Inference on Welfare and Value Functionals under Optimal Treatment Assignment
Xiaohong Chen, Zhenxiao Chen, Wayne Yuan Gao · 2025
Read Inference on Welfare and Value Functionals under Optimal Treatment Assignment by Xiaohong Chen, Zhenxiao Chen, Wayne Yuan Gao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25607.txt.
Introduction
Xiaohong Chen, Zhenxiao Chen, and Wayne Yuan Gao study treatment assignment inference. Their 2025 economics paper covers welfare and value functionals. Optimal treatment assigns treatment when benefit is nonnegative. Their functionals depend on that nonparametric effect function. Estimation and inference theory are given here.
Only people with nonnegative effects receive treatment optimally. A variance formula in closed form is also given. More general value functionals behave differently in rates. Plug-in estimators converge at one-dimensional nonparametric rates usually. Edge populations explain the varied convergence rates. Welfare integrands vanish at zero-effect edges there. Monte Carlo runs show good finite-sample results. Job training program effectiveness supplies empirical use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xiaohong Chen, Zhenxiao Chen, Wayne Yuan Gao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Inference on Welfare and Value Functionals under Optimal Treatment Assignment Thanks: We thank Xu Cheng, Yanqin Fan, Sukjin Han, Patrick Kline, Soonwoo Kwon, Oliver Linton, Liyang Sun, Petra Todd, and conference participants at 2025 World Congress of the Econometric Society, 2025 California Econometrics Conference, 2025 Cowles Conference on Econometrics Celebrating Don Andrews for helpful comments and suggestions. Xiaohong Chen, Zhenxiao Chen, Wayne Yuan Gao Abstract We provide theoretical results for the estimation and inference of a class of welfare and value functionals of the nonparametric conditional average treatment effect (CATE) function under optimal treatment assignment, i.e., treatment is assigned to an observed type if and only if its CATE is nonnegative. For the optimal welfare functional defined as the average value of CATE on the subpopulation with nonnegative CATE, we establish the n \sqrt{n} asymptotic normality of the semiparametric plug-in estimators and provide an analytical asymptotic variance formula. For more general value functionals, we show that the plug-in estimators are typically asymptotically normal at the 1-dimensional nonparametric estimation rate, and we provide a consistent variance estimator based on the sieve Riesz representer, as well as a proposed computational procedure for numerical integration on submanifolds. The key reason underlying the different convergence rates for the welfare functional versus the general value functional lies in that, on the boundary subpopulation for whom CATE is zero, the integrand vanishes for the welfare functional but does not for general value functionals. We demonstrate in Monte Carlo simulations the good finite-sample performance of our estimation and inference procedures, and conduct an empirical application of our methods on the effectiveness of job training programs on earnings using the JTPA data set. Keywords: optimal treatment assignment, conditional average treatment effect, semiparametric estimation and inference, regular and irregular functionals 1 Introduction In this paper, we study the estimation and inference on welfare and value functionals of a given treatment under optimal (“first-best”) treatment assignment. Let D_{i}\in\left\{0,1\right\} denote a certain binary treatment for subject i , \left(Y_{i}\left(0\right),Y_{i}\left(1\right)\right) denote the potential outcomes of interest, and Y_{i}:=Y_{i}\left(D_{i}\right)\in\mathbb{R} denote the observed outcome. Let X_{i}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} denote subject i ’s observable characteristics of i , which is distributed with density f_{0} . We suppose that researchers have access to a random sample of training data \left\{(D_{i},Y_{i},X_{i})\right\}_{i=1}^{n} . Under the standard conditional unconfoundedness assumption \left.\left(Y_{i}\left(0\right),Y_{i}\left(1\right)\right)\perp D_{i}\right|X_{i} and the overlap condition p_{0}\left(x\right):=\mathbb{E}\left[\left.D_{i}\right|X_{i}=x\right]\in\left(0,1\right) , the conditional average treatment effect (CATE) defined by \text{CATE}\left(x\right):=\mathbb{E}\left[\left.Y_{i}\left(1\right)-Y_{i}\left(0\right)\right|X_{i}=x\right] is identified from data by \displaystyle\text{CATE}\left(x\right)\equiv h_{0}\left(x\right) \displaystyle:=\mu_{0}\left(x,1\right)-\mu_{0}\left(x,0\right), (1) where h_{0}:\mathbb{R}^{d}\mapsto\mathbb{R} , and \mu_{0}\left(x,d\right):=\mathbb{E}\left[\left.Y_{i}\right|X_{i}=x,D_{i}=d\right] (2) is the nonparametric regression function of the outcome Y_{i} on X_{i} and D_{i} . We maintain the conditional unconfoundedness assumption and the overlap condition, and will thereafter simply refer to h_{0} as the CATE function. We further assume that h_{0} belongs to a Holder class of functions with smoothness s>1 . We consider a standard scenario where policymakers can assign treatments based on covariates, and focus on the following two core types of welfare and value parameters. The first type is the maximized welfare of the target population