Global Non-Axisymmetric Hall Instabilities in a Rotating Plasma

A.P. Sainterme, Fatima Ebrahimi · 2025

Read Global Non-Axisymmetric Hall Instabilities in a Rotating Plasma by A.P. Sainterme, Fatima Ebrahimi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25532.txt.

Introduction

Alexandre Sainterme and Fatima Ebrahimi study Hall instabilities in plasma. Their 2025 physics paper examines a differentially rotating cylinder. The plasma model is incompressible Hall magnetohydrodynamics. Non-axisymmetric, flow-driven instabilities are the focus here. Flow shear can supply energy to waves. Both whistler and ion-cyclotron waves extract that energy.

Two distinct branches of global instability result. Non-axisymmetric whistler modes grow significantly faster than ideal modes. The authors discuss the global whistler instability mechanism. Large ion skin depth gives an electron-MHD limit. When magnetic field is azimuthal, special modes appear. Zero axial wave number whistler modes get destabilized. A co-rotation amplifier mechanism drives that destabilization. Hall effects become appreciable at modest skin depths. Distinct global modes emerge in strong Hall regime. Stronger magnetic fields are required there than usual. Hall effect weakens field-line bending stabilization by decoupling. These modes may matter in weakly ionized accretion disks.

Catalog record

CREATORA.P. Sainterme, Fatima Ebrahimi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25532

