Identity Management for Agentic AI: The new frontier of authorization, authentication, and security for an AI agent world

Tobin South, Subramanya Nagabhushanaradhya, Ayesha Dissanayaka, Sarah Cecchetti, George Fletcher, Victor Lu, Aldo Pietropaolo, Dean H. Saxe, Jeff Lombardo, Abhishek Shivalingaiah, Stan Bounev, Alex Keisner, Andor Kesselman, Zack Proser, Ginny Fahs, Andrew Bunyea, Ben Moskowitz, Atul Tulshibagwale, D · 2025

Read Identity Management for Agentic AI: The new frontier of authorization, authentication, and security for an AI agent world by Tobin South, Subramanya Nagabhushanaradhya, Ayesha Dissanayaka, Sarah Cecchetti, George Fletcher, Victor Lu, Aldo Pietropaolo, Dean H. Saxe, Jeff Lombardo, Abhishek Shivalingaiah, Stan Bounev, Alex Keisner, Andor Kesselman, Zack Proser, Ginny Fahs, Andrew Bunyea, Ben Moskowitz, Atul Tulshibagwale, D (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25819.txt.

Introduction

Tobin South leads twenty co-authors in a white paper on identity rules for AI agents. An AI agent is software that acts on its own to carry out tasks for a user. Such agents need clear rules for proving who they are, who may act, and what access they should get, and current protocols leave those rules unclear.

South and the team, writing for the OpenID Foundation audience, list tools already available to secure agents in use today. They then set an agenda for harder problems ahead, such as access control at scale, delegated authority, and telling AI workloads apart. The paper speaks to builders and policy makers alike.

Catalog record

CREATORTobin South, Subramanya Nagabhushanaradhya, Ayesha Dissanayaka, Sarah Cecchetti, George Fletcher, Victor Lu, Aldo Pietropaolo, Dean H. Saxe, Jeff Lombardo, Abhishek Shivalingaiah, Stan Bounev, Alex Keisner, Andor Kesselman, Zack Proser, Ginny Fahs, Andrew Bunyea, Ben Moskowitz, Atul Tulshibagwale, D
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25819

