Ringed vs. Ringless Worlds: How Poynting-Robertson Drag Shapes Rings Across the Solar System

Ryuki Hyodo, Shigeru Ida · 2025

Read Ringed vs. Ringless Worlds: How Poynting-Robertson Drag Shapes Rings Across the Solar System by Ryuki Hyodo, Shigeru Ida (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2510-25302.txt.

Introduction

Ryuki Hyodo and Shigeru Ida ask why inner planets lack rings. Their 2025 astronomy paper compares ringed and ringless worlds. Giant outer planets all host rings today. Some small distant bodies also host rings. No inner Solar System object shows rings. The pair seek a dynamical cause for that split.

They model Poynting-Robertson drag over billions of years. That drag comes from sunlight acting on small particles. Their model was checked with numeric work. It tracks particle size and distance from the Sun. Without extra effects, drag alone explains the pattern. Outer bodies can keep rings for the Solar System age. Inner planet rings vanish far more quickly. Lifetime grows steeply with distance from the Sun. They predict surveys will find more distant ringed bodies.

Catalog record

CREATORRyuki Hyodo, Shigeru Ida
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510-25302

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ringed vs. Ringless Worlds: How Poynting-Robertson Drag Shapes Rings Across the Solar System Ryuki Hyodo, Shigeru Ida Abstract Planetary rings are not only ubiquitous around the giant planets in the outer Solar System, but have also been discovered around several small distant bodies. In contrast, no rings have been observed around any inner Solar System objects. To constrain the dynamical origin of this ringed-versus-ringless dichotomy, we employ a numerically cross-checked analytical model of gigayear-scale Poynting-Robertson (PR) drag due to the solar flux acting on an isolated particle, expressed as a function of the host body’s heliocentric distance a pla \,a_{\mathrm{pla}} and the particle radius r par \,r_{\mathrm{par}} . Here we show that, in the absence of additional perturbations, PR drag alone can explain the observed ring architecture of the Solar System: outer planets and Centaurs/TNOs are able to retain rings for the age of the Solar System, whereas any rings around the inner planets are removed on much shorter timescales. Because the PR-drag lifetime scales steeply with heliocentric distance ( τ decay ∝ a pla 2 ​ r par ) \bigl(\tau_{\mathrm{decay}}\propto a_{\mathrm{pla}}^{2}\,r_{\mathrm{par}}\bigr) , we predict that forthcoming surveys will reveal an ever-growing population of ring-bearing bodies in the distant Solar System. I Introduction Planetary rings are among the most striking — but also the most selective — features in the Solar System. Although a variety of mechanisms can generate rings, only a fraction of planetary bodies are actually observed to host them. As discussed below, a ringed-versus-ringless dichotomy appears to exist between the inner and outer Solar System. Understanding why rings persist around some objects but not others therefore remains a fundamental problem in planetary science. One well-studied ring formation pathway around terrestrial planets in the inner Solar System is collisional. During the final stages of terrestrial planet formation, giant impacts inevitably eject debris that can be gravitationally captured by the surviving body ( W. K. Hartmann & D. R. Davis 1975 ) . The canonical Earth-Moon-forming impact ( R. M. Canup 2004 ; E. Kokubo et al. 2000 , e.g.,) and the putative giant impact that produced Phobos and Deimos ( R. Hyodo et al. 2017b ; P. Rosenblatt et al. 2016 , e.g.,) have been studied in terms of the dynamical evolution of the resulting planetocentric debris: each would have left an optically thin particulate ring once satellite accretion was complete. Yet no such rings are seen around Earth or Mars today ( M. R. Showalter et al. 2006 ) . Similarly, Mercury and Venus lack both moons and rings — perhaps because their impacts never produced disks/rings massive enough to form satellites, or because any satellites were later removed by tidal interactions ( K. Atobe & S. Ida 2007 ) . Even smaller-scale impacts can in principle create transient debris rings, but none of the present-day terrestrial planets and small inner solar system bodies exhibit ring