On the Similarity between Epidemiologic Strains, Minimal Self-Replicable Siphons, and autocatalytic cores in (Chemical) Reaction Networks: Towards a Unifying Framework
Florin Avram, Rim Adenane, Lasko Basnarkov, Andras Horvath · 2025
Read On the Similarity between Epidemiologic Strains, Minimal Self-Replicable Siphons, and autocatalytic cores in (Chemical) Reaction Networks: Towards a Unifying Framework by Florin Avram, Rim Adenane, Lasko Basnarkov, Andras Horvath (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26526.txt.
Introduction
Florin Avram, Rim Adenane, Lasko Basnarkov, and Andras Horvath link two fields that study how things spread. Mathematical epidemiology tracks disease strains in populations. Chemical reaction network theory tracks species in reacting mixes. The authors argue these fields share deep structure, and they set out a unifying frame, mostly as a review.
Avram and his three co-authors match disease strains to two network ideas: minimal siphons, small sets that can trap a process, and autocatalytic cores, sets that can sustain themselves. In every model they checked, the two matches lined up. From that match they define the disease-free face of a model and a graph of how the small sets interact. When that graph has no cycles, the famous reproduction number takes a clean max form for multi-strain models. Their software package computes these structures automatically.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Florin Avram, Rim Adenane, Lasko Basnarkov, Andras Horvath |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26526
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Similarity between Epidemiologic Strains, Minimal Self-Replicable Siphons, and autocatalytic cores in (Chemical) Reaction Networks: Towards a Unifying Framework Florin Avram, Rim Adenane, Lasko Basnarkov, Andras Horvath Abstract Motivation : We aim to study boundary stability and persistence of positive odes in mathematical epidemiology models by importing structural tools from chemical reaction networks. This is largely a review work, which attempts to bring closer together the fields of mathematical epidemiology (ME), and chemical reaction networks (CRNs), based on several observations. We started by observing the conceptual correspondence between epidemiologic strains and both critical minimal siphons and minimal autocatalytic sets (cores) in an underlying CRN, and confirmed this in all the models we studied. We leverage this to provide a definition of the disease free equilibrium (DFE) face/infected set as the union of either all minimal siphons, or of all cores (they coincide always in our examples). Next, we provide a proposed definition of ME models, as models which have a unique boundary fixed point on the DFE face, and for which the Jacobian of the infected subnetwork admits a regular splitting, which allows defining the famous next generating matrix (NGM). We then define the interaction graph on minimal siphons (IGMS), whose vertices are minimal siphons, and whose edges indicate the existence of reactions producing species in one siphon from species in another. When this graph is acyclic, we say the model exhibits a Acyclic Minimal Siphon Decomposition (AMSD). For AMSD models whose minimal siphons partition the infection species, we show that the NGM is block triangular after permutation, which implies the classical max structure of the reproduction number R 0 R_{0} for multi-strain models. In conclusion, using irreversible reaction networks, minimal siphons and acyclic siphon decompositions we provide a natural bridge from CRN to ME. We implement algorithms to compute IGMS and detect AMSD in the Epid-CRN Mathematica package ( https://github.com/florinav/EpidCRNmodels ) (which contains already modules to identify minimal siphons, criticality, drainability, self-replicability, etc). Finally, we illustrate on several multi-strain ME examples how the block structure induced by AMSD, and the ME reproduction functions (as introduced in [ AAN , AAHK ] , these are the eigenvalues of the NGM which are always positive, for any values of the non-infection variables), allow expressing boundary stability and persistence conditions by comparing growth numbers to 1 1 , as customary in ME. Note that while not addressing the general Persistence Conjecture mentioned in the title, our work provides a systematic method for deriving boundary instability conditions for a significant class of structured models. 