Optimal Bidding and Coordinated Dispatch of Hybrid Energy Systems in Regulation Markets
Tanmay Mishra, Dakota Hamilton, Mads R. Almassalkhi · 2025
Read Optimal Bidding and Coordinated Dispatch of Hybrid Energy Systems in Regulation Markets by Tanmay Mishra, Dakota Hamilton, Mads R. Almassalkhi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26602.txt.
Introduction
Tanmay Mishra, Dakota Hamilton, and Mads R Almassalkhi help hybrid energy systems earn money in power markets. A hybrid system mixes controllable generators, flexible loads, and batteries at one site. Such systems can offer frequency regulation, quick adjustments that keep the grid's rhythm steady, but wind and solar uncertainty makes bidding risky.
Mishra and his two co-authors build a two-level framework. The upper level picks capacity bids with a chance-constrained optimisation based on past regulation signals. The lower level splits the called power among the site's resources in real time. They benchmark that split against an offline optimum. The study also tests overbidding, bidding more than a site can surely give, and finds the points where weak performance starts to draw penalties. Uneven mixes of resource sizes are compared too.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tanmay Mishra, Dakota Hamilton, Mads R. Almassalkhi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26602
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Optimal Bidding and Coordinated Dispatch of Hybrid Energy Systems in Regulation Markets Tanmay Mishra, Dakota Hamilton, Mads R. Almassalkhi Abstract The increasing integration of renewable energy sources and distributed energy resources (DER) into modern power systems introduces significant uncertainty, posing challenges for maintaining grid flexibility and reliability. Hybrid energy systems (HES), composed of controllable generators, flexible loads, and battery storage, offer a decentralized solution to enhance flexibility compared to single centralized resources. This paper presents a two-level framework to enable HES participation in frequency regulation markets. The upper level performs a chance-constrained optimization to choose capacity bids based on historical regulation signals. At the lower level, a real-time control strategy disaggregates the regulation power among the constituent resources. This real-time control strategy is then benchmarked against an offline optimal dispatch to evaluate flexibility performance. Additionally, the framework evaluates the profitability of overbidding strategies and identifies thresholds beyond which performance degradation may lead to market penalties or disqualification. The proposed framework also compare the impact of imbalance of power capacities on performance and battery state of charge (SoC) through asymmetric HES configurations. \old@ps@headings \thanksto This material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) under the Solar Energy Technologies Office Award Number DE-EE0010147. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent the views of the U.S.Department of Energy or the United States Government. I Introduction The modern power system is undergoing rapid transformation driven by the integration of variable renewable energy sources (RES) such as solar and wind, coupled with the proliferation of distributed energy resources (DER) including battery storage, electric vehicles (EV), and flexible controllable loads [ 1 ] . This transition poses significant challenges for maintaining grid stability and reliability due to the variability and uncertainty of RES, along with bi-directional power flows and shifting load profiles introduced by widespread DER integration [ 2 , 3 ] . These evolving dynamics highlight the need to revisit the concept of system flexibility centering around these resources, as traditional measures may no longer capture the diverse and rapid response capabilities required for modern power systems [ 4 ] . Flexibility in this context can be defined as the ability to export and import a required power (e.g, provide \pm M MW for frequency regulation for a given duration of time), quantified by the feasible set of maximum power and net energy within a specified dispatch window [ 5 , 6 ] . While large scale battery storage has often been the go-to solution, recent grid events (e.g., California’s “duck curve” over-generation [ 7 ] ) have exposed the limitations of relying solely on centralized, single-resource flexibility. These events underscore the high costs, under-utilization, and inability of such singular solutions to address the location-specific and temporally nuanced needs of a dynamic grid [ 8 ] . This highlights a critical need for a multi-resource system such as hybrid energy systems (HES), as shown in Fig. 1 , which coordinates a controllable generator and loads along with energy storage to provide flexibility