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Global Non-Axisymmetric Hall Instabilities in a Rotating Plasma A.P. Sainterme, Fatima Ebrahimi Abstract Non-axisymmetric, flow-driven instabilities in the incompressible Hall-MHD model are studied in a differentially rotating cylindrical plasma. It is found that in the Hall-MHD regime, both whistler waves and ion-cyclotron waves can extract energy from the flow shear, resulting in two distinct branches of global instability. The non-axisymmetric whistler modes grow significantly faster than non-axisymmetric, ideal MHD modes. A discussion of the whistler instability mechanism is presented in the large-ion-skin-depth, ‘electron-MHD’ limit. It is observed that the effect of the Hall term on the non-axisymmetric modes can be appreciable when d i d_{i} is on the order of a few % of the width of the cylindrical annulus. Distinct global modes emerge in the Hall-MHD regime at significantly stronger magnetic fields than those required for unstable global MHD modes. show][email protected] I Introduction Weakly magnetized, differentially rotating plasmas are unstable to flow-driven hydromagnetic instabilities ( E. Velikhov 1959 ; S. Chandrasekhar 1960 ) . The relevance of this mechanism to accretion disks was explored in the seminal work of S. A. Balbus & J. F. Hawley 1991 , wherein the phenomenon was given the name magneto-rotational instability (MRI). The study of such linear instabilities is motivated by the question of whether their onset leads to the generation of turbulence, and if the associated turbulent viscosity contributes significantly rate of angular momentum transport in accretion disks ( N. I. Shakura & R. A. Sunyaev 1973 ) . While the MRI descriptions of E. Velikhov 1959 , S. Chandrasekhar 1960 and S. A. Balbus & J. F. Hawley 1991 use ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) to model the ionized gases in an accretion disk, it has been noted that plasma behavior beyond ideal MHD is likely important in weakly ionized protoplanetary disks (PPDs) ( O. M. Blaes & S. A. Balbus 1994 ) . Other work ( M. Wardle 1999 ; S. A. Balbus & C. Terquem 2001 ; M. W. Kunz & S. A. Balbus 2004 ; F. Ebrahimi et al. 2011 ) has specifically considered the influence of the Hall term, \boldsymbol{J}\times\boldsymbol{B}/en_{e} , on the linear dispersion relation for the axisymmetric MRI using local, WKB-like approximations of the governing differential equations. Linear studies of MRI modes in non-ideal regime have shown that inclusion of the Hall term modifies the axisymmetric dispersion relation in two ways. First, S. A. Balbus & C. Terquem 2001 note that Hall effect allows instability in systems that have a radially increasing rotation rate. Such rotation profiles are predicted to be stable in MHD limit. The second observation is that the local dispersion relation becomes asymmetric with respect to the orientation of the magnetic field relative to the axis of rotation/vorticity of the flow. Local linear theory was developed by M. W. Kunz 2008 for a non-rotating flow instability in Hall-MHD using a shearing box approximation that was dubbed the Hall-shear instability (HSI). The flow shear driven Hall-MHD instability in non-rotating plasmas has also been referred to as a magnetoshear instability (MSI) ( C. Bejarano et al. 2011 ) . 3D Hall-MHD calculations show that the MSI can out-compete the growth of Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in a shear layer with perpendicular magnetic field if the vorticity is sufficiently large ( D. O. Gómez et al. 2014 ) . It has also been shown that there exists a second branch of instability in the local dispersion Hall-MHD dispersion relation that results from coupling of the ion-cyclotron wave to the epicyclic motion of a differentially rotating disc ( J. B. Simon et al. 2015 ) . In these local linear calculations ( M. Wardle 1999 ; S. A. Balbus & C. Terquem 2001 ; M. W. Kunz 2008 ; C. Bejarano et al. 2011 ; J. B. Simon et al. 2015 ) , it was shown that growth rate depends on the relative orientation of the vorticity and the magnetic field, and instability is possible for either positive or negative shear (increasing or decreasing rotation rate). Recent work solving the radial eigenvalue problem has elucidated the importance of global non-axisymmetric modes in the MHD model due to the cylindrical curvature of the geometry and flow curvature ( F. Ebrahimi & M. Pharr 2022 ; F. Ebrahimi & A. Haywood 2025 ; A. Haywood & F. Ebrahimi 2025a ) , as well as in laboratory settings ( Y. Wang et al. 2025 ) . Alfvénic resonances ( R. Matsumoto & T. Tajima 1995 ; G. I. Ogilvie & J. E. Pringle 1996 ; F. Ebrahimi & M. Pharr 2022 ) are shown to be instrumental in the global nature of the MHD non-axisymmetric flow-driven and curvature modes (the global non-axisymmetric MRI branch). The question arises whether dispersive Hall-MHD modes contribute to the onset of global flow-driven instabilities in differentially rotating systems. Here, we uncover that in fact whistler and ion-cyclotron waves can have a dominant effect on the onset of non-axisymmetric modes in the weakly-ionzied regime (Hall-MHD model). This work presents a comprehensive global linear study of non-axisymmetric, flow driven instabilities in the Hall MHD model. In the Hall-MHD model, we show that there are two distinct branches of instability in the presence of the Hall effect. One branch is faster growing the MHD MRI modes at modest values of the ion skin depth, d_{i} . We identify this branch as a whistler wave that is able to extract energy from the steady-state flow shear. The second branch is akin to the incompressible MHD modes with growth rates and mode structures that are modified by the hall term. We also explore the instabilities of the rotating system in the large d_{i} , electron-MHD (EMHD) limit. In this regime, the ions provide an effectively stationary, neutralizing background through which the electron fluid moves. This model retains the coupling between the mean rotation profile and the whistler waves. In this way, the electron MHD model shows that there is a distinct branch of linear instability that is not simply explained as a destabilizing effect on the non-axisymmetric MRI modes. Both local and global analysis and calculations of the electron MHD system are presented. Using a combination of local and global eigenvalue analysis as well as numerical calculations, we assess the degree to which the Hall-MHD waves extract energy from the differential rotation - leading to new non-axisymmetric modes that exist at larger magnetic field strengths than MHD modes ( F. Ebrahimi & M. Pharr 2022 ) . We find that for k=0 modes in the EMHD model, the local instability criterion predicts stability despite the presence of global unstable whistler modes. The organization of this paper is as follows. Section II presents analysis and numerical calculations of the linear, non-axisymmetric instabilities of the rotating disk in the EMHD limit. It is shown that non-axisymmetric whistler waves are driven unstable by the sheared rotation when the wave frequency is similar in magnitude to the rotation rate. The local, point-wise dispersion relation theory is compared to the results of global analysis. Necessary conditions for the existence of unstable modes are derived based on global properties of the EMHD system. Numerical results for the global eigenvalue problem are presented at several values of disk aspect ratio

Read the complete text