Atmospheric collapse and re-inflation through impacts for terrestrial planets around M dwarfs

Prune C. August, Robin Wordsworth, Mikayla Huffman, David Brain, Lars A. Buchhave · 2025

Read Atmospheric collapse and re-inflation through impacts for terrestrial planets around M dwarfs by Prune C. August, Robin Wordsworth, Mikayla Huffman, David Brain, Lars A. Buchhave (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25896.txt.

Introduction

Prune C. August, Robin Wordsworth, Mikayla Huffman, David Brain, and Lars A. Buchhave ask whether impacts could bring back an atmosphere on a rocky planet after it has frozen out. Planets close to small red dwarf stars are locked with one side in night, so gases can condense as ice on the dark side and the air can collapse. That ice, though, forms a store that an impact could vaporize.

August and the team use a simple energy balance model with random impacts for carbon dioxide atmospheres. Middle sized impactors, five to ten kilometers wide, at plausible rates can rebuild visible, short lived air. For some known rocky worlds, planets may spend half or more of their time with such restored air.

Catalog record

CREATORPrune C. August, Robin Wordsworth, Mikayla Huffman, David Brain, Lars A. Buchhave
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25896

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Atmospheric collapse and re-inflation through impacts for terrestrial planets around M dwarfs Prune C. August, Robin Wordsworth, Mikayla Huffman, David Brain, Lars A. Buchhave Abstract Detection of an atmosphere around a terrestrial exoplanet will be a major milestone in the field, but our observational capacities are biased towards to tidally locked, close-in planets orbiting M-dwarf stars. The atmospheres of these planets are vulnerable to atmospheric erosion and collapse due to condensation of volatiles on the nightside. However, these collapsed volatiles accumulated as nightside ice constitute a stable reservoir that could be re-vaporised by meteorite impacts and re-establish the atmospheres. Through a simple energy balance model applied to atmospheric evolution simulations with stochastic impacts, we assess the viability and importance of this mechanism for CO 2 atmospheres. We find that moderate-sized impactors ( 5 − 10 ​ km 5-10~\rm{km} diameter) occurring at a frequency of 1 − 100 ​ Gyr − 1 1-100~\rm{Gyr}^{-1} can regenerate observable transient atmospheres on previously airless planets. We focus on specific targets from the JWST DDT Rocky Worlds programme, and compute the fraction of their evolution spent with a transient CO 2 atmosphere generated through this mechanism. We find this fraction can reach 70 % 70\% for GJ 3929 b, 50 % 50\% for LTT 1445 Ac, 80 % 80\% for LTT 1445 Ab, at high impact rates and strong CO 2 outgassing over the planet’s lifetime. We also show that atmospheric collapse can shield volatiles from escape, particularly in the early, high-XUV phase of M-dwarf evolution. Overall, our work suggests that terrestrial planet atmospheres may not evolve monotonically but instead may be shaped by episodic external forcings. I Introduction The influence of meteorite impacts on atmospheric evolution of terrestrial planets is well documented. Incoming comets can deliver volatiles to replenish atmospheres ( A. Morbidelli et al. 2000 ; F. J. Ciesla et al. 2015 , e.g.) or conversely, erode them through high energy collisions ( V. Shuvalov 2009 ; Q. Kral et al. 2018 , e.g.) . They can also dramatically alter the climatic conditions of a planet by vaporising target materials and injecting them into the atmosphere, as exemplified by the Chicxulub impact ( L. W. Alvarez et al. 1980 ; E. Pierazzo et al. 1998 ) . On Mars, impact cratering has been proposed as a mechanism to trigger transient warming and precipitations necessary to explain the observed extensive valley networks ( T. L. Segura et al. 2002 ; T. L. Segura et al. 2008 ; O. B. Toon et al. 2010 ) . Building on this idea, A. M. Palumbo & J. W. Head 2018 further quantified the water cycle that would result from such an impact, showing that large and basin-scale impacts would result in high and homogeneously distributed rainfall. Although the authors conclude the mechanism is incompatible with the observed equatorial concentration of valley networks, their work