SoK: Honeypots & LLMs, More Than the Sum of Their Parts?

1 st Robert A. Bridges, 2 nd Thomas R. Mitchell, 3 st Mauricio Muñoz, 4 th Ted Henriksson · 2025

Read SoK: Honeypots & LLMs, More Than the Sum of Their Parts? by 1 st Robert A. Bridges, 2 nd Thomas R. Mitchell, 3 st Mauricio Muñoz, 4 th Ted Henriksson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25939.txt.

Introduction

Robert A. Bridges, Thomas R. Mitchell, Mauricio Munoz, and Ted Henriksson survey what happens when large language models meet honeypots. A honeypot is a decoy computer system set up to lure attackers and study them. Designers have long faced a trade off between rich deception and low running risk, and models promised to ease that trade off.

Bridges and the team give the first broad overview of the new field since work took off in late twenty twenty two. They classify ways attackers can detect a honeypot, map how model based simulation helps or fails for each, and trace a common system design and test pattern. Their roadmap argues the real gain lies in autonomous systems, not single tricks.

Catalog record

CREATOR1 st Robert A. Bridges, 2 nd Thomas R. Mitchell, 3 st Mauricio Muñoz, 4 th Ted Henriksson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25939

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

SoK: Honeypots & LLMs, More Than the Sum of Their Parts? 1 st Robert A. Bridges, 2 nd Thomas R. Mitchell, 3 st Mauricio Muñoz, 4 th Ted Henriksson Abstract The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) promised to resolve the long-standing paradox in honeypot design: achieving high-fidelity deception with low operational risk. However, despite a flurry of research since late 2022, progress has been incremental, and the field lacks a cohesive understanding of the emerging architectural patterns, core challenges, and evaluation paradigms. To fill this gap, this Systematization of Knowledge (SoK) paper provides the first comprehensive overview of this new domain. We survey and systematize three critical, intersecting research areas: first, we provide a taxonomy of honeypot detection vectors, structuring the core problems that LLM-based realism must solve; second, we synthesize the emerging literature on LLM-honeypots, identifying a canonical architecture and key evaluation trends; and third, we chart the evolutionary path of honeypot log analysis, from simple data reduction to automated intelligence generation. We synthesize these findings into a forward-looking research roadmap, arguing that the true potential of this technology lies in creating autonomous, self-improving deception systems to counter the emerging threat of intelligent, automated attackers. I Introduction Cybersecurity honeypots—decoy systems designed to lure and analyze attackers—have long grappled with a fundamental design paradox. The spectrum of honeypots ranges from “low-interaction” systems, which are safe and easy to deploy but simplistic and easily detected, to “high-interaction” systems, which offer high-fidelity engagement at the cost of significant risk and management overhead. For decades, the central goal of honeypot research has been to resolve this tension: to achieve the high fidelity of a real system with the low risk and effort of a simulated one. The recent advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) appeared to offer a silver bullet. With their uncanny ability to generate convincing text, code, and shell interactions, LLMs promised a paradigm shift for honeypots. The vision was clear: low-interaction decoys could finally be imbued with dynamic, adaptive, and believable personalities, luring attackers into revealing their tools and techniques. 1 1 1 While our focus is on enterprise network server emulation, researchers have explored other creative applications, including honeypots for IoT devices [ 1 ] , systems to misdirect web scrapers [ 2 ] , and chatbots designed to waste the resources of email and phone scammers [ 3 , 4 ] . This vision spurred a flurry of research over the last two years seeking to integrate LLMs into existing honeypot frameworks. As this work was often performed concurrently, many of these formative papers do not cite or build directly upon each other, creating a fragmented landscape. A comprehensive understanding of how this new field is developing is needed to identify its fundamental limitations and most promising directions. To address this, we provide the first systematic review of LLM-powered honeypots, uniquely situating it between surveys of two critical, flanking topics: honeypot fingerprinting, to understand the core problems of realism, and honeypot data analysis, to understand the ultimate goal of intelligence generation. The goal of this Systematization of Knowledge (SoK) paper is to provide the necessary foundational understanding of