for diverse grid services [ 9 , 10 ] . Fig. 1 : Hybrid energy system consisting of a controllable generator, battery storage, and a controllable load connected to an utility grid. However, this potential solution introduces new challenges, such as: How can the flexibility of an HES be maximized, and how can its diverse resources be coordinated in real-time to effectively participate in frequency regulation markets? In practice, maximizing flexibility is closely tied to determining the optimal dispatch capacity, large enough to capture market value but constrained by the minimum performance requirement set by the market regulators [ 11 , 12 ] . Achieving this balance requires an HES to operate with a real-time dispatch strategy that complements operational limits of its assets while collectively maintaining the desired performance score [ 13 ] . This interdependence of choosing the optimal bid and dispatch becomes even more challenging when the regulation signal is not known in advance. This motivates the need for bidding strategies that are robust to regulation signal uncertainty while ensuring market compliance [ 14 ] . One approach is to treat these two (optimal bidding and dispatch) as separate problems [ 15 ] , or to assume that resources can always dispatch the optimal bid obtained through scenario-based techniques without violating their operational limits [ 16 ] ; however, such simplifications often lead to suboptimal bids that either violate performance requirements or fail to fully utilize the system’s flexibility. To overcome these limitations, a framework that jointly considers performance requirements, asset constraints, and market participation objectives is required. One promising direction is a bi-level formulation in which bidding and dispatch are inherently coupled [ 14 ] . In this approach, the capacity bidding problem is solved using chance constraints to a guaranteed probability of success for a minimum performance score, while a real-time control strategy determines the optimal power dispatch during market operation. In [ 14 ] , this framework is demonstrated for a battery participation in frequency regulation market where battery aging is explicitly considered as a key factor influencing the bidding and dispatch decisions. Building on this foundation, the main contributions of the paper are as follows: 1) A chance-constrained bidding strategy to maximize HES participation in frequency regulation markets. 2) A real-time control strategy is proposed to disaggregate the regulation signal among controllable generators, flexible loads, and battery storage in an optimal manner. 3) Simulation-based analysis benchmarks the proposed real-time control strategy against the offline optimal dispatch and evaluates tradeoffs in profitability and performance across different bidding scenarios. The study also quantifies how symmetric and asymmetric HES configurations influence achievable performance and SoC sustainability. The rest of this paper is organized as follows: Section II presents the modeling of HES components. Section III describes the pay-for-performance market framework. Section IV outlines the proposed optimal bidding and real-time control strategy for power allocation among HES assets. Section V evaluates performance through case studies. Finally, Section VI summarizes key findings and discusses future work. II HES Component Modeling An HES combines multiple controllable resources, such as generators, storage, and flexible loads, to provide real-time grid flexibility beyond what a single resource can offer. We model the HES shown in Fig. 1 , consisting of three key components: a controllable generator, an energy storage device (battery), and a controllable load. Their power variables and operational constraints are defined below. II-A Controllable generator The generator may represent an intermittent renewable source (e.g., solar or wind) or a dispatchable unit (e.g., natural gas or diesel genset). The output power of the generator at each discrete time step k is denoted by P_{\text{gen}}[k] , and is constrained by \underline{P}_{\text{gen}}\leq P_{\text{gen}}[k]\leq\overline{P}_{\!\text{gen}}\,, (1) where \underline{P}_{\text{gen}} and \overline{P}_{\!\text{gen}} are the minimum and maximum generator power outputs. For intermittent sources such as solar photovoltaics (PV) or wind, the power limit is time-varying, can be denoted as \overline{P}_{\!\text{gen}}[k] however, in this work, a constant power limit is assumed for simplicity. II-B Battery energy storage The battery dispatch capability is defined using power and energy bounds with total battery dispatch power P_{\text{batt}}[k]=P^{\text{d}}_{\text{batt}}[k]+P^{\text{c}}_{\text{batt}}[k] , where P^{\text{d}}_{\text{batt}}[k]\geq 0 and P^{\text{c}}_{\text{batt}}[k]\leq 0 represent discharging and charging powers, respectively. The