under optimal treatment assignment: \displaystyle W\left(h_{0}\right) \displaystyle:=\int\left[h_{0}\left(x\right)\right]_{+}f\left(x\right)dx (3) where f is the marginal density of x in the target population and \left[t\right]_{+}:=\max\left(t,0\right) is the rectified linear unit (ReLU) function. W\left(h_{0}\right) averages the CATE over the population under the “first-best” treatment assignment rule: “treat type x if and only if \text{CATE}\left(x\right)\geq 0 ,” and is thus often referred to as the welfare under optimal treatment assignment. We will thereafter refer to W\left(h_{0}\right) as the welfare functional. Alternatively, one may also be interested in evaluating the average of a value other than CATE over the population under optimal treatment assignment: \displaystyle V\left(h_{0}\right) \displaystyle:=\int\mathbf{\mathbbm{1}}\left\{h_{0}\left(x\right)\geq 0\right\}v_{0}\left(x\right)f\left(x\right)dx (4) where v_{0}:\mathbb{R}^{d}\mapsto\mathbb{R} is a user-defined function that may be a utility function, a cost function, or any economically meaningful function of the observed covariate x . For example, setting v_{0}\left(x\right)=a^{\prime}x endows V\left(h_{0}\right) with the interpretation as certain aggregate characteristics of the treated population under optimal treatment assignment, and setting v_{0}\equiv 1 implies that V\left(h_{0}\right)\equiv\mathbb{P}_{f}\left(h_{0}\left(X_{i}\right)\geq 0\right) becomes the share of the target population to be treated (i.e. with nonnegative CATE). In the formulation of W\left(h_{0}\right) and V\left(h_{0}\right) above, we take the density f\left(x\right) to be known. This is in itself relevant in settings where the covariate density of the target population is configured or known/estimated from other sources than the training sample used to estimated CATE. For example, CATE may be estimated from a smaller pilot program, while the policymakers are contemplating to implement the policy on a statewide or nation-wide basis with a much larger population. That said, in this paper we also consider an important case where f is unknown and set to be the covariate density in the underlying population of the training sample. In this case, f does not need to be estimated, as the integral with respect to f can be naturally approximated via sample average in the training sample. This corresponds more closely to the “empirical welfare” as considered in Kitagawa and Tetenov 2018 . We provide results for this setting as well. In this paper, we establish inference results for the welfare and value functionals W\left(h_{0}\right) and V\left(h_{0}\right) with nonparametric estimated CATE h_{0} . The results can be summarized informally as follows. For the welfare functional W\left(h_{0}\right) , we establish semiparametric plug-in estimators of the welfare functional are asymptotically normal at the parametric \sqrt{n} rate and derive closed-form asymptotic variance formulas, along with consistent asymptotic variance estimators. The key insight of the \sqrt{n} rate is geometric: by the definition of the welfare functional, the integrand h_{0} \left(x\right) vanishes on the boundary of the integration \left\{x:h_{0}\left(x\right)=0\right\} , neutralizing the non-smoothness of the indicator function \mathbf{\mathbbm{1}}\left\{h_{0}\left(x\right)\geq 0\right\} . In contrast, for the value functional V\left(h_{0}\right) with general weight v_{0} that does not vanish on the boundary \left\{x:h_{0}\left(x\right)=0\right\} , we show that the rate of convergence is slower than \sqrt{n} , and is instead given by the 1-dimensional nonparametric regression rate n^{-\frac{s}{2s+1}} under appropriate conditions. We establish asymptotic normality of the semiparametric plug-in estimator under this irregular convergence rate, and provide a consistent variance estimator based on the sieve Riesz representer. In particular, the consistent variance estimator features a Hausdorff integral on the boundary submanifold \left\{x:h_{0}\left(x\right)=0\right\} , for which we provide a numerical integration and differentiation procedure for the computation of submanifold integrals. We conduct an array of Monte Carlo experiments to document the good finite-sample accuracy of our theoretical inferential results. We show that the proposed standard error estimators perform well in finite sample, and the corresponding confidence intervals based on the asymptotic normality result and the standard error estimators have coverage probabilities close to their nominal levels. These findings hold not only for the \sqrt{n} -estimable welfare functional, but also for the value functional, which is estimated at slower-than- \sqrt{n} rate with standard errors computed through numerical integration and differentiation. We also apply our results to empirical data from the Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA) data set. Following Kitagawa and Tetenov 2018 , we take 30-month post-program earning as the outcome variable and consider two covariates: pre-program earning and education. We then provide empirical estimates and confidence intervals for two parameters: the welfare under first-best treatment assignment, which is \sqrt{n} estimable, and the share of population to be treated under first-best treatment assignment,