Hot Jupiter Origin and Tidal Evolution Constrained by a Broken Age–Frequency Relation
Di-Chang Chen, Ji-Wei Xie, Ji-Lin Zhou, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Songhu Wang, Chao Liu · 2025
Read Hot Jupiter Origin and Tidal Evolution Constrained by a Broken Age–Frequency Relation by Di-Chang Chen, Ji-Wei Xie, Ji-Lin Zhou, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Songhu Wang, Chao Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26084.txt.
Introduction
Di-Chang Chen leads six co-authors in a study of hot Jupiters, giant planets that orbit very close to their stars, and what their ages reveal about their origins. Hot Jupiters challenge classic planet formation theory, and several rival channels could make them. The team use a sample around single Sun like stars with measured kinematic properties, which give a handle on age.
Chen and the team find that the decline in hot Jupiter frequency with age is broken by a ridge at about two billion years, direct evidence for multiple origins on different timescales. Fitting theory to the pattern constrains the tidal quality factor for Sun like stars and the channel shares. Most form early, but about forty percent form late in their account.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Di-Chang Chen, Ji-Wei Xie, Ji-Lin Zhou, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Songhu Wang, Chao Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 111 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26084
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hot Jupiter Origin and Tidal Evolution Constrained by a Broken Age–Frequency Relation Di-Chang Chen, Ji-Wei Xie, Ji-Lin Zhou, Fei Dai, Bo Ma, Songhu Wang, Chao Liu Abstract The discovery of hot Jupiters has challenged the classical planet formation theory. Although various formation mechanisms have been proposed, the dominant channel and relative contributions remain unclear. Furthermore, hot Jupiters offer a unique opportunity to test tidal theory and measure the fundamental tidal quality factor Q ′ ∗ Q^{{}^{\prime}}_{*} , which is yet to be well-constrained. In this work, based on a hot Jupiter sample around single Sun-like stars with kinematic properties, we find that the declining trend of their frequency is broken with a ridge at ∼ \sim 2 Gyr, providing direct evidence that hot Jupiters are formed with multiple origins of different timescales. By fitting with the theoretical expectations, we provide a constraint of log Q ′ ∗ ∼ 5.7 + 0.4 − 0.3 \log Q^{{}^{\prime}}_{*}\sim 5.7^{+0.4}_{-0.3} for Sun-like stars, which aligns well with the detected number of hot Jupiters with orbital decay. Moreover, we simultaneously constrain the relative importance of different channels: although the majority of hot Jupiters are formed early, within several tenths of Gyr via ‘Early’ models (e.g., in-situ formation, disk migration, planet-planet scattering and Kozai-Lidov interaction), a significant portion ( 38 − 14 + 16 % 38^{+16}_{-14}\% ) should be formed late on a relatively long timescale extending up to several Gyr mainly via the secular chaos mechanism, further supported by the obliquity distribution of ‘late-arrived’ hot Jupiters. Our findings provide a unified framework that reconciles hot Jupiter demographics and long-term evolution with multichannel formation. keywords exoplanet, planet formation, planetary dynamics The discovery and peculiarities of hot Jupiters present significant challenges to the classical planet formation theories based on our Solar system ( 1995Natur.378..355M ; 2018ARA&A..56..175D ) . To explain the origin of hot Jupiters, previous studies have proposed various models, e.g., in-situ formation ( 2016ApJ…829..114B ; 2016ApJ…817L..17B ) , disk migration ( 1996Natur.380..606L ; 2014prpl.conf..667B ) and high-eccentricity migration ( 1996Sci…274..954R ; 2003ApJ…585.1056G ; 2011Natur.473..187N ; 2011ApJ…735..109W ; 2015ApJ…805…75P ) . However, none of these models alone can satisfactorily explain all the observational evidence, and the origin of hot Jupiters remains puzzling (see the review by ( 2018ARA&A..56..175D ) ). An outstanding question is: what is the predominant channel and how much do different models contribute to the formation of hot Jupiters? Furthermore, as hot Jupiters are close to the host stars, their orbits are expected to decay with age due to tidal interaction ( 2008ApJ…678.1396J ; 2012MNRAS.423..486L ) . Previous studies have looked for observational evidence for the tidal decays from individual ( 2020ApJ…888L…5Y ; 2021AJ….161…72T ; 2024ApJS..270…14W ) and ensemble properties of hot Jupiters ( 2008ApJ…678.1396J ; 2017AA…602A.107B ; 2018MNRAS.476.2542C ; 2019AJ….158..190H ; 2020AJ….160..138H ) as well as the properties (e.g., age, spin-up) of their host stars ( 2019AJ….158..190H ; 