginally trapped . It is outermost if there are no trapped surfaces or marginally trapped surfaces outside of and homologous to \Sigma . Marginally trapped surfaces admit a well-known notion of stability, i.e., it is stable if the first eigenvalue of its stability operator is nonnegative. It’s not hard to see that stability implies outermost. Similarly, there are analogous notions of outermost and stable for marginally f -trapped surfaces. The second variation formula for marginally f -trapped surfaces was studied in [ 38 ] for the m=\infty case. There it was found that the constraints on the topology of marginally