Beyond the Uncanny Valley: A Mixed-Method Investigation of Anthropomorphism in Protective Responses to Robot Abuse CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Computer systems organization-Embedded and cyber-physical systems-Robotics
Fan Yang, Lingyao Li, Yaxin Hu, Michael D. Rodgers, Renkai Ma · 2025
Read Beyond the Uncanny Valley: A Mixed-Method Investigation of Anthropomorphism in Protective Responses to Robot Abuse CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Computer systems organization-Embedded and cyber-physical systems-Robotics by Fan Yang, Lingyao Li, Yaxin Hu, Michael D. Rodgers, Renkai Ma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-26082.txt.
Introduction
Fan Yang, Lingyao Li, Yaxin Hu, Michael Rodgers, and Renkai Ma study how people react when they see a robot being abused. The response depends on how human like the robot looks. Anthropomorphism means giving a machine human traits. Two hundred one participants watched videos of abuse toward a spider like robot, a two footed robot, or a humanoid robot, spanning low to high human likeness.
Yang and the team combine self report surveys, automated facial expression analysis, and written reflections. Protective responses did not rise in a straight line. The middle robot, rated most eerie in line with uncanny valley theory. It drew the strongest physical anger expressions. Self reported anger and guilt were higher for both the middle and humanoid robots than for the spider.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fan Yang, Lingyao Li, Yaxin Hu, Michael D. Rodgers, Renkai Ma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-26082
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond the Uncanny Valley: A Mixed-Method Investigation of Anthropomorphism in Protective Responses to Robot Abuse CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Computer systems organization-Embedded and cyber-physical systems-Robotics Fan Yang, Lingyao Li, Yaxin Hu, Michael D. Rodgers, Renkai Ma Abstract . Robots with anthropomorphic features are increasingly shaping how humans perceive and morally engage with them. Our research investigates how different levels of anthropomorphism influence protective responses to robot abuse, extending the Computers as Social Actors (CASA) and uncanny valley theories into a moral domain. In an experiment, we invite 201 participants to view videos depicting abuse toward a robot with low (Spider), moderate (Two-Foot), or high (Humanoid) anthropomorphism. To provide a comprehensive analysis, we triangulate three modalities: self-report surveys measuring emotions and uncanniness, physiological data from automated facial expression analysis, and qualitative reflections. Findings indicate that protective responses are not linear. The moderately anthropomorphic Two-Foot robot, rated highest in eeriness and “spine-tingling” sensations consistent with the uncanny valley, elicited the strongest physiological anger expressions. Self-reported anger and guilt are significantly higher for both the Two-Foot and Humanoid robots compared to the Spider. Qualitative findings further reveal that as anthropomorphism increases, moral reasoning shifts from technical assessments of property damage to condemnation of the abuser’s character, while governance proposals expand from property law to calls for quasi-animal rights and broader societal responsibility. These results suggest that the uncanny valley does not dampen moral concern but paradoxically heightens protective impulses, offering critical implications for robot design, policy, and future legal frameworks. 1. INTRODUCTION The Computers as Social Actors (CASA) paradigm ( Nass et al. 1994 ; Nass and Moon 2000 ) has been extensively examined in numerous empirical studies across different contexts ( Gambino et al. 2020 ; Katagiri et al. 2001 ) . From computers ( Lee and Nass 2010 ; Nass and Steuer 1993 ) to AI ( Park et al. 2021 ; Xu et al. 2022 ; Seok et al. 2025 ; Gu et al. 2024 ; Zhao et al. 2025 ) , and to robots ( Lee et al. 2005 ; Xu et al. 2023 ; Xu 2019 ) , scholars have found that humans are inclined to apply social rules (e.g., etiquette, reciprocity, stereotypes) to social agents, especially when they resemble human characteristics or display social cues ( Lombard and Xu 2021 ) , a phenomenon known as anthropomorphism ( Gong 2008 ; Nass and Moon 2000 ; Lee 2010 ; Kim and Sundar 2012 ) . However, extensive human-robot interaction (HRI) research also suggests a potential caveat: social responses to robots do not always increase linearly with anthropomorphism. Instead, near-human appearance can paradoxically trigger aversion and discomfort and subsequently inhibit engagement with a robot, a hypothesis known as the uncanny valley effect ( Mori et al. 2012 ; MacDorman 2006 ; Zhang et al. 2020 ) . While existing literature has shown mixed evidence, with both support for and challenges to the existence of CASA ( Heyselaar 2023 ; Lee 2010 ; Antos et al. 2011 ; Gambino et al. 2020 ) and the uncanny valley ( Poliakoff et al. 2013 ; Diel et al. 2021 ; Weisman 2024 ; Urgen et al. 2018 ; Złotowski et al. 2015b ) , the majority of existing HRI research has examined them primarily in benign social interaction contexts (e.g., engaging conversations, performing collaborative tasks) ( Chiou et al. 2020 ; Seok et al. 2025 ; De Kervenoael et al. 2024 ) . This raises a critical question: Can the uncanny valley effect also impact how we apply moral rules to robots when they are mistreated? By examining protective responses to robots in abusive rather than neutral or cooperative interactions, this study investigates whether the psychological mechanisms predicted by the uncanny valley hypothesis can also govern moral concern in a similar fashion. While people may avoid interacting with uncanny robots due to discomfort, they might still feel morally obligated to protect them from harm. Alternatively, the uncanny valley effect might be so powerful that it suppresses protective impulses even when robots are clear victims of mistreatment. Utilizing a mixed-methods experimental research design that triangulates three distinct data modalities—objective physiological measures, self-report survey responses, and qualitative open-ended reflections, this study provides a comprehensive empirical examination of how anthropomorphism, a core concept in both CASA and the uncanny valley effect, influences protective responses to robot abuse. Findings of this research study directly extend CASA and uncanny valley into a novel context of robot abuse and advance theoretical understanding of how anthropomorphism impacts moral considerations towards robots. In addition, these findings also have critical practical implications for robot design, deployment policies, and legal frameworks, informing how robots should be designed to elicit appropriate moral consideration, particularly in vulnerable contexts such as public service ( Shiomi et al. 2025 ; Shum et al. 2024 ) , education ( Tan et al. 2018 ) , and hospitality ( Sun et al. 2026 ) where robots may face mistreatment. Building on the existing CASA ( Nass and Moon 2000 ; Nass and Steuer 1993 ) and uncanny valley ( Mori et al. 2012 ; MacDorman 2006 ) literature, our study employs a mixed-method experimental design combining quantitative, physiological, and qualitative data to investigate the role of anthropomorphism - a central concept in both CASA and uncanny valley - in shaping up protective responses to robot abuse. Understanding how anthropomorphism influences moral consideration critically extends both CASA paradigm and uncanny valley hypothesis beyond their currently tested boundaries and addresses practical concerns about robot abuse and its potential to shape societal norms. As such, we ask: • RQ1 : How do individual self-report reactions to robot abuse vary by a robot’s anthropomorphic level? • RQ2 : How do individual physiological reactions to robot abuse vary by a robot’s anthropomorphic level? • RQ3 : How do individual views on robot abuse and protection vary by a robot’s anthropomorphic level, if any? 2. RELATED WORK 2.1. Robots as Social Actors A central debate about CASA resides in whether humans apply social rules to intelligent agents mindlessly—as automatic responses—or mindfully through conscious anthropomorphism ( Kim and Sundar 2012 ; Xu et al. 2023 ) . While the original CASA assumed mindless application of social scripts regardless of anthropomorphic cues ( Nass and Moon 2000 ) , significant research has shown that anthropomorphism plays a crucial, albeit complex, role in driving social responses to technologies ( Lombard and Xu 2021 ) . For instance, while Lee (2010) found that anthropomorphic cartoon characters enhanced social attractiveness and trustworthiness of computers ( Lee 2010 ) , the other study demonstrated significant influences of anthropomorphic design cues on agent perceptions ( Araujo 2018 ) . Further scholarly inquiries discover that anthropomorphism can occur both mindlessly and mindfully, suggesting these are not mutually exclusive mechanisms ( Kim and Sundar 2012 ) . In the attempt to unify the two explanatory mechanisms of CASA - mindless and mindful anthropomorphism, Lombard and Xu (2021) propose that mindless anthropomorphism better explains social responses when technologies display high-quality and high-quantity social cues, such as highly human-like robots ( Phillips et al. 2018 ; Christou et al. 2020 ) , where users experience intuitive, spontaneous responses to natural