Benchmarking quantum key distribution by mixing single photons and laser light

Yann Portella, Petr Steindl, Juan Rafael Álvarez, Tim Hebenstreit, Aristide Lemaître, Martina Morassi, Niccolo Somaschi, Loïc Lanco, Filip Rozpędek, Pascale Senellart, Dario A. Fioretto · 2025

Read Benchmarking quantum key distribution by mixing single photons and laser light by Yann Portella, Petr Steindl, Juan Rafael Álvarez, Tim Hebenstreit, Aristide Lemaître, Martina Morassi, Niccolo Somaschi, Loïc Lanco, Filip Rozpędek, Pascale Senellart, Dario A. Fioretto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26337.txt.

Introduction

Yann Portella leads ten co-authors in a benchmark of quantum key distribution that mixes true single photons with laser light. Many protocols need single photons, usually approximated by strongly attenuated laser pulses whose photon counts follow Poisson statistics. Their source is a quantum dot in a micropillar, and information is encoded on an incoherent mixture of single photons and laser pulses running the BB84 protocol.

A phenomenological model matches the experiment nearly perfectly in their report. The hybrid design can compensate for limited brightness of single photon sources. Their model also gives an efficiency threshold for when single photons hold an unconditional advantage over laser light, and clarifies how photon purity and collected brightness trade off in BB84 performance.

Catalog record

CREATORYann Portella, Petr Steindl, Juan Rafael Álvarez, Tim Hebenstreit, Aristide Lemaître, Martina Morassi, Niccolo Somaschi, Loïc Lanco, Filip Rozpędek, Pascale Senellart, Dario A. Fioretto
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26337

