Constraints on the resolution of spacetime singularities

Arvin Shahbazi-Moghaddam · 2025

Read Constraints on the resolution of spacetime singularities by Arvin Shahbazi-Moghaddam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25927.txt.

Introduction

Arvin Shahbazi-Moghaddam, working alone, reviews new limits on how spacetime singularities might be resolved. A singularity is a point where gravity theory breaks down, such as inside a black hole. A theorem by Penrose and Wall constrains what can happen there, but it rests on the generalized second law, a rule that total entropy never falls. Until recently that law was proved only in an approximate way.

Shahbazi-Moghaddam highlights a non perturbative proof of that law in holographic brane world models at the species scale, where many matter fields matter. With it, a trapped surface still forces incompleteness, so any true resolution must evade the theorem conditions. He illustrates both outcomes with a BTZ black hole and a resolved null singularity.

Catalog record

CREATORArvin Shahbazi-Moghaddam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25927

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraints on the resolution of spacetime singularities Arvin Shahbazi-Moghaddam Abstract What happens at spacetime singularities is poorly understood. The Penrose–Wall singularity theorem constrains possible scenarios, but until recently its key assumption—the generalized second law (GSL)—had only been proven perturbatively, severely limiting this application. We highlight that recent progress enables a proof of the GSL in holographic brane-world models, valid non-perturbatively at the species scale c ​ G cG (with c c the number of matter fields and G G Newton’s constant). This enables genuine constraints: an outer-trapped surface in the Einstein gravity regime implies geodesic incompleteness non-perturbatively at the species scale. Conversely, any genuine resolution must evade Penrose’s criteria. We illustrate both possibilities with explicit examples: the classical BTZ black hole evolves to a more severe singularity, while a null singularity on the Rindler horizon is resolved, both by species-scale effects. Subject to the GSL, these constraints on singularity resolution apply beyond brane-worlds: namely, in any theory with a geometric UV scale —roughly, where the metric remains well-defined but classical Einstein gravity breaks down. I Introduction A robust signature of a spacetime singularity is the presence of an incomplete causal geodesic, i.e., a future (or past) inextendible causal curve with finite affine parameter Wald 1984 . For example, in the Schwarzschild spacetime, causal geodesics falling into the r=0 singularity are incomplete (see Fig. 1 ). A major advantage of defining singularities via the presence of geodesic incompleteness is that the latter can be proved via singularity theorems. This is extremely powerful because the conditions of the theorems may be verified in the low curvature region, without the (impractical) need to solve for the full geometry. The Penrose singularity theorem is a primary example, and will be the main focus in this paper Penrose 1965 . Penrose’s singularity theorem establishes that in a spacetime with non-compact Cauchy slices, the existence of an outer-trapped surface (i.e., a compact spacelike codimension-two surface whose outward null expansion is everywhere negative) implies the existence of at least one incomplete null geodesic. The theorem put to rest the idea that singularities are unphysical artifacts of highly non-generic solutions, at least in the regime of validity of the theorem, that is, classical Einstein gravity coupled to matter satisfying the null energy condition (NEC). 1 1 1 The NEC states that T_{ij}k^{i}k^{j}\geq 0 , where T_{ij} is the stress-energy tensor and k^{i} is any null vector. In fact, the regime of validity of Penrose’s theorem is larger, and includes any spacetime which satisfies the null curvature condition, i.e., R_{ij}k^{i}k^{j}\geq 0 , where R_{ij} is the Ricci tensor. The conditions are equivalent in Einstein gravity. This is a powerful result on the status of classical singularities. It is believed, however, that Einstein gravity is a truncation of a more complete theory of quantum gravity. And this truncation provides a bad approximation in large curvature regions where Ultraviolet (UV) effects (e.g., quantum effects of matter or gravity) become important. For instance, the NEC can be violated boundlessly in the quantum