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Identity Management for Agentic AI: The new frontier of authorization, authentication, and security for an AI agent world Tobin South, Subramanya Nagabhushanaradhya, Ayesha Dissanayaka, Sarah Cecchetti, George Fletcher, Victor Lu, Aldo Pietropaolo, Dean H. Saxe, Jeff Lombardo, Abhishek Shivalingaiah, Stan Bounev, Alex Keisner, Andor Kesselman, Zack Proser, Ginny Fahs, Andrew Bunyea, Ben Moskowitz, Atul Tulshibagwale, Dazza Greenwood, Jiaxin Pei, Alex Pentland Abstract See pages 1 of coverpage.pdf Executive Summary The rapid rise of AI agents presents urgent challenges in authentication, authorization, and identity management. Current agent-centric protocols (like MCP) highlight the demand for clarified best practices in authentication and authorization. Looking ahead, ambitions for highly autonomous agents raise complex long-term questions regarding scalable access control, agent-centric identities, AI workload differentiation, and delegated authority. This whitepaper is for stakeholders at the intersection of AI agents and access management. It outlines the resources already available for securing today’s agents and presents a strategic agenda to address the foundational authentication, authorization, and identity problems pivotal for tomorrow’s widespread autonomous systems. Today’s frameworks handle simple AI agent scenarios: • AI agents differ fundamentally from traditional software; they take autonomous actions on external services, exhibiting non-deterministic, flexible behavior that adapts in real-time, rather than simply executing predetermined instructions. • Existing OAuth 2.1 frameworks, when used with AI agents, work well within single trust domains with synchronous agent operations (e.g., enterprise agents accessing internal tools, consumers accessing their services through AI tools), but may fall short in scenarios that are cross-domain, highly autonomous, or asynchronous, as well as those which require the agent to use or enforce delegated permissions on behalf of multiple human users at the same time. • The Model Context Protocol (MCP) is leading in adoption as the key framework for connecting language models to external data sources and tools when building agents. Other approaches exist and should be supported, including function calling (tool use) and agent-to-agent (e.g., A2A) communication protocols. • Enterprise SSO and SCIM provisioning can help enable the use of enterprise agents and facilitate centralized agent lifecycle management, as well as governance of permissions and access for various AI agent use cases. • Enterprise security profiles provide the baseline for safe AI adoption. To mitigate risks, this paper recommends that AI agents conform to rigorous, interoperable profiles of existing identity standards. Working groups, such as the Interoperability Profiling for Secure Identity in the Enterprise (IPSIE), can provide guidance on this, giving organizations the confidence to adopt AI by ensuring robust controls are in place. • User-centric consent models are the foundation for consumer agents. For agents connecting to third-party consumer services (e.g., email, social media, financial data), the established OAuth 2.1 user consent flow is the primary mechanism for granting delegated authority, making transparency and clear scope definition critical for user trust. Critical future challenges exist: • Agent identity fragmentation should be avoided. Vendors could develop proprietary agentic identity systems, which would reduce developer velocity by forcing repeated one-off integrations. It would also compromise security by creating multiple security models, each with different risks and vulnerabilities. • User impersonation by agents should be replaced by delegated authority. Currently, agents often act indistinguishably from users, creating accountability gaps and security risks. True delegation requires explicit “on-behalf-of” flows where agents prove their delegated scope while remaining identifiable as distinct from the user they represent. • Scalability problems exist in human oversight & user consent. Users will face thousands of authorization requests as agents proliferate, creating security risks from reflexive approval. Preemptive authorization and scoping of flexible agents are at odds with least privilege. • Recursive delegation creates risks. Agents spawning sub-agents or communicating tasks to other agents create complex authorization chains without clear scope attenuation mechanisms. • Agents acting on behalf of and reporting to teams of humans lack support. While OAuth and OpenID Connect were designed for individual user authorization, agents can be employed in shared codebases or chat channels in groups. In these multi-user environments, various permission levels may exist for different users, but all of them share a common objective within a single context. No popular protocol exists to support shared agents. • Trustworthy autonomy lacks automated verification. Scaling beyond human-in-the-loop safety models requires new, programmatic methods to ensure an agent’s actions continuously align with its operational goals and constraints. • Browser and computer-use agents break the current authorization paradigm. Agents controlling visual interfaces directly (or via MCP into browser orchestrators) bypass all traditional API-based authorization controls. Protecting the open web from lockdown will require robust authentication of web bots or web agents. • Multi-facet behavior of agents complicates identity. Technological advancements allow an agent to act on its own, requiring agents to have their own credentials, permissions, and audit trails. Furthermore, an agent’s nature can be hybrid, enabling it to alternate between independent execution and acting on behalf of a user. Contributors This report was prepared for the OpenID Foundation by Tobin South starting in April 2025, in collaboration with the Artificial Intelligence Identity Management Community Group , Stanford’s Loyal Agents Initiative , and many independent reviewers and contributors, with thanks to WorkOS for supporting its completion with the author’s time and practical contributions towards testing the ideas herein. Many collaborators, co-authors, advisors, and reviewers contributed to this work. Special thanks for direct contributions goes to Subramanya Nagabhushanaradhya, Sarah Cecchetti, Ayesha Dissanayaka, George Fletcher, Aaron Parecki, Pamela Dingle, Tom Jones, Aldo Pietropaolo, Łukasz Jaromin, Tal Skverer, Wils Dawson, Andor Kessleman, Stan Bounev, Kunal Sinha, Bhavna Bhatnagar, Nick Steele, Abhishek Maligehalli Shivalingaiah, Victor Lu, Chris Keogh, Govindaraj Palanisamy (Govi), Alex Keisner, Mahendra Kutare, Pavindu Lakshan, Michael Hadley, Zack Proser, Cameron Matheson, Dan Dorman, Zack Prosner, Alex Pentland, Jiaxin Pei, Dazza Greenwood, Ginny Fahs, Andrew Bunyea, Ben Moskowitz, Atul Tulshibagwale, Jeff Lombardo, Elizabeth Garber, and Gail Hodges. 1 Agents are Different this Time? The first step in understanding the unique identity, authentication, authorization, and audit needs of AI agents is to define exactly what they are and why they differ. Figure 1: An illustrative example of the different types of AI agents and how they use tools, such as the Model Context Protocol (MCP), across increasing levels of autonomy. 1.1 Defining AI Agents AI systems are taking the world by storm and come in a range of formats, from chat interfaces using language models to internal workflow automations using traditional machine learning techniques. What delineates an AI agent in the context of this paper is the ability for the AI-based system to take ‘action’ based on ‘decisions’ made at model inference time to achieve specific goals . This is beyond simple chatbots producing text outputs. Unlike traditional software, which follows predefined rules and instructions, AI agents can learn from context, adapt to new situations, and make decisions autonomously. Traditional software typically requires manual updates to handle new scenarios, while AI agents use context and reasoning to improve their performance and adapt. They can interact via APIs as well as specialized agent communication protocols, such as the Model Context Protocol (MCP), or browser interfaces. Some of these behaviors can resemble standard remote workloads or applications, but are distinct due to their highly flexible, non-deterministic, and contextual nature. Generally, “agents” are defined as identified and authorized software that uses language models to

Read the complete text