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Benchmarking quantum key distribution by mixing single photons and laser light Yann Portella, Petr Steindl, Juan Rafael Álvarez, Tim Hebenstreit, Aristide Lemaître, Martina Morassi, Niccolo Somaschi, Loïc Lanco, Filip Rozpędek, Pascale Senellart, Dario A. Fioretto Abstract Quantum key distribution is a key application of quantum mechanics, shaping the future of privacy and secure communications. Many protocols require single photons, often approximated by strongly attenuated laser pulses. Here, we harness the emission of a quantum dot embedded in a micropillar and explore a hybrid approach where the information is encoded on a mixture of single photons and laser pulses. We derive a phenomenological analysis of the configuration where both sources of light are mixed incoherently to perform the BB84 protocol, showing nearly perfect matching between theory and experiment. This provides a flexible technology compensating limited collected brightnesses of single-photon sources as well as a thorough investigation of single-photon statistics advantage scenarios over Poisson-distributed statistics. Explicitly, our model highlights an efficiency threshold for unconditional advantage of single photons over laser along with insights on the interplay between single-photon purity and collected brightness in the performances of BB84. Introduction Figure 1: BB84 implementation with a QDS. Photons are produced by exciting the QD, operating in a 4 K cryostat, with blue-detuned laser light by \Delta_{\text{LA}} . The excitation laser is split into two different paths using a 50:50 fibered beam-splitter (FBS). One path is used to excite the QD, and the laser light is later suppressed with three bandpass filters with two (green) mounted on motorized stages. The second path contains a delay line to temporally match laser pulses and single photons that are recombined with a 99:1 fibered coupler. The photons are linearly polarized using a linear polarizer (red) and a quarter (green) and a half waveplate (yellow). A polarizing beam splitter (PBS) allows a small pick-off of the photons into a Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) measurement setup. The four BB84 states are encoded using another pair of half and quarter waveplates. After the variable optical attenuator (VOA) used to emulate losses over long fiber links, a polarization analyser setup enables randomized measurements in two orthogonal bases: \{|H\rangle,|V\rangle\} and \{|D\rangle,|A\rangle\} with two waveplates and one Wollaston prism (WP) on each arm. The events measured on superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs) are monitored and processed using a time tagging device. Quantum communications protocols and quantum networks tackle many concerns about the future of privacy and are a feasible approach to scale quantum computing by interconnecting remote quantum processors wehner_quantum_2018 . Quantum key distribution (QKD) is a primitive of quantum communication where two legitimate users trusting each other (Alice and Bob) distribute a key, with the secrecy of this exchange being guaranteed by the laws of physics xu_secure_2020 . To ensure security, the implementation of QKD protocols require qubits to be carried via single photons, benefiting from the no-cloning theorem. However, producing high-performance single-photon sources (SPS) remains technically challenging. As a result, significant theoretical and experimental progress has been made using Poisson-distributed sources (PDS) such as attenuated laser pulses, as practical substitutes for ideal single photons liao_satellite–ground_2017 ; liao_satellite-relayed_2018 ; grunenfelder_simple_2018 . The drawback of PDS is the occurrence of multiphoton emissions, which introduce security loopholes that an eavesdropper (Eve) can exploit – for example, with a photon-number splitting (PNS) attack lutkenhaus_quantum_2002 . The fundamental vulnerability induced by the multiphoton components can be suppressed by reducing the mean photon number, which inevitably lowers the amount of transmitted photons from Alice to Bob. This significant performance reduction can be overcome with techniques such as using decoy states lo_decoy_2005 and by monitoring photon number correlations to reduce uncertainties on the source’s parameters dynes_testing_2018 . With near ideal single-photon purity, SPS do not suffer from this problem and could allow longer communication distance waks_security_2002 . Still, the full advantage of SPS requires high photon collected brightness, a requirement that has long remained technologically challenging. Recently, semiconductor quantum-dot sources (QDS) have demonstrated high performances, generating single photons on demand. The collected brightness has been constantly increased, reaching record value in terms of fiber brightness (probability to get a photon on demand) up to 50-70 % somaschi_near-optimal_2016 ; tomm_bright_2021 ; ding_high-efficiency_2025 . This comes with a near unity single-photon purity above 97 %. These features have recently allowed reaching high key rates and cover long distances bozzio_enhancing_2022 ; zahidy_quantum_2024 ; yang_high-rate_2024 . It has also been proven experimentally that QDS can surpass the fundamental limit achievable with PDS in free space demonstrations zhang_experimental_2025 . Lastly, QDS are also now integrated in plug-and-play commercial devices margaria_efficient_2025 . These milestones represent a fundamental landmark for the technology, opening the way to practical quantum communication studies using QDS. In the present work, we explore a route to reach higher performances in QKD by taking advantage of both QDS and PDS. We implement a proof-of-concept of the polarization-encoded BB84 protocol bennett_quantum_2014 with the additional ability to mix photon-number statistics of single photons and laser light at the transmitter output. We show that such incoherent mixing of those sources can be leveraged to increase the secret key rate (SKR) by tuning the ratio of the mixing, depending on the QDS brightness and photon losses. This shows a new method to increase secret key rates in realistic scenarios, and paves the way towards hybrid approaches for quantum communications as well as better understanding of advantage conditions for QDS. Results Experimental protocol We investigate a BB84-like setup bennett_quantum_2014 where Alice and Bob distribute a secret key composed of bits of information encoded in the polarization of photons in two bases: { |H\rangle , |V\rangle } and { |D\rangle , |A\rangle }. The bases are later reconciled publicly: whenever the preparation and measurement bases match, a raw random bit is shared between the two users. We implement a proof-of-concept setup for BB84 using three modules shown in Fig. 1 . A first module (Alice) contains the generation of single photons, their spectral selection, incoherent mixing with the excitation laser, and subsequent polarization control. The semiconductor quantum dot (QD) used in this demonstration is embedded in a micropillar cavity where the Purcell effect allows for efficient photon collection somaschi_near-optimal_2016 ; thomas_bright_2021 . The source is placed in a cryostat at approximately 4K. A neutral exciton from which we consider only one of the linearly polarized optical transition (energy level diagram in Fig. 1 ), is excited using 10 ps laser pulses, blue-detuned by \Delta_{\text{LA}}= 0.8 nm with respect to the QD transition, at a repetition rate of 81.96 MHz. This excitation scheme enables an efficient population transfer to the excited state assisted by the interaction with acoustic phonon during the excitation process thomas_bright_2021 . The excitation laser is precisely aligned in polarization to one of the two dipoles of the neutral exciton, guaranteeing polarized monochromatic single-photon emission. The frequency difference between the laser pulse and the single photons offers the practical advantage of easily separating the two via commercially available spectral filters. Furthermore, the bandwidth of these filters can be tuned by changing their tilt angle with respect to the incident beam. We use optimized filtering (see Supplementary Material) to maintain high brightness and single-photon purity with a detected count rate of 8 MHz and a second-order

Read the complete text