regime Ford 1978 . This challenges the physical relevance of Penrose’s theorem. One must either give it up when studying quantum gravity, or extend it to a broader regime of validity. Figure 1: In the Schwarzschild spacetime, a spacetime wedge \mathcal{W} is shown in grey, with a non-compact Cauchy slice \Sigma , and with future/past boundaries \partial^{\pm}\mathcal{W} . L^{\pm} denotes portions of the boundaries of the future/past of \mathcal{W} . The generators of \partial^{+}\mathcal{W} are incomplete, since they fall into the r=0 singularity after a finite affine parameter. A causal horizon \mathcal{H}^{+} can be defined as \partial I^{-}(\gamma) , the boundary of the past of the future-infinite causal curve \gamma . In Wall 2013a , significant progress was made in the latter direction, which can be described as follows: First, it was shown that the NEC assumption can be replaced by the (weaker) assumption of a horizon area law, namely, that cross-sectional areas of future (resp. past) causal horizons cannot decrease towards the future (resp. past) Hawking and Ellis 1973 . 2 2 2 A future causal horizon is defined as the boundary of the past of any future-infinite causal curve. A past horizon can be defined in the analogous way. In a theory like Einstein gravity which enjoys time-reversal symmetry, the future and past area laws are equivalent. This is a powerful deduction, since this feature of causal horizons is believed to be the classical gravity manifestation of a more general truth in quantum gravity. In particular, it was conjectured that it generalizes to the so-called generalized second law (GSL) in the presence of quantum effects Bekenstein 1973 . Roughly speaking, the GSL states that the generalized entropy ( S_{\rm gen} ), a sort of entropy of spacetime regions, cannot decrease along causal horizons. The generalized entropy of a spacetime wedge \mathcal{W} (i.e., a domain of dependence of a partial Cauchy slice) is schematically: \displaystyle S_{\rm gen}(\mathcal{W})=\frac{A(\eth\mathcal{W})}{4G}+S_{\rm ren}(\mathcal{W}), (1) where \eth\mathcal{W} denotes the edge of the wedge \mathcal{W} , G denotes the renormalized Newton’s constant, and S_{\rm ren} denotes the renormalized von Neumann entropy of quantum fields inside \mathcal{W} Bekenstein 1973 ; Susskind and Uglum 1994 . 3 3 3 A widely believed feature of the generalized entropy is that it is well-defined despite the fact that matter von Neumann entropy in subregions is ill-defined. A schematic explanation for this is that the UV divergence of the von Neumann entropy renormalizes Newton’s constant G in the area term, resulting in a finite expression ( 1 ) Susskind and Uglum 1994 . See Witten 2022 for a more modern perspective. For instance, Hawking radiation causes the area of black hole horizons to shrink, though their generalized entropies grow due to compensation from the von Neumann entropy of the radiation, upholding the GSL Page 1976 ; Page 1983 . In Wall 2013b , it was then shown that the GSL implies a quantum generalization of Penrose’s singularity theorem whereby in a spacetime with non-compact Cauchy slices, a compact (quantum) trapped surface, i.e., a spacelike codimension-two surface whose associated outward null (quantum) expansion is negative, implies the existence of a singularity (see Sec. II for a review). We will henceforth refer to this as the Penrose-Wall singularity theorem (PW). The theorem unlocks several potential applications. We focus here on its implications regarding the resolution of spacetime singularities. A major puzzle in quantum gravity is finding mechanisms for singularity resolution. Near a curvature singularity, one expects large corrections to classical Einstein gravity that can affect the geometry significantly. It is then a logical possibility that what appears as a singularity in a solution of Einstein gravity gives way to a region of large but finite curvature in a more complete theory. In the language of geodesic incompleteness, the Einstein gravity truncation of the theory can, in principle, predict a metric with geodesic incompleteness, even though the exact metric is geodesically complete. An application of the PW singularity theorem would rule out this scenario for singularities which are diagnosed by a (quantum) trapped surface. This does not mean that the singularity must fundamentally persist in the ultimate theory of quantum gravity, but that at least a more exotic mechanism of singularity resolution would have

Read the complete text