demonstrates the capacity of impacts to regenerate significant transient atmospheres. Collapsed or partially collapsed atmospheres are common in the Solar System. Mars’ polar ice caps likely have been formed and shaped by collapse processes ( F. Forget et al. 2013 ; A. Soto et al. 2015 ) , and MESSENGER observations revealed evidence of volatile-rich surfaces on Mercury, where evidence of volatile-rich layers and glacier-like terrains has also been found ( J. A. P. Rodriguez et al. 2023 , e.g.) . Additionally, spectra of Io’s atmosphere before and during its eclipse by Jupiter show the SO 2 feature appearing and disappearing, indicating that the atmosphere collapses on its surface when in Jupiter’s shadow and gets reinflated as it comes back out ( C. C. C. Tsang et al. 2016 ) . These examples illustrate that collapsed atmospheres can act as volatile reservoirs, capable of regenerating transient atmospheres if sufficient energy is provided. Cratering records on the Moon ( E. M. Shoemaker et al. 1969 ; E. M. Shoemaker & E. C. Morris 1970 ) , Mercury ( R. G. Strom et al. 2008 ) and Mars ( W. K. Hartmann & G. Neukum 2001 ) suggest that impacts are a common phenomenon in the Solar System, at least on geological timescales. On Earth, estimated impact rates are 10 to 100 impacts/Gyr for objects with a diameter >5~\rm{km} and 1 to 10 impacts/Gyr for those >10~\rm{km} ( J. S. Stuart & R. P. Binzel 2004 ; M. Le Feuvre & M. A. Wieczorek 2011 ) . Impactor fluxes are currently poorly constrained on exoplanets, but TESS photometric observations of exocomet transits in the \beta Pic b system indicate a differential power law slope of \gamma=3.6\pm 0.8 for the comet size distribution, consistent with both Solar System comet populations and with expectations for a collisionally relaxed distribution ( \gamma=3.5 ) ( A. Lecavelier des Etangs et al. 2022 ) . Close-in tidally locked rocky exoplanets around M dwarfs may host substantial surface ice reservoirs in cold traps on their nightsides. These planets experience a high amount of XUV radiation, which significantly erodes their atmospheres ( A. L. Shields et al. 2016 ; J. Krissansen-Totton 2023a ; R. Wordsworth & L. Kreidberg 2022 , e.g.,) . Once the atmospheric pressure drops below a critical threshold, the nightside becomes cool enough for the volatiles to condense on the surface, initiating catastrophic atmospheric collapse ( R. Wordsworth 2015 ) . Once the atmosphere has collapsed, a new stable state is reached, and continued outgassing leads to further condensation on the nightside. 1 1 1 The only exception would be if the mass outgassed exceeded that of the critical pressure threshold of the planet over timescales shorter than condensation timescales, which is unlikely from volcanism alone. This creates the possibility of vast volatile reservoirs trapped in ice sheets on the nightside, which could in principle be vaporised by impact heating as described by A. M. Palumbo & J. W. Head 2018 . The launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has given a major push to the hunt for terrestrial exoplanet atmospheres. Many programmes targeting M-dwarf rocky planets have returned non-detections (e.g., S. Zieba et al. 2023 ; M. Zhang et al. 2024 ; Q. Xue et al. 2024 ; M. Weiner Mansfield et al. 2024 ; E. A. Meier Valdés et al. 2025 ; M. Fortune et al. 2025 , Allen et al. submitted) , or at most tentative detections ( R. Hu et al. 2024 ; P. C. August et al. 2025 ; A. Bello-Arufe et al. 2025 ) , with many of these results requiring additional observations to establish a consensus. The recently announced 500 hour Director’s Discretionary Time (DDT) ”Rocky Worlds” programme ( S. Redfield et al. 2024 ) underscores the timeliness of theoretical work on the formation and survival of secondary atmospheres on these planets. Here, we propose a mechanism for the formation of transient, secondary atmospheres around rocky exoplanets. Section II outlines the theoretical basis for atmospheric collapse and our impact-driven regeneration mechanism, and Section III describes our model. In Section IV , we show the results of our simulations, and we discuss key findings and limitations in Section V . Finally, we summarise and link our findings to the current observational context in Section VI , and propose avenues for future

Read the complete text