1 Laboratoire de Mathématiques Appliquées, Université de Pau, Pau, France; [email protected] 2 Laboratoire d’Analyse, Géométrie et Applications, département des Mathématiques, Université Ibn-Tofail, Kenitra, Maroc; [email protected] 3 Faculty of Computer Science and Engineering, SS Cyril and Methodius University, and Macedonian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Skopje, Macedonia ; [email protected] 4 Department of Computer Science, University of Turin, Italy; [email protected] Keywords: biochemical interaction networks; essentially nonnegative/positive systems; chemical reaction networks; mathematical epidemiology; multi-strain models; reproduction functions; invasion numbers; regular splitting; chemical reaction networks; stoichiometric matrix; siphons/semi-locking sets; critical self-replicable siphons; autocatalytic cores; disease free equilibrium; admissible communities; Routh-Hurwitz stability conditions; polynomial factorization; Descartes-type polynomials; Glossary 1 Introduction Population dynamics, ecology, mathematical epidemiology (ME), virology, the theory of chemical reaction networks (CRN), to name just some biological interaction networks (BIN) subfields, study all positive dynamical systems, and have similar preoccupations: the existence and multiplicity of equilibria, their local and global stability, the occurrence of bifurcations, persistence, permanence, extinction, etc. CRN offers a versatile mathematical framework for modelling positive systems in a variety of disciplines; examples include biochemical, pharmacokinetic, epidemiological, ecological, social, neural, and multi-agent networks [ Goutsias ] . Of special relevance to us is that CRN theory (CRNT) investigates mass–action systems, which include ME models, and revealed the roles of Petri graphs and siphons in determining boundary behavior. For some recent papers combining both new CRNT results (including for the SIR mathematical epidemiology (ME) model) and interesting historical references, see [ Plesa , GagPoly , XuGAS , XuNon , BloStaVas ] .Let us mention also that CRNT is unavoidable in the study of ODEs with many variables (tens, hundreds). Note however that a considerable part of CRNT focuses on systems which enjoy various degrees of “reversibility”, which is absent in ME. Ecology studies often Lotka–Volterra–Kolmogorov/generalized Lotka–Volterra (LVK/GLV) systems, whose behaviour might seem simpler than those in ME, due to the linear complementarity principle (LCP); however, as shown by Smale, generalized Lotka–Volterra systems may have already very complicated dynamical behaviors, and display chaos [ Smale ] . For some recent developments, including some which tie Smale’s work to CRNs and to ecology, see [ vano2006chaos , sprott2010elegant , wang2023lower , Susits , banaji2024bifurcations , chen2024stability , jafari2025simplest , Plesa ] . One subfield in which CRNT and ecology come together is that of Chemical organisation theory [ dittrich2007chemical , heylighen2015chemical , veloz2017reaction , veloz2020complexity , heylighen2024chemical ] . These authors study both ODE and PDE models, and touched also briefly the topic of ME models [ peter2020structure ] . Epidemiology is especially relevant to our unification quest due to the intricate boundary behaviors encountered in the study of its multi-strain models, whose stability and persistence may sometimes be expressed via remarkably simple threshold conditions involving basic and invasion reproduction numbers. Ecology, ME and CRNT share also common open problems, like the notorious persistence conjecture, which they formulate however differently, since CRNT considers only the case of weakly-reversible systems – see Section for further references. The fact that this conjecture, lying at the intersection of these fields, is only studied by each of them for restricted structural classes, suggests the interest of integrating their different perspectives; let us also note that CRNs have started been applied in ecology and related fields in a few recent papers [ veloz2021reaction , heylighen2022role , VAA , reyes2025functional ] . Our paper focuses on three key concepts: 1. Siphons and reaction networks from CRNT. 2. The next generation matrix (NGM) method from ME, which is also related to the regular splitting method in numerical analysis. 3. The use of reproduction functions – see Definition – for expressing stability in terms or reproduction and invasion numbers, where the second concept originated in ecology (see [ HofSch , feng2025theory , seno2025persistent ] for recent references). To argue our thesis that not sufficient effort has been invested in cross-pollination (interdisciplinary integration) of CRNT, ecology and ME, we add now some more information on the three points enumerated above. 1. The reaction network (RN) representation of ODEs, and the concept of siphons are essential in CRNT, and absent in ME, even though they seem intuitively important. In support of this, our main result below started from the observation that there is a correspondence between minimal siphons and strains in multi-strain epidemic models. This lead to the notion of interaction graph on the minimal siphons (IGMS), and to Theorem : if IGMS is acyclic, and the minimal siphons do not intersect, then the NGM can be block-triangularized (recovering well-known results obtained previously only in examples). 2. The “next generation matrix” (NGM) method (which expresses the stability of the “disease free equilibrium” (DFE) in terms of one inequality R_{0}<1 , where R_{0}