Reconfigurable Analog Computers
Bernd Ulmann · 2025
Read Reconfigurable Analog Computers by Bernd Ulmann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25942.txt.
Introduction
Bernd Ulmann, working alone, reviews ways to reprogram analog computers automatically. An analog computer solves problems with continuous electrical signals rather than digital steps. Classic machines were slow to program, since users had to patch hundreds or thousands of cords by hand and set many dials. The job could take hours or days, even with removable patch panels.
Ulmann notes that analog machines draw fresh interest as co processors because digital chips face limits in energy use, clock speed, and density. That interest needs autopatch systems, where a host digital computer rewires the analog machine on its own. The paper surveys classic and modern approaches to such automatic reconfiguration and compares how they work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bernd Ulmann |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 17 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25942
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reconfigurable Analog Computers The author would like to thank his colleagues at anabrid GmbH for their incredible work. He would also like to thank Mrs. Nicole Matje for proofreading. Bernd Ulmann Abstract The Achilles heel of classic analog computers was the complex, error prone, and time consuming process of programming. This typically involved manually patching hundreds or even thousands of connections between individual computing elements as well as setting many precision 10-turn potentiometers manually, often taking hours, or even days. Albeit being simplified by means of removable patch panels, switching from one program to another still was time consuming and thus expensive. With digital computers about to hit physical boundaries with respect to energy consumption, clock frequency, and integration density, analog computers have gained a lot of interest as co-processors for certain application areas in recent years. This requires some means for automatic reconfiguration of these systems under control of an attached digital computer. The following sections give an overview of classic and modern approaches towards such autopatch systems. , I Introduction and requirements Analog computing has been gaining a lot of interest in recent years due to its promise of substantial speedups and unmatched energy efficiency for the solution of problems described by systems of coupled (nonlinear) differential equations or by partial differential equations. In contrast to today’s prevailing digital computers, which solve problems by executing a sequence of rather simple instructions read from some memory attached to a central processing unit ( CPU ), an analog computer does not have any memory in the classic sense at all, it does not execute instructions, and it typically does not represent values by sequences of bits. Instead, an analog computer works by setting up an (electronic) model of the problem under consideration by connecting a number of computing elements in a suitable fashion. These work on values represented by continuous voltages or currents and work in continuous time and full parallelism (see [ Ulmann 2023 ] for a thorough treatment of analog and hybrid computers, their history, programming techniques, etc.). This different approach is best described by a toy problem such as the computation of a(b+c) . On a digital computer this would require six individual instructions: Three to read the values a , b , and c , one addition, one multiplication, and one instruction to store the result back into memory. Since all of these instructions depend on each other there is not too much that can be done in order to achieve parallelism in execution. On an analog computer, this problem would require two computing elements, one adder and one multiplier connected as shown in figure 1 . All values are represented by a corresponding voltage (or a current), so each connection between computing elements is just a single wire, the program being a directed graph with edges resembling connections and vertices representing computing elements. b c + * a x Fig. 1: Computing a(b+c) on an analog computer It should be noted here that while a digital computer is always capable of trading time against problem size, given that enough memory is available, an analog computer must physically grow with the problem size, i. e., there must be enough individual computing elements for any given problem. Back in the heyday of analog computing, the 1950s–1960s, this was a problem due to the cost and size of analog computers. Using modern CMOS techniques, it is now possible to integrate hundreds or thousands of computing elements on a single integrated circuit, allowing next generation analog computers to scale to sizes previously unheard of. This problem of scaling, however, is complemented by a great benefit: While the time to solution on a digital computer typically grows with problem size, often much worse than linearly, typically described by the Big-O notation , the solution time on an analog computer is basically constant, regardless of the number of computing elements required for the implementation of a particular problem. This is a fundamental advantage of analog computers over stored-program digital computers. Figure 2 shows an early mechanical differential analyzer (a mechanical analog computer) with its creator, Vannevar Bush (11.03.1890–30.06.1974) standing next to it. He is looking at the central interconnect structure. The computing elements are arranged to the left and right of this interconnect. This also becomes visible in the classic program circuit shown in figure 3 . Variables were transmitted between computing elements by rotating shafts and gears. Programming such a machine basically required to dismantle and reassemble it from scratch, a process that could take up to two “man-days” (see [ Bush et al. 1945 , p. 277] ). This often invalidated the advantage in speed offered by the system as one could also solve the problem executing a manual numeric integration technique in about the same time. Fig. 2: Mechanical differential analyzer Fig. 3: Setup of the Bush differential analyzer for a cosmic ray problem (see [ Owens 1986 , p. 77] ) II Early attempts at an autopatch Accordingly, the process of programming the machine, i. e., connecting the various computing elements, had to be sped up considerably. This led to the Rockefeller differential analyzer, which still relied on mechanical computing elements. However, these were no longer directly connected to each other by means of rotating shafts and gears but used servo motors and synchros for input and output. This made it possible to use a crossbar switch from a telephone exchange system as the central interconnect of the machine, implementing an n\times m matrix of switches. From its structure this is the holy grail of analog computing – having a full n\times m switch matrix makes it possible to connect the computing elements without any restrictions. Unfortunately, this does obviously not scale. In a machine such as the Rockefeller analyzer with several dozen computing elements it was a viable option, but for machines employing hundreds, thousands, of even more computing elements, a full matrix interconnect is just not practical. III Hannauer’s work In 1961, Electronic Associates Inc. ( EAI ) performed a study on an autopatch system based on an EAI 231R analog computer. This vacuum tube system featured about 2\cdot 10^{2} individual computing elements. The study concluded that a viable switch matrix would require between 5\cdot 10^{4} and 10^{5} individual switches (reed relays back than) – clearly impractical. In the second half of the 1960s, George Hannauer , also at EAI, performed a comprehensive study on the problem of autopatch systems (see [ Hannauer 1968 ] ) under a NASA contract. In order to reduce the number of switches required for a realistically large analog computer, a hierarchy of switch matrices had to be employed. For this, Hannauer coined the terms concentrator and expander for switch matrices depending on the quotient e=m/n of their inputs and outputs with e<1 being a concentrator and e>1 an expander. Fig. 4: Interconnect structure as proposed in [ Hannauer 1968 , p. 4-2] This quite closely resembled the structure of a telephone exchange where the number of users substantially exceeds the average number of connections required (see [ Clos 1953 ] and [ Benes 1965 ] for details). While blocking conditions in a telephone exchange are clearly undesirable, they can