2023PNAS..12004179C ; 2023AJ….166..209M ; 2024AJ….168….7B ; 2018AJ….155..165P ) . However, the derived stellar modified tidal quality factor Q^{{}^{\prime}}_{*} from different works vary by several orders of magnitude ( 2008ApJ…678.1396J ; 2017AA…602A.107B ; 2018MNRAS.476.2542C ; 2019AJ….158..190H ; 2020ApJ…888L…5Y ; 2021AJ….161…72T ; 2022AJ….163..208B ) , ranging from \sim 10^{4}-10^{9} (Extended Data Tab. 1 ). Therefore, obtaining a well-constrained stellar tidal quality factor is vital to resolve this discrepancy and to achieve a fundamental understanding of tidal phenomena. The age-frequency relationship of hot Jupiters offers novel insights into their origin and tidal evolution. Specifically, different formation mechanisms operate on timescales ranging from millions to billions of years ( 2018ARA&A..56..175D ) , resulting in distinct arrival time distributions. After hot Jupiters arrive at \lesssim 0.1 AU and have been largely circularized, the orbits of hot Jupiters are expected to decay under tidal forces, with the decay rate primarily determined by Q^{{}^{\prime}}_{*} ( 2008ApJ…678.1396J ; 2012MNRAS.423..486L ) . Some of them will eventually pass into the Roche limit and be disrupted within the lifetime of their host stars ( 2012MNRAS.423..486L ; 2023PNAS..12004179C ) . Consequently, hot Jupiters formed through different origin models, under the tidal forces of stars with varying Q^{{}^{\prime}}_{*} , will exhibit distinct evolutionary patterns over time. Based on the kinematic method for estimating age and a sample of hot Jupiters with kinematic properties, in a previous study ( 2023PNAS..12004179C ) , we derived the age-frequency relation and revealed a generally declining trend using a mathematical exponential function. In this work, we perform detailed analyses of the age-frequency trend and focus on the physical interpretation of the observational results by quantitatively fitting with the theoretical expectations of the tidal evolution of hot Jupiters originating from different channels. This not only allows us to obtain a precise constraint on the stellar tidal quality factor but also enables the determination of the relative importance of different models in forming hot Jupiters across varying timescales. Sample selection Our work builds upon the planetary sample selected and the stellar parent sample constructed in our previous study ( 2023PNAS..12004179C , for details, see the § 1 and 3 of Supporting information of) . The planetary sample was collected from the kinematic catalogs of the Planets Across Space and Time series ( 2021ApJ…909..115C ; 2021AJ….162..100C , PAST;) and composed of giant planets orbiting single Sun-like stars in the Galactic disks, which was further divided into three subsamples based on the discovery method and facility, i.e., radial velocity (RV), space-based transit (ST), and ground-based transit (GT). In this work, we further expand the GT subsample by utilizing the Gaia DR2 catalog. The final sample consists of 123 hot Jupiters (17 RV, 14 ST and 92 GT) and 936,815 (1662 RV, 19,228 ST and 915,925 GT) parent stars (Methods, § 1.1). Analyses and Results A broken Age-frequency relation of hot Jupiters We derive a ‘combined’ frequency of hot Jupiters F_{\rm HJ} (i.e., also termed as ’occurrence’, defined as the fraction of stars with a hot Jupiter) as a function of kinematic age by jointly using the data from the three subsamples discovered by different methods/facilities (Methods, § 1.2). The detection efficiencies and geometric effects are corrected with the same procedures described in § 3 of Supporting information of ( 2023PNAS..12004179C ) . As can be seen in the top panel of Figure 1 , F_{\rm HJ} generally declines with increasing age (Methods, § 1.3.1), which is consistent with previous studies ( 2023PNAS..12004179C ; 2023AJ….166..209M ) . Figure 1: The observed age-frequency relation of hot Jupiters. Frequency of hot Jupiters as a function of kinematic age for the entire hot Jupiter sample (Top), and separately for the two populations: ‘late-arrived’ (Middle) and ‘early-arrived’ (Bottom). The vertical and horizontal errorbars represent the uncertainties of Frequencies of hot Jupiters and kinematic ages, respectively. Beyond the generally declining trend, there are some more intriguing characteristics: a ridge occurs at \sim 2 Gyr, and the declining trend of F_{\rm HJ} is mild in the early stage, but becomes steeper in the late stage. To evaluate the existence of the ridge, we adopt the findpeaks function from from the scipy.signal module and returns a ridge at 1.94^{+0.72}_{-0.50} Gyr. We also resample the observation data (e.g., kinematic ages, observed number of planets and stars, detection efficiencies, geometric effects) for 10,000 times from their uncertainties and perform the sequences and reversals test to