Hawking Radiation meets the Double Copy
Rafael Aoude, Donal O’Connell, Matteo Sergola, Chris D. White · 2025
Read Hawking Radiation meets the Double Copy by Rafael Aoude, Donal O’Connell, Matteo Sergola, Chris D. White (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25866.txt.
Introduction
Rafael Aoude, Donal O'Connell, Matteo Sergola, and Chris D. White describe an electric system that mirrors a collapsing black hole through the double copy link. The double copy turns gauge theory results into gravity results. They study a massless particle crossing a collapsing electromagnetic background, which is the single copy partner of the Vaidya space used for a black hole that forms from infalling matter.
Aoude and the team pick out the diagrams that dominate at large scale and derive the coefficients that set how many particles are created. A separate ray tracing check in the same background gives the same result. They then discuss what the number pattern means for heat and energy in the double copy picture.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rafael Aoude, Donal O’Connell, Matteo Sergola, Chris D. White |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25866
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hawking Radiation meets the Double Copy Rafael Aoude, Donal O’Connell, Matteo Sergola, Chris D. White Abstract We describe an electromagnetic system which is related to black hole production with Hawking radiation through the double copy. We consider the scattering of a massless scalar particle through a collapsing electromagnetic background – the single copy of Vaidya – and identify the Feynman diagrams that exponentiate in the geometric-optics limit. The Bogoliubov coefficients obtained from the diagrammatic approach are reproduced by a semiclassical ray-tracing computation of null rays in this same background. We discuss the thermodynamic interpretation of the resulting number distribution in light of the double copy. 1 Introduction The study of scattering amplitudes in gauge and gravity theories continues to attract attention. Two major topics in recent years have been the use of amplitudes to reveal intriguing connections between different (quantum) field theories; also, their ability to shed new light on questions in (semi-)classical physics, particularly those relating to black holes. Motivated by this, ref. Aoude:2024sve considered the well-known phenomenon of Hawking radiation Hawking:1974rv ; Hawking:1975vcx (see e.g. refs. Harlow:2014yka ; Page:2004xp for extensive reviews), addressing the problem using amplitude methods developed in the context of gravitational wave physics Kosower:2018adc (see also refs. Goldberger:2020geb ; Goldberger:2020wbx ; Kim:2020dif ; Ilderton:2023ifn ; Gaddam:2021zka ; Gaddam:2020mwe ; Ferreira:2020whz ; Melville:2023kgd ; Aoude:2023fdm ; Chen:2023qzo ; Vidal:2024inh ; Aoki:2025ihc ; Ilderton:2025umd ; Clark:2025tqi for related ideas). Motivated by Hawking’s original calculation, the authors considered the metric corresponding to a collapsing shell of null dust, and a one-to-one scattering amplitude of a scalar particle in this background. By resumming a set of all possible Feynman diagrams involving interactions with the background field, the authors could relate the amplitude to the thermal spectrum of emitted particles. One way to understand this is through the known interpretation of Hawking radiation as pair creation of particles near the black hole horizon, followed by quantum tunnelling of one of the particles Parikh:1999mf . The pair creation amplitude is related to the Hawking (one-to-one) amplitude by crossing. Scattering amplitudes in gravity theories are related to those in gauge theory by the double copy Bern:2008qj ; Bern:2010ue ; Bern:2010yg , itself inspired by previous work in string theory Kawai:1985xq . The double copy has also been extended to classical solutions Monteiro:2014cda ; Luna:2015paa ; Ridgway:2015fdl ; Bahjat-Abbas:2017htu ; Carrillo-Gonzalez:2017iyj ; CarrilloGonzalez:2019gof ; Bah:2019sda ; Alkac:2021seh ; Alkac:2022tvc ; Luna:2018dpt ; Sabharwal:2019ngs ; Alawadhi:2020jrv ; Godazgar:2020zbv ; White:2020sfn ; Chacon:2020fmr ; Chacon:2021wbr ; Chacon:2021hfe ; Chacon:2021lox ; Dempsey:2022sls ; Emond:2021lfy ; Easson:2022zoh ; Chawla:2022ogv ; Han:2022mze ; Armstrong-Williams:2022apo ; Han:2022ubu ; Elor:2020nqe ; Farnsworth:2021wvs ; Anastasiou:2014qba ; LopesCardoso:2018xes ; Anastasiou:2018rdx ; Luna:2020adi ; Borsten:2020xbt ; Borsten:2020zgj ; Goldberger:2017frp ; Goldberger:2017vcg ; Goldberger:2017ogt ; Goldberger:2019xef ; Goldberger:2016iau ; Prabhu:2020avf ; Luna:2016hge ; Luna:2017dtq ; Cheung:2016prv ; Cheung:2021zvb ; Cheung:2022vnd ; Cheung:2022mix ; Chawla:2024mse ; Keeler:2024bdt ; Chawla:2023bsu ; Easson:2020esh ; Armstrong-Williams:2024bog ; Armstrong-Williams:2023ssz ; Farnsworth:2023mff ; Emond:2025nxa ; Moynihan:2025vcs ; Ilderton:2025gug (see e.g. refs. Borsten:2020bgv ; Bern:2019prr ; Adamo:2022dcm ; Bern:2022wqg ; White:2021gvv ; White:2024pve for recent reviews), where a canonical formalism is that of the Kerr-Schild double copy of ref. Monteiro:2014cda . Given that the analysis of ref. Aoude:2024sve adopted a Kerr-Schild form for the gravitational background field, the authors already posed the question of whether a single copy of their calculation exists, and can be interpreted. The aim of this paper is to carry out this investigation, and there are a number of motivations for doing so. Firstly, despite a broad literature on the double copy, its ultimate origin and scope remain somewhat mysterious. Concrete examples of how known physics in either gauge or gravity theories can be directly related is highly sought after, providing much-needed physical intuition of how the double copy operates. Indeed, such insights may be useful for the more general web of QFTs that are now known to be related by double-copy-like correspondences. Secondly, a single copy of Hawking radiation may be valuable for understanding further quantum properties of black holes. The study of semi-classical gravity remains an ongoing research area, with many open questions, including the precise nature of potential microstates that can lead to the known black hole entropy. Knowing that one can obtain Hawking radiation from a double copy opens the door for finding further black hole properties, by recycling results from a simpler gauge theory. For completeness, we note that gauge theory analogues of Hawking radiation have an established history Parikh:1999mf ; Wondrak:2023zdi ; Wondrak:2023hcz ; Stephens:1989fb ; Parentani:1991tx ; Kim:2011fs ; Kim:2012wg ; Srinivasan:1998ty . Our work is complementary to these, in that the nature of the analogue is determined by the particular relationship of the single copy, which offers alternative possibilities for extending our approach to obtain additional insights. The structure of our paper is as follows. In section 2 , we find and interpret the single copy of the classical (Vaidya) spacetime used in ref. Aoude:2024sve to derive Hawking radiation from an appropriate scattering amplitude. In sec. 3 , we find the gauge theory analogue of this amplitude, and spell out its relation to the Bogoliubov coefficients needed to examine particle production properties. We cross-check our results in sec. 4 by comparing with a ray-tracing calculation, as described in ref. Aoude:2024sve . In sec. 5 , we examine the number spectrum of emitted particles from the single-copy Vaidya solution. This shows crucial differences from the gravitational case, and we will speculate regarding the physical interpretation of our results. Finally, we discuss our results and conclude in sec 6 . Appendix A proves energy-momentum conservation for the non-static background current. Note added In the final stages of this project we learned about the parallel research in reference Ilderton:2025 which contains some overlap with our work and is to appear in a forthcoming article. We thank the authors for cooperating with us in the submission of our work and for sharing advance copies of their drafts. We have also checked that our results are compatible by comparing our eikonal with the wavefunctions computed in Ilderton:2025 . 2 The classical background In this section, we begin our detailed discussion of the single-copy of Hawking radiation. We will follow the basic logic of Hawking’s original paper, computing Bogoliubov coefficients A and B , which describe the dynamics of a massless scalar field in a time-dependent background, and extracting the statistical number distribution from B . Let us start by developing an understanding of the relevant background. Hawking considered a situation involving some matter collapsing to form a black hole. A very simple example of a collapse background is given by the Vaidya metric Vaidya:1966zza ; Stephani_Kramer_MacCallum_Hoenselaers_Herlt_2003 \displaystyle g_{\mu\nu}=\eta_{\mu\nu}-\frac{2GM}{r}\Theta(t+r)\mathsf{k}_{\mu}\mathsf{k}_{\nu}\,, (1) where M is the mass of the (future) black hole, while \mathsf{k}\cdot\mathrm{d}x=\mathrm{d}(t+r) . This is a Kerr-Schild metric: exact although it is linear in Newton’s constant G . More precisely, Vaidya metrics are a class of spacetimes involving time-dependent mass functions, but for our purposes the choice M\Theta(t+r) is particularly convenient. The Heaviside theta function corresponds to a black hole forming suddenly on the time scales of interest. Physically, this metric describes a black hole formed from a thin shell of infalling light-like radiation — therefore the spacetime involves a specific stress-energy tensor describing radiation