Matter Sourced Bubble Nucleation in the Asymmetron Scalar-Tensor Theory

Usama Syed Aqeel, Clare Burrage, Oliver Gould, Paul M. Saffin · 2025

Read Matter Sourced Bubble Nucleation in the Asymmetron Scalar-Tensor Theory by Usama Syed Aqeel, Clare Burrage, Oliver Gould, Paul M. Saffin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25499.txt.

Introduction

Usama Syed Aqeel, Clare Burrage, Oliver Gould, and Paul M Saffin study bubble nucleation. Their 2025 physics paper uses the asymmetron scalar-tensor theory. That theory couples universally to matter in cosmology. It also has explicit symmetry breaking built in. Matter density distributions affect thin-wall bubble formation. Screening inside dense objects changes the picture.

Screening induces a surface tension at object edges. That yields richer bubble answers than standard nucleation. Standard Coleman-Callan bulk nucleation is the comparison case. Edge tensions modify the Nambu-Goto action for instantons. Euclidean actions are computed for several surface geometries. Flat planes and cylindrical surfaces are considered here. Smallest action occurs at concave spherical edges. Edge nucleation beats bulk nucleation within their approximation. Weak asymmetron couplings largely explain that preference. Uses include cosmic void curvature limits in cosmology. Domain wall nucleation preferentially occurs at void edges. Homogeneous gas around substrates reduces the maximum radius.

Catalog record

CREATORUsama Syed Aqeel, Clare Burrage, Oliver Gould, Paul M. Saffin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25499