systems. Various formation mechanisms have been proposed to explain the rings observed around bodies in the outer Solar System. For example, close encounters between a giant planet and a passing large body can tidally strip material from a passing body, seeding a ring around the planet ( L. Dones 1991 ; R. Hyodo et al. 2017a ) . Meanwhile, the remaining large body can gravitationally capture part of its own debris to acquire a ring of its own ( R. Hyodo et al. 2016 ) . This is just one example of ring formation, but such processes demonstrate that rings are not confined to massive planets in the outer Solar System. Indeed, at the time of this paper is written, particulate rings are confirmed or suspected around several small outer solar system bodies through observing stellar occultations — including the Centaur Chariklo ( F. Braga-Ribas et al. 2014 ) , possibly Chiron ( J. L. Ortiz et al. 2015 ) , the dwarf planet Haumea ( J. L. Ortiz et al. 2017 ) , and the trans-Neptunian object Quaoar ( B. E. Morgado et al. 2023 ; C. Pereira et al. 2023 ) . Statistical estimates suggest that rings occur around roughly 8-12 % of small outer solar system bodies ( B. Sicardy et al. 2020 ) , implying that additional ring-bearing objects will likely be discovered. Indeed, the aforementioned ring-forming processes could operate in both the inner and outer Solar System; however, observations clearly indicate that rings are more prevalent in the outer Solar System. Whether produced by impacts, tidal encounters, or other processes, the ultimate survival of a ring depends on the dynamical evolution of its constituent particles. Accordingly, this evolution should be consistent with the observed ringed-versus-ringless dichotomy between the inner and outer Solar System. The evolution of ring particles is governed by several distinct physical regimes. When a ring is optically thick, collisional and gravitational interactions among the particles can dominate, leading to viscous spreading ( D. Lynden-Bell & A. Kalnajs 1972 ; P. Goldreich & S. Tremaine 1978 ) . As an alternative, when the central body’s shape is non-axisymmetric, resonant effects arise between the object’s spin rate and the ring particles’ mean motion ( B. Sicardy et al. 2020 ) . Here we instead consider the optically thin limit and follow the dynamics of individual, isolated particles around a spherical central body due to non-gravitational forces. The dominant non-gravitational force on a ring particle depends on its size. Here we focus on ”medium-sized” particles — typically centimeter- to meter-sized — which we assume are neither rapidly removed by solar radiation pressure, taking into account the planetary shadow ( Y. Liang & R. Hyodo 2023 ) , nor strongly affected by Yarkovsky or YORP effects ( D. P. Rubincam 2000 ) . In this size regime, Poynting-Robertson (PR) drag due to the solar flux may dominate the non-gravitational evolution, gradually removing orbital energy and leading to a contraction of the semimajor axis ( J. A. Burns et al. 2001 , see also) . Note that if the planetary shadow is neglected, solar PR drag produces no secular change in eccentricity ( J. A. Burns et al. 1979 ) ; to the best of my knowledge, the giga-year scale long-term effect of the shadow on eccentricity has not yet been investigated. Previous studies ( J. A. Burns et al. 1979 , e.g.,) carried out an extensive analytical study of Poynting-Robertson drag, but at that time rings had not yet been discovered around the wide range of body sizes and orbital radii we know today. Consequently, the theory could neither fully account for observational data nor be tightly constrained by it. In this present work, we revisit the problem in light of new observations to reassess the potential role of PR-drag in shaping the distribution of rings throughout the solar system. II Methods In this section we describe the methodology of our numerical simulations. We concentrate exclusively on Poynting-Robertson (PR) drag due to the solar flux. To isolate the role of PR drag, we adopt a deliberately simplified approach. We assume that an isolated ring particle is present at around a spherical host body and then follow its dynamical evolution over gigayear timescales. Our results are presented as functions of particle size r_{\rm par} and the radial distance

Read the complete text