this burgeoning research area and to accelerate the development of effective LLM-powered defenses. This paper is organized as follows. Section II provides background on cybersecurity and honeypots for readers seeking more context. Section III contains our three core systematizations. Section IV presents our synthesized takeaways and V is a forward-looking research roadmap. I-A Related Works & Our Contributions To situate our work, we conducted a review of recent surveys and Systematization of Knowledge (SoK) papers. Our search on Google Scholar for the terms ("survey" OR "systemization of knowledge" OR "SoK") AND "honeypot" AND ("Large Language Model" OR "LLM") from 2024 to the present yielded no prior SoKs on this specific topic. The closest works are broader surveys on the impact of LLMs on cybersecurity [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . While these papers acknowledge honeypots as a potential application, they are discussed only briefly within a much larger context. Our work is therefore complementary, providing a deep and focused systematization solely on this intersection. The most relevant prior survey on modern deception technology is by Javadpour et al. [ 8 ] . This comprehensive work offers a detailed review of cyber deception literature from 2008-2023, establishing a clear baseline for the pre-LLM era. Contributions Our work distinguishes itself from these prior surveys not only through its focused scope but by providing several novel systematizations that structure this emerging field. While Javadpour et al. provide a definitive look at the classic era of deception technology, our work provides the first systematic treatment of the LLM-driven era by contributing the following: • We provide a foundational framework for how honeypots are detected, which systematizes the core problems that LLM-based realism must solve, a perspective not offered in prior work. • We synthesize the literature on LLM-powered honeypots into an emerging canonical model, identifying the common architectural patterns (e.g., filter/router logic, state management) that have rapidly evolved. • We chart the progression of honeypot log analysis through four distinct phases of maturity, from simple data reduction to the modern goal of operationalizing intelligence with agents. • Finally, we synthesize these findings into a forward-looking research roadmap, identifying high-impact directions such as the need for dynamic evaluation ecosystems and autonomous, self-improving feedback loops. By providing these frameworks, our SoK offers a structured, multi-faceted understanding of the challenges, architectures, and future trajectory of LLM-powered honeypots, a contribution distinct from both the broad cybersecurity surveys and the pre-LLM deception literature. I-B Summarized Findings Our systematization reveals several key findings regarding the current state of the art. Historic honeypot fingerprinting principles often still apply as even with LLM simulation, fundamental limitations will give these systems away to a reasonably intelligent adversary. Architecturally, we identify an emerging canonical model for LLM-honeypots that incorporates components for filtering, state management, and generation, but we note a significant gap in open-source tooling. We find the field has developed a valuable trichotomy of evaluation criteria and methodologies: deceptiveness (human evaluation), accuracy (statistical), overall (real-world deployments). Yet there persists an evaluation paradox: while multiple methodologies exist, their utility is hampered by a real-world ”data desert” of low-sophistication traffic, making it difficult to measure progress against meaningful threats. This leads to our finding that the appropriate target for these systems is not skilled humans, whom they are unlikely to deceive, but the emerging threat of sophisticated automated agents. Finally, we find that while automated threat intelligence generation is now possible, it remains in a nascent, proof-of-concept stage, primarily blocked by the lack of large-scale, labeled training data. Based on these findings, we propose a forward-looking research roadmap centered on the development of autonomous and self-improving deception systems. Architecturally, we highlight the need for open-source, modular frameworks and research into efficient, privacy-preserving models using techniques like LoRA. We advocate for the creation of a dynamic adversarial research ecosystem to solve the ”data desert” problem and enable meaningful evaluation against the true target: sophisticated, automated attackers. Finally, we outline a path toward true autonomy through the implementation of feedback loops, enabling systems to automatically generate intelligence for security operations centers and reconfigure themselves

Read the complete text