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Matter Sourced Bubble Nucleation in the Asymmetron Scalar-Tensor Theory Preprint: APS/123-QED Usama Syed Aqeel, Clare Burrage, Oliver Gould, Paul M. Saffin Abstract We investigate how matter density distributions affect thin-wall bubble formation in the asymmetron mechanism, a scalar–tensor theory with a universal coupling to matter and explicit symmetry-breaking, and analyse the stability of its metastable state. We show that the screening mechanism of the asymmetron inside dense objects induces a surface tension associated with the boundary of the screening object, leading to a richer class of bubble solutions than the standard Coleman–Callan bulk nucleation. These boundary surface tensions are used to modify the Nambu-Goto action for instantons, allowing for the computation of the corresponding Euclidean action for bubbles nucleating on flat planes, as well as on concave and convex cylindrical surfaces. We find that the smallest Euclidean action occurs for bubbles nucleating along the edge of a concave spherical surface. Comparing this edge nucleation channel with the bulk one, we determine the maximum curvature radius for which concave edge nucleation is preferred. Since the maximum radius of curvature is exponentially suppressed by the action of a bulk bubble, we find that within the regime of the instanton approximation, edge nucleation is always preferred. This is largely due to the weak couplings of the asymmetron. We apply these findings to determine the maximum curvature radius of a cosmic void and discuss how our results affect the seeding of N N -body simulations of asymmetron domains, showing that domain wall nucleation preferentially occurs at the edges of cosmological voids. We also demonstrate that the presence of a homogeneous gas around the dense substrates reduces the maximum curvature radius, enabling bulk bubbles to form preferentially as the asymmetron undergoes a density-driven phase transition. I Introduction The dynamics of scalar fields in the early Universe provide essential insights into cosmological phase transitions Mazumdar and White 2019 , vacuum stability Coleman 1977 ; Callan and Coleman 1977 ; Coleman and De Luccia 1980 ; Affleck 1981 and the origin of cosmic structure Guth 1981 ; Linde 1983 ; Mukhanov et al. 1992 . In particular, non-perturbative Euclidean solutions of the field equations, known as instantons Paranjape 2018 ; Coleman 1985 , describe tunnelling from a metastable vacuum to the true vacuum of a theory. A well-studied application of scalar fields in Cosmology is the symmetron mechanism introduced in Ref Hinterbichler and Khoury 2010 , a scalar-tensor theory in which the scalar has a bare symmetry-breaking potential. In the Einstein frame, the scalar is minimally coupled to gravity, while in the Jordan frame, it couples universally to Standard Model matter fields. The presence of matter shifts the effective mass of the symmetron at the origin, making it tachyonic in low-density environments and real in regions of high density. Consequently, the effective potential has a single minimum in the high-density environment of the early Universe, but as the matter density redshifts below a critical density, the \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry spontaneously breaks and the potential develops two minima Hinterbichler et al. 2011 . As the scalar rolls into the different minima in distinct patches of the Universe, a domain wall network forms. A crucial feature of the symmetron in the cosmological picture is that it delays the formation of domain walls to a redshift of z\sim 1 , as mentioned in Ref Hinterbichler et al. 2011 , which prevents the energy density of the Universe from becoming dominated by the domain wall network during the inflationary epoch Vilenkin and Shellard 1994 ; Vachaspati 2007 , which ensures the symmetron model is consistent with current cosmological observations in Ref Abdul Karim et al. 2025 . The more general asymmetron potential Perivolaropoulos and Skara 2022 ; Christiansen et al. 2023 ; Chen et al. 2015 introduces a cubic term that explicitly breaks the \mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry of the bare potential. The effective potential features false and true vacua Coleman 1977 . As in the symmetron, the onset of symmetry-breaking at low densities generates domains separated by unstable walls Perivolaropoulos and Skara 2022 . The pressure difference from the true domain onto the false domain destabilises the network. The earliest systematic treatment of metastable decay was given by J. S. Langer in Ref. Langer 1969 ; Langer 1967 , who developed the theory of nucleation of first-order phase transitions in thermodynamic systems. Building on the world of Langer, Coleman and Callan Coleman 1977 ; Callan and Coleman 1977 established the semiclassical method for computing the associated decay rate, which remains a cornerstone of modern studies of vacuum stability. A pedagogical review of false vacuum decay and modern applications beyond bubble nucleation can be found in Ref. Devoto et al. 2022 . Recently, there has been a rise in interest in seeding false vacuum decay in analogue condensed matter systems Canaletti and Moss 2024 ; Jenkins et al. 2025 . Semiclassical analyses suggest that nucleation may be enhanced at boundaries, such as the edge of a cylindrical substrate Canaletti and Moss 2024 . However, Ref. Brown et al. 2025 ; Jenkins et al. 2025 argues that for analogue experiments to faithfully mimic cosmological tunnelling, boundary effects, such as bubble nucleation on the interior edge of a spherical chamber, should be suppressed, since bubble nucleation in the early Universe is a bulk process. Seeded nucleation has also been considered in curved spacetimes. For example, the nucleation of scalar bubbles around black holes in Schwarzschild-de-Sitter (SdS) spacetimes has been explored in Refs. Moss 1985 ; Gregory et al. 2014 ; Gregory et al. 2020 ; Shkerin and Sibiryakov 2021 . In such settings, decay of the false vacuum acquires a thermal interpretation, since the Euclidean continuation renders time compact Brown and Weinberg 2007 , which induces a continuation of the Euclidean action into a statistical thermal free energy of the scalar field. Additionally, spacetimes with horizons, such as de Sitter space, have an associated temperature known as the Gibbons-Hawking temperature Gibbons and Hawking 1977 . However, spacetimes with multiple horizons, such as SdS, exhibit different surface gravities, implying different temperatures; thus, a global thermal equilibrium is absent, except in special cases, like the Nariai limit (where the temperatures of the cosmic and black hole horizons are equal and constant Bousso and Hawking 1998 ). While these studies neglect the quantum effects of the black hole, such as black hole evaporation, the approximations can be justified on timescales shorter than the horizon, where non-equilibrium effects are negligible. In this work, we investigate how quantum fluctuations render the asymmetron false vacuum metastable: the scalar field can tunnel through the barrier, nucleating a spherical bubble of true vacuum. The decay rate is computed semiclassically from the Euclidean continuation of the path integral Coleman 1985 ; Callan and Coleman 1977 ; Coleman 1985 ; Coleman and De Luccia 1980 ; Paranjape 2018 . We extend the calculations of Coleman and Callan to discuss the role that boundaries play in bubble nucleation. Unlike the discussion in Ref. Brown et al. 2025 ; Jenkins et al. 2025 , boundary nucleation is physically relevant here, since the explicit coupling of the asymmetron to dense astrophysical objects such as stars and the edges of galactic voids acts as an effective boundary for